Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2312.13372 · Physical Review Letters

Nonequilibrium Criticality at the Onset of Time-Crystalline Order

Romain Daviet, Carl Philipp Zelle, Achim Rosch, Sebastian Diehl

Published Apr 19, 2024• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We explore the phase transitions at the onset of time-crystalline order in O(N) models driven out of equilibrium. The spontaneous breaking of time translation symmetry and its Goldstone mode are captured by an effective description with O(N)×SO(2) symmetry, where the emergent external SO(2) results from a transmutation of the internal symmetry of time translations. Using the renormalization group and the ε=4-d expansion in a leading two-loop analysis, we identify a new nonequilibrium universality class. Strikingly, it controls the long-distance physics no matter how small the microscopic breaking of equilibrium conditions is. The O(N=2)×SO(2) symmetry group is realized for magnon condensation in pumped yttrium iron garnet films and in exciton-polariton systems with a polarization degree of freedom.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.132.167102

Related papers

Far-from-equilibrium scaling of non-abelian Goldstone modes

Carl Philipp Zelle, Gustav John, Orla Supple +2 more

We identify a broad class of nonthermal phases generated by the interplay of continuous symmetry breaking and weak nonequilibrium driving. Extending Kardar-Parisi-Zhang (KPZ) physics beyond the single $SO(2)$ chronon associated with periodically broken time translations, we construct nonequilibrium nonlinear sigma models for $SO(2)\times O(N)$ symmetry, describing non-Abelian time crystals with coexisting temporal and internal order. This symmetry structure arises naturally in driven quantum materials, active matter, and optically induced periodic states. For rotating and oscillating phases, we derive the Goldstone theories and show that chronon-$O(N)$ couplings remain finite deep in the ordered regime. One-loop renormalization group analysis reveals a KPZ-like dimensional structure: in $d=1,2$, arbitrarily weak nonequilibrium perturbations destabilize the equilibrium fixed point and generate strongly coupled nonthermal fixed points, realizing emergent equilibrium breaking. By contrast, for $d > 2$, weak perturbations are irrelevant and effective equilibrium is restored. A central result is unconventional weak dynamic scaling in the rotating phase: strongly coupled Goldstone sectors acquire distinct universal dynamical exponents despite belonging to the same order parameter. We characterize this scaling analytically and corroborate it through direct simulations in $1+1$ dimensions. In the oscillating phase, we recover and extend weak-scaling regimes known from drifting polymers. Finally, compactness and topological defects ultimately destroy long-range order but leave experimentally accessible nonthermal scaling windows. Together, these results extend KPZ universality to non-Abelian symmetry breaking.

arXiv:2608.13666•Aug 13, 2026•1 citation

Kardar-Parisi-Zhang Scaling in Time-Crystalline Matter

Romain Daviet, Carl Philipp Zelle, Armin Asadollahi +1 more

We discuss the universal behavior linked to the Goldstone mode associated with the spontaneous breaking of time-translation symmetry in many-body systems, in which the order parameter traces out a limit cycle. We show that this universal behavior is closely tied to Kardar-Parisi-Zhang physics, which can strongly affect the scaling properties in all dimensions. Our Letter predicts and rationalizes the emergence of Kardar-Parisi-Zhang in numerous systems such as nonreciprocal phases in active matter, active magnets, driven-dissipative quantum systems, and synchronization of oscillators.

arXiv:2412.09677•Physical Review Letters•Jun 5, 2025•20 citations

Nonequilibrium orders in parametrically driven field theories

Carl Philipp Zelle, Romain Daviet, Andrew J. Millis +1 more

Driving quantum materials with coherent light has proven a powerful platform to realize a plethora of interesting phases and transitions, ranging from ferroelectricity to superconductivity and limit cycles in pumped magnonics. In this paper we develop the field theoretical framework to describe nonequilibrium phases that emerge in systems pumped by rapid parametric drives. We consider paradigmatic O(N) models that describe the long-wavelength fluctuations of ordering fields in many condensed matter set ups. We show that rapid parametric driving of these models can induce an effective pump mechanism in the long wavelength regime through nonlinear scattering. This induces a nonequilibrium transition into a time-crystalline phase.

arXiv:2506.18622•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 25, 2026•3 citations

Universal Phenomenology at Critical Exceptional Points of Nonequilibrium O ( N ) Models

Carl Philipp Zelle, Romain Daviet, Achim Rosch +1 more

In thermal equilibrium the dynamics of phase transitions is largely controlled by fluctuation-dissipation relations: On the one hand, friction suppresses fluctuations, while on the other hand, the thermal noise is proportional to friction constants. Out of equilibrium, this balance dissolves and one can have situations where friction vanishes due to antidamping in the presence of a finite noise level. We study a wide class of O ( N ) field theories where this situation is realized at a phase transition, which we identify as a critical exceptional point. In the ordered phase, antidamping induces a continuous limit cycle rotation of the order parameter with an enhanced number of 2 N − 3 Goldstone modes. Close to the critical exceptional point, however, fluctuations diverge so strongly due to the suppression of friction that in dimensions d < 4 they universally either destroy a preexisting static order or give rise to a fluctuation-induced first-order transition. This is demonstrated within a full resummation of loop corrections via Dyson-Schwinger equations for N = 2 , and a generalization for arbitrary N , which can be solved in the long wavelength limit. We show that in order to realize this physics it is not necessary to drive a system far out of equilibrium: Using the peculiar protection of Goldstone modes, the transition from an x y magnet to a ferrimagnet is governed by an exceptional critical point once weakly perturbed away from thermal equilibrium. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2304.09207•Physical Review X•Jun 26, 2024•40 citations

Emergent Nambu-Goldstone phase of Z q model from dynamics

Minghui Hu, Yanan Sun, Dajun Zhang +1 more

Using extensive simulations, we study the dynamic critical phenomena of the Z_{q} model in an oscillating field. We find Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions for q=6 in two dimensions and a first-order transition for q=3 in three dimensions, hence the equilibrium-nonequilibrium correspondence is conditionally validated. Surprisingly, the correspondence is apparently violated at q=5, 6, and 7 in three dimensions, for which the equilibrium and nonequilibrium scenarios feature a single transition and two transitions, respectively. In the nonequilibrium case, the discrete q-fold order is washed away by the first dynamic transition at the period P_{z} of the oscillating field, where an O(2) symmetry-breaking Nambu-Goldstone phase starts to emerge, persisting up to a higher period P_{o}. The dynamic transition at P_{o} falls into the O(2) critical universality class. We relate the highly nontrivial dynamic behaviors to the two-length criticality arising from dangerously irrelevant fields and find that the dynamics decode the extremely subtle equilibrium criticality. Our findings significantly expand the current understanding of emergent phenomena and offer a promising methodology for elucidating critical phenomena that are notoriously challenging.

Physical review. E•Dec 19, 2024•1 citation

Emergent Dynamical Translational Symmetry Breaking as an Order Principle for Localization and Topological Transitions

Yucheng Wang

Localization transitions represent a fundamental class of continuous phase transitions, yet they occur without any accompanying symmetry breaking. We resolve this by introducing the concept of dynamical translational symmetry (DTS), which is defined not by the Hamiltonian but by the long-time dynamics of local observables. Its order parameter, the time-averaged local translational contrast (TLTC), quantitatively diagnoses whether evolution restores or breaks translational equivalence. We demonstrate that the TLTC universally captures the Anderson localization transition, the many-body localization transition, and topological phase transitions, revealing that these disparate phenomena are unified by the emergent breaking of DTS. This work establishes a unified dynamical-symmetry framework for phases transitions beyond the equilibrium paradigm.

cond-mat.dis-nnCross-listedarXiv:2511.04360•Nov 7, 2025•1 citation
We explore the phase transitions at the onset of time-crystalline order in O(N) models driven out of equilibrium. The spontaneous breaking of time translation symmetry and its Goldstone mode are captured by an effective description with O(N)×SO(2) symmetry, where the emergent external SO(2) results from a transmutation of the internal symmetry of time translations. Using the renormalization group and the ε=4-d expansion in a leading two-loop analysis, we identify a new nonequilibrium universality class. Strikingly, it controls the long-distance physics no matter how small the microscopic breaking of equilibrium conditions is. The O(N=2)×SO(2) symmetry group is realized for magnon condensation in pumped yttrium iron garnet films and in exciton-polariton systems with a polarization degree of freedom.
We identify a broad class of nonthermal phases generated by the interplay of continuous symmetry breaking and weak nonequilibrium driving. Extending Kardar-Parisi-Zhang (KPZ) physics beyond the single SO(2)SO(2)SO(2) chronon associated with periodically broken time translations, we construct nonequilibrium nonlinear sigma models for SO(2)×O(N)SO(2)\times O(N)SO(2)×O(N) symmetry, describing non-Abelian time crystals with coexisting temporal and internal order. This symmetry structure arises naturally in driven quantum materials, active matter, and optically induced periodic states. For rotating and oscillating phases, we derive the Goldstone theories and show that chronon-O(N)O(N)O(N) couplings remain finite deep in the ordered regime. One-loop renormalization group analysis reveals a KPZ-like dimensional structure: in d=1,2d=1,2d=1,2, arbitrarily weak nonequilibrium perturbations destabilize the equilibrium fixed point and generate strongly coupled nonthermal fixed points, realizing emergent equilibrium breaking. By contrast, for d>2d > 2d>2, weak perturbations are irrelevant and effective equilibrium is restored. A central result is unconventional weak dynamic scaling in the rotating phase: strongly coupled Goldstone sectors acquire distinct universal dynamical exponents despite belonging to the same order parameter. We characterize this scaling analytically and corroborate it through direct simulations in 1+11+11+1 dimensions. In the oscillating phase, we recover and extend weak-scaling regimes known from drifting polymers. Finally, compactness and topological defects ultimately destroy long-range order but leave experimentally accessible nonthermal scaling windows. Together, these results extend KPZ universality to non-Abelian symmetry breaking.
We discuss the universal behavior linked to the Goldstone mode associated with the spontaneous breaking of time-translation symmetry in many-body systems, in which the order parameter traces out a limit cycle. We show that this universal behavior is closely tied to Kardar-Parisi-Zhang physics, which can strongly affect the scaling properties in all dimensions. Our Letter predicts and rationalizes the emergence of Kardar-Parisi-Zhang in numerous systems such as nonreciprocal phases in active matter, active magnets, driven-dissipative quantum systems, and synchronization of oscillators.
Driving quantum materials with coherent light has proven a powerful platform to realize a plethora of interesting phases and transitions, ranging from ferroelectricity to superconductivity and limit cycles in pumped magnonics. In this paper we develop the field theoretical framework to describe nonequilibrium phases that emerge in systems pumped by rapid parametric drives. We consider paradigmatic O(N) models that describe the long-wavelength fluctuations of ordering fields in many condensed matter set ups. We show that rapid parametric driving of these models can induce an effective pump mechanism in the long wavelength regime through nonlinear scattering. This induces a nonequilibrium transition into a time-crystalline phase.
In thermal equilibrium the dynamics of phase transitions is largely controlled by fluctuation-dissipation relations: On the one hand, friction suppresses fluctuations, while on the other hand, the thermal noise is proportional to friction constants. Out of equilibrium, this balance dissolves and one can have situations where friction vanishes due to antidamping in the presence of a finite noise level. We study a wide class of O ( N ) field theories where this situation is realized at a phase transition, which we identify as a critical exceptional point. In the ordered phase, antidamping induces a continuous limit cycle rotation of the order parameter with an enhanced number of 2 N − 3 Goldstone modes. Close to the critical exceptional point, however, fluctuations diverge so strongly due to the suppression of friction that in dimensions d < 4 they universally either destroy a preexisting static order or give rise to a fluctuation-induced first-order transition. This is demonstrated within a full resummation of loop corrections via Dyson-Schwinger equations for N = 2 , and a generalization for arbitrary N , which can be solved in the long wavelength limit. We show that in order to realize this physics it is not necessary to drive a system far out of equilibrium: Using the peculiar protection of Goldstone modes, the transition from an x y magnet to a ferrimagnet is governed by an exceptional critical point once weakly perturbed away from thermal equilibrium. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Using extensive simulations, we study the dynamic critical phenomena of the Z_{q} model in an oscillating field. We find Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions for q=6 in two dimensions and a first-order transition for q=3 in three dimensions, hence the equilibrium-nonequilibrium correspondence is conditionally validated. Surprisingly, the correspondence is apparently violated at q=5, 6, and 7 in three dimensions, for which the equilibrium and nonequilibrium scenarios feature a single transition and two transitions, respectively. In the nonequilibrium case, the discrete q-fold order is washed away by the first dynamic transition at the period P_{z} of the oscillating field, where an O(2) symmetry-breaking Nambu-Goldstone phase starts to emerge, persisting up to a higher period P_{o}. The dynamic transition at P_{o} falls into the O(2) critical universality class. We relate the highly nontrivial dynamic behaviors to the two-length criticality arising from dangerously irrelevant fields and find that the dynamics decode the extremely subtle equilibrium criticality. Our findings significantly expand the current understanding of emergent phenomena and offer a promising methodology for elucidating critical phenomena that are notoriously challenging.
Localization transitions represent a fundamental class of continuous phase transitions, yet they occur without any accompanying symmetry breaking. We resolve this by introducing the concept of dynamical translational symmetry (DTS), which is defined not by the Hamiltonian but by the long-time dynamics of local observables. Its order parameter, the time-averaged local translational contrast (TLTC), quantitatively diagnoses whether evolution restores or breaks translational equivalence. We demonstrate that the TLTC universally captures the Anderson localization transition, the many-body localization transition, and topological phase transitions, revealing that these disparate phenomena are unified by the emergent breaking of DTS. This work establishes a unified dynamical-symmetry framework for phases transitions beyond the equilibrium paradigm.