Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2311.14914

A Replica-BCS theory for dirty superconductors

Yat Fan Lau, Tai Kai Ng

Published Nov 25, 2023• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we revisit the problem of dirty superconductors using a replica-symmetric BCS (RS-BCS) theory. We apply the RS-BCS theory to dirty superconductor grains of size $L^d$, where $L$ is the localization length and $d$ is the dimension of the system, assuming that the macroscopic system is composed of weakly coupled grains. Besides disordered potential, We also consider the case where regions with opposite signs of interaction exist in the grains, with net attractive interaction between electrons. Within the RS-BCS mean field theory, the system phase diagram, single-particle tunneling density of states and the superfluid density are computed within the RS-BCS theory for different strengths of disorder, We show that our result agrees qualitatively with previous numerical studies in the case with pure attractive interaction, and that a Cooper-pair-glass state may exist when regions with opposite sign of interaction exists and the net interaction between electrons is close to zero. The plausible relevance of our result to the anomalous metal state is discussed.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2311.14914

Related papers

Quantum Theory of Disordered Superconductors - A Replica Approach

Yat Fan Lau

Motivated by the experimental observations of the anomalous metal states in many superconducting thin films systems, this thesis studies the interplay of disorder and interactions in superconductivity. We first demonstrate that the Fermi glass ground state is unstable in first-order perturbation theory under weak, short-ranged interaction, provided all states are localized. This finding elucidates why methods like the Hartree-Fock approximation are adequate to explain local moment formation in repulsive interactions. We then revisit the problem of dirty superconductors using a replica-symmetric BCS (RS-BCS) theory. We apply RS-BCS theory to disordered superconducting grains within the localization length, assuming the macroscopic system consists of weakly coupled grains. Besides disordered potential, We also consider regions with opposite signs of interaction exist in the grains, with net attractive interaction between electrons. Using RS-BCS mean field theory, we compute the phase diagram, tunneling density of states, and superfluid density across disorder strengths. Our results qualitatively agree with prior numerical studies for purely attractive interactions, and suggest a possible Cooper-pair-glass state when interactions of opposite signs nearly cancel.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

BCS-Bose model of exotic superconductors: Generalized coherence length

Montserrat Casas, J. M. Getino, MANUEL DE LLANO +4 more

Analytic expressions are derived for the root-mean-square (rms) radius of a pair of fermions in a BCS many-fermion state in one, two, and three dimensions, in terms of the BCS gap energy and the associated chemical potential. These expressions are valid for any coupling strength of any pair interaction model implying a momentum-independent gap energy. The latter holds, e.g., for an attractive \ensuremath{\delta} pair potential examined in the one-dimensional (1D) case (whose N-fermion ground state can be determined exactly) or for the BCS (electron-phonon) model interaction in any dimension. Weak-coupling and/or high-density limits for the rms radius are identical in 1D, 2D, and 3D, and reduce to the familiar well-known Pippard result to within a factor of order unity. In contrast, strong-coupling and/or low-density limits coincide in 1D and 3D, but differ by a factor of order unity in the 2D limit, and in each case are essentially the size of a single, isolated pair. The 1D \ensuremath{\delta} interaction McGuire-Yang-Gaudin many-fermion model is studied in detail. The interaction renormalization scheme of Miyake and of Randeria, Duan, and Shieh, and the BCS interaction model, both in 2D, are employed to analyze cuprate superconductor empirical results. Reasonable agreement between theoretical rms radii with experimental coherence lengths suggests that cuprates can be described moderately well as weakly coupled superconductors within the BCS-Bose formalism.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 1, 1994•27 citations

Exact expectation values within Richardson's approach for the pairing Hamiltonian in a macroscopic system

G. Gorohovsky, Eldad Bettelheim

BCS superconductivity is explained by a simple Hamiltonian describing an attractive pairing interaction between pairs of electrons. The Hamiltonian may be treated using a mean-field method, which is adequate to study equilibrium properties and a variety of nonequilibrium effects. Nevertheless, in certain nonequilibrium situations, even in a macroscopic rather than a microscopic superconductor, the application of mean-field theory may not be valid. In such cases, one may resort to the full solution of the Hamiltonian, as given by Richardson in the 1960s. The relevance of Richardson's solution to macroscopic nonequilibrium superconductors was pointed out recently based on the existence of quantum instabilities out of equilibrium. It is then of interest to obtain analytical expressions for expectation values between exact eigenvalues of the pairing Hamiltonian within the Richardson approach for macroscopic systems. We undertake this task in the current paper. It should be noted that Richardson's approach yields the full set of eigenvalues of the Hamiltonian, while BCS theory yields only a subset. The results obtained here, then, generalize the familiar BCS expressions (e.g., for the electron occupation or pairing correlations) to cases where the spectrum of excitations diverges from BCS theory (e.g., in cases where the spectrum exhibits multiple gaps).

arXiv:1111.1519•Physical Review B•Dec 14, 2011•18 citations

MEAN-FIELD TRANSITION TEMPERATURE OF STRONGLY DISORDERED SUPERCONDUCTORS

Igor F. Herbut

I discuss the mean-field theory of superconductivity in a strongly disordered system of fermions with short-range attraction. It is argued that in this limit the effective theory at low energies is equivalent to the disordered Bose–Hubbard model, and I consider both the infinite-range and the "nearest-neighbor" hopping of bosons between the localized states. In the infinite-range case the mean-field theory is exact, and the superconducting gap is uniform in space, while in the latter case, the gap becomes highly non-uniform in space, but, surprisingly, is finite everywhere at T < T MF . I find that the mean-field transition temperature T MF > 0 always, and argue that the superconductor–insulator transition at T = 0 in models with net attraction between fermions is in the universality class of "dirty-bosons".

arXiv:cond-mat/9902305•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Mar 10, 2000•5 citations

The Cooper Pair Problem

Monique Combescot, Shiue-Yuan Shiau

Abstract Chapter 6 introduces the BCS theory of superconductivity, proposed in 1957 by Bardeen, Cooper, and Schrieffer and which is based on the idea that electrons form a coherent state of electron pairs with opposite spins and opposite momenta. It then briefly explains how, along the Fröhlich idea, the electron-phonon interaction can lead to the ion-mediated attractive potential for Cooper pairing. Next, it introduces the reduced BCS potential, which acts between electrons having opposite spins and opposite momenta. Finally, this chapter discusses the drastic consequence of the reduced BCS potential on Cooper pair interaction and explains why Cooper pairs can strongly overlap without dissociating.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 1, 2015•0 citations

Normal phase and superconducting instability in attractive Hubbard model: the DMFT(NRG) study

N. A. Kuleeva, É. Z. Kuchinskiǐ, Michael V. Sadovskii

We study the normal (non-superconducting) phase of attractive Hubbard model within dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) using numerical renormalization group (NRG) as impurity solver. Wide range of attractive potentials $U$ is considered, from the weak-coupling limit, where superconducting instability is well described by BCS approximation, up to the strong-coupling region, where superconducting transition is described by Bose-condensation of compact Cooper pairs, which are formed at temperatures much exceeding superconducting transition temperature. We calculate density of states, spectral density and optical conductivity in the normal phase for this wide range of $U$, including the disorder effects. Also we present the results on superconducting instability of the normal state dependence on the attraction strength $U$ and the degree of disorder. Disorder influence on the critical temperature $T_c$ is rather weak, suggesting in fact the validity of Anderson theorem, with the account of the general widening of the conduction band due to disorder.

arXiv:1401.2295•Jan 10, 2014•8 citations
In this paper, we revisit the problem of dirty superconductors using a replica-symmetric BCS (RS-BCS) theory. We apply the RS-BCS theory to dirty superconductor grains of size LdL^dLd, where LLL is the localization length and ddd is the dimension of the system, assuming that the macroscopic system is composed of weakly coupled grains. Besides disordered potential, We also consider the case where regions with opposite signs of interaction exist in the grains, with net attractive interaction between electrons. Within the RS-BCS mean field theory, the system phase diagram, single-particle tunneling density of states and the superfluid density are computed within the RS-BCS theory for different strengths of disorder, We show that our result agrees qualitatively with previous numerical studies in the case with pure attractive interaction, and that a Cooper-pair-glass state may exist when regions with opposite sign of interaction exists and the net interaction between electrons is close to zero. The plausible relevance of our result to the anomalous metal state is discussed.
Motivated by the experimental observations of the anomalous metal states in many superconducting thin films systems, this thesis studies the interplay of disorder and interactions in superconductivity. We first demonstrate that the Fermi glass ground state is unstable in first-order perturbation theory under weak, short-ranged interaction, provided all states are localized. This finding elucidates why methods like the Hartree-Fock approximation are adequate to explain local moment formation in repulsive interactions. We then revisit the problem of dirty superconductors using a replica-symmetric BCS (RS-BCS) theory. We apply RS-BCS theory to disordered superconducting grains within the localization length, assuming the macroscopic system consists of weakly coupled grains. Besides disordered potential, We also consider regions with opposite signs of interaction exist in the grains, with net attractive interaction between electrons. Using RS-BCS mean field theory, we compute the phase diagram, tunneling density of states, and superfluid density across disorder strengths. Our results qualitatively agree with prior numerical studies for purely attractive interactions, and suggest a possible Cooper-pair-glass state when interactions of opposite signs nearly cancel.
Analytic expressions are derived for the root-mean-square (rms) radius of a pair of fermions in a BCS many-fermion state in one, two, and three dimensions, in terms of the BCS gap energy and the associated chemical potential. These expressions are valid for any coupling strength of any pair interaction model implying a momentum-independent gap energy. The latter holds, e.g., for an attractive \ensuremath{\delta} pair potential examined in the one-dimensional (1D) case (whose N-fermion ground state can be determined exactly) or for the BCS (electron-phonon) model interaction in any dimension. Weak-coupling and/or high-density limits for the rms radius are identical in 1D, 2D, and 3D, and reduce to the familiar well-known Pippard result to within a factor of order unity. In contrast, strong-coupling and/or low-density limits coincide in 1D and 3D, but differ by a factor of order unity in the 2D limit, and in each case are essentially the size of a single, isolated pair. The 1D \ensuremath{\delta} interaction McGuire-Yang-Gaudin many-fermion model is studied in detail. The interaction renormalization scheme of Miyake and of Randeria, Duan, and Shieh, and the BCS interaction model, both in 2D, are employed to analyze cuprate superconductor empirical results. Reasonable agreement between theoretical rms radii with experimental coherence lengths suggests that cuprates can be described moderately well as weakly coupled superconductors within the BCS-Bose formalism.
BCS superconductivity is explained by a simple Hamiltonian describing an attractive pairing interaction between pairs of electrons. The Hamiltonian may be treated using a mean-field method, which is adequate to study equilibrium properties and a variety of nonequilibrium effects. Nevertheless, in certain nonequilibrium situations, even in a macroscopic rather than a microscopic superconductor, the application of mean-field theory may not be valid. In such cases, one may resort to the full solution of the Hamiltonian, as given by Richardson in the 1960s. The relevance of Richardson's solution to macroscopic nonequilibrium superconductors was pointed out recently based on the existence of quantum instabilities out of equilibrium. It is then of interest to obtain analytical expressions for expectation values between exact eigenvalues of the pairing Hamiltonian within the Richardson approach for macroscopic systems. We undertake this task in the current paper. It should be noted that Richardson's approach yields the full set of eigenvalues of the Hamiltonian, while BCS theory yields only a subset. The results obtained here, then, generalize the familiar BCS expressions (e.g., for the electron occupation or pairing correlations) to cases where the spectrum of excitations diverges from BCS theory (e.g., in cases where the spectrum exhibits multiple gaps).
I discuss the mean-field theory of superconductivity in a strongly disordered system of fermions with short-range attraction. It is argued that in this limit the effective theory at low energies is equivalent to the disordered Bose–Hubbard model, and I consider both the infinite-range and the "nearest-neighbor" hopping of bosons between the localized states. In the infinite-range case the mean-field theory is exact, and the superconducting gap is uniform in space, while in the latter case, the gap becomes highly non-uniform in space, but, surprisingly, is finite everywhere at T < T MF . I find that the mean-field transition temperature T MF > 0 always, and argue that the superconductor–insulator transition at T = 0 in models with net attraction between fermions is in the universality class of "dirty-bosons".
Abstract Chapter 6 introduces the BCS theory of superconductivity, proposed in 1957 by Bardeen, Cooper, and Schrieffer and which is based on the idea that electrons form a coherent state of electron pairs with opposite spins and opposite momenta. It then briefly explains how, along the Fröhlich idea, the electron-phonon interaction can lead to the ion-mediated attractive potential for Cooper pairing. Next, it introduces the reduced BCS potential, which acts between electrons having opposite spins and opposite momenta. Finally, this chapter discusses the drastic consequence of the reduced BCS potential on Cooper pair interaction and explains why Cooper pairs can strongly overlap without dissociating.
We study the normal (non-superconducting) phase of attractive Hubbard model within dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) using numerical renormalization group (NRG) as impurity solver. Wide range of attractive potentials UUU is considered, from the weak-coupling limit, where superconducting instability is well described by BCS approximation, up to the strong-coupling region, where superconducting transition is described by Bose-condensation of compact Cooper pairs, which are formed at temperatures much exceeding superconducting transition temperature. We calculate density of states, spectral density and optical conductivity in the normal phase for this wide range of UUU, including the disorder effects. Also we present the results on superconducting instability of the normal state dependence on the attraction strength UUU and the degree of disorder. Disorder influence on the critical temperature TcT_cTc​ is rather weak, suggesting in fact the validity of Anderson theorem, with the account of the general widening of the conduction band due to disorder.