Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2311.05389 · npj Quantum Information

Verifying the security of a continuous variable quantum communication protocol via quantum metrology

Lorcán O. Conlon, Biveen Shajilal, Angus Walsh, Jie Zhao, Jiří Janoušek, Ping Koy Lam, Syed M. Assad

Published Apr 4, 2024• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Quantum mechanics offers the possibility of unconditionally secure communication between multiple remote parties. Security proofs for such protocols typically rely on bounding the capacity of the quantum channel in use. In a similar manner, Cramér-Rao bounds in quantum metrology place limits on how much information can be extracted from a given quantum state about some unknown parameters of interest. In this work we establish a connection between these two areas. We first demonstrate a three-party sensing protocol, where the attainable precision is dependent on how many parties work together. This protocol is then mapped to a secure access protocol, where only by working together can the parties gain access to some high security asset. Finally, we map the same task to a communication protocol where we demonstrate that a higher mutual information can be achieved when the parties work collaboratively compared to any party working in isolation.

DOI
10.1038/s41534-024-00834-9

Related papers

Cryptographic quantum metrology

Zixin Huang, Chiara Macchiavello, Lorenzo Maccone

We develop a general framework for parameter estimation that allows only trusted parties to access the result and achieves optimal precision. The protocols are designed such that adversaries can access some information indeterministically, but only at the risk of getting caught (cheat sensitivity); under the assumption that the adversary can access the channel only once, then the protocol is unconditionally secure. By combining techniques from quantum cryptography and quantum metrology, we devise cryptographic procedures for single-parameter estimation when an arbitrary number of parties are involved.

arXiv:1706.03894•Physical Review A•Feb 13, 2019•38 citations

A security study of two non-tomographic quantum communication protocols

Syed M. Assad

The aim of this thesis is to study the security of two particular quantum communication protocols. We want to investigate what is the maximum amount of channel noise for which the protocols can still be secure. We do this by using well known bounds for limiting the information that an eavesdropper can obtain. The first protocol that we study is a direct communication protocol using two-qubit states. We find the security threshold by analyzing the protocol in an enanglement based setting. The Holevo bound was used to put an upper bound on the information of an eavesdropper. To arrive at a manageable optimisation probem, we restrict the eavesdropper's attack strategy such that the noise introduced will be unbiased. Furthermore, we also impose some additional constraints on the eavesdropper that arises from the symmetry of the protocol. After doing this we then optimise the remaining parameters to arrive at the eavesdropper's optimal strategy and find out what is the maximum amount of information she can obtain. Once the eavesdropper's maximum information is known, the security threshold for secure communication was obtained by comparing that information with the information between the legitimate communicating parties. The second protocol studied is a continuous variable quantum key distribution protocol using post-selection. For this protocol, we investigate the maximum amount of information the eavesdropper can get under individual and collective attacks in the presence of Gaussian excess noise in the channel. By providing the eavesdropper with additional information, we can use known results on the accessible information for pure input states to bound the eavesdropper's information. For individual attacks, Levitin's result on the optimal measurement was used while for collective attacks, Holevo's bound was used to arrive at an upper bound for the eavesdropper's information. From this we can then arrive at the post-selection region where the legitimate communicating parties have more information than the eavesdropper. We can then find the maximum amount of noise that the protocol can tolerate before the eavesdropper knows too much and the protocol fails.

•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Protocols for optical quantum metrology

Zixin Huang

This thesis explores various protocols which can be applied to quantum metrology, such that precision of the measurement can beat the best classical approaches. We first demonstrate that ancilla-assisted schemes can improve phase estimation in the presence of noise, and we propose an experiment to demonstrate these effects. Given that the use of ancillae helps, it is no surprise that there are noisy channels for which the optimal strategy may depend on the noise level. We show that there is a non-trivial crossover between the ancilla-assisted strategy and the parallel-entangled strategy for Pauli noise channels and the amplitude damping channel. We see that under certain circumstances, the environment cannot access the parameter of interest. We then integrated techniques from quantum communication, to derive a general framework that renders quantum metrology protocols into cryptographic ones. Here the protocol is unconditionally secure if the trusted parties wish only to achieve the standard quantum limit. If Heisenberg-limited precision is to be achieved, they sacrifice some security, where adversaries can access information, but only at the risk of getting caught at it (cheat-sensitivity). In many scenarios, the quantum Fisher information is achieved for only one value of the phase. In a particular phase estimation scheme that measures the parity at the output of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer where the input is a two-mode squeezed vacuum, this problem is particularly imminent. We apply an adaptive technique to resolve this issue, showing that one can achieve precisions substantially below the shot noise limit. The key to a quadratically enhanced improvement in quantum metrology is entanglement. Finally, we demonstrate in a photonic system how high-dimensional entanglement can be certified, and provide an alternate interpretation of entanglement from an information-theoretic perspective.

•Apr 5, 2018•0 citations

Certification of Network Quantum Sensing

Matteo Rosati, Gabriele Bizzarri, Marco Barbieri

The distribution of quantum sensors on quantum networks is a key enabler of quantum technologies in interferometry, gravimetry, timekeeping, biological monitoring, and beyond. Yet, guaranteeing the security of these distributed sensors over noisy, insecure networks remains a formidable challenge. Previous efforts to combine quantum metrology and cryptography have encountered an apparently unavoidable tension, proposing bounds for security which are only loosely tied to the achievable measurement performance. Here we introduce a quantum remote sensing protocol that can rigorously certify privacy and integrity of the estimation. By employing offline bilateral Pauli-twirling, our approach forces the effective quantum channel into a Bell-diagonal form, independently of the attack. Surprisingly, this also preserves metrological sensitivity without introducing additional experimental overhead. Relying solely on public communication alongside an insecure quantum link, the protocol enables legitimate users to exactly quantify their estimation error relative to an eavesdropper controlling the channels. We experimentally demonstrate this framework by estimating an optical phase using entangled photons, observing that the users' precision consistently surpasses the eavesdropper's capabilities across a broad parameter regime. By unifying quantum cryptography and metrology, our results provide a practical pathway to achieve simultaneous quantum-limited precision and rigorous information security in real-world quantum networks.

quant-pharXiv:2606.10700•Jun 10, 2026•1 citation

Quantum metrology with delegated tasks

Nathan Shettell, Damian Markham

A quantum metrology scheme can be decomposed into three quantum tasks: state preparation, parameter encoding, and measurements. Consequently, it is imperative to have access to the technologies which can execute the aforementioned tasks to fully implement a quantum metrology scheme. In the absence of one or more of these technologies, one can proceed by delegating the tasks to a third party. However, doing so has security ramifications: the third party can bias the result or leak information. In this paper, we outline different scenarios where one or more tasks are delegated to an untrusted (and possibly malicious) third party. In each scenario, we outline cryptographic protocols which can be used to circumvent malicious activity. Further, we link the effectiveness of the quantum metrology scheme to the soundness of the cryptographic protocols.

arXiv:2112.09199•Physical Review A•Nov 23, 2022•11 citations

Continuous Variable Quantum Communication

Nathan Walk

In this thesis we consider quantum communication as realised in the continuous variable quantum optical regime. The work presented includes results concerning quantum communication applications, such as entanglement distillation and quantum key distributions, as well as fundamental questions regarding measurement uncertainty and the boundary between classical and quantum correlations. In the first part of the thesis we investigate various protocols in which one engages in a trade-off between determinism and the quality of quantum correlations. In discrete variable quantum optics non-determinism is ubiquitous, with photon sources, detectors and various gates commonly operating probabilistically. In the continuous variable regime one has access to many quantum states and operations, including exotic effects such as entanglement, in a fully deterministic fashion and one might regard giving up this feature as highly undesirable. However it has been discovered that certain vital tasks such as entanglement distillation, indispensable for large scale quantum information networks, cannot be realised deterministically. We address precisely these limitations, firstly by conducting the most general analysis to date of a non-deterministic but heralded quantum amplifier that can circumvent the standard quantum limits, and distill Gaussian entanglement. We then analyse the security of long standing technique in continuous variable quantum key distribution, known as post-selection, which again allows the distillation of higher quality correlations. We provide a complete security proof in the asymptotic limit and show that there is in fact an relationship between this method and the noiseless amplifier. Furthermore, the protocol allows secure key to be generated for channel parameters where all previous CVQKD protocols fail. Thirdly we consider this equivalence between post-selection and heralded operations more generally, and conduct a detailed analysis of the post-selection based emulation of the noiseless amplifier. Turning to more fundamental issues, we consider links between several recently proposed entropic measures of quantum correlations and their potential operational links to continuous variable quantum key distribution. Finally we consider entropic uncertainty relations for continuous variables on infinite dimensional Hilbert spaces and apply these to one-sided device independent continuous variable quantum key distribution protocols.n

•Jan 1, 2014•1 citation
Abstract Quantum mechanics offers the possibility of unconditionally secure communication between multiple remote parties. Security proofs for such protocols typically rely on bounding the capacity of the quantum channel in use. In a similar manner, Cramér-Rao bounds in quantum metrology place limits on how much information can be extracted from a given quantum state about some unknown parameters of interest. In this work we establish a connection between these two areas. We first demonstrate a three-party sensing protocol, where the attainable precision is dependent on how many parties work together. This protocol is then mapped to a secure access protocol, where only by working together can the parties gain access to some high security asset. Finally, we map the same task to a communication protocol where we demonstrate that a higher mutual information can be achieved when the parties work collaboratively compared to any party working in isolation.
We develop a general framework for parameter estimation that allows only trusted parties to access the result and achieves optimal precision. The protocols are designed such that adversaries can access some information indeterministically, but only at the risk of getting caught (cheat sensitivity); under the assumption that the adversary can access the channel only once, then the protocol is unconditionally secure. By combining techniques from quantum cryptography and quantum metrology, we devise cryptographic procedures for single-parameter estimation when an arbitrary number of parties are involved.
The aim of this thesis is to study the security of two particular quantum communication protocols. We want to investigate what is the maximum amount of channel noise for which the protocols can still be secure. We do this by using well known bounds for limiting the information that an eavesdropper can obtain. The first protocol that we study is a direct communication protocol using two-qubit states. We find the security threshold by analyzing the protocol in an enanglement based setting. The Holevo bound was used to put an upper bound on the information of an eavesdropper. To arrive at a manageable optimisation probem, we restrict the eavesdropper's attack strategy such that the noise introduced will be unbiased. Furthermore, we also impose some additional constraints on the eavesdropper that arises from the symmetry of the protocol. After doing this we then optimise the remaining parameters to arrive at the eavesdropper's optimal strategy and find out what is the maximum amount of information she can obtain. Once the eavesdropper's maximum information is known, the security threshold for secure communication was obtained by comparing that information with the information between the legitimate communicating parties. The second protocol studied is a continuous variable quantum key distribution protocol using post-selection. For this protocol, we investigate the maximum amount of information the eavesdropper can get under individual and collective attacks in the presence of Gaussian excess noise in the channel. By providing the eavesdropper with additional information, we can use known results on the accessible information for pure input states to bound the eavesdropper's information. For individual attacks, Levitin's result on the optimal measurement was used while for collective attacks, Holevo's bound was used to arrive at an upper bound for the eavesdropper's information. From this we can then arrive at the post-selection region where the legitimate communicating parties have more information than the eavesdropper. We can then find the maximum amount of noise that the protocol can tolerate before the eavesdropper knows too much and the protocol fails.
This thesis explores various protocols which can be applied to quantum metrology, such that precision of the measurement can beat the best classical approaches. We first demonstrate that ancilla-assisted schemes can improve phase estimation in the presence of noise, and we propose an experiment to demonstrate these effects. Given that the use of ancillae helps, it is no surprise that there are noisy channels for which the optimal strategy may depend on the noise level. We show that there is a non-trivial crossover between the ancilla-assisted strategy and the parallel-entangled strategy for Pauli noise channels and the amplitude damping channel. We see that under certain circumstances, the environment cannot access the parameter of interest. We then integrated techniques from quantum communication, to derive a general framework that renders quantum metrology protocols into cryptographic ones. Here the protocol is unconditionally secure if the trusted parties wish only to achieve the standard quantum limit. If Heisenberg-limited precision is to be achieved, they sacrifice some security, where adversaries can access information, but only at the risk of getting caught at it (cheat-sensitivity). In many scenarios, the quantum Fisher information is achieved for only one value of the phase. In a particular phase estimation scheme that measures the parity at the output of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer where the input is a two-mode squeezed vacuum, this problem is particularly imminent. We apply an adaptive technique to resolve this issue, showing that one can achieve precisions substantially below the shot noise limit. The key to a quadratically enhanced improvement in quantum metrology is entanglement. Finally, we demonstrate in a photonic system how high-dimensional entanglement can be certified, and provide an alternate interpretation of entanglement from an information-theoretic perspective.
The distribution of quantum sensors on quantum networks is a key enabler of quantum technologies in interferometry, gravimetry, timekeeping, biological monitoring, and beyond. Yet, guaranteeing the security of these distributed sensors over noisy, insecure networks remains a formidable challenge. Previous efforts to combine quantum metrology and cryptography have encountered an apparently unavoidable tension, proposing bounds for security which are only loosely tied to the achievable measurement performance. Here we introduce a quantum remote sensing protocol that can rigorously certify privacy and integrity of the estimation. By employing offline bilateral Pauli-twirling, our approach forces the effective quantum channel into a Bell-diagonal form, independently of the attack. Surprisingly, this also preserves metrological sensitivity without introducing additional experimental overhead. Relying solely on public communication alongside an insecure quantum link, the protocol enables legitimate users to exactly quantify their estimation error relative to an eavesdropper controlling the channels. We experimentally demonstrate this framework by estimating an optical phase using entangled photons, observing that the users' precision consistently surpasses the eavesdropper's capabilities across a broad parameter regime. By unifying quantum cryptography and metrology, our results provide a practical pathway to achieve simultaneous quantum-limited precision and rigorous information security in real-world quantum networks.
A quantum metrology scheme can be decomposed into three quantum tasks: state preparation, parameter encoding, and measurements. Consequently, it is imperative to have access to the technologies which can execute the aforementioned tasks to fully implement a quantum metrology scheme. In the absence of one or more of these technologies, one can proceed by delegating the tasks to a third party. However, doing so has security ramifications: the third party can bias the result or leak information. In this paper, we outline different scenarios where one or more tasks are delegated to an untrusted (and possibly malicious) third party. In each scenario, we outline cryptographic protocols which can be used to circumvent malicious activity. Further, we link the effectiveness of the quantum metrology scheme to the soundness of the cryptographic protocols.
In this thesis we consider quantum communication as realised in the continuous variable quantum optical regime. The work presented includes results concerning quantum communication applications, such as entanglement distillation and quantum key distributions, as well as fundamental questions regarding measurement uncertainty and the boundary between classical and quantum correlations. In the first part of the thesis we investigate various protocols in which one engages in a trade-off between determinism and the quality of quantum correlations. In discrete variable quantum optics non-determinism is ubiquitous, with photon sources, detectors and various gates commonly operating probabilistically. In the continuous variable regime one has access to many quantum states and operations, including exotic effects such as entanglement, in a fully deterministic fashion and one might regard giving up this feature as highly undesirable. However it has been discovered that certain vital tasks such as entanglement distillation, indispensable for large scale quantum information networks, cannot be realised deterministically. We address precisely these limitations, firstly by conducting the most general analysis to date of a non-deterministic but heralded quantum amplifier that can circumvent the standard quantum limits, and distill Gaussian entanglement. We then analyse the security of long standing technique in continuous variable quantum key distribution, known as post-selection, which again allows the distillation of higher quality correlations. We provide a complete security proof in the asymptotic limit and show that there is in fact an relationship between this method and the noiseless amplifier. Furthermore, the protocol allows secure key to be generated for channel parameters where all previous CVQKD protocols fail. Thirdly we consider this equivalence between post-selection and heralded operations more generally, and conduct a detailed analysis of the post-selection based emulation of the noiseless amplifier. Turning to more fundamental issues, we consider links between several recently proposed entropic measures of quantum correlations and their potential operational links to continuous variable quantum key distribution. Finally we consider entropic uncertainty relations for continuous variables on infinite dimensional Hilbert spaces and apply these to one-sided device independent continuous variable quantum key distribution protocols.n