Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2401.04085

A dynamic programming interpretation of quantum mechanics

Adam Brownstein

Published Jan 8, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce a transformation of the quantum phase $S'=S+\frac{\hbar}{2}\logρ$, which converts the deterministic equations of quantum mechanics into the Lagrangian reference frame of stochastic particles. We show that the quantum potential can be removed from the transformed quantum Hamilton-Jacobi equations if they are solved as stochastic Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equations. The system of equations provide a local description of quantum mechanics, which is enabled by the inherently retrocausal nature of stochastic Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equations. We also investigate the stochastic transformation of the classical system, where is it shown that quantum mechanics with the quantum potential reduced by a factor of $\frac{1}{2}$ has a classical representation, which may have interesting implications. Finally, we discuss the notion of a subsystem correspondence principle, which constrains the ontology of the total quantum system.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2401.04085

Related papers

Quantum mechanics without quantum potentials

Adam Brownstein

The issue of non-locality in quantum mechanics can potentially be resolved by considering relativistically covariant diffusion in four-dimensional spacetime. Stochastic particles described by the Klein-Gordon equation are shown to undergo a classical diffusion process in spacetime coordinates, which is seen by transforming the quantum Cauchy-momentum equations to a Lagrangian frame of reference. Since the quantum potential term is removed under this transformation, the equations for momentum propagation along particle trajectories assume a classical form. A local stochastic de Broglie-Bohm interpretation for the Klein-Gordon system can subsequently be derived. We also introduce the concept of momentum equivariance to replace the second-order Bohm-Newton equations of motion, which break down due to non-linear terms of the stochastic Lagrangian derivative.

arXiv:2401.04091•Jan 8, 2024•0 citations

Origin of the quantum observable operator algebra in the frame of stochastic mechanics

Francesco Guerra, R. Marra

In previous work the approach to stochastic quantization, originally proposed by Nelson, has been formulated in the frame of the stochastic variational principles of control theory. Then the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equation is interpreted as the programming equation of the controlled problem, to be associated with the hydrodynamical continuity equation. Here we point out explicitly the canonical Hamiltonian structure of these equations, by introducing a suitable symplectic structure on the underlying phase space in various representations. One possible representation leads to the Schr\"odinger equation, which, together with its complex conjugate, can be recognized as a particular form of the Hamilton canonical equations in this frame. Then a suitably selected time-invariant subalgebra of the classical hydrodynamical algebra, closed under Poisson bracket pairing, is shown to be connected to the standard quantum observable operator algebra. In this correspondence Poisson brackets for hydrodynamical observables become averages of quantum observables in the given state. From this point of view stochastic quantization can be interpreted as giving an explanation for the standard quantization procedure of replacing the classical particle (or field) observables with operators, according to the scheme $p\ensuremath{\rightarrow}(\frac{h}{i})\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}}{\ensuremath{\partial}x}$, $l\ensuremath{\rightarrow}(\frac{h}{i})\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}}{\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\varphi}}$, etc. This discussion shows also the relevance of the canonical symplectic structure of the quantum state space, a feature which seems to have been overlooked in the axiomatic approaches to quantum mechanics.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Oct 15, 1983•36 citations

Canonical transformations and the Hamilton-Jacobi theory in quantum mechanics

J.-H. Kim, H.-W. Lee

Canonical transformations using the idea of quantum generating functions are applied to construct a quantum Hamilton-Jacobi theory, based on the analogy with the classical case. An operator and a c-number form of the time-dependent quantum Hamilton-Jacobi equation are derived and used to find dynamical solutions of quantum problems. The phase-space picture of quantum mechanics is discussed in connection with the present theory.PACS Nos.: 03.65-w, 03.65Ca, 03.65Ge

arXiv:quant-ph/9904012•Canadian Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1999•19 citations

A First Principles Derivation of Classical and Quantum Mechanics as the Natural Theories for Smooth Stochastic Paths

W. Westra

We derive the classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation from first principles as the natural description for smooth stochastic processes when one neglects stochastic velocity fluctuations. The Schrödinger equation is shown to be the natural exact equation for describing smooth stochastic processes. In particular, processes with up to quadratic stochastic fluctuations are electromagnetically coupled quantum point particles. The stochastic derivation offers a clear geometric picture for Quantum Mechanics as a locally realistic hidden variable theory. While that sounds paradoxical, we show that Bell's formula for local realism is incomplete. If one includes smooth stochastic fluctuations for the hidden variables, local realism is preserved and quantum mechanics is obtained. Quantum mechanics should therefore be viewed as a "nondeterministic, non-Bell locally realistic hidden variable theory". Since the description is simply a stochastic process, it should be relatively straightforward to create mesoscopic analogue systems that show all the hallmarks of Quantum Mechanics, including super-Bell correlations. In fact, any system that can be described by the linear time evolution of a density matrix is both a stochastic and a Quantum system from our point of view, since we show that the existence of a transition probability density directly implies the existence of a density matrix. Systems for which the stochastic degrees of freedom vary smoothly over time have quantum Hamiltonians with standard kinetic terms.

arXiv:2011.09181•Nov 18, 2020•0 citations

Quantum Hamilton Equations from Stochastic Optimal Control Theory

Jeanette Köppe, Markus Patzold, Michael Beyer +2 more

In 1966, E. Nelson laid the foundations for an understanding of quantum mechanics in terms of stochastic processes. He showed that a description of the motion of quantum particles based on time-reversible Brownian motion leads to a set of hydrodynamic equations derived by Madelung, which in turn can be transformed into the Schrödinger equation. We recently established that the generalization of Hamilton’s equations of motion to the quantum world in terms of coupled forward-backward stochastic differential equations can be derived, when the quantum Hamilton principle, which is the quantum analogue of the Hamilton principle of classical mechanics, is interpreted as a stochastic optimal control problem for the two velocity fields in Nelson’s equations. The quantum Hamilton equations typically have to be solved numerically. Additionally, we will establish links to the theory of supersymmetric Hamiltonians and explain how this allows to obtain the complete bound spectrum of a quantum problem from the quantum Hamilton equations. All mathematical results will be exemplified by applications to suitable quantum mechanical problems from physics.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 26, 2020•0 citations

Quantum Hamilton equations for multidimensional systems

Michael Beyer, Markus Patzold, Wilfried Grecksch +1 more

Within a stochastic picture quantum systems can be described in terms of kinematic and dynamic equations where the particles follow a conservative diffusion process. Pavon has shown that these equations and the Schrödinger equation can be derived from a quantum Hamilton principle, generalizing the Hamilton principle from classical mechanics. As shown recently by Köppe et al for the one-dimensional case, the reformulation of the quantum Hamilton principle as a stochastic optimal control problem leads to quantum Hamilton equations of motion which can be seen as a non relativistic generalization of Hamilton's equations of motion to the quantum world. In this report we will extend this to higher dimensional problems and derive, by incorporating the concept of supersymmetric quantum mechanics, a general scheme that allows the determination of all bound states within the stochastic framework. Physical principles from classical mechanics like the decoupling of the center-of-mass motion in multi-particle systems or the solution of the Kepler problem, as a special case of the two-body problem, using space-time symmetries, are translated to this formulation of quantum mechanics. We will present numerical results for the ground state and lower excited states of the hydrogen atom in Cartesian coordinates, and, additionally, we will show that for spherically symmetric potentials the solution of the two-body problem can be reduced to a system of equations concerning only the radial part.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Mar 1, 2019•4 citations
We introduce a transformation of the quantum phase S′=S+ℏ2log⁡ρS'=S+\frac{\hbar}{2}\logρS′=S+2ℏ​logρ, which converts the deterministic equations of quantum mechanics into the Lagrangian reference frame of stochastic particles. We show that the quantum potential can be removed from the transformed quantum Hamilton-Jacobi equations if they are solved as stochastic Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equations. The system of equations provide a local description of quantum mechanics, which is enabled by the inherently retrocausal nature of stochastic Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equations. We also investigate the stochastic transformation of the classical system, where is it shown that quantum mechanics with the quantum potential reduced by a factor of 12\frac{1}{2}21​ has a classical representation, which may have interesting implications. Finally, we discuss the notion of a subsystem correspondence principle, which constrains the ontology of the total quantum system.
The issue of non-locality in quantum mechanics can potentially be resolved by considering relativistically covariant diffusion in four-dimensional spacetime. Stochastic particles described by the Klein-Gordon equation are shown to undergo a classical diffusion process in spacetime coordinates, which is seen by transforming the quantum Cauchy-momentum equations to a Lagrangian frame of reference. Since the quantum potential term is removed under this transformation, the equations for momentum propagation along particle trajectories assume a classical form. A local stochastic de Broglie-Bohm interpretation for the Klein-Gordon system can subsequently be derived. We also introduce the concept of momentum equivariance to replace the second-order Bohm-Newton equations of motion, which break down due to non-linear terms of the stochastic Lagrangian derivative.
In previous work the approach to stochastic quantization, originally proposed by Nelson, has been formulated in the frame of the stochastic variational principles of control theory. Then the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equation is interpreted as the programming equation of the controlled problem, to be associated with the hydrodynamical continuity equation. Here we point out explicitly the canonical Hamiltonian structure of these equations, by introducing a suitable symplectic structure on the underlying phase space in various representations. One possible representation leads to the Schr\"odinger equation, which, together with its complex conjugate, can be recognized as a particular form of the Hamilton canonical equations in this frame. Then a suitably selected time-invariant subalgebra of the classical hydrodynamical algebra, closed under Poisson bracket pairing, is shown to be connected to the standard quantum observable operator algebra. In this correspondence Poisson brackets for hydrodynamical observables become averages of quantum observables in the given state. From this point of view stochastic quantization can be interpreted as giving an explanation for the standard quantization procedure of replacing the classical particle (or field) observables with operators, according to the scheme $p\ensuremath{\rightarrow}(\frac{h}{i})\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}}{\ensuremath{\partial}x}$, $l\ensuremath{\rightarrow}(\frac{h}{i})\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}}{\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\varphi}}$, etc. This discussion shows also the relevance of the canonical symplectic structure of the quantum state space, a feature which seems to have been overlooked in the axiomatic approaches to quantum mechanics.
We derive the classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation from first principles as the natural description for smooth stochastic processes when one neglects stochastic velocity fluctuations. The Schrödinger equation is shown to be the natural exact equation for describing smooth stochastic processes. In particular, processes with up to quadratic stochastic fluctuations are electromagnetically coupled quantum point particles. The stochastic derivation offers a clear geometric picture for Quantum Mechanics as a locally realistic hidden variable theory. While that sounds paradoxical, we show that Bell's formula for local realism is incomplete. If one includes smooth stochastic fluctuations for the hidden variables, local realism is preserved and quantum mechanics is obtained. Quantum mechanics should therefore be viewed as a "nondeterministic, non-Bell locally realistic hidden variable theory". Since the description is simply a stochastic process, it should be relatively straightforward to create mesoscopic analogue systems that show all the hallmarks of Quantum Mechanics, including super-Bell correlations. In fact, any system that can be described by the linear time evolution of a density matrix is both a stochastic and a Quantum system from our point of view, since we show that the existence of a transition probability density directly implies the existence of a density matrix. Systems for which the stochastic degrees of freedom vary smoothly over time have quantum Hamiltonians with standard kinetic terms.
In 1966, E. Nelson laid the foundations for an understanding of quantum mechanics in terms of stochastic processes. He showed that a description of the motion of quantum particles based on time-reversible Brownian motion leads to a set of hydrodynamic equations derived by Madelung, which in turn can be transformed into the Schrödinger equation. We recently established that the generalization of Hamilton’s equations of motion to the quantum world in terms of coupled forward-backward stochastic differential equations can be derived, when the quantum Hamilton principle, which is the quantum analogue of the Hamilton principle of classical mechanics, is interpreted as a stochastic optimal control problem for the two velocity fields in Nelson’s equations. The quantum Hamilton equations typically have to be solved numerically. Additionally, we will establish links to the theory of supersymmetric Hamiltonians and explain how this allows to obtain the complete bound spectrum of a quantum problem from the quantum Hamilton equations. All mathematical results will be exemplified by applications to suitable quantum mechanical problems from physics.
Within a stochastic picture quantum systems can be described in terms of kinematic and dynamic equations where the particles follow a conservative diffusion process. Pavon has shown that these equations and the Schrödinger equation can be derived from a quantum Hamilton principle, generalizing the Hamilton principle from classical mechanics. As shown recently by Köppe et al for the one-dimensional case, the reformulation of the quantum Hamilton principle as a stochastic optimal control problem leads to quantum Hamilton equations of motion which can be seen as a non relativistic generalization of Hamilton's equations of motion to the quantum world. In this report we will extend this to higher dimensional problems and derive, by incorporating the concept of supersymmetric quantum mechanics, a general scheme that allows the determination of all bound states within the stochastic framework. Physical principles from classical mechanics like the decoupling of the center-of-mass motion in multi-particle systems or the solution of the Kepler problem, as a special case of the two-body problem, using space-time symmetries, are translated to this formulation of quantum mechanics. We will present numerical results for the ground state and lower excited states of the hydrogen atom in Cartesian coordinates, and, additionally, we will show that for spherically symmetric potentials the solution of the two-body problem can be reduced to a system of equations concerning only the radial part.