Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2311.03418 · Physical Review A

Spontaneous symmetry breaking of vortex number in binary alternating current countersuperflow

Wei-Can Yang, Makoto Tsubota, Hua-Bi Zeng

Published Apr 3, 2024• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In binary superfluid counterflow systems, vortex nucleation arises as a consequence of hydrodynamic instabilities when the coupling coefficient and counterflow velocity exceed the critical value. When dealing with two identical components, one might naturally anticipate that the number of vortices generated would remain equal. However, through the numerical experiments of the holographic model and the Gross-Pitaevskii equation, our investigation has unveiled a remarkable phenomenon: in alternating current counterflow systems, once the coupling coefficient and frequency exceed certain critical values, a surprising symmetry-breaking phenomenon occurs. This results in an asymmetry in the number of vortices in the two components. We establish that this phenomenon represents a continuous phase transition, which, as indicated by the phase diagram, is exclusively observable in alternating current counterflow. We provide an explanation for this intriguing phenomenon through soliton structures, thereby uncovering the complex and unique characteristics of quantum fluid instabilities and their rich phenomena.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.109.043303

Related papers

Counterflow and coflow instabilities in miscible binary superfluids

Yu-Ping An, Blaise Goutéraux, Li Li

We explore instabilities in binary superfluids with a nonvanishing relative superflow, particularly focusing on counterflow and coflow instabilities. We extend recent results on the thermodynamic origin of finite superflow instabilities in single-component superfluids to binary systems and derive a criterion for the onset of instability through a hydrodynamic analysis, which applies to interacting many-body systems at finite temperature. We find that the onset of these instabilities is signaled by the determinant of the Hessian of the thermal free energy diverging and changing sign. We verify this hydrodynamic prediction in a holographic binary superfluid modeled with gauge/gravity duality, which naturally incorporates strong coupling, finite temperature, and dissipation. We also compare to results obtained using the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for weakly interacting Bose-Einstein condensates and find that the same criterion continues to apply at zero temperature, where it reduces to evaluating derivatives of the supercurrents with respect to the superfluid velocities. We observe that the critical velocities of these instabilities follow a general scaling law related to the interaction strength between superfluid components. Finally, the nonlinear stages of the instabilities are studied by full time evolution using gauge/gravity duality, where vortex annihilation leads to a decrease of superfluid velocity back to a value where the binary superfluid phase is stable.

arXiv:2411.01972•Physical Review A•Jan 2, 2026•1 citation

Vortex Nucleation and Transition to Turbulence in two-component Bose—Einstein condensates

Shungo Ishino, Makoto Tsubota, Hiromitsu Takeuchi

We theoretically study the instability of countersuperflow, i.e. , two counter-propagating miscible superflows, in uniform two-component Bose-Einstein condensates. When the relative velocity of the counterflow exceeds a critical value, the instability causes the nucleation and expansion of vortex rings. A lot of vortex reconnections are caused and lead to binary quantum turbulence, where both components become turbulent. Then we introduce the unique velocity in two-component Bose-Einstein condensates and investigate the probability distribution of the velocity in the binary quantum turbulence to obtain the probability distribution whose tail in the high-velocity region is considerably suppressed compared to single-component quantum turbulence.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Dec 17, 2012•0 citations

Countersuperflow instability in miscible two-component Bose-Einstein condensates

Shungo Ishino, Makoto Tsubota, Hiromitsu Takeuchi

We study theoretically the instability of countersuperflow, i.e., two counterpropagating miscible superflows, in uniform two-component Bose-Einstein condensates. Countersuperflow instability causes mutual friction between the superfluids, causing a momentum exchange between the two condensates, when the relative velocity of the counterflow exceeds a critical value. The momentum exchange leads to nucleation of vortex rings from characteristic density patterns due to the nonlinear development of the instability. Expansion of the vortex rings drastically accelerates the momentum exchange, leading to a highly nonlinear regime caused by intervortex interaction and vortex reconnection between the rings. For a sufficiently large interaction between the two components, rapid expansion of the vortex rings causes isotropic turbulence and the global relative motion of the two condensates relaxes. The maximum vortex line density in the turbulence is proportional to the square of the relative velocity.

arXiv:1106.0884•Physical Review A•Jun 3, 2011•56 citations

Counter-rotating vortices in miscible two-component Bose-Einstein condensates

Shungo Ishino, Makoto Tsubota, Hiromitsu Takeuchi

Counter-rotating vortices in miscible two-component Bose-Einstein condensates, in which superflows counter-rotate between the two components around the overlapped vortex cores, are studied theoretically in a pancake-shaped potential. In a linear stability analysis with the Bogoliubov--de Gennes model, we show that counter-rotating vortices are dynamically unstable against splitting into multiple vortices. The instability shows characteristic behaviors as a result of counter-superflow instability, which causes relaxation of relative flows between the two components in binary condensates. The characteristic behaviors are completely different from those of multiquantum vortices in single-component Bose-Einstein condensates; the number of vortices generated by the instability can become larger than the initial winding number of the counter-rotating vortex. We also investigate the nonlinear dynamics of the instability by numerically solving the Gross-Pitaevskii equations. The nonlinear dynamics drastically changes when the winding number of counter-rotating vortices becomes larger, which lead to nucleation of vortex pairs outside of the vortex core. The instability eventually develops into turbulence after the relaxation of the relative rotation between the two components.

arXiv:1310.2082•Physical Review A•Dec 10, 2013•24 citations

Generation of Dark-Bright Soliton Trains in Superfluid-Superfluid Counterflow

Chris Hamner, JiaJia Chang, Peter Engels +1 more

The dynamics of two penetrating superfluids exhibit an intriguing variety of nonlinear effects. Using two distinguishable components of a Bose-Einstein condensate, we investigate the counterflow of two superfluids in a narrow channel. We present the first experimental observation of trains of dark-bright solitons generated by the counterflow. Our observations are theoretically interpreted by three-dimensional numerical simulations for the coupled Gross-Pitaevskii equations and the analysis of a jump in the two relatively flowing components' densities. Counterflow-induced modulational instability for this miscible system is identified as the central process in the dynamics.

arXiv:1005.2610•Physical Review Letters•Feb 11, 2011•324 citations

Vortex–bright-soliton dipoles: Bifurcations, symmetry breaking, and soliton tunneling in a vortex-induced double well

M. Pola, Jan Stockhofe, Peter Schmelcher +1 more

The emergence of vortex-bright soliton dipoles in two-component Bose-Einstein condensates through bifurcations from suitable eigenstates of the underlying linear system is examined. These dipoles can have their bright solitary structures be in phase (symmetric) or out of phase (anti-symmetric). The dynamical robustness of each of these two possibilities is considered and the out-of-phase case is found to exhibit an intriguing symmetry-breaking instability that can in turn lead to tunneling of the bright wave function between the two vortex ``wells.'' We interpret this phenomenon by virtue of a vortex-induced double-well system, whose spontaneous symmetry breaking leads to asymmetric vortex-bright dipoles, in addition to the symmetric and antisymmetric ones. The theoretical prediction of these states is corroborated by detailed numerical computations.

arXiv:1207.0386•Physical Review A•Nov 2, 2012•50 citations
In binary superfluid counterflow systems, vortex nucleation arises as a consequence of hydrodynamic instabilities when the coupling coefficient and counterflow velocity exceed the critical value. When dealing with two identical components, one might naturally anticipate that the number of vortices generated would remain equal. However, through the numerical experiments of the holographic model and the Gross-Pitaevskii equation, our investigation has unveiled a remarkable phenomenon: in alternating current counterflow systems, once the coupling coefficient and frequency exceed certain critical values, a surprising symmetry-breaking phenomenon occurs. This results in an asymmetry in the number of vortices in the two components. We establish that this phenomenon represents a continuous phase transition, which, as indicated by the phase diagram, is exclusively observable in alternating current counterflow. We provide an explanation for this intriguing phenomenon through soliton structures, thereby uncovering the complex and unique characteristics of quantum fluid instabilities and their rich phenomena.
We explore instabilities in binary superfluids with a nonvanishing relative superflow, particularly focusing on counterflow and coflow instabilities. We extend recent results on the thermodynamic origin of finite superflow instabilities in single-component superfluids to binary systems and derive a criterion for the onset of instability through a hydrodynamic analysis, which applies to interacting many-body systems at finite temperature. We find that the onset of these instabilities is signaled by the determinant of the Hessian of the thermal free energy diverging and changing sign. We verify this hydrodynamic prediction in a holographic binary superfluid modeled with gauge/gravity duality, which naturally incorporates strong coupling, finite temperature, and dissipation. We also compare to results obtained using the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for weakly interacting Bose-Einstein condensates and find that the same criterion continues to apply at zero temperature, where it reduces to evaluating derivatives of the supercurrents with respect to the superfluid velocities. We observe that the critical velocities of these instabilities follow a general scaling law related to the interaction strength between superfluid components. Finally, the nonlinear stages of the instabilities are studied by full time evolution using gauge/gravity duality, where vortex annihilation leads to a decrease of superfluid velocity back to a value where the binary superfluid phase is stable.
We theoretically study the instability of countersuperflow, i.e. , two counter-propagating miscible superflows, in uniform two-component Bose-Einstein condensates. When the relative velocity of the counterflow exceeds a critical value, the instability causes the nucleation and expansion of vortex rings. A lot of vortex reconnections are caused and lead to binary quantum turbulence, where both components become turbulent. Then we introduce the unique velocity in two-component Bose-Einstein condensates and investigate the probability distribution of the velocity in the binary quantum turbulence to obtain the probability distribution whose tail in the high-velocity region is considerably suppressed compared to single-component quantum turbulence.
We study theoretically the instability of countersuperflow, i.e., two counterpropagating miscible superflows, in uniform two-component Bose-Einstein condensates. Countersuperflow instability causes mutual friction between the superfluids, causing a momentum exchange between the two condensates, when the relative velocity of the counterflow exceeds a critical value. The momentum exchange leads to nucleation of vortex rings from characteristic density patterns due to the nonlinear development of the instability. Expansion of the vortex rings drastically accelerates the momentum exchange, leading to a highly nonlinear regime caused by intervortex interaction and vortex reconnection between the rings. For a sufficiently large interaction between the two components, rapid expansion of the vortex rings causes isotropic turbulence and the global relative motion of the two condensates relaxes. The maximum vortex line density in the turbulence is proportional to the square of the relative velocity.
Counter-rotating vortices in miscible two-component Bose-Einstein condensates, in which superflows counter-rotate between the two components around the overlapped vortex cores, are studied theoretically in a pancake-shaped potential. In a linear stability analysis with the Bogoliubov--de Gennes model, we show that counter-rotating vortices are dynamically unstable against splitting into multiple vortices. The instability shows characteristic behaviors as a result of counter-superflow instability, which causes relaxation of relative flows between the two components in binary condensates. The characteristic behaviors are completely different from those of multiquantum vortices in single-component Bose-Einstein condensates; the number of vortices generated by the instability can become larger than the initial winding number of the counter-rotating vortex. We also investigate the nonlinear dynamics of the instability by numerically solving the Gross-Pitaevskii equations. The nonlinear dynamics drastically changes when the winding number of counter-rotating vortices becomes larger, which lead to nucleation of vortex pairs outside of the vortex core. The instability eventually develops into turbulence after the relaxation of the relative rotation between the two components.
The dynamics of two penetrating superfluids exhibit an intriguing variety of nonlinear effects. Using two distinguishable components of a Bose-Einstein condensate, we investigate the counterflow of two superfluids in a narrow channel. We present the first experimental observation of trains of dark-bright solitons generated by the counterflow. Our observations are theoretically interpreted by three-dimensional numerical simulations for the coupled Gross-Pitaevskii equations and the analysis of a jump in the two relatively flowing components' densities. Counterflow-induced modulational instability for this miscible system is identified as the central process in the dynamics.
The emergence of vortex-bright soliton dipoles in two-component Bose-Einstein condensates through bifurcations from suitable eigenstates of the underlying linear system is examined. These dipoles can have their bright solitary structures be in phase (symmetric) or out of phase (anti-symmetric). The dynamical robustness of each of these two possibilities is considered and the out-of-phase case is found to exhibit an intriguing symmetry-breaking instability that can in turn lead to tunneling of the bright wave function between the two vortex ``wells.'' We interpret this phenomenon by virtue of a vortex-induced double-well system, whose spontaneous symmetry breaking leads to asymmetric vortex-bright dipoles, in addition to the symmetric and antisymmetric ones. The theoretical prediction of these states is corroborated by detailed numerical computations.