Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2310.15090

The prince and the pauper. A quantum paradox of Hilbert-space fundamentalism

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

Published Oct 23, 2023• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The quantum world is described by a unit vector in the Hilbert space and the Hamiltonian. Do these abstract basis-independent objects give a complete description of the physical world, or should we include observables like positions and momenta and the decomposition into subsystems? According to "Hilbert-space fundamentalism" they give a complete description, and all other features of the physical world emerge from them (Carroll, arXiv:2103.09780). Here I will give a concrete refutation of this thesis based on the symmetries of the theory of quantum measurements. These results show that even if a tensor product structure is assumed along with the unit vector and the Hamiltonian, concrete physically distinct worlds can be described by the same structures.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2310.15090

Related papers

Refutation of Hilbert Space Fundamentalism

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

According to the "Hilbert Space Fundamentalism" Thesis, all features of a physical system, including the 3D-space, a preferred basis, and factorization into subsystems, uniquely emerge from the state vector and the Hamiltonian alone. I give a simplified account of the proof from arXiv:2102.08620 showing that such emerging structures cannot be both unique and physically relevant.

arXiv:2103.15104•Mar 28, 2021•2 citations

Nothing happens in the Universe of the Everett Interpretation

Jan-Markus Schwindt

Since the scalar product is the only internal structure of a Hilbert space, all vectors of norm 1 are equivalent, in the sense that they form a perfect sphere in the Hilbert space, on which every vector looks the same. The state vector of the universe contains no information that distinguishes it from other state vectors of the same Hilbert space. If the state vector is considered as the only fundamental entity, the world is completely structureless. The illusion of interacting subsystems is due to a "bad" choice of factorization (i.e. decomposition into subsystems) of the Hilbert space. There is always a more appropriate factorization available in which subsystems don't interact and nothing happens at all. This factorization absorbs the time evolution of the state vector in a trivial way. The Many Worlds Interpretation is therefore rather a No World Interpretation. A state vector gets the property of "representing a structure" only with respect to an external observer who measures the state according to a specific factorization and basis.

arXiv:1210.8447•Oct 31, 2012•8 citations

3D-space and the preferred basis cannot uniquely emerge from the quantum structure

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

Hilbert-Space Fundamentalism (HSF) states that the only fundamental structures are the quantum state vector and the Hamiltonian, and from them everything else emerge uniquely, including the 3D-space, a preferred basis, and a preferred factorization of the Hilbert space. In this article it is shown that whenever such a structure emerges from the Hamiltonian and the state vector alone, if it is physically relevant, it is not unique. Moreover, HSF leads to strange effects like "passive" travel in time and in alternative realities, realized simply by passive transformations of the Hilbert space. The results from this article affect all theories that adhere to HSF, whether they assume branching or state vector reduction (in particular the version of Everett's Interpretation coined by Carroll and Singh "Mad-dog Everettianism"), various proposals based on decoherence, proposals that aim to describe everything by the quantum structure alone, and proposals that spacetime emerges from a purely quantum theory of gravity.

arXiv:2102.08620•Advances in Theoretical and Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2022•26 citations

No change in Hilbert space fundamentalism

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

Hilbert space fundamentalism (HSF) states that everything about the physical world is encoded in the Hamiltonian operator and the state vector (as a unit vector, not a wavefunction, which requires additional specification of a configuration space, a position basis, or the position observables). That all structures needed to describe reality, including subsystems, space, fields, emerge from these. I show that HSF can't account for our observations that the physical world changes in time.

quant-pharXiv:2602.20331•Feb 25, 2026•2 citations

No-go results on emergent space and other structures

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

Abstract It is often claimed that, from the abstract quantum state vector and Hamiltonian, everything emerges uniquely (for example the 3D-space, a preferred factorization of the Hilbert space, and a preferred basis). This thesis, called Hilbert-Space Fundamentalism (HSF), is assumed for example in Carroll and Singh’s “Mad-dog Everettianism”, some proposals based on decoherence, proposals that aim to describe everything by the quantum structure alone, and proposals that spacetime emerges from a purely quantum theory of gravity. I show that whenever the 3D-space, a preferred factorization, or any other structure emerges like this, there are infinitely many solutions. This refutes Hilbert-Space Fundamentalism. Implications for various research programs aiming to show that certain structures emerge uniquely, and for various interpretations of Quantum Mechanics, are discussed.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2023•2 citations

The world of quantum physics

Danko Dimchev Georgiev

Quantum physics is the most successful description of the physical world we live in. Quantum theoretical predictions have been experimentally tested and confirmed up to the astonishing 14 digits of precision in terms of the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron. The bra-ket notation, composed of angle brackets and vertical bars, enhances the clarity of mathematical operations and improves the comprehension of quantum mechanical expressions. Quantum wave functions participate in interference phenomenona in which two waves superpose to form a resultant wave of greater, lower, or the same amplitude. When a quantum system is measured, it undergoes indeterministic transition that actualizes only one of the states from the set of all physically possible future states of the system. The Hilbert vector space structure of the space of quantum states follows from the linearity of the Schrodinger equation. The quantum state vector and the quantum wave function in a Hilbert space are abstract mathematical concepts that are basis independent.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 6, 2017•0 citations
The quantum world is described by a unit vector in the Hilbert space and the Hamiltonian. Do these abstract basis-independent objects give a complete description of the physical world, or should we include observables like positions and momenta and the decomposition into subsystems? According to "Hilbert-space fundamentalism" they give a complete description, and all other features of the physical world emerge from them (Carroll, arXiv:2103.09780). Here I will give a concrete refutation of this thesis based on the symmetries of the theory of quantum measurements. These results show that even if a tensor product structure is assumed along with the unit vector and the Hamiltonian, concrete physically distinct worlds can be described by the same structures.
Since the scalar product is the only internal structure of a Hilbert space, all vectors of norm 1 are equivalent, in the sense that they form a perfect sphere in the Hilbert space, on which every vector looks the same. The state vector of the universe contains no information that distinguishes it from other state vectors of the same Hilbert space. If the state vector is considered as the only fundamental entity, the world is completely structureless. The illusion of interacting subsystems is due to a "bad" choice of factorization (i.e. decomposition into subsystems) of the Hilbert space. There is always a more appropriate factorization available in which subsystems don't interact and nothing happens at all. This factorization absorbs the time evolution of the state vector in a trivial way. The Many Worlds Interpretation is therefore rather a No World Interpretation. A state vector gets the property of "representing a structure" only with respect to an external observer who measures the state according to a specific factorization and basis.
Hilbert-Space Fundamentalism (HSF) states that the only fundamental structures are the quantum state vector and the Hamiltonian, and from them everything else emerge uniquely, including the 3D-space, a preferred basis, and a preferred factorization of the Hilbert space. In this article it is shown that whenever such a structure emerges from the Hamiltonian and the state vector alone, if it is physically relevant, it is not unique. Moreover, HSF leads to strange effects like "passive" travel in time and in alternative realities, realized simply by passive transformations of the Hilbert space. The results from this article affect all theories that adhere to HSF, whether they assume branching or state vector reduction (in particular the version of Everett's Interpretation coined by Carroll and Singh "Mad-dog Everettianism"), various proposals based on decoherence, proposals that aim to describe everything by the quantum structure alone, and proposals that spacetime emerges from a purely quantum theory of gravity.
Abstract It is often claimed that, from the abstract quantum state vector and Hamiltonian, everything emerges uniquely (for example the 3D-space, a preferred factorization of the Hilbert space, and a preferred basis). This thesis, called Hilbert-Space Fundamentalism (HSF), is assumed for example in Carroll and Singh’s “Mad-dog Everettianism”, some proposals based on decoherence, proposals that aim to describe everything by the quantum structure alone, and proposals that spacetime emerges from a purely quantum theory of gravity. I show that whenever the 3D-space, a preferred factorization, or any other structure emerges like this, there are infinitely many solutions. This refutes Hilbert-Space Fundamentalism. Implications for various research programs aiming to show that certain structures emerge uniquely, and for various interpretations of Quantum Mechanics, are discussed.
Quantum physics is the most successful description of the physical world we live in. Quantum theoretical predictions have been experimentally tested and confirmed up to the astonishing 14 digits of precision in terms of the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron. The bra-ket notation, composed of angle brackets and vertical bars, enhances the clarity of mathematical operations and improves the comprehension of quantum mechanical expressions. Quantum wave functions participate in interference phenomenona in which two waves superpose to form a resultant wave of greater, lower, or the same amplitude. When a quantum system is measured, it undergoes indeterministic transition that actualizes only one of the states from the set of all physically possible future states of the system. The Hilbert vector space structure of the space of quantum states follows from the linearity of the Schrodinger equation. The quantum state vector and the quantum wave function in a Hilbert space are abstract mathematical concepts that are basis independent.