Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2311.10024 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Topological gap opening without symmetry breaking from dynamical quantum correlations

F. Paoletti, Laura Fanfarillo, Massimo Capone, A. Amaricci

Published Feb 22, 2024• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Topological phase transitions are typically associated with the formation of gapless states. Spontaneous symmetry breaking can lead to a gap opening, thereby obliterating the topological nature of the system. Here we highlight a completely different destiny for a topological transition in the presence of interaction. Solving a Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang model with local interaction, we show that dynamical quantum fluctuations can lead to the opening of a gap without any symmetry breaking. As we vary the interaction and the bare mass of the model, the continuous gapless topological transition turns into a first-order one, associated with the presence of a massive Dirac fermion at the transition point, showing a Gross-Neveu critical behavior near the quantum critical endpoint. We identify the gap opening as a condensed matter analog of the Coleman-Weinberg mechanism of mass generation.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.109.075148

Related papers

Static and Dynamical Correlations in Topological Transitions

Francesca Paoletti

This thesis focuses on the effects of strong electron-electron interactions on topological phase transitions.In very general terms, topological phase transitions are typically associated with the formation of gapless states at the boundary between two gapped phases.The opening of a gap is usually associated with a spontaneous symmetry breaking that can obliterate the topological nature of the system.In this work we highlight a completely different destiny for a topological transition in the presence of interaction and we develop a theoretical framework to address this physics identifying the physical origin for the unconventional scenario.In particular, we show that strong electronic correlation can lead to a gap opening at the topological transition without any symmetry breaking.This turns the topological transition discontinuous, thereby giving rise to a quantum critical point connecting the continuous region with the discontinuous one.This unconventional scenario establishes a surprising connection between a topological transition and quantum criticality.By solving a Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang model supplemented with a local symmetric interaction, we demonstrate that the crucial role of orbital polarization naturally emerges, already at the mean-field level.This local parameter effectively captures the essence of the topological transition, complementing the established evaluation of topological invariants and enabling a Landau-like description.Within this framework, we analyze the interplay between band topology and the dynamical effects of electronic correlations, achieved by developing a non-perturbative method for calculating the effective free energy, the Variational Gaussian Approximation, which is compared with both a simple static mean-field, which is not able to capture any critical behavior for the topological transition and with the accurate Dynamical Mean-Field Theory which provides an important benchmark for the accuracy of the approach.We show indeed that dynamical quantum fluctuations can lead to gap opening without any symmetry breaking.The growth of these quantum effects as the interaction is increased turns indeed the topological transition from continuous to discontinuous.This change of behavior is associated with the presence of massive Dirac fermion at the transition point showing a Gross-Neveu critical behaviour near the quantum critical endpoint.We identify the gap opening as a condensed matter analog of the Coleman-Weinberg mechanism of mass generation.The theory presented offers a broad scope for extension in various directions, ranging from changing the topological model and modifying the interactions, to incorporating non-local effects, or even applying it to entirely trivial strongly correlated models.

•Mar 15, 2024•0 citations

Nature of Topological Phase Transition of Kitaev Quantum Spin Liquids

Huanzhi Hu, Frank Krüger

We investigate the nature of the topological quantum phase transition between the gapless and gapped Kitaev quantum spin liquid phases away from the exactly solvable point. The transition is driven by anisotropy of the Kitaev couplings. At the critical point, the two Dirac points of the gapless Majorana modes merge, resulting in the formation of a semi-Dirac point with quadratic and linear band touching directions. We derive an effective Gross-Neveu-Yukawa-type field theory that describes the topological phase transition in the presence of additional magnetic interactions. We obtain the infrared scaling form of the propagator of the dynamical Ising order parameter field and perform a renormalization-group analysis. The universality of the transition is found to be different from that of symmetry-breaking phase transitions of semi-Dirac electrons. However, as in the electronic case, the Majorana fermions acquire an anomalous dimension, indicative of the breakdown of the fractionalized quasiparticle description.

arXiv:2402.12610•Physical Review Letters•Oct 2, 2024•6 citations

Quantum critical point of Dirac fermion mass generation without spontaneous symmetry breaking

Yuan-Yao He, Han-Qing Wu, Yi‐Zhuang You +3 more

We study a lattice model of interacting Dirac fermions in $(2+1)$ dimensions space-time with an SU(4) symmetry. While increasing the interaction strength, this model undergoes a continuous quantum phase transition from a weakly interacting Dirac semimetal to a fully gapped and nondegenerate phase without condensing any Dirac fermion bilinear mass operator. This unusual mechanism for mass generation is consistent with recent studies of interacting topological insulators/superconductors, and also consistent with recent progress in the lattice QCD community.

arXiv:1603.08376•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 20, 2016•46 citations

Quantum Criticality in Topological Insulators and Superconductors: Emergence of Strongly Coupled Majoranas and Supersymmetry

Tarun Grover, Ashvin Vishwanath

We study symmetry breaking quantum phase transitions in topological insulators and superconductors where the single electron gap remains open in the bulk. Specifically, we consider spontaneous breaking of the symmetry that protects the gapless boundary modes, so that in the ordered phase these modes are gapped. Here we determine the fate of the topological boundary modes right at the transition where they are coupled to the strongly fluctuating order parameter field. Using a combination of exact solutions and renormalization group techniques, we find that the surface fermionic modes either decouple from the bulk fluctuations, or flow to a strongly coupled fixed point which remains gapless. In addition, we study transitions where the critical fluctuations are confined only to the surface and find that in several cases the critical point is naturally supersymmetric. This allows a determination of critical exponents and points to an underlying connection between band topology and supersymmetry. Finally, we study the fate of gapless Majorana modes localized on point and line defects in topological superconductors at bulk criticality, which is analogous to a quantum impurity problem. Again, an interplay of topology and strong correlations causes these modes to remain gapless but in a strongly coupled state. Experimental candidates for realizing these phenomena are discussed.

arXiv:1206.1332•Jun 6, 2012•85 citations

First-order quantum phase transition in three-dimensional topological band insulators

Vladimir Juričić, David Abergel, Alexander V. Balatsky

Topological states of matter are characterized by global topological invariants which change their value across a topological quantum phase transition. It is commonly assumed that the transition between topologically distinct noninteracting gapped phases of fermions is necessarily accompanied by the closing of the band gap as long as the symmetries of the system are maintained. We show that such a quantum phase transition is possible without closing the gap in the case of a three-dimensional topological band insulator. We demonstrate this by calculating the free energy of the minimal model for a topological insulator, the Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang model, and show that as the band curvature continuously varies, a jump between the band-gap minima corresponding to the topologically trivial and nontrivial insulators occurs. Therefore, this first-order phase transition is a generic feature of three-dimensional topological band insulators. For a certain parameter range we predict a reentrant topological phase transition. We discuss our findings in connection with the recent experimental observation of a discontinuous topological phase transition in a family of topological crystalline insulators.

arXiv:1608.07819•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 11, 2017•14 citations

Topological quantum critical points in strong coupling limits: Global symmetries and strongly interacting Majorana fermions

Fei Zhou

In this paper, we discuss strong coupling limits of topological quantum critical points (TQCPs) where quantum phase transitions between two topological distinct superconducting states take place. We illustrate that while superconducting phases on both sides of TQCPs spontaneously break the same symmetries, universality classes of critical states can be identified only when global symmetries in topological states are further specified. In dimensions $d=2\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}\text{and}\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}3$, we find that continuous $(d+1)\mathrm{th}$-order transitions at weakly interacting TQCPs that were pointed out previously in the presence of the emergent Lorentz symmetry can be terminated by strongly interacting fixed points of Majorana fields. For $2d$ time reversal symmetry breaking TQCPs, termination points are supersymmetric with $\mathcal{N}=4{N}_{f}=1$ (where ${N}_{f}$ is the number of four-component Dirac fermions and $\mathcal{N}$ is the number of two-component real fermions) beyond which transitions are discontinuous first-order ones. For $2d$ time reversal symmetric TQCPs without other global symmetries, termination points of $(d+1)\mathrm{th}$-order continuous transition lines are generically conformal invariant without supersymmetry. Beyond these strong coupling fixed points, there are first-order discontinuous transitions as far as the protecting symmetry is not spontaneously broken but no direct transitions if the protecting symmetry is spontaneously broken in the presence of strong interactions. In this case, termination points can become supersymmetric with $\mathcal{N}=4{N}_{f}=2$ only when interacting Majorana fermions further display an emergent global $\text{U}(1)$ symmetry. In $3d$, strong coupling termination points can be further effectively represented by new emergent gapless real bosons weakly coupled with free gapless Majorana fermions. However, in $1d$, time reversal symmetric $(d+1)\mathrm{th}$ continuous transition lines of TQCPs are terminated by simple free Majorana fermion fixed points.

arXiv:2110.08332•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 3, 2022•10 citations
Topological phase transitions are typically associated with the formation of gapless states. Spontaneous symmetry breaking can lead to a gap opening, thereby obliterating the topological nature of the system. Here we highlight a completely different destiny for a topological transition in the presence of interaction. Solving a Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang model with local interaction, we show that dynamical quantum fluctuations can lead to the opening of a gap without any symmetry breaking. As we vary the interaction and the bare mass of the model, the continuous gapless topological transition turns into a first-order one, associated with the presence of a massive Dirac fermion at the transition point, showing a Gross-Neveu critical behavior near the quantum critical endpoint. We identify the gap opening as a condensed matter analog of the Coleman-Weinberg mechanism of mass generation.
This thesis focuses on the effects of strong electron-electron interactions on topological phase transitions.In very general terms, topological phase transitions are typically associated with the formation of gapless states at the boundary between two gapped phases.The opening of a gap is usually associated with a spontaneous symmetry breaking that can obliterate the topological nature of the system.In this work we highlight a completely different destiny for a topological transition in the presence of interaction and we develop a theoretical framework to address this physics identifying the physical origin for the unconventional scenario.In particular, we show that strong electronic correlation can lead to a gap opening at the topological transition without any symmetry breaking.This turns the topological transition discontinuous, thereby giving rise to a quantum critical point connecting the continuous region with the discontinuous one.This unconventional scenario establishes a surprising connection between a topological transition and quantum criticality.By solving a Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang model supplemented with a local symmetric interaction, we demonstrate that the crucial role of orbital polarization naturally emerges, already at the mean-field level.This local parameter effectively captures the essence of the topological transition, complementing the established evaluation of topological invariants and enabling a Landau-like description.Within this framework, we analyze the interplay between band topology and the dynamical effects of electronic correlations, achieved by developing a non-perturbative method for calculating the effective free energy, the Variational Gaussian Approximation, which is compared with both a simple static mean-field, which is not able to capture any critical behavior for the topological transition and with the accurate Dynamical Mean-Field Theory which provides an important benchmark for the accuracy of the approach.We show indeed that dynamical quantum fluctuations can lead to gap opening without any symmetry breaking.The growth of these quantum effects as the interaction is increased turns indeed the topological transition from continuous to discontinuous.This change of behavior is associated with the presence of massive Dirac fermion at the transition point showing a Gross-Neveu critical behaviour near the quantum critical endpoint.We identify the gap opening as a condensed matter analog of the Coleman-Weinberg mechanism of mass generation.The theory presented offers a broad scope for extension in various directions, ranging from changing the topological model and modifying the interactions, to incorporating non-local effects, or even applying it to entirely trivial strongly correlated models.
We investigate the nature of the topological quantum phase transition between the gapless and gapped Kitaev quantum spin liquid phases away from the exactly solvable point. The transition is driven by anisotropy of the Kitaev couplings. At the critical point, the two Dirac points of the gapless Majorana modes merge, resulting in the formation of a semi-Dirac point with quadratic and linear band touching directions. We derive an effective Gross-Neveu-Yukawa-type field theory that describes the topological phase transition in the presence of additional magnetic interactions. We obtain the infrared scaling form of the propagator of the dynamical Ising order parameter field and perform a renormalization-group analysis. The universality of the transition is found to be different from that of symmetry-breaking phase transitions of semi-Dirac electrons. However, as in the electronic case, the Majorana fermions acquire an anomalous dimension, indicative of the breakdown of the fractionalized quasiparticle description.
We study a lattice model of interacting Dirac fermions in (2+1)(2+1)(2+1) dimensions space-time with an SU(4) symmetry. While increasing the interaction strength, this model undergoes a continuous quantum phase transition from a weakly interacting Dirac semimetal to a fully gapped and nondegenerate phase without condensing any Dirac fermion bilinear mass operator. This unusual mechanism for mass generation is consistent with recent studies of interacting topological insulators/superconductors, and also consistent with recent progress in the lattice QCD community.
We study symmetry breaking quantum phase transitions in topological insulators and superconductors where the single electron gap remains open in the bulk. Specifically, we consider spontaneous breaking of the symmetry that protects the gapless boundary modes, so that in the ordered phase these modes are gapped. Here we determine the fate of the topological boundary modes right at the transition where they are coupled to the strongly fluctuating order parameter field. Using a combination of exact solutions and renormalization group techniques, we find that the surface fermionic modes either decouple from the bulk fluctuations, or flow to a strongly coupled fixed point which remains gapless. In addition, we study transitions where the critical fluctuations are confined only to the surface and find that in several cases the critical point is naturally supersymmetric. This allows a determination of critical exponents and points to an underlying connection between band topology and supersymmetry. Finally, we study the fate of gapless Majorana modes localized on point and line defects in topological superconductors at bulk criticality, which is analogous to a quantum impurity problem. Again, an interplay of topology and strong correlations causes these modes to remain gapless but in a strongly coupled state. Experimental candidates for realizing these phenomena are discussed.
Topological states of matter are characterized by global topological invariants which change their value across a topological quantum phase transition. It is commonly assumed that the transition between topologically distinct noninteracting gapped phases of fermions is necessarily accompanied by the closing of the band gap as long as the symmetries of the system are maintained. We show that such a quantum phase transition is possible without closing the gap in the case of a three-dimensional topological band insulator. We demonstrate this by calculating the free energy of the minimal model for a topological insulator, the Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang model, and show that as the band curvature continuously varies, a jump between the band-gap minima corresponding to the topologically trivial and nontrivial insulators occurs. Therefore, this first-order phase transition is a generic feature of three-dimensional topological band insulators. For a certain parameter range we predict a reentrant topological phase transition. We discuss our findings in connection with the recent experimental observation of a discontinuous topological phase transition in a family of topological crystalline insulators.
In this paper, we discuss strong coupling limits of topological quantum critical points (TQCPs) where quantum phase transitions between two topological distinct superconducting states take place. We illustrate that while superconducting phases on both sides of TQCPs spontaneously break the same symmetries, universality classes of critical states can be identified only when global symmetries in topological states are further specified. In dimensions d=2and3d=2\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}\text{and}\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}3d=2and3, we find that continuous (d+1)th(d+1)\mathrm{th}(d+1)th-order transitions at weakly interacting TQCPs that were pointed out previously in the presence of the emergent Lorentz symmetry can be terminated by strongly interacting fixed points of Majorana fields. For 2d2d2d time reversal symmetry breaking TQCPs, termination points are supersymmetric with N=4Nf=1\mathcal{N}=4{N}_{f}=1N=4Nf​=1 (where Nf{N}_{f}Nf​ is the number of four-component Dirac fermions and N\mathcal{N}N is the number of two-component real fermions) beyond which transitions are discontinuous first-order ones. For 2d2d2d time reversal symmetric TQCPs without other global symmetries, termination points of (d+1)th(d+1)\mathrm{th}(d+1)th-order continuous transition lines are generically conformal invariant without supersymmetry. Beyond these strong coupling fixed points, there are first-order discontinuous transitions as far as the protecting symmetry is not spontaneously broken but no direct transitions if the protecting symmetry is spontaneously broken in the presence of strong interactions. In this case, termination points can become supersymmetric with N=4Nf=2\mathcal{N}=4{N}_{f}=2N=4Nf​=2 only when interacting Majorana fermions further display an emergent global U(1)\text{U}(1)U(1) symmetry. In 3d3d3d, strong coupling termination points can be further effectively represented by new emergent gapless real bosons weakly coupled with free gapless Majorana fermions. However, in 1d1d1d, time reversal symmetric (d+1)th(d+1)\mathrm{th}(d+1)th continuous transition lines of TQCPs are terminated by simple free Majorana fermion fixed points.