Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2401.14396 · Physical Review Letters

Entanglement Entropy and Deconfined Criticality: Emergent SO(5) Symmetry and Proper Lattice Bipartition

Jonathan D’Emidio, Anders W. Sandvik

Published Oct 16, 2024• 34 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the Rényi entanglement entropy (EE) of the two-dimensional J-Q model, the emblematic quantum spin model of deconfined criticality at the phase transition between antiferromagnetic and valence-bond-solid ground states. State-of-the-art quantum Monte Carlo calculations of the EE reveal critical corner contributions that scale logarithmically with the system size, with a coefficient in remarkable agreement with the form expected from a large-N conformal field theory with SO(N=5) symmetry. However, details of the bipartition of the lattice are crucial in order to observe this behavior. If the subsystem for the reduced density matrix does not properly accommodate valence-bond fluctuations, logarithmic contributions appear even for cornerless bipartitions. We here use a 45° tilted cut on the square lattice. Beyond supporting an SO(5) deconfined quantum critical point, our results for both the regular and tilted cuts demonstrate important microscopic aspects of the EE that are not captured by conformal field theory.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.133.166702

Related papers

Critical SO(5) scaling of entanglement entropy at honeycomb lattice deconfined criticality

Sankalp Kumar, Jonathan D’Emidio, Sumiran Pujari

The deconfined quantum critical point (DQCP) in square lattice S=1/2 quantum antiferromagnets has been extensively studied with a large body of evidence pointing to a weakly first-order transition scenario. Recent studies, which focused on entanglement at this nearly continuous DQCP in square lattice J-Q models, have observed conflicting bipartite entanglement entropy (EE) scaling behavior. One bipartition choice gave scaling coefficients in remarkable agreement with predictions from the unitary CFT corresponding to the putative DQCP. While another equally natural choice gave scaling coefficients in complete violation of unitary CFT that may be attributed to lack of scale invariance at the known weakly first-order behavior of the model. This motivates the exploration of DQCP behavior via entanglement measures in lattice models with distinct crystalline symmetries. Here we study a S=1/2 honeycomb model that hosts a nearly continuous transition between Néel and valence-bond-solid ground states relevant to probing DQCP. Using large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations, we compute the Rényi EE for a variety of bipartitions and test the CFT based description of the DQCP on the honeycomb lattice. For smooth bipartitions, we find no evidence of logarithmic corrections, in accordance with CFT, thereby essentially ruling out contributions from Goldstone modes. For subsystems with corners, CFT predicts universal logarithmic contributions, which we extract for corners with 60 and 120 degree angles and find close agreement with an emergent SO(5) CFT. While we observe scaling consistent with a critical system in the majority of cases, we also demonstrate an intriguing counterexample of the hexagon subsystem that exhibits a subtle period three oscillation. This results in three separate finite-size series, where the sign of the logarithmic term apparently changes depending on the series.

arXiv:2607.07248•Jul 8, 2026•0 citations

Diagnosing Quantum Phase Transition Order and Deconfined Criticality via Entanglement Entropy

Zehui Deng, Lu Liu, Wenan Guo +1 more

We study the scaling behavior of the Rényi entanglement entropy with smooth boundaries at the putative deconfined critical point separating the Néel antiferromagnetic and valence-bond-solid states of the two-dimensional J-Q_{3} model. We observe a subleading logarithmic term with a coefficient indicating the presence of four Goldstone modes, signifying the presence of an SO(5) symmetry at the transition point, which spontaneously breaks into an O(4) symmetry in the thermodynamic limit. This result supports the conjecture that an SO(5) symmetry emerges at the transition point, but reveals the transition to be weakly first-order. We demonstrate, through this Letter, a novel approach to detect emergent continuous symmetry and, more importantly, identify weakly first-order phase transitions efficiently, which have been notoriously challenging for conventional methods.

arXiv:2401.12838•Physical Review Letters•Sep 4, 2024•40 citations

Emergent quantum criticality from fractionalizing one-dimensional SO(5) symmetric valence-bond solid states

Wen-Jia Rao, Kang Cai, Xin Wan +1 more

A common feature of topological phases of matter is the fractionalization of the quantum number in their low-energy excitations. Such information is encoded in their ground state wave functions, but emerges in the bipartite entanglement spectra. The symmetric extensive bipartition is an effective novel method to create deconfined fractionalized edge particles in the reduced subsystem, which lead to quantum critical behavior associated with the transition from the topological phase to its adjacent trivial phase. Here we report the interesting results revealed by applying this method to the one-dimensional SO(5) symmetric valence-bond solid state being a spin-2 symmetry protected topological phase. From the finite-size entanglement spectrum, we find the lowest level to be an SO(5) singlet with a logarithmic entanglement entropy. Surprisingly, the first excited level is also an SO(5) singlet and the spectral gap scales with the subsystem size as ${L}_{A}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\nu}}$ with $\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremath{\simeq}1.978$. In the thermodynamic limit, a novel quantum criticality emerges with SO(5) spinons and their four-body singlet bound states as elementary excitations, hence ruling out the possibility of being described by a conformal field theory. Moreover, the entanglement Hamiltonian can be determined as an SO(5) symmetric nearest neighbor spin-3/2 quadruple-quadruple interaction with a negative coupling. Our work thus demonstrates the power of this new method in the study of quantum criticality encoded in the topological ground states.

Physical Review B•Dec 21, 2015•1 citation

Deconfined quantum criticality and emergent SO(5) symmetry in fermionic systems

Zixiang Li, Shao-Kai Jian, Hong Yao

Deconfined quantum criticality with emergent SO(5) symmetry in correlated systems remains elusive. Here, by performing numerically-exact state-of-the-art quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations, we show convincing evidences of deconfined quantum critical points (DQCP) between antiferromagnetic and valence-bond-solid phases in the extended Hubbard model of fermions on the honeycomb lattice with large system sizes. We further demonstrate evidences of the SO(5) symmetry at the DQCP. It is important to note that the critical exponents obtained by finite-size scaling at the DQCP here are consistent with the rigourous conformal bounds. Consequently, we established a promising arena of DQCP with emergent SO(5) symmetry in interacting systems of fermions. Its possible experimental relevances in correlated systems of Dirac fermions will be discussed briefly.

arXiv:1904.10975•Apr 24, 2019•57 citations

The teaching from entanglement: 2D SU(2) antiferromagnet to valence bond solid deconfined quantum critical points are not conformal

Yuan Da Liao, Gaopei Pan, Weilun Jiang +2 more

The deconfined quantum critical point (DQCP) -- the enigmatic incarnation of the quantum phase transition beyond the Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm of symmetries and their spontaneous breaking -- has been proposed and actively pursued for more than two decades. Various 2D quantum many-body lattice models, both in spin/boson and fermion representations have been tested with the state-of-the-art numerical techniques and field-theoretical analyses, and yet, the conclusion is still controversial. Experimental realizations of DQCP in the quantum magnet SrCu$_2$(BO$_3$)$_2$ and superconducting quantum criticality in 2D material have either shown first order transition or intermediate phase. The tension between the lattice scale details and the requirement from continuum limit, manifested in the form of the inconsistent critical scaling behavior and violations of generic conformal bootstrap bound, has not been resolved. Here we solve these decades-long controversies from the new and fundamental perspective of the quantum entanglement. We develop the incremental algorithm to compute the entanglement entropy at a fermionic DQCP with unprecedentedly accurate data and reveal the universal coefficient of the logarithmic correction therein is negative and at odds with positivity requirement of the conformal field theory. Together with results in other 2D DQCP lattice models (both in fermion and spin systems), our discoveries clearly demonstrate the 2D SU(2) antiferromagnet to valence bond solid DQCPs are not conformal fixed point and naturally explain the experimental difficulties in finding them. This marks the end of the beginning of unambiguous finding of the quantum phase transitions truely beyond the Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm, since its suggestion two decades ago.

arXiv:2302.11742•Feb 23, 2023•42 citations

SO(5) multicriticality in two-dimensional quantum magnets

Jun Takahashi, Hui Shao, Bowen Zhao +2 more

We resolve the nature of the quantum phase transition between antiferromagnetic and valence-bond solid ground states in square-lattice spin-1/2 magnets - the putative deconfined quantum-critical point. Using quantum Monte Carlo simulations of J-Q models, in which Heisenberg exchange J competes with multi-spin interactions Qn formed by n singlet projectors, we demonstrate first-order discontinuities increasing with n. For n=2 and n=3, the first-order signatures are very weak and we extract universal scaling dimensions of a proximate multicritical point. Their values coincide closely with known bounds for an SO(5) symmetric conformal field theory (CFT) containing a relevant SO(5) singlet operator that destabilizes the generic deconfined critical point. We characterize the emergent SO(5) symmetry by its scaling dimensions of the leading irrelevant perturbations. Using the J-Q2-Q6 model, we tune the transition from weak to stronger first-order and find scaling of the coexisting order parameters with a large exponent beta ~ 0.85, in agreement with the relevant scaling dimensions of the multicritical point. The exponent that had previously been identified with the correlation length does not have a corresponding CFT level, and we explain it as pseudo-critical length scale of bubbles of one phase inside the other that are compressed in size by an SO(5)-violating irrelevant repulsive interaction between the two order parameters. The bubble scale reflects a hierarchy of excitation gaps generated by the SO(5) perturbation in the neighborhood of the first-order transition, akin to a Higgs mechanism. We argue that the multicritical point is the tip of a gapless spin liquid phase in frustrated Heisenberg models into which the J-Q models can be deformed, but the spin liquid, and perhaps the multicritical point itself, exist outside the regime amenable to sign-free simulations.

arXiv:2405.06607•May 10, 2024•66 citations
We study the Rényi entanglement entropy (EE) of the two-dimensional J-Q model, the emblematic quantum spin model of deconfined criticality at the phase transition between antiferromagnetic and valence-bond-solid ground states. State-of-the-art quantum Monte Carlo calculations of the EE reveal critical corner contributions that scale logarithmically with the system size, with a coefficient in remarkable agreement with the form expected from a large-N conformal field theory with SO(N=5) symmetry. However, details of the bipartition of the lattice are crucial in order to observe this behavior. If the subsystem for the reduced density matrix does not properly accommodate valence-bond fluctuations, logarithmic contributions appear even for cornerless bipartitions. We here use a 45° tilted cut on the square lattice. Beyond supporting an SO(5) deconfined quantum critical point, our results for both the regular and tilted cuts demonstrate important microscopic aspects of the EE that are not captured by conformal field theory.
The deconfined quantum critical point (DQCP) in square lattice S=1/2 quantum antiferromagnets has been extensively studied with a large body of evidence pointing to a weakly first-order transition scenario. Recent studies, which focused on entanglement at this nearly continuous DQCP in square lattice J-Q models, have observed conflicting bipartite entanglement entropy (EE) scaling behavior. One bipartition choice gave scaling coefficients in remarkable agreement with predictions from the unitary CFT corresponding to the putative DQCP. While another equally natural choice gave scaling coefficients in complete violation of unitary CFT that may be attributed to lack of scale invariance at the known weakly first-order behavior of the model. This motivates the exploration of DQCP behavior via entanglement measures in lattice models with distinct crystalline symmetries. Here we study a S=1/2 honeycomb model that hosts a nearly continuous transition between Néel and valence-bond-solid ground states relevant to probing DQCP. Using large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations, we compute the Rényi EE for a variety of bipartitions and test the CFT based description of the DQCP on the honeycomb lattice. For smooth bipartitions, we find no evidence of logarithmic corrections, in accordance with CFT, thereby essentially ruling out contributions from Goldstone modes. For subsystems with corners, CFT predicts universal logarithmic contributions, which we extract for corners with 60 and 120 degree angles and find close agreement with an emergent SO(5) CFT. While we observe scaling consistent with a critical system in the majority of cases, we also demonstrate an intriguing counterexample of the hexagon subsystem that exhibits a subtle period three oscillation. This results in three separate finite-size series, where the sign of the logarithmic term apparently changes depending on the series.
We study the scaling behavior of the Rényi entanglement entropy with smooth boundaries at the putative deconfined critical point separating the Néel antiferromagnetic and valence-bond-solid states of the two-dimensional J-Q_{3} model. We observe a subleading logarithmic term with a coefficient indicating the presence of four Goldstone modes, signifying the presence of an SO(5) symmetry at the transition point, which spontaneously breaks into an O(4) symmetry in the thermodynamic limit. This result supports the conjecture that an SO(5) symmetry emerges at the transition point, but reveals the transition to be weakly first-order. We demonstrate, through this Letter, a novel approach to detect emergent continuous symmetry and, more importantly, identify weakly first-order phase transitions efficiently, which have been notoriously challenging for conventional methods.
A common feature of topological phases of matter is the fractionalization of the quantum number in their low-energy excitations. Such information is encoded in their ground state wave functions, but emerges in the bipartite entanglement spectra. The symmetric extensive bipartition is an effective novel method to create deconfined fractionalized edge particles in the reduced subsystem, which lead to quantum critical behavior associated with the transition from the topological phase to its adjacent trivial phase. Here we report the interesting results revealed by applying this method to the one-dimensional SO(5) symmetric valence-bond solid state being a spin-2 symmetry protected topological phase. From the finite-size entanglement spectrum, we find the lowest level to be an SO(5) singlet with a logarithmic entanglement entropy. Surprisingly, the first excited level is also an SO(5) singlet and the spectral gap scales with the subsystem size as ${L}_{A}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\nu}}$ with $\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremath{\simeq}1.978$. In the thermodynamic limit, a novel quantum criticality emerges with SO(5) spinons and their four-body singlet bound states as elementary excitations, hence ruling out the possibility of being described by a conformal field theory. Moreover, the entanglement Hamiltonian can be determined as an SO(5) symmetric nearest neighbor spin-3/2 quadruple-quadruple interaction with a negative coupling. Our work thus demonstrates the power of this new method in the study of quantum criticality encoded in the topological ground states.
Deconfined quantum criticality with emergent SO(5) symmetry in correlated systems remains elusive. Here, by performing numerically-exact state-of-the-art quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations, we show convincing evidences of deconfined quantum critical points (DQCP) between antiferromagnetic and valence-bond-solid phases in the extended Hubbard model of fermions on the honeycomb lattice with large system sizes. We further demonstrate evidences of the SO(5) symmetry at the DQCP. It is important to note that the critical exponents obtained by finite-size scaling at the DQCP here are consistent with the rigourous conformal bounds. Consequently, we established a promising arena of DQCP with emergent SO(5) symmetry in interacting systems of fermions. Its possible experimental relevances in correlated systems of Dirac fermions will be discussed briefly.
The deconfined quantum critical point (DQCP) -- the enigmatic incarnation of the quantum phase transition beyond the Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm of symmetries and their spontaneous breaking -- has been proposed and actively pursued for more than two decades. Various 2D quantum many-body lattice models, both in spin/boson and fermion representations have been tested with the state-of-the-art numerical techniques and field-theoretical analyses, and yet, the conclusion is still controversial. Experimental realizations of DQCP in the quantum magnet SrCu2_22​(BO3_33​)2_22​ and superconducting quantum criticality in 2D material have either shown first order transition or intermediate phase. The tension between the lattice scale details and the requirement from continuum limit, manifested in the form of the inconsistent critical scaling behavior and violations of generic conformal bootstrap bound, has not been resolved. Here we solve these decades-long controversies from the new and fundamental perspective of the quantum entanglement. We develop the incremental algorithm to compute the entanglement entropy at a fermionic DQCP with unprecedentedly accurate data and reveal the universal coefficient of the logarithmic correction therein is negative and at odds with positivity requirement of the conformal field theory. Together with results in other 2D DQCP lattice models (both in fermion and spin systems), our discoveries clearly demonstrate the 2D SU(2) antiferromagnet to valence bond solid DQCPs are not conformal fixed point and naturally explain the experimental difficulties in finding them. This marks the end of the beginning of unambiguous finding of the quantum phase transitions truely beyond the Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm, since its suggestion two decades ago.
We resolve the nature of the quantum phase transition between antiferromagnetic and valence-bond solid ground states in square-lattice spin-1/2 magnets - the putative deconfined quantum-critical point. Using quantum Monte Carlo simulations of J-Q models, in which Heisenberg exchange J competes with multi-spin interactions Qn formed by n singlet projectors, we demonstrate first-order discontinuities increasing with n. For n=2 and n=3, the first-order signatures are very weak and we extract universal scaling dimensions of a proximate multicritical point. Their values coincide closely with known bounds for an SO(5) symmetric conformal field theory (CFT) containing a relevant SO(5) singlet operator that destabilizes the generic deconfined critical point. We characterize the emergent SO(5) symmetry by its scaling dimensions of the leading irrelevant perturbations. Using the J-Q2-Q6 model, we tune the transition from weak to stronger first-order and find scaling of the coexisting order parameters with a large exponent beta ~ 0.85, in agreement with the relevant scaling dimensions of the multicritical point. The exponent that had previously been identified with the correlation length does not have a corresponding CFT level, and we explain it as pseudo-critical length scale of bubbles of one phase inside the other that are compressed in size by an SO(5)-violating irrelevant repulsive interaction between the two order parameters. The bubble scale reflects a hierarchy of excitation gaps generated by the SO(5) perturbation in the neighborhood of the first-order transition, akin to a Higgs mechanism. We argue that the multicritical point is the tip of a gapless spin liquid phase in frustrated Heisenberg models into which the J-Q models can be deformed, but the spin liquid, and perhaps the multicritical point itself, exist outside the regime amenable to sign-free simulations.