Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2311.01306 · npj Quantum Information

Quantum error mitigation in quantum annealing

Jack Raymond, M. H. S. Amin, Andrew D. King, Richard Harris, William Bernoudy, A. J. Berkley, Kelly Boothby, Anatoly Yu. Smirnov, Fabio Altomare, Michael C. Babcock, Catia Baron, Jake Connor, Martin H. Dehn, Colin Enderud, Emile Hoskinson, Shuiyuan Huang, Mark W. Johnson, E. Ladizinsky, Trevor M. Lanting, Allison MacDonald, G. Marsden, Reza Molavi, Travis Oh, Gabriel Poulin-Lamarre, Hugh Ramp, Chris C. Rich, Berta Trullas Clavera, Nicholas Tsai, Mark Volkmann, Jed D. Whittaker, Jason J. Yao, Niclas Heinsdorf, Nitin Kaushal, Alberto Nocera, Marcel Franz, Jacek Dziarmaga

Published Mar 6, 2025• 26 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Quantum error mitigation (QEM) presents a promising near-term approach to reducing errors when estimating expectation values in quantum computing. Here, we introduce QEM techniques tailored for quantum annealing, using zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE). We implement ZNE through zero-temperature and zero-time extrapolations. The practical zero-time extrapolation developed exploits the Kibble-Zurek mechanism so that only problem-Hamiltonian rescaling is required. We conduct experimental investigations into the quantum critical and post-critical dynamics of a transverse-field Ising spin chain by examining statistics with weak and strong post-critical dynamics. We demonstrate successful mitigation of thermal noise and non-thermal errors through both of these extrapolation techniques.

DOI
10.1038/s41534-025-00977-3

Related papers

Infinite Distance Extrapolation: How error mitigation can enhance quantum error correction

George Umbrarescu, Oscar Higgott, Dan E. Browne

Quantum error mitigation (QEM) and quantum error correction (QEC) are two research areas that are often considered as distinct entities, and the problem of combining the two approaches in a non-trivial way has only recently started to be explored. In this paper, we explore a paradigm at the intersection of the two, based on the error mitigation technique of Zero-Noise Extrapolation (ZNE), that uses the distance of an error correcting code as a noise parameter. This is distinct from some alternative approaches, as QEC is here used as a subroutine inside the QEM framework, while other proposals use QEM as a subroutine inside QEC experiments. Intuitively, we exploit the fact that a reduction in the physical noise level is analogous to an increase in the code distance, as both of them result in a decrease in the logical error rate. As such, the extrapolation to zero noise in the case of ZNE becomes comparable to the extrapolation to infinite distance in the case of this method. We describe how to calculate expectation values from a fault-tolerant computation, and we gain some analytical intuition for our ansatz choice. We explore the performance of the considered method to reduce the errors in a range of expectation values for a realistic circuit-level noise model and realistic device imperfections on the rotated surface code, and we particularly show that the performance of the method holds even in the case of non-stabiliser input states.

quant-pharXiv:2603.11285•Mar 13, 2026•6 citations

Quantum Error Mitigation: A Comprehensive Survey

Ratun Rahman, Dinh C. Nguyen

Quantum noise poses a significant challenge for current near-term quantum computing. Quantum error mitigation (QEM) has therefore emerged as a key strategy, offering a practical and effective solution to reduce error impacts and enhance the performance of near-term variational quantum circuits (VQC). Given the lack of a comprehensive survey on this important topic in the literature, this article provides a dedicated overview of QEM, including both during and after the training of VQC. Specifically, during VQC training, we explore and discuss key QEM techniques such as optimal control and dynamical decoupling. For the post-processing stage of VQC, we will examine and discuss mitigation techniques such as zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) and probabilistic error cancellation (PEC). For each of these QEM techniques, we will investigate the fundamentals, mitigation concepts, and recent advances. Subsequently, we also explore research toolboxes, including Mitiq and Qiskit Aer, as well as provide a case study that demonstrates contextual multi-armed bandit-guided ZNE. Finally, we discuss ongoing problems and future research initiatives, including ML-assisted mitigation and integration with error correction. This survey article aims to synthesize the state-of-the-art in QEM, offer organized insights across approaches, and propose potential paths towards error-resilient quantum computing.

ACM Computing Surveys•Aug 21, 2026•0 citations

Sample-efficient quantum error mitigation via classical learning surrogates

Wei-You Liao, Ge Yan, Yujin Song +5 more

The pursuit of practical quantum utility on near-term quantum processors is critically challenged by their inherent noise. Quantum error mitigation (QEM) techniques are leading solutions to improve computation fidelity with relatively low qubit-overhead, while full-scale quantum error correction remains a distant goal. However, QEM techniques incur substantial measurement overheads, especially when applied to families of quantum circuits parameterized by classical inputs. Focusing on zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE), a widely adopted QEM technique, here we devise the surrogate-enabled ZNE (S-ZNE), which leverages classical learning surrogates to perform ZNE entirely on the classical side. Unlike conventional ZNE, whose measurement cost scales linearly with the number of circuits, S-ZNE requires only constant measurement overhead for an entire family of quantum circuits, offering superior scalability. Theoretical analysis indicates that S-ZNE achieves accuracy comparable to conventional ZNE in many practical scenarios, and numerical experiments on up to 100-qubit ground-state energy and quantum metrology tasks confirm its effectiveness. Our approach provides a template that can be effectively extended to other quantum error mitigation protocols, opening a promising path toward scalable error mitigation.

quant-pharXiv:2511.07092•Communications Physics•Nov 11, 2025•5 citations

Application of zero-noise-extrapolation-based quantum error mitigation to a silicon spin qubit

Hanseo Sohn, Jaewon Jung, Jaemin Park +5 more

As quantum computing advances towards practical applications, reducing errors remains a crucial frontier for developing near-term devices. Errors in the quantum gates and quantum state readout could result in noisy circuits, which would prevent the acquisition of the exact expectation values of the observables. Although ultimate robustness to errors is known to be achievable by quantum error correction-based fault-tolerant quantum computing, its successful implementation demands large-scale quantum processors with low average error rates that are not yet widely available. In contrast, quantum error mitigation (QEM) offers more immediate and practical techniques, which do not require extensive resources and can be readily applied to existing quantum devices to improve the accuracy of the expectation values. Here, we report the implementation of a zero-noise extrapolation-based error mitigation technique on a silicon spin qubit platform. This technique has recently been successfully demonstrated for other platforms such as superconducting qubits, trapped-ion qubits, and photonic processors. We first explore three methods for amplifying noise on a silicon spin qubit: global folding, local folding, and pulse stretching, using a standard randomized benchmarking protocol. We then apply global folding-based zero-noise extrapolation to the state tomography and achieve a state fidelity of 99.96% (98.52%), compared to the unmitigated fidelity of 75.82% (82.16%) for different preparation states. The results show that the zero-noise extrapolation technique is a versatile approach that is generally adaptable to quantum computing platforms with different noise characteristics through appropriate noise amplification methods.

arXiv:2410.10339•Physical Review A•May 13, 2025•6 citations

Sample-efficient quantum error mitigation via classical learning surrogates

He-Liang Huang, Wei-You Liao, Ge Yan +5 more

Abstract The pursuit of practical quantum utility on near-term quantum processors is critically challenged by their inherent noise. Quantum error mitigation (QEM) techniques are leading solutions to improve computation fidelity with relatively low qubit-overhead, while full-scale quantum error correction remains a distant goal. However, QEM techniques incur substantial measurement overheads, especially when applied to families of quantum circuits parameterized by classical inputs. Focusing on zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE), a widely adopted QEM technique, here we devise the surrogate-enabled ZNE (S-ZNE), which leverages classical learning surrogates to perform ZNE entirely on the classical side. Unlike conventional ZNE, whose measurement cost scales linearly with the number of circuits, S-ZNE requires only constant measurement overhead for an entire family of quantum circuits, offering superior scalability. Theoretical analysis indicates that S-ZNE achieves accuracy comparable to conventional ZNE in many practical scenarios, and numerical experiments on up to 100-qubit ground-state energy and quantum metrology tasks confirm its effectiveness. Our approach provides a template that can be effectively extended to other quantum error mitigation protocols, opening a promising path toward scalable error mitigation.

•Feb 6, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Error Mitigation and Quantum Error Correction in Near-Term Application

Ugnė Liaubaitė

Quantum computation is expected to have significant practical applications. The main problem in quantum computing is susceptibility to noise. Quantum error correction was developed to allow large-scale applications of quantum computing by achieving fault tolerance. However, as large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computation is not available, the question of applications of near-term hardware remains important. Current noisy intermediate-scale (NISQ) quantum devices can be used for small applications or as testbeds for larger applications; noise suppression techniques are of significant importance to their applicability. This thesis addresses noise suppression via quantum error mitigation (QEM) and quantum error correction (QEC) for near-term applications. The work aims to improve the understanding of noise-suppression techniques and their performance for exploring the physical systems of interest. The results presented in this thesis are divided into QEM and QEC chapters. The majority of the work is focused on QEM. The main interest of this thesis is the application of QEM to Hamiltonian simulations. Two simulation methods: the Trotter method and a quantum signal processing-based method, are explored. Both simulation methods, enhanced by zero-noise extrapolation, are employed to simulate the transverse-field Ising model. The obtained numerical results are promising, as the QEM allows a good recovery of noiseless values in low-noise shallow circuits, even with fixed sampling resources. A further result obtained in the QEM domain is a definition of a mitigation technique based on optimal measurement (in a metrological sense). The presentation includes analytical calculations of implementation costs and error propagation, as well as a numerical application to Hamiltonian simulation, yielding promising results: noise suppression by several orders of magnitude. The QEC part of the thesis explores its application in quantum metrology. The focus is on parameter sensing in many-body Hamiltonians. The results are purely analytical and extend a known lemma to $m$-local homogeneous Pauli Hamiltonian parameter sensing. This allows discussion of the scaling achieved for sensing the Hamiltonian parameters with respect to the code properties. The results in this thesis establish applications of QEM and QEC in selected near-term applications, quantify their performance, and discuss caveats and potential future applications. This thesis presents a theoretical and numerical study with implications for future experimental implementations. The relative success of the QEM and QEC shown in this thesis relies on tailoring the techniques to a chosen problem, highlighting the importance of technique adaptation in near-term applications.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
Abstract Quantum error mitigation (QEM) presents a promising near-term approach to reducing errors when estimating expectation values in quantum computing. Here, we introduce QEM techniques tailored for quantum annealing, using zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE). We implement ZNE through zero-temperature and zero-time extrapolations. The practical zero-time extrapolation developed exploits the Kibble-Zurek mechanism so that only problem-Hamiltonian rescaling is required. We conduct experimental investigations into the quantum critical and post-critical dynamics of a transverse-field Ising spin chain by examining statistics with weak and strong post-critical dynamics. We demonstrate successful mitigation of thermal noise and non-thermal errors through both of these extrapolation techniques.
Quantum error mitigation (QEM) and quantum error correction (QEC) are two research areas that are often considered as distinct entities, and the problem of combining the two approaches in a non-trivial way has only recently started to be explored. In this paper, we explore a paradigm at the intersection of the two, based on the error mitigation technique of Zero-Noise Extrapolation (ZNE), that uses the distance of an error correcting code as a noise parameter. This is distinct from some alternative approaches, as QEC is here used as a subroutine inside the QEM framework, while other proposals use QEM as a subroutine inside QEC experiments. Intuitively, we exploit the fact that a reduction in the physical noise level is analogous to an increase in the code distance, as both of them result in a decrease in the logical error rate. As such, the extrapolation to zero noise in the case of ZNE becomes comparable to the extrapolation to infinite distance in the case of this method. We describe how to calculate expectation values from a fault-tolerant computation, and we gain some analytical intuition for our ansatz choice. We explore the performance of the considered method to reduce the errors in a range of expectation values for a realistic circuit-level noise model and realistic device imperfections on the rotated surface code, and we particularly show that the performance of the method holds even in the case of non-stabiliser input states.
Quantum noise poses a significant challenge for current near-term quantum computing. Quantum error mitigation (QEM) has therefore emerged as a key strategy, offering a practical and effective solution to reduce error impacts and enhance the performance of near-term variational quantum circuits (VQC). Given the lack of a comprehensive survey on this important topic in the literature, this article provides a dedicated overview of QEM, including both during and after the training of VQC. Specifically, during VQC training, we explore and discuss key QEM techniques such as optimal control and dynamical decoupling. For the post-processing stage of VQC, we will examine and discuss mitigation techniques such as zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) and probabilistic error cancellation (PEC). For each of these QEM techniques, we will investigate the fundamentals, mitigation concepts, and recent advances. Subsequently, we also explore research toolboxes, including Mitiq and Qiskit Aer, as well as provide a case study that demonstrates contextual multi-armed bandit-guided ZNE. Finally, we discuss ongoing problems and future research initiatives, including ML-assisted mitigation and integration with error correction. This survey article aims to synthesize the state-of-the-art in QEM, offer organized insights across approaches, and propose potential paths towards error-resilient quantum computing.
The pursuit of practical quantum utility on near-term quantum processors is critically challenged by their inherent noise. Quantum error mitigation (QEM) techniques are leading solutions to improve computation fidelity with relatively low qubit-overhead, while full-scale quantum error correction remains a distant goal. However, QEM techniques incur substantial measurement overheads, especially when applied to families of quantum circuits parameterized by classical inputs. Focusing on zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE), a widely adopted QEM technique, here we devise the surrogate-enabled ZNE (S-ZNE), which leverages classical learning surrogates to perform ZNE entirely on the classical side. Unlike conventional ZNE, whose measurement cost scales linearly with the number of circuits, S-ZNE requires only constant measurement overhead for an entire family of quantum circuits, offering superior scalability. Theoretical analysis indicates that S-ZNE achieves accuracy comparable to conventional ZNE in many practical scenarios, and numerical experiments on up to 100-qubit ground-state energy and quantum metrology tasks confirm its effectiveness. Our approach provides a template that can be effectively extended to other quantum error mitigation protocols, opening a promising path toward scalable error mitigation.
As quantum computing advances towards practical applications, reducing errors remains a crucial frontier for developing near-term devices. Errors in the quantum gates and quantum state readout could result in noisy circuits, which would prevent the acquisition of the exact expectation values of the observables. Although ultimate robustness to errors is known to be achievable by quantum error correction-based fault-tolerant quantum computing, its successful implementation demands large-scale quantum processors with low average error rates that are not yet widely available. In contrast, quantum error mitigation (QEM) offers more immediate and practical techniques, which do not require extensive resources and can be readily applied to existing quantum devices to improve the accuracy of the expectation values. Here, we report the implementation of a zero-noise extrapolation-based error mitigation technique on a silicon spin qubit platform. This technique has recently been successfully demonstrated for other platforms such as superconducting qubits, trapped-ion qubits, and photonic processors. We first explore three methods for amplifying noise on a silicon spin qubit: global folding, local folding, and pulse stretching, using a standard randomized benchmarking protocol. We then apply global folding-based zero-noise extrapolation to the state tomography and achieve a state fidelity of 99.96% (98.52%), compared to the unmitigated fidelity of 75.82% (82.16%) for different preparation states. The results show that the zero-noise extrapolation technique is a versatile approach that is generally adaptable to quantum computing platforms with different noise characteristics through appropriate noise amplification methods.
Abstract The pursuit of practical quantum utility on near-term quantum processors is critically challenged by their inherent noise. Quantum error mitigation (QEM) techniques are leading solutions to improve computation fidelity with relatively low qubit-overhead, while full-scale quantum error correction remains a distant goal. However, QEM techniques incur substantial measurement overheads, especially when applied to families of quantum circuits parameterized by classical inputs. Focusing on zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE), a widely adopted QEM technique, here we devise the surrogate-enabled ZNE (S-ZNE), which leverages classical learning surrogates to perform ZNE entirely on the classical side. Unlike conventional ZNE, whose measurement cost scales linearly with the number of circuits, S-ZNE requires only constant measurement overhead for an entire family of quantum circuits, offering superior scalability. Theoretical analysis indicates that S-ZNE achieves accuracy comparable to conventional ZNE in many practical scenarios, and numerical experiments on up to 100-qubit ground-state energy and quantum metrology tasks confirm its effectiveness. Our approach provides a template that can be effectively extended to other quantum error mitigation protocols, opening a promising path toward scalable error mitigation.
Quantum computation is expected to have significant practical applications. The main problem in quantum computing is susceptibility to noise. Quantum error correction was developed to allow large-scale applications of quantum computing by achieving fault tolerance. However, as large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computation is not available, the question of applications of near-term hardware remains important. Current noisy intermediate-scale (NISQ) quantum devices can be used for small applications or as testbeds for larger applications; noise suppression techniques are of significant importance to their applicability. This thesis addresses noise suppression via quantum error mitigation (QEM) and quantum error correction (QEC) for near-term applications. The work aims to improve the understanding of noise-suppression techniques and their performance for exploring the physical systems of interest. The results presented in this thesis are divided into QEM and QEC chapters. The majority of the work is focused on QEM. The main interest of this thesis is the application of QEM to Hamiltonian simulations. Two simulation methods: the Trotter method and a quantum signal processing-based method, are explored. Both simulation methods, enhanced by zero-noise extrapolation, are employed to simulate the transverse-field Ising model. The obtained numerical results are promising, as the QEM allows a good recovery of noiseless values in low-noise shallow circuits, even with fixed sampling resources. A further result obtained in the QEM domain is a definition of a mitigation technique based on optimal measurement (in a metrological sense). The presentation includes analytical calculations of implementation costs and error propagation, as well as a numerical application to Hamiltonian simulation, yielding promising results: noise suppression by several orders of magnitude. The QEC part of the thesis explores its application in quantum metrology. The focus is on parameter sensing in many-body Hamiltonians. The results are purely analytical and extend a known lemma to mmm-local homogeneous Pauli Hamiltonian parameter sensing. This allows discussion of the scaling achieved for sensing the Hamiltonian parameters with respect to the code properties. The results in this thesis establish applications of QEM and QEC in selected near-term applications, quantify their performance, and discuss caveats and potential future applications. This thesis presents a theoretical and numerical study with implications for future experimental implementations. The relative success of the QEM and QEC shown in this thesis relies on tailoring the techniques to a chosen problem, highlighting the importance of technique adaptation in near-term applications.