Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2312.17322 · SciPost Physics

The club sandwich: Gapless phases and phase transitions with non-invertible symmetries

Lakshya Bhardwaj, Lea E. Bottini, Daniel Pajer, Sakura Schäfer‐Nameki

Published May 14, 2025• 117 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We provide a generalization of the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) framework to characterize phase transitions and gapless phases with categorical symmetries. The central tool is the club sandwich, which extends the SymTFT setup to include an interface between two topological orders: there is a symmetry boundary, which is gapped, and a physical boundary that may be gapless, but in addition, there is also a gapped interface in the middle. The club sandwich generalizes so-called Kennedy-Tasaki (KT) transformations. Building on the results in [L. Bhardwaj et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 161601 (2024); L. Bhardwaj et al., SciPost Phys. 18, 032 (2025)] on gapped phases with categorical symmetries, we construct gapless theories describing phase transitions with non-invertible symmetries by applying suitable KT transformations on known phase transitions provided by the critical Ising model and the 3-state Potts model. We also describe in detail the order parameters in these gapless theories characterizing the phase transitions, which are generally mixtures of conventional and string-type order parameters mixed together by the action of categorical symmetries. Additionally, removing the physical boundary from the club sandwiches results in club quiches, which characterize all possible gapped boundary phases with (possibly non-invertible) symmetries that can arise on the boundary of a bulk gapped phase. We also provide a mathematical characterization of gapped boundary phases with symmetries as pivotal tensor functors whose targets are pivotal multi-fusion categories.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphys.18.5.156

Related papers

Gapless phases in (2+1)d with non-invertible symmetries

Lakshya Bhardwaj, Yuhan Gai, Sheng-Jie Huang +4 more

The study of gapless phases with categorical (or so-called non-invertible) symmetries is a formidable task, in particular in higher than two space-time dimensions. In this paper we build on previous works [L. Bhardwaj et al. SciPost Phys. 19, 056 (2025); L. Bhardwaj et al. arXiv:2502.20440] on gapped phases in (2+1)d and provide a systematic framework to study phase transitions with categorical symmetries. The Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) is, as often in these matters, the central tool. Applied to gapless theories, we need to consider the extension of the SymTFT to interfaces between topological orders, so-called “club sandwiches”, which realize generalizations of so-called Kennedy-Tasaki (KT) transformations. This requires an input phase transition for a smaller symmetry, such as the Ising transition for \mathbb{Z}_2 ℤ 2 , and the SymTFT constructs a transformation to a gapless phase with a larger categorical symmetry. We carry this out for categorical symmetries whose SymTFT is a (3+1)d Dijkgraaf-Witten (DW) theory for a finite group G G with twist - so-called all bosonic fusion 2-categories. We classify such interfaces using a physically motivated picture of generalized gauging, as well as with a complementary analysis using (bi-)module 2-categories. This is exemplified in numerous Abelian and non-Abelian DW theories, giving rise to interesting gapless phases such as intrinsically gapless symmetry protected phases (igSPTs) and spontaneous symmetry breaking phases (igSSBs) from Abelian, S_3 S 3 , and D_8 D 8 DW theories.

arXiv:2503.12699•SciPost Physics•Jul 23, 2026•33 citations

Gapped phases with non-invertible symmetries: (1+1)d

Lakshya Bhardwaj, Lea E. Bottini, Daniel Pajer +1 more

We propose a general framework to characterize gapped infra-red (IR) phases of theories with non-invertible (or categorical) symmetries. In this paper we focus on (1+1)d gapped phases with fusion category symmetries. The approach that we propose uses the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) as a key input: associated to a field theory in d d spacetime dimensions, the SymTFT lives in one dimension higher and admits a gapped boundary, which realizes the categorical symmetries. It also admits a second, physical, boundary, which is generically not gapped. Upon interval compactification of the SymTFT by colliding the gapped and physical boundaries, we regain the original theory. In this paper, we realize gapped symmetric phases by choosing the physical boundary to be a gapped boundary condition as well. This set-up provides computational power to determine the number of vacua, the symmetry breaking pattern, and the action of the symmetry on the vacua. The SymTFT also manifestly encodes the order parameters for these gapped phases, thus providing a generalized, categorical Landau paradigm for (1+1)d gapped phases. We find that for non-invertible symmetries the order parameters involve multiplets containing both untwisted and twisted sector local operators, and hence can be interpreted as mixtures of conventional and string order parameters. We also observe that spontaneous breaking of non-invertible symmetries can lead to vacua that are physically distinguishable: unlike the standard symmetries described by groups, non-invertible symmetries can have different actions on different vacua of an irreducible gapped phase. This leads to the presence of relative Euler terms between physically distinct vacua. Along with the physical description of symmetric gapped phases, we also provide a mathematical one as pivotal 2-functors whose source 2-category is the delooping of the fusion category characterizing the symmetry and the target 2-category is the Euler completion of 2-vector spaces.

arXiv:2310.03784•SciPost Physics•Jan 24, 2025•165 citations

Fermionic non-invertible symmetries in (1+1)d: Gapped and gapless phases, transitions, and symmetry TFTs

Lakshya Bhardwaj, Kansei Inamura, Apoorv Tiwari

We study fermionic non-invertible symmetries in (1+1)d, which are generalized global symmetries that mix fermion parity symmetry with other invertible and non-invertible internal symmetries. Such symmetries are described by fermionic fusion supercategories, which are fusion \pi π -supercategories with a choice of fermion parity. The aim of this paper is to flesh out the categorical Landau paradigm for fermionic symmetries. We use the formalism of Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) to study possible gapped and gapless phases for such symmetries, along with possible deformations between these phases, which are organized into a Hasse phase diagram. The phases can be characterized in terms of sets of condensed, confined and deconfined generalized symmetry charges, reminiscent of notions familiar from superconductivity. Many of the gapless phases also serve as phase transitions between gapped phases. The associated fermionic conformal field theories (CFTs) can be obtained by performing generalized fermionic Kennedy-Tasaki (KT) transformations on bosonic CFTs describing simpler transitions. The fermionic non-invertible symmetries along with their charges and phases discussed here can be obtained from those of bosonic non-invertible symmetries via fermionization or Jordan-Wigner transformation, which is discussed in detail.

arXiv:2405.09754•SciPost Physics•Jun 18, 2025•49 citations

Hasse diagrams for gapless SPT and SSB phases with non-invertible symmetries

Lakshya Bhardwaj, Daniel Pajer, Sakura Schäfer‐Nameki +1 more

We discuss (1+1)d gapless phases with non-invertible global symmetries, also referred to as categorical symmetries. This includes gapless phases showing properties analogous to gapped symmetry protected topological (SPT) phases, known as gapless SPT (or gSPT) phases; and gapless phases showing properties analogous to gapped spontaneous symmetry broken (SSB) phases, that we refer to as gapless SSB (or gSSB) phases. We fit these gapless phases, along with gapped SPT and SSB phases, into a phase diagram describing possible deformations connecting them. This phase diagram is partially ordered and defines a so-called Hasse diagram. Based on these deformations, we identify gapless phases exhibiting symmetry protected criticality, that we refer to as intrinsically gapless SPT (igSPT) and intrinsically gapless SSB (igSSB) phases. This includes the first examples of igSPT and igSSB phases with non-invertible symmetries. Central to this analysis is the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT), where each phase corresponds to a condensable algebra in the Drinfeld center of the symmetry category. On a mathematical note, gSPT phases are classified by functors between fusion categories, generalizing the fact that gapped SPT phases are classified by fiber functors; and gSSB phases are classified by functors from fusion to multi-fusion categories. Finally, our framework can be applied to understand gauging of trivially acting non-invertible symmetries, including possible patterns of decomposition arising due to such gaugings.

arXiv:2403.00905•SciPost Physics•Oct 28, 2025•120 citations

Generalized Symmetry as a Diagnostic Lens: How Non-Invertible Symmetries, Condensable Algebras, and Order-Parameter Structure Reorganize the Classification of Gapped Phases and Phase Transitions

Saluca Agentic AI Research Team

A candidate reading of seven recent preprints from cond-mat.str-el and physics.atom-ph suggests that the classical toolkit for classifying gapped phases and their transitions—built on Landau symmetry breaking, local order parameters, and invertible group symmetries—requires systematic extension at the level of microscopic algebraic structure, not merely at the phenomenological level. The emerging picture, drawn from the corpus, is that *generalized symmetries* (non-invertible, categorical, and higher-form) impose precise algebraic constraints on what constitutes a valid order parameter, what boundary conditions are permissible, and which phase transitions can occur without any form of spontaneous symmetry breaking, even after arbitrary gauging. Concretely: (i) condensable algebras in 2+1d topological orders classify gapped boundaries, and twin algebras sharing identical anyon content but inequivalent algebra structure describe physically distinct phases with isomorphic ground-state degeneracy but inequivalent order parameters [corpus:arxiv:2605.31602]; (ii) these twin phases can undergo direct transitions that are provably beyond-Landau even after partial gauging [corpus:arxiv:2605.31601]; (iii) string order parameters in 1d systems organize into Lagrangian algebras in the Drinfel'd center of the symmetry category, making the fusion rule of the symmetry category—not just its representation theory—the operative diagnostic [corpus:arxiv:2605.27193]; (iv) non-invertible symmetry-breaking transitions can be mapped via generalized gauging to deconfined quantum critical points, and vice versa, establishing a precise duality [corpus:arxiv:2605.27672]; and (v) non-invertible symmetry enriched topological orders (NI-SETOs) can be constructed from string-net models, extending symmetry enrichment beyond the group-theoretic setting [corpus:arxiv:2605.28794]. Two additional corpus entries—a Rydberg spin-chain study [corpus:arxiv:2605.27166] and a topological lattice gauge theory paper [corpus:arxiv:2605.28688]—provide microscopic anchoring and structural context, respectively. The central falsification path is explicit: if a twin-phase transition can be shown to spontaneously break some hidden symmetry after arbitrary gauging, the framework collapses. Concrete tensor-network (DMRG/MPS) constructions of twin-phase order parameters in 1+1d would constitute a direct test. --- Authorship: Saluca Agentic AI Research Team (Saluca LLC). AI-drafted from arXiv preprint corpus on the date in the filename. Cited arXiv preprints: 2605.27166, 2605.27193, 2605.27672, 2605.28688, 2605.28794, 2605.29745, 2605.29875, 2605.30421, 2605.31185, 2605.31540, 2605.31601, 2605.31602

•Jun 3, 2026•0 citations

Intrinsically/purely gapless-SPT from non-invertible duality transformations

Linhao Li, Masaki Oshikawa, Yunqin Zheng

The Kennedy-Tasaki (KT) transformation was used to construct the gapped symmetry protected topological (SPT) phase from the symmetry breaking phase with open boundary condition, and was generalized in our proceeding work [Phys. Rev. B 108, 214429 (2023)] on a ring by sacrificing the unitarity, and should be understood as a non-invertible duality transformation. In this work, we further apply the KT transformation to systematically construct gapless symmetry protected topological phases. This construction reproduces the known examples of (intrinsically) gapless SPT where the non-trivial topological features come from the gapped sectors by means of decorated defect constructions. We also construct new (intrinsically) purely gapless SPTs where there are no gapped sectors, hence are beyond the decorated defect construction. This construction elucidates the field theory description of the various gapless SPTs, and can also be applied to analytically study the stability of various gapless SPT models on the lattice under certain symmetric perturbations.

arXiv:2307.04788•SciPost Physics•May 13, 2025•99 citations
We provide a generalization of the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) framework to characterize phase transitions and gapless phases with categorical symmetries. The central tool is the club sandwich, which extends the SymTFT setup to include an interface between two topological orders: there is a symmetry boundary, which is gapped, and a physical boundary that may be gapless, but in addition, there is also a gapped interface in the middle. The club sandwich generalizes so-called Kennedy-Tasaki (KT) transformations. Building on the results in [L. Bhardwaj et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 161601 (2024); L. Bhardwaj et al., SciPost Phys. 18, 032 (2025)] on gapped phases with categorical symmetries, we construct gapless theories describing phase transitions with non-invertible symmetries by applying suitable KT transformations on known phase transitions provided by the critical Ising model and the 3-state Potts model. We also describe in detail the order parameters in these gapless theories characterizing the phase transitions, which are generally mixtures of conventional and string-type order parameters mixed together by the action of categorical symmetries. Additionally, removing the physical boundary from the club sandwiches results in club quiches, which characterize all possible gapped boundary phases with (possibly non-invertible) symmetries that can arise on the boundary of a bulk gapped phase. We also provide a mathematical characterization of gapped boundary phases with symmetries as pivotal tensor functors whose targets are pivotal multi-fusion categories.
The study of gapless phases with categorical (or so-called non-invertible) symmetries is a formidable task, in particular in higher than two space-time dimensions. In this paper we build on previous works [L. Bhardwaj et al. SciPost Phys. 19, 056 (2025); L. Bhardwaj et al. arXiv:2502.20440] on gapped phases in (2+1)d and provide a systematic framework to study phase transitions with categorical symmetries. The Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) is, as often in these matters, the central tool. Applied to gapless theories, we need to consider the extension of the SymTFT to interfaces between topological orders, so-called “club sandwiches”, which realize generalizations of so-called Kennedy-Tasaki (KT) transformations. This requires an input phase transition for a smaller symmetry, such as the Ising transition for \mathbb{Z}_2 ℤ 2 , and the SymTFT constructs a transformation to a gapless phase with a larger categorical symmetry. We carry this out for categorical symmetries whose SymTFT is a (3+1)d Dijkgraaf-Witten (DW) theory for a finite group G G with twist - so-called all bosonic fusion 2-categories. We classify such interfaces using a physically motivated picture of generalized gauging, as well as with a complementary analysis using (bi-)module 2-categories. This is exemplified in numerous Abelian and non-Abelian DW theories, giving rise to interesting gapless phases such as intrinsically gapless symmetry protected phases (igSPTs) and spontaneous symmetry breaking phases (igSSBs) from Abelian, S_3 S 3 , and D_8 D 8 DW theories.
We propose a general framework to characterize gapped infra-red (IR) phases of theories with non-invertible (or categorical) symmetries. In this paper we focus on (1+1)d gapped phases with fusion category symmetries. The approach that we propose uses the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) as a key input: associated to a field theory in d d spacetime dimensions, the SymTFT lives in one dimension higher and admits a gapped boundary, which realizes the categorical symmetries. It also admits a second, physical, boundary, which is generically not gapped. Upon interval compactification of the SymTFT by colliding the gapped and physical boundaries, we regain the original theory. In this paper, we realize gapped symmetric phases by choosing the physical boundary to be a gapped boundary condition as well. This set-up provides computational power to determine the number of vacua, the symmetry breaking pattern, and the action of the symmetry on the vacua. The SymTFT also manifestly encodes the order parameters for these gapped phases, thus providing a generalized, categorical Landau paradigm for (1+1)d gapped phases. We find that for non-invertible symmetries the order parameters involve multiplets containing both untwisted and twisted sector local operators, and hence can be interpreted as mixtures of conventional and string order parameters. We also observe that spontaneous breaking of non-invertible symmetries can lead to vacua that are physically distinguishable: unlike the standard symmetries described by groups, non-invertible symmetries can have different actions on different vacua of an irreducible gapped phase. This leads to the presence of relative Euler terms between physically distinct vacua. Along with the physical description of symmetric gapped phases, we also provide a mathematical one as pivotal 2-functors whose source 2-category is the delooping of the fusion category characterizing the symmetry and the target 2-category is the Euler completion of 2-vector spaces.
We study fermionic non-invertible symmetries in (1+1)d, which are generalized global symmetries that mix fermion parity symmetry with other invertible and non-invertible internal symmetries. Such symmetries are described by fermionic fusion supercategories, which are fusion \pi π -supercategories with a choice of fermion parity. The aim of this paper is to flesh out the categorical Landau paradigm for fermionic symmetries. We use the formalism of Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) to study possible gapped and gapless phases for such symmetries, along with possible deformations between these phases, which are organized into a Hasse phase diagram. The phases can be characterized in terms of sets of condensed, confined and deconfined generalized symmetry charges, reminiscent of notions familiar from superconductivity. Many of the gapless phases also serve as phase transitions between gapped phases. The associated fermionic conformal field theories (CFTs) can be obtained by performing generalized fermionic Kennedy-Tasaki (KT) transformations on bosonic CFTs describing simpler transitions. The fermionic non-invertible symmetries along with their charges and phases discussed here can be obtained from those of bosonic non-invertible symmetries via fermionization or Jordan-Wigner transformation, which is discussed in detail.
We discuss (1+1)d gapless phases with non-invertible global symmetries, also referred to as categorical symmetries. This includes gapless phases showing properties analogous to gapped symmetry protected topological (SPT) phases, known as gapless SPT (or gSPT) phases; and gapless phases showing properties analogous to gapped spontaneous symmetry broken (SSB) phases, that we refer to as gapless SSB (or gSSB) phases. We fit these gapless phases, along with gapped SPT and SSB phases, into a phase diagram describing possible deformations connecting them. This phase diagram is partially ordered and defines a so-called Hasse diagram. Based on these deformations, we identify gapless phases exhibiting symmetry protected criticality, that we refer to as intrinsically gapless SPT (igSPT) and intrinsically gapless SSB (igSSB) phases. This includes the first examples of igSPT and igSSB phases with non-invertible symmetries. Central to this analysis is the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT), where each phase corresponds to a condensable algebra in the Drinfeld center of the symmetry category. On a mathematical note, gSPT phases are classified by functors between fusion categories, generalizing the fact that gapped SPT phases are classified by fiber functors; and gSSB phases are classified by functors from fusion to multi-fusion categories. Finally, our framework can be applied to understand gauging of trivially acting non-invertible symmetries, including possible patterns of decomposition arising due to such gaugings.
A candidate reading of seven recent preprints from cond-mat.str-el and physics.atom-ph suggests that the classical toolkit for classifying gapped phases and their transitions—built on Landau symmetry breaking, local order parameters, and invertible group symmetries—requires systematic extension at the level of microscopic algebraic structure, not merely at the phenomenological level. The emerging picture, drawn from the corpus, is that *generalized symmetries* (non-invertible, categorical, and higher-form) impose precise algebraic constraints on what constitutes a valid order parameter, what boundary conditions are permissible, and which phase transitions can occur without any form of spontaneous symmetry breaking, even after arbitrary gauging. Concretely: (i) condensable algebras in 2+1d topological orders classify gapped boundaries, and twin algebras sharing identical anyon content but inequivalent algebra structure describe physically distinct phases with isomorphic ground-state degeneracy but inequivalent order parameters [corpus:arxiv:2605.31602]; (ii) these twin phases can undergo direct transitions that are provably beyond-Landau even after partial gauging [corpus:arxiv:2605.31601]; (iii) string order parameters in 1d systems organize into Lagrangian algebras in the Drinfel'd center of the symmetry category, making the fusion rule of the symmetry category—not just its representation theory—the operative diagnostic [corpus:arxiv:2605.27193]; (iv) non-invertible symmetry-breaking transitions can be mapped via generalized gauging to deconfined quantum critical points, and vice versa, establishing a precise duality [corpus:arxiv:2605.27672]; and (v) non-invertible symmetry enriched topological orders (NI-SETOs) can be constructed from string-net models, extending symmetry enrichment beyond the group-theoretic setting [corpus:arxiv:2605.28794]. Two additional corpus entries—a Rydberg spin-chain study [corpus:arxiv:2605.27166] and a topological lattice gauge theory paper [corpus:arxiv:2605.28688]—provide microscopic anchoring and structural context, respectively. The central falsification path is explicit: if a twin-phase transition can be shown to spontaneously break some hidden symmetry after arbitrary gauging, the framework collapses. Concrete tensor-network (DMRG/MPS) constructions of twin-phase order parameters in 1+1d would constitute a direct test. --- Authorship: Saluca Agentic AI Research Team (Saluca LLC). AI-drafted from arXiv preprint corpus on the date in the filename. Cited arXiv preprints: 2605.27166, 2605.27193, 2605.27672, 2605.28688, 2605.28794, 2605.29745, 2605.29875, 2605.30421, 2605.31185, 2605.31540, 2605.31601, 2605.31602
The Kennedy-Tasaki (KT) transformation was used to construct the gapped symmetry protected topological (SPT) phase from the symmetry breaking phase with open boundary condition, and was generalized in our proceeding work [Phys. Rev. B 108, 214429 (2023)] on a ring by sacrificing the unitarity, and should be understood as a non-invertible duality transformation. In this work, we further apply the KT transformation to systematically construct gapless symmetry protected topological phases. This construction reproduces the known examples of (intrinsically) gapless SPT where the non-trivial topological features come from the gapped sectors by means of decorated defect constructions. We also construct new (intrinsically) purely gapless SPTs where there are no gapped sectors, hence are beyond the decorated defect construction. This construction elucidates the field theory description of the various gapless SPTs, and can also be applied to analytically study the stability of various gapless SPT models on the lattice under certain symmetric perturbations.