Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2311.18290 · Journal of High Energy Physics

Constrained HRT Surfaces and their Entropic Interpretation

Xi Dong, Donald M. Marolf, Pratik Rath

Published Feb 21, 2024• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Consider two boundary subregions A and B that lie in a common boundary Cauchy surface, and consider also the associated HRT surface γ B for B. In that context, the constrained HRT surface γ A:B can be defined as the codimension-2 bulk surface anchored to A that is obtained by a maximin construction restricted to Cauchy slices containing γ B . As a result, γ A:B is the union of two pieces, $$ {\gamma}_{A:B}^B $$ γ A : B B and $$ {\gamma}_{A:B}^{\overline{B}} $$ γ A : B B ¯ lying respectively in the entanglement wedges of B and its complement $$ \overline{B} $$ B ¯ . Unlike the area $$ \mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_A\right) $$ A γ A of the HRT surface γ A , at least in the semiclassical limit, the area $$ \mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_{A:B}\right) $$ A γ A : B of γ A:B commutes with the area $$ \mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_B\right) $$ A γ B of γ B . To study the entropic interpretation of $$ \mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_{A:B}\right) $$ A γ A : B , we analyze the Rényi entropies of subregion A in a fixed-area state of subregion B. We use the gravitational path integral to show that the n ≈ 1 Rényi entropies are then computed by minimizing $$ \mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_A\right) $$ A γ A over spacetimes defined by a boost angle conjugate to $$ \mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_B\right) $$ A γ B . In the case where the pieces $$ {\gamma}_{A:B}^B $$ γ A : B B and $$ {\gamma}_{A:B}^{\overline{B}} $$ γ A : B B ¯ intersect at a constant boost angle, a geometric argument shows that the n ≈ 1 Rényi entropy is then given by $$ \frac{\mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_{A:B}\right)}{4G} $$ A γ A : B 4 G

DOI
10.1007/jhep02(2024)151

Related papers

Modular flow as a disentangler

Yiming Chen, Xi Dong, Aitor Lewkowycz +1 more

Abstract In holographic duality, the entanglement entropy of a boundary region is proposed to be dual to the area of an extremal codimension-2 surface that is homologous to the boundary region, known as the Hubeny-Rangamani-Takayanagi (HRT) surface. In this paper, we study when the HRT surfaces of two boundary subregions R, A are in the same Cauchy slice. This condition is necessary for the subregion-subregion mapping to be local for both subregions and for states to have a tensor network description. To quantify this, we study the area of a surface that is homologous to A and is extremal except at possible intersections with the HRT surface of R (minimizing over all such possible surfaces), which we call the constrained area. We give a boundary proposal for an upper bound of this quantity, a bound which is saturated when the constrained surface intersects the HRT surface of R at a constant angle. This boundary quantity is the minimum entropy of region A in a modular evolved state — a state that has been evolved unitarily with the modular Hamiltonian of R. We can prove this formula in two boundary dimensions or when the modular Hamiltonian is local. This modular minimal entropy is a boundary quantity that probes bulk causality and, from this quantity, we can extract whether two HRT surfaces are in the future or past of each other. These entropies satisfy some inequalities reminiscent of strong subadditivity and can be used to remove certain corner divergences.

arXiv:1806.09622•Journal of High Energy Physics•Dec 1, 2018•35 citations

Link-area commutators in AdS3 area-networks

Jesse Held, Molly Kaplan, Donald M. Marolf +1 more

A bstract Random tensor networks (RTNs) have proved to be fruitful tools for modelling the AdS/CFT correspondence. Due to their flat entanglement spectra, when discussing a given boundary region R and its complement $$ \overline{R} $$ R ¯ , standard RTNs are most analogous to fixed-area states of the bulk quantum gravity theory, in which quantum fluctuations have been suppressed for the area of the corresponding HRT surface. However, such RTNs have flat entanglement spectra for all choices of R, $$ \overline{R} $$ R ¯ , while quantum fluctuations of multiple HRT-areas can be suppressed only when the corresponding HRT-area operators mutually commute. We probe the severity of such obstructions in pure AdS 3 Einstein-Hilbert gravity by constructing networks whose links are codimension-2 extremal-surfaces and by explicitly computing semiclassical commutators of the associated link-areas. Since d = 3, codimension-2 extremal-surfaces are geodesics, and codimension-2 ‘areas’ are lengths. We find a simple 4-link network defined by an HRT surface and a Chen-Dong-Lewkowycz-Qi constrained HRT surface for which all link-areas commute. However, the algebra generated by the link-areas of more general networks tends to be non-Abelian. One such non-Abelian example is associated with entanglement-wedge cross sections and may be of more general interest.

arXiv:2401.02487•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jul 30, 2024•4 citations

Rényi entropies and area operator from gravity with Hayward term

Marcelo Botta-Cantcheff, Pedro J. Martínez, Juan F. Zarate

Abstract In the context of the holographic duality, the entanglement entropy of ordinary QFT in a subregion in the boundary is given by a quarter of the area of an minimal surface embedded in the bulk spacetime. This rule has been also extended to a suitable one-parameter generalization of the von-Neuman entropy Ŝn that is related to the Rényi entropies Sn, as given by the area of a cosmic brane minimally coupled with gravity, with a tension related to n that vanishes as n → 1, and moreover, this parameter can be analytically extended to arbitrary real values. However, the brane action plays no role in the duality and cannot be considered a part of the theory of gravity, thus it is used as an auxiliary tool to find the correct background geometry. In this work we study the construction of the gravitational (reduced) density matrix from holographic states, whose wave-functionals are described as euclidean path integrals with arbitrary conditions on the asymptotic boundaries, and argue that in general, a non-trivial Hayward term must be haven into account. So we propose that the gravity model with a coupled Nambu-Goto action is not an artificial tool to account for the Rényi entropies, but it is present in the own gravity action through a Hayward term. As a result we show that the computations using replicas simplify considerably and we recover the holographic prescriptions for the measures of entanglement entropy; in particular, derive an area law for the original Rényi entropies (Sn) related to a minimal surface in the n replicated spacetime. Moreover, we show that the gravitational modular flow contains the area operator and can explain the Jafferis-Lewkowycz-Maldacena-Suh proposal.

arXiv:2005.11338•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jul 1, 2020•13 citations

The gravity dual of Rényi entropy

Xi Dong

A remarkable yet mysterious property of black holes is that their entropy is proportional to the horizon area. This area law inspired the holographic principle, which was later realized concretely in gauge-gravity duality. In this context, entanglement entropy is given by the area of a minimal surface in a dual spacetime. However, discussions of area laws have been constrained to entanglement entropy, whereas a full understanding of a quantum state requires Rényi entropies. Here we show that all Rényi entropies satisfy a similar area law in holographic theories and are given by the areas of dual cosmic branes. This geometric prescription is a one-parameter generalization of the minimal surface prescription for entanglement entropy. Applying this we provide the first holographic calculation of mutual Rényi information between two disks of arbitrary dimension. Our results provide a framework for efficiently studying Rényi entropies and understanding entanglement structures in strongly coupled systems and quantum gravity.

arXiv:1601.06788•Nature Communications•Aug 12, 2016•381 citations

Multi-entropy at low Renyi index in 2d CFTs

Jonathan Harper, Tadashi Takayanagi B, Takashi Tsuda

For a static time slice of AdS _3 3 we describe a particular class of minimal surfaces which form trivalent networks of geodesics. Through geometric arguments we provide evidence that these surfaces describe a measure of multipartite entanglement. By relating these surfaces to Ryu-Takayanagi surfaces it can be shown that this multipartite contribution is related to the angles of intersection of the bulk geodesics. A proposed boundary dual [Phys. Rev. D 106, 126001 (2022), J. High Energy Phys. 08, 202 (2023), J. High Energy Phys. 05, 008 (2023)], the multi-entropy, generalizes replica trick calculations involving twist operators by considering monodromies with finite group symmetry beyond the cyclic group used for the computation of entanglement entropy. We make progress by providing explicit calculations of Renyi multi-entropy in two dimensional CFTs and geometric descriptions of the replica surfaces for several cases with low genus. We also explore aspects of the free fermion and free scalar CFTs. For the free fermion CFT we examine subtleties in the definition of the twist operators used for the calculation of Renyi multi-entropy. In particular the standard bosonization procedure used for the calculation of the usual entanglement entropy fails and a different treatment is required.

arXiv:2401.04236•SciPost Physics•May 13, 2024•41 citations

Towards bit threads in general gravitational spacetimes

Dong-Hui Du, Jia-Rui Sun

A bstract The concept of the generalized entanglement wedge was recently proposed by Bousso and Penington, which states that any bulk gravitational region a possesses an associated generalized entanglement wedge E ( a ) ⊃ a on a static Cauchy surface M in general gravitational spacetimes, where E ( a ) may contain an entanglement island I ( a ). It suggests that the fine-grained entropy for bulk region a is given by the generalized entropy S gen ( E ( a )). Motivated by this proposal, we extend the quantum bit thread description to general gravitational spacetimes, no longer limited to the AdS spacetime. By utilizing the convex optimization techniques, a dual flow description for the generalized entropy S gen ( E ( a )) of a bulk gravitational region a is established on the static Cauchy surface M , such that S gen ( E ( a )) is equal to the maximum flux of any flow that starts from the boundary ∂M and ends at bulk region a , or equivalently, the maximum number of bit threads that connect the boundary ∂M to the bulk region a . In addition, the nesting property of flows is also proved. Thus the basic properties of the entropy for bulk regions, i.e. the monotonicity, subadditivity, Araki-Lieb inequality and strong subadditivity, can be verified from flow perspectives by using properties of flows, such as the nesting property. Moreover, in max thread configurations, we find that there exists some lower bounds on the bulk entanglement entropy of matter fields in the region E ( a ) \ a , particularly on an entanglement island region I ( a ) ⊂ ( E ( a ) \ a ), as required by the existence of a nontrivial generalized entanglement wedge. Our quantum bit thread formulation may provide a way to investigate more fine-grained entanglement structures in general spacetimes.

arXiv:2406.04092•Journal of High Energy Physics•Aug 5, 2024•5 citations
Abstract Consider two boundary subregions A and B that lie in a common boundary Cauchy surface, and consider also the associated HRT surface γ B for B. In that context, the constrained HRT surface γ A:B can be defined as the codimension-2 bulk surface anchored to A that is obtained by a maximin construction restricted to Cauchy slices containing γ B . As a result, γ A:B is the union of two pieces, γA:BB{\gamma}_{A:B}^BγA:BB​ γ A : B B and γA:BB‾{\gamma}_{A:B}^{\overline{B}}γA:BB​ γ A : B B ¯ lying respectively in the entanglement wedges of B and its complement B‾\overline{B}B B ¯ . Unlike the area A(γA)\mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_A\right)A(γA​) A γ A of the HRT surface γ A , at least in the semiclassical limit, the area A(γA:B)\mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_{A:B}\right)A(γA:B​) A γ A : B of γ A:B commutes with the area A(γB)\mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_B\right)A(γB​) A γ B of γ B . To study the entropic interpretation of A(γA:B)\mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_{A:B}\right)A(γA:B​) A γ A : B , we analyze the Rényi entropies of subregion A in a fixed-area state of subregion B. We use the gravitational path integral to show that the n ≈ 1 Rényi entropies are then computed by minimizing A(γA)\mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_A\right)A(γA​) A γ A over spacetimes defined by a boost angle conjugate to A(γB)\mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_B\right)A(γB​) A γ B . In the case where the pieces γA:BB{\gamma}_{A:B}^BγA:BB​ γ A : B B and γA:BB‾{\gamma}_{A:B}^{\overline{B}}γA:BB​ γ A : B B ¯ intersect at a constant boost angle, a geometric argument shows that the n ≈ 1 Rényi entropy is then given by A(γA:B)4G\frac{\mathcal{A}\left({\gamma}_{A:B}\right)}{4G}4GA(γA:B​)​ A γ A : B 4 G
Abstract In holographic duality, the entanglement entropy of a boundary region is proposed to be dual to the area of an extremal codimension-2 surface that is homologous to the boundary region, known as the Hubeny-Rangamani-Takayanagi (HRT) surface. In this paper, we study when the HRT surfaces of two boundary subregions R, A are in the same Cauchy slice. This condition is necessary for the subregion-subregion mapping to be local for both subregions and for states to have a tensor network description. To quantify this, we study the area of a surface that is homologous to A and is extremal except at possible intersections with the HRT surface of R (minimizing over all such possible surfaces), which we call the constrained area. We give a boundary proposal for an upper bound of this quantity, a bound which is saturated when the constrained surface intersects the HRT surface of R at a constant angle. This boundary quantity is the minimum entropy of region A in a modular evolved state — a state that has been evolved unitarily with the modular Hamiltonian of R. We can prove this formula in two boundary dimensions or when the modular Hamiltonian is local. This modular minimal entropy is a boundary quantity that probes bulk causality and, from this quantity, we can extract whether two HRT surfaces are in the future or past of each other. These entropies satisfy some inequalities reminiscent of strong subadditivity and can be used to remove certain corner divergences.
A bstract Random tensor networks (RTNs) have proved to be fruitful tools for modelling the AdS/CFT correspondence. Due to their flat entanglement spectra, when discussing a given boundary region R and its complement R‾ \overline{R} R R ¯ , standard RTNs are most analogous to fixed-area states of the bulk quantum gravity theory, in which quantum fluctuations have been suppressed for the area of the corresponding HRT surface. However, such RTNs have flat entanglement spectra for all choices of R, R‾ \overline{R} R R ¯ , while quantum fluctuations of multiple HRT-areas can be suppressed only when the corresponding HRT-area operators mutually commute. We probe the severity of such obstructions in pure AdS 3 Einstein-Hilbert gravity by constructing networks whose links are codimension-2 extremal-surfaces and by explicitly computing semiclassical commutators of the associated link-areas. Since d = 3, codimension-2 extremal-surfaces are geodesics, and codimension-2 ‘areas’ are lengths. We find a simple 4-link network defined by an HRT surface and a Chen-Dong-Lewkowycz-Qi constrained HRT surface for which all link-areas commute. However, the algebra generated by the link-areas of more general networks tends to be non-Abelian. One such non-Abelian example is associated with entanglement-wedge cross sections and may be of more general interest.
Abstract In the context of the holographic duality, the entanglement entropy of ordinary QFT in a subregion in the boundary is given by a quarter of the area of an minimal surface embedded in the bulk spacetime. This rule has been also extended to a suitable one-parameter generalization of the von-Neuman entropy Ŝn that is related to the Rényi entropies Sn, as given by the area of a cosmic brane minimally coupled with gravity, with a tension related to n that vanishes as n → 1, and moreover, this parameter can be analytically extended to arbitrary real values. However, the brane action plays no role in the duality and cannot be considered a part of the theory of gravity, thus it is used as an auxiliary tool to find the correct background geometry. In this work we study the construction of the gravitational (reduced) density matrix from holographic states, whose wave-functionals are described as euclidean path integrals with arbitrary conditions on the asymptotic boundaries, and argue that in general, a non-trivial Hayward term must be haven into account. So we propose that the gravity model with a coupled Nambu-Goto action is not an artificial tool to account for the Rényi entropies, but it is present in the own gravity action through a Hayward term. As a result we show that the computations using replicas simplify considerably and we recover the holographic prescriptions for the measures of entanglement entropy; in particular, derive an area law for the original Rényi entropies (Sn) related to a minimal surface in the n replicated spacetime. Moreover, we show that the gravitational modular flow contains the area operator and can explain the Jafferis-Lewkowycz-Maldacena-Suh proposal.
A remarkable yet mysterious property of black holes is that their entropy is proportional to the horizon area. This area law inspired the holographic principle, which was later realized concretely in gauge-gravity duality. In this context, entanglement entropy is given by the area of a minimal surface in a dual spacetime. However, discussions of area laws have been constrained to entanglement entropy, whereas a full understanding of a quantum state requires Rényi entropies. Here we show that all Rényi entropies satisfy a similar area law in holographic theories and are given by the areas of dual cosmic branes. This geometric prescription is a one-parameter generalization of the minimal surface prescription for entanglement entropy. Applying this we provide the first holographic calculation of mutual Rényi information between two disks of arbitrary dimension. Our results provide a framework for efficiently studying Rényi entropies and understanding entanglement structures in strongly coupled systems and quantum gravity.
For a static time slice of AdS _3 3 we describe a particular class of minimal surfaces which form trivalent networks of geodesics. Through geometric arguments we provide evidence that these surfaces describe a measure of multipartite entanglement. By relating these surfaces to Ryu-Takayanagi surfaces it can be shown that this multipartite contribution is related to the angles of intersection of the bulk geodesics. A proposed boundary dual [Phys. Rev. D 106, 126001 (2022), J. High Energy Phys. 08, 202 (2023), J. High Energy Phys. 05, 008 (2023)], the multi-entropy, generalizes replica trick calculations involving twist operators by considering monodromies with finite group symmetry beyond the cyclic group used for the computation of entanglement entropy. We make progress by providing explicit calculations of Renyi multi-entropy in two dimensional CFTs and geometric descriptions of the replica surfaces for several cases with low genus. We also explore aspects of the free fermion and free scalar CFTs. For the free fermion CFT we examine subtleties in the definition of the twist operators used for the calculation of Renyi multi-entropy. In particular the standard bosonization procedure used for the calculation of the usual entanglement entropy fails and a different treatment is required.
A bstract The concept of the generalized entanglement wedge was recently proposed by Bousso and Penington, which states that any bulk gravitational region a possesses an associated generalized entanglement wedge E ( a ) ⊃ a on a static Cauchy surface M in general gravitational spacetimes, where E ( a ) may contain an entanglement island I ( a ). It suggests that the fine-grained entropy for bulk region a is given by the generalized entropy S gen ( E ( a )). Motivated by this proposal, we extend the quantum bit thread description to general gravitational spacetimes, no longer limited to the AdS spacetime. By utilizing the convex optimization techniques, a dual flow description for the generalized entropy S gen ( E ( a )) of a bulk gravitational region a is established on the static Cauchy surface M , such that S gen ( E ( a )) is equal to the maximum flux of any flow that starts from the boundary ∂M and ends at bulk region a , or equivalently, the maximum number of bit threads that connect the boundary ∂M to the bulk region a . In addition, the nesting property of flows is also proved. Thus the basic properties of the entropy for bulk regions, i.e. the monotonicity, subadditivity, Araki-Lieb inequality and strong subadditivity, can be verified from flow perspectives by using properties of flows, such as the nesting property. Moreover, in max thread configurations, we find that there exists some lower bounds on the bulk entanglement entropy of matter fields in the region E ( a ) \ a , particularly on an entanglement island region I ( a ) ⊂ ( E ( a ) \ a ), as required by the existence of a nontrivial generalized entanglement wedge. Our quantum bit thread formulation may provide a way to investigate more fine-grained entanglement structures in general spacetimes.