Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2401.07912 · Quantum

Lower Bounds for Unitary Property Testing with Proofs and Advice

Jordi R. Weggemans

Published Apr 18, 2025• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In unitary property testing a quantum algorithm, also known as a tester, is given query access to a black-box unitary and has to decide whether it satisfies some property. We propose a new technique for proving lower bounds on the quantum query complexity of unitary property testing and related problems, which utilises its connection to unitary channel discrimination. The main advantage of this technique is that all obtained lower bounds hold for any C -tester with C⊆QMA(2)/qpoly , showing that even having access to both (unentangled) quantum proofs and advice does not help for many unitary property testing problems. We apply our technique to prove lower bounds for problems like quantum phase estimation, the entanglement entropy problem, quantum Gibbs sampling and more, removing all logarithmic factors in the lower bounds obtained by the sample-to-query lifting theorem of Wang and Zhang (2023). As a direct corollary, we show that there exist quantum oracles relative to which QMA(2)⊅SBQP and QMA/qpoly⊅SBQP . The former shows that, at least in a black-box way, having unentangled quantum proofs does not help in solving problems that require high precision.

DOI
10.22331/q-2025-04-18-1717

Related papers

Unitary Property Testing Lower Bounds by Polynomials

Adrian She, Henry Yuen

We study unitary property testing, where a quantum algorithm is given query access to a black-box unitary and has to decide whether it satisfies some property. In addition to containing the standard quantum query complexity model (where the unitary encodes a binary string) as a special case, this model contains "inherently quantum" problems that have no classical analogue. Characterizing the query complexity of these problems requires new algorithmic techniques and lower bound methods. Our main contribution is a generalized polynomial method for unitary property testing problems. By leveraging connections with invariant theory, we apply this method to obtain lower bounds on problems such as determining recurrence times of unitaries, approximating the dimension of a marked subspace, and approximating the entanglement entropy of a marked state. We also present a unitary property testing-based approach towards an oracle separation between $\mathsf{QMA}$ and $\mathsf{QMA(2)}$, a long standing question in quantum complexity theory.

arXiv:2210.05885•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Oct 12, 2022•31 citations

A List of Complexity Bounds for Property Testing by Quantum Sample-to-Query Lifting

Kean Chen, Qisheng Wang, Zhicheng Zhang

Quantum sample-to-query lifting, a relation between quantum sample complexity and quantum query complexity presented in Wang and Zhang (SIAM J. Comput. 2025), was significantly strengthened by Tang, Wright, and Zhandry (2025) to the case of state-preparation oracles. In this paper, we compile a list of quantum lower and upper bounds for property testing that are obtained by quantum sample-to-query lifting. The problems of interest include testing properties of probability distributions and quantum states, such as entropy and closeness. This collection contains new results, as well as new proofs of known bounds. In total, we present 49 complexity bounds, where 41 are new and 18 are (near-)optimal.

quant-pharXiv:2512.01971•Dec 2, 2025•22 citations

Optimal Quantum Junta Testing without Inverse Queries

Jinge Bao, Minbo Gao, Penghui Yao

We study the query complexity of testing quantum juntas. Given an unknown $n$-qubit unitary or quantum channel, the goal is to decide whether it acts nontrivially on at most $k$ qubits or is $\varepsilon$-far from every such operation. For unitaries, we consider the forward-only model, where the tester has access to $U$, but not to $U^\dagger$ or controlled-$U$. We give tight bounds for both unitary and channel junta testing. For sufficiently large $k$, $n \ge 2k$, and a broad range of $\varepsilon$, both problems have query complexity $Θ\left(k/(\varepsilon^2\log k)\right)$. Our upper bounds are achieved by simple nonadaptive testers using product inputs and single-qubit measurements. For junta channels, this closes the gap by Bao and Yao (COLT 23, TPAMI 2025) between an $\widetilde{O}(k)$ upper bound and a $\widetildeΩ(\sqrt{k})$ lower bound at constant $\varepsilon$, establishing the optimal $Θ(k/\log k)$ query complexity. At the heart of both bounds is a strong connection between quantum junta testing and classical support-size testing. For the upper bounds, we reduce quantum junta testing to a generalized support-size problem for distributions over random subsets, and develop a new tester with improved sample complexity. For the lower bounds, we proceed in the reverse direction, reducing classical support-size testing to quantum junta testing through a phase-masked hard ensemble and showing that forward quantum queries can be exactly classicalized on average. Together, these reductions identify support-size testing as the classical core of quantum junta testing and yield matching lower bounds. At constant $\varepsilon$, they also give a separation between $Θ(k/\log k)$ forward queries and $\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{k})$ queries with inverse access.

quant-pharXiv:2609.37926•Sep 30, 2026•1 citation

Quantum Lower Bounds by Sample-to-Query Lifting

Qisheng Wang, Zhicheng Zhang

Abstract. The polynomial method by Beals, Buhrman, Cleve, Mosca, and de Wolf (FOCS 1998; [ J. ACM, 48 (2001), pp. 778–797]) and the adversary method by Ambainis (STOC 2000; [ J. Comput. System Sci., 64 (2002), pp. 750–767]) and the compressed oracle method by Zhandry [ Proceedings of the 39 th CRYPTO, 2019, pp. 239–268] have been shown to be powerful in proving quantum query lower bounds for a wide variety of problems. In this paper, we propose a new method for proving quantum query lower bounds by a quantum sample-to-query lifting theorem, which is from an information theory perspective. Using this method, we obtain the following new results: (1) A quadratic relation between quantum sample and query complexities regarding quantum property testing, which is optimal and saturated by quantum state discrimination. Here, the sample complexity is measured given sample access to the quantum state to be tested, while the query complexity is measured given query access to an oracle that block-encodes the quantum state. (2) A matching lower bound [Formula: see text] for quantum Gibbs sampling at inverse temperature [Formula: see text] ([Formula: see text] suppresses logarithmic factors), showing that the quantum Gibbs sampler by Gilyén, Su, Low, and Wiebe [ Proceedings of the 51 st STOC, 2019, pp. 193–204] is optimal. (3) A new lower bound [Formula: see text] for the entanglement entropy problem with gap [Formula: see text], which was recently studied by She and Yuen [ Proceedings of the 14 th ITCS, 2023, pp. 96:1–96:17]. (4) A series of quantum query lower bounds for matrix spectrum testing, based on the sample lower bounds for quantum state spectrum testing by O’Donnell and Wright (STOC 2015; [ Comm. Math. Phys., 387 (2021), pp. 1–95]). In addition, we provide unified proofs for some known lower bounds that have been proven previously via different techniques, including those for phase/amplitude estimation and Hamiltonian simulation.

arXiv:2308.01794•SIAM Journal on Computing•Oct 10, 2025•35 citations

A Unified Complexity Framework for Quantum Property Testing

Qisheng Wang

We develop a unified framework for analyzing the complexity of quantum property testing through functionals of the form $\mathcal{L}_φ(ρ) = \operatorname{tr}(φ(dρ))/d$, where $ρ$ is an unknown $d$-dimensional quantum state and $φ$ is a given function. A master theorem is established that derives sample complexity lower bounds for estimating $\mathcal{L}_φ(ρ)$ from properties of $φ$, combining Haar-random moment encoding with moment matching and best polynomial approximation. Corresponding query complexity lower bounds follow from quantum sample-to-query lifting. The framework yields (nearly) tight bounds for a broad class of problems, including entropy estimation (von Neumann, Rényi, and Tsallis), closeness estimation (trace distance and Uhlmann fidelity), spectrum estimation, rank testing (operator rank, Schmidt rank, and matrix product states). In particular, combined with known upper bounds, we show that the sample complexity of von Neumann entropy estimation is \[ Θ\!\left(\frac{d^2}{\varepsilon\log^2(d)\max\{1, \varepsilon\log^2(d)\}} + \frac{\log^2(d)}{\varepsilon^2}\right), \] and the sample complexity of spectrum estimation is \[ Θ\!\left(\frac{d^2}{\varepsilon^2\log^2(d)\max\{1, \varepsilon^2\log^2(d)\}}\right). \] In summary, our results resolve several open problems and establish the optimality of 37 quantum algorithms since 2015, up to constant or polylogarithmic factors.

quant-pharXiv:2608.02600•Aug 4, 2026•10 citations

Quantum Query Complexity of Unitary Operator Discrimination

Akinori Kawachi, Kenichi Kawano, François Le Gall +1 more

Unitary operator discrimination is a fundamental problem in quantum information theory. The basic version of this problem can be described as follows: Given a black box implementing a unitary operator U∈S:={U1, U2} under some probability distribution over S, the goal is to decide whether U=U1 or U=U2. In this paper, we consider the query complexity of this problem. We show that there exists a quantum algorithm that solves this problem with bounded error probability using $\lceil{\sqrt{6}\theta_{\rm cover}^{-1}}\rceil$ queries to the black box in the worst case, i.e., under any probability distribution over S, where the parameter θcover, which is determined by the eigenvalues of $U_1^\dagger {U_2}$, represents the “closeness” between U1 and U2. We also show that this upper bound is essentially tight: we prove that for every θcover > 0 there exist operators U1 and U2 such that any quantum algorithm solving this problem with bounded error probability requires at least $\lceil{\frac{2}{3 \theta_{\rm cover}}}\rceil$ queries under uniform distribution over S.

IEICE Transactions on Information and Systems•Feb 28, 2019•4 citations
In unitary property testing a quantum algorithm, also known as a tester, is given query access to a black-box unitary and has to decide whether it satisfies some property. We propose a new technique for proving lower bounds on the quantum query complexity of unitary property testing and related problems, which utilises its connection to unitary channel discrimination. The main advantage of this technique is that all obtained lower bounds hold for any C -tester with C⊆QMA(2)/qpoly , showing that even having access to both (unentangled) quantum proofs and advice does not help for many unitary property testing problems. We apply our technique to prove lower bounds for problems like quantum phase estimation, the entanglement entropy problem, quantum Gibbs sampling and more, removing all logarithmic factors in the lower bounds obtained by the sample-to-query lifting theorem of Wang and Zhang (2023). As a direct corollary, we show that there exist quantum oracles relative to which QMA(2)⊅SBQP and QMA/qpoly⊅SBQP . The former shows that, at least in a black-box way, having unentangled quantum proofs does not help in solving problems that require high precision.
We study unitary property testing, where a quantum algorithm is given query access to a black-box unitary and has to decide whether it satisfies some property. In addition to containing the standard quantum query complexity model (where the unitary encodes a binary string) as a special case, this model contains "inherently quantum" problems that have no classical analogue. Characterizing the query complexity of these problems requires new algorithmic techniques and lower bound methods. Our main contribution is a generalized polynomial method for unitary property testing problems. By leveraging connections with invariant theory, we apply this method to obtain lower bounds on problems such as determining recurrence times of unitaries, approximating the dimension of a marked subspace, and approximating the entanglement entropy of a marked state. We also present a unitary property testing-based approach towards an oracle separation between QMA\mathsf{QMA}QMA and QMA(2)\mathsf{QMA(2)}QMA(2), a long standing question in quantum complexity theory.
Quantum sample-to-query lifting, a relation between quantum sample complexity and quantum query complexity presented in Wang and Zhang (SIAM J. Comput. 2025), was significantly strengthened by Tang, Wright, and Zhandry (2025) to the case of state-preparation oracles. In this paper, we compile a list of quantum lower and upper bounds for property testing that are obtained by quantum sample-to-query lifting. The problems of interest include testing properties of probability distributions and quantum states, such as entropy and closeness. This collection contains new results, as well as new proofs of known bounds. In total, we present 49 complexity bounds, where 41 are new and 18 are (near-)optimal.
We study the query complexity of testing quantum juntas. Given an unknown nnn-qubit unitary or quantum channel, the goal is to decide whether it acts nontrivially on at most kkk qubits or is ε\varepsilonε-far from every such operation. For unitaries, we consider the forward-only model, where the tester has access to UUU, but not to U†U^\daggerU† or controlled-UUU. We give tight bounds for both unitary and channel junta testing. For sufficiently large kkk, n≥2kn \ge 2kn≥2k, and a broad range of ε\varepsilonε, both problems have query complexity Θ(k/(ε2log⁡k))Θ\left(k/(\varepsilon^2\log k)\right)Θ(k/(ε2logk)). Our upper bounds are achieved by simple nonadaptive testers using product inputs and single-qubit measurements. For junta channels, this closes the gap by Bao and Yao (COLT 23, TPAMI 2025) between an O~(k)\widetilde{O}(k)O(k) upper bound and a Ω~(k)\widetildeΩ(\sqrt{k})Ω(k​) lower bound at constant ε\varepsilonε, establishing the optimal Θ(k/log⁡k)Θ(k/\log k)Θ(k/logk) query complexity. At the heart of both bounds is a strong connection between quantum junta testing and classical support-size testing. For the upper bounds, we reduce quantum junta testing to a generalized support-size problem for distributions over random subsets, and develop a new tester with improved sample complexity. For the lower bounds, we proceed in the reverse direction, reducing classical support-size testing to quantum junta testing through a phase-masked hard ensemble and showing that forward quantum queries can be exactly classicalized on average. Together, these reductions identify support-size testing as the classical core of quantum junta testing and yield matching lower bounds. At constant ε\varepsilonε, they also give a separation between Θ(k/log⁡k)Θ(k/\log k)Θ(k/logk) forward queries and O~(k)\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{k})O(k​) queries with inverse access.
Abstract. The polynomial method by Beals, Buhrman, Cleve, Mosca, and de Wolf (FOCS 1998; [ J. ACM, 48 (2001), pp. 778–797]) and the adversary method by Ambainis (STOC 2000; [ J. Comput. System Sci., 64 (2002), pp. 750–767]) and the compressed oracle method by Zhandry [ Proceedings of the 39 th CRYPTO, 2019, pp. 239–268] have been shown to be powerful in proving quantum query lower bounds for a wide variety of problems. In this paper, we propose a new method for proving quantum query lower bounds by a quantum sample-to-query lifting theorem, which is from an information theory perspective. Using this method, we obtain the following new results: (1) A quadratic relation between quantum sample and query complexities regarding quantum property testing, which is optimal and saturated by quantum state discrimination. Here, the sample complexity is measured given sample access to the quantum state to be tested, while the query complexity is measured given query access to an oracle that block-encodes the quantum state. (2) A matching lower bound [Formula: see text] for quantum Gibbs sampling at inverse temperature [Formula: see text] ([Formula: see text] suppresses logarithmic factors), showing that the quantum Gibbs sampler by Gilyén, Su, Low, and Wiebe [ Proceedings of the 51 st STOC, 2019, pp. 193–204] is optimal. (3) A new lower bound [Formula: see text] for the entanglement entropy problem with gap [Formula: see text], which was recently studied by She and Yuen [ Proceedings of the 14 th ITCS, 2023, pp. 96:1–96:17]. (4) A series of quantum query lower bounds for matrix spectrum testing, based on the sample lower bounds for quantum state spectrum testing by O’Donnell and Wright (STOC 2015; [ Comm. Math. Phys., 387 (2021), pp. 1–95]). In addition, we provide unified proofs for some known lower bounds that have been proven previously via different techniques, including those for phase/amplitude estimation and Hamiltonian simulation.
We develop a unified framework for analyzing the complexity of quantum property testing through functionals of the form Lφ(ρ)=tr⁡(φ(dρ))/d\mathcal{L}_φ(ρ) = \operatorname{tr}(φ(dρ))/dLφ​(ρ)=tr(φ(dρ))/d, where ρρρ is an unknown ddd-dimensional quantum state and φφφ is a given function. A master theorem is established that derives sample complexity lower bounds for estimating Lφ(ρ)\mathcal{L}_φ(ρ)Lφ​(ρ) from properties of φφφ, combining Haar-random moment encoding with moment matching and best polynomial approximation. Corresponding query complexity lower bounds follow from quantum sample-to-query lifting. The framework yields (nearly) tight bounds for a broad class of problems, including entropy estimation (von Neumann, Rényi, and Tsallis), closeness estimation (trace distance and Uhlmann fidelity), spectrum estimation, rank testing (operator rank, Schmidt rank, and matrix product states). In particular, combined with known upper bounds, we show that the sample complexity of von Neumann entropy estimation is Θ ⁣(d2εlog⁡2(d)max⁡{1,εlog⁡2(d)}+log⁡2(d)ε2), Θ\!\left(\frac{d^2}{\varepsilon\log^2(d)\max\{1, \varepsilon\log^2(d)\}} + \frac{\log^2(d)}{\varepsilon^2}\right), Θ(εlog2(d)max{1,εlog2(d)}d2​+ε2log2(d)​), and the sample complexity of spectrum estimation is Θ ⁣(d2ε2log⁡2(d)max⁡{1,ε2log⁡2(d)}). Θ\!\left(\frac{d^2}{\varepsilon^2\log^2(d)\max\{1, \varepsilon^2\log^2(d)\}}\right). Θ(ε2log2(d)max{1,ε2log2(d)}d2​). In summary, our results resolve several open problems and establish the optimality of 37 quantum algorithms since 2015, up to constant or polylogarithmic factors.
Unitary operator discrimination is a fundamental problem in quantum information theory. The basic version of this problem can be described as follows: Given a black box implementing a unitary operator U∈S:={U1, U2} under some probability distribution over S, the goal is to decide whether U=U1 or U=U2. In this paper, we consider the query complexity of this problem. We show that there exists a quantum algorithm that solves this problem with bounded error probability using ⌈6θcover−1⌉\lceil{\sqrt{6}\theta_{\rm cover}^{-1}}\rceil⌈6​θcover−1​⌉ queries to the black box in the worst case, i.e., under any probability distribution over S, where the parameter θcover, which is determined by the eigenvalues of U1†U2U_1^\dagger {U_2}U1†​U2​, represents the “closeness” between U1 and U2. We also show that this upper bound is essentially tight: we prove that for every θcover > 0 there exist operators U1 and U2 such that any quantum algorithm solving this problem with bounded error probability requires at least ⌈23θcover⌉\lceil{\frac{2}{3 \theta_{\rm cover}}}\rceil⌈3θcover​2​⌉ queries under uniform distribution over S.