Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2310.03852 · Oxford University Press eBooks

How weak values illuminate the role of ‘hidden’ variables as predictive tools

Xabier Oianguren-Asua, Albert Solé, Carlos F. Destefani, Xavier Oriols

Published Apr 1, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract In this chapter we offer an introduction to weak values from a three-fold perspective: first, outlining the protocols that enable their experimental determination; next, deriving their correlates in the quantum formalism and, finally, discussing their ontological significance according to different quantum theories or interpretations. We argue that weak values have predictive power and provide novel ways to characterise quantum systems. We show that this holds true regardless of ongoing ontological disputes. And, still, we contend that certain “hidden” variables theories like Bohmian mechanics constitute very valuable heuristic tools for identifying informative weak values or functions thereof. To illustrate these points, we present a case study concerning quantum thermalization. We show that certain weak values, singled out by Bohmian mechanics as physically relevant, play a crucial role in elucidating the thermalization time of certain systems, whereas standard expectation values are “blind” to the onset of thermalization.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780198901853.003.0016

Related papers

Grounding Bohmian mechanics in weak values and bayesianism

Howard M. Wiseman

Bohmian mechanics (BM) is a popular interpretation of quantum mechanics (QM) in which particles have real positions. The velocity of a point x in configuration space is defined as the standard probability current j ( x ) divided by the probability density P ( x ). However, this 'standard' j is in fact only one of infinitely many that transform correctly and satisfy . In this paper, I show that a particular j is singled out if one requires that j be determined experimentally as a weak value , using a technique that would make sense to a physicist with no knowledge of QM. This 'naively observable' j seems the most natural way to define j operationally. Moreover, I show that this operationally defined j equals the standard j , so, assuming , one obtains the dynamics of BM. It follows that the possible Bohmian paths are naively observable from a large enough ensemble. Furthermore, this justification for the Bohmian law of motion singles out x as the hidden variable, because (for example) the analogously defined momentum current is in general incompatible with the evolution of the momentum distribution. Finally I discuss how, in this setting, the usual quantum probabilities can be motivated from a Bayesian standpoint, via the principle of indifference.

arXiv:0706.2522•New Journal of Physics•Jun 15, 2007•206 citations

BOHM AND BOHMIAN MECHANICS

G. Introzzi, Marco Rossetti

The standard, or Copenhagen, formulation of quantum mechanics postulates that the complete specification of a quantum state is given by the corresponding state vector (completeness). A different approach is possible, assuming instead the incompleteness of the theory. Additional parameters, called “hidden variables” since they are not empirically known, would be needed to completely characterize the quantum state. The knowledge of these hidden variables would allow the precise determination of the values for the observables of the quantum system. In 1952 David Bohm, starting from such an assumption, has proposed a hidden variables formulation of quantum mechanics that is empirically equivalent to standard quantum mechanics, but offers a more rational and coherent picture of reality. Bohm's model integrates the ordinary quantum theory by introducing particle coordinates as hidden variables. Therefore, particles are distinguishable and describe trajectories in space or in configuration space that are causally determinate. In this context it is possible to explain double slit experiments and interference phenomena in terms of particle trajectories. Quantum probabilities become epistemic: the probabilistic nature of physical predictions is not an intrinsic characteristic of nature, but depends on our ignorance of the exact value of the hidden variables. Since Bohm's interpretation is, both epistemologically and ontologically, a natural extension of classical mechanics to the quantum domain, the visualization of physical processes is still possible, and the corresponding picture of reality is more intuitive. Bohm's interpretation clearly also presents limits and weaknesses: a Lorentz invariant formulation of the model is still lacking, and all the observables result to be dependent on the global context (contextuality), with the only exception of position observables.

Conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Historical Analysis and Open Questions•Jun 1, 2006•0 citations

Determination of weak values of quantum operators using only strong measurements

Eliahu Cohen, Eli Pollak

Weak values have been shown to be helpful especially when considering them as the outcomes of weak measurements. In this paper we show that, in principle, the real and imaginary parts of the weak value of any operator may be elucidated from expectation values of suitably defined density, flux, and Hermitian commutator operators. Expectation values are the outcomes of strong (projective) measurements, implying that weak values are general properties of operators in association with pre- and postselection and they need not be preferentially associated with weak measurements. They should be considered as an important measurable property which provides added information compared with the ``standard'' diagonal expectation value of an operator. As the first specific example we consider the determination of the real and imaginary parts of the weak value of the momentum operator employing projective time-of-flight experiments. Then the results are analyzed from the point of view of Bohmian mechanics. Finally, we consider recent neutron interferometry experiments used to determine the weak values of the neutron spin.

arXiv:1804.11298•Physical Review A•Oct 9, 2018•49 citations

Weak measurements: From measuring incompatible observables and testing quantum contextuality to protective measurements

Fabrizio Piacentini, Alessio Avella, Rudi Lussana +9 more

Summary form only given. Measurements are the very basis of Physics, especially in Quantum Mechanics, where they assume even a more fundamental role because of wave function collapse after a “strong” (projective) measurement. Furthermore, measuring a quantum-mechanical observable completely erases the information on its conjugate one (e.g. measurement of position erases information on momentum, and vice-versa). Nevertheless, in Quantum Mechanics other kinds of measurement are possible. For example, wave function collapse can be overcome through Weak Measurements, i.e. measurements performed with an interaction sufficiently weak not to collapse the original state, featuring several interesting properties. An example of these are weak values [1-3], realised for the first time in [4-6], that have been used for addressing fundamental questions [7-12] as Contextuality and are also a tool for Quantum Metrology [13-19]. One of the most intriguing properties of Weak Measurements is that, since they are not affected by wave function collapse, they can allow gathering simultaneous information on non-commuting observables [20], impossible with the standard (projective) measurement protocols. A second example is offered by Protective Measurements [21], a new technique able to extract information on the expectation value of an observable even measuring a single particle. In this talk, after a general introduction to WMs, we present the first realisation of sequential weak value measurements [22], i.e. a joint measurement of the weak value of (incompatible) polarizations on a single photon. Then, we present an experiment addressed to explore the connection between anomalous weak values and Contextuality [23], showing a clear violation of the inequality proposed in [12] while satisfying all the additional theoretical requests, unequivocally demonstrating the contextual nature of weak values. Finally, we present and discuss the first implementation of Protective Measurements, showing unprecedented measurement capability and demonstrating how the expectation value of an observable can be obtained with a single measurement on a single particle.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•Jun 1, 2017•0 citations

Identifying weak values with intrinsic dynamical properties in modal theories

Devashish Pandey, Rui Sampaio, Tapio Ala-Nissilä +2 more

The so-called eigenvalue-eigenstate link states that no property can be associated to a quantum system unless it is in an eigenstate of the corresponding operator. This precludes the assignation of properties to unmeasured quantum systems in general. This arbitrary limitation of orthodox quantum mechanics generates many puzzling situations such as for example the impossibility to uniquely define a work distribution, an essential building block of quantum thermodynamics. Alternatively, modal theories (e.g., Bohmian mechanics) provide an ontology that always allows one to define intrinsic properties, i.e., properties of quantum systems that are detached from any possible measuring context. We prove here that Aharonov, Albert, and Vaidman's notion of a weak value can always be identified with an intrinsic dynamical property of a quantum system defined in a certain modal theory. Furthermore, the fact that weak values are experimentally accessible (as an ensemble average of weak measurements which are postselected by a strong measurement) strengthens the idea that understanding the intrinsic (unperturbed) dynamics of quantum systems is possible and useful in a given modal theory. As examples of the physical soundness of these intrinsic properties, we discuss three intrinsic Bohmian properties, viz., the dwell time, the work distribution, and the quantum noise at high frequencies.

arXiv:1812.10257•Physical Review A•May 28, 2021•12 citations

Ontological Approaches (Hidden Variables and All That)

Bernard d’Espagnat

The highly speculative nature of the pilot-wave theory is obvious and acknowledged even by its keenest supporters. But many physicists, including those who do not believe it is a true description of what exists, may well find it useful when trying to interpret quantum theory. Hidden-variables theories are not the only theories susceptible of being interpreted as faithful descriptions of "what exists" (so-called ontological theories). In particular, several physicists investigated the possibility of building up ontological theories in which the state vector would constitute the complete specification of the physical state of the system. Within such an approach the main difficulty is of course the one linked with the reduction of the wave packet. In any ontologically interpretable theory elements must be added to standard quantum mechanics in order that objective states of individual physical systems can be defined. The models reviewed in this chapter are a sample of what has been proposed in the domain of ontologically interpretable theories.

CRC Press eBooks•May 4, 2018•0 citations
Abstract In this chapter we offer an introduction to weak values from a three-fold perspective: first, outlining the protocols that enable their experimental determination; next, deriving their correlates in the quantum formalism and, finally, discussing their ontological significance according to different quantum theories or interpretations. We argue that weak values have predictive power and provide novel ways to characterise quantum systems. We show that this holds true regardless of ongoing ontological disputes. And, still, we contend that certain “hidden” variables theories like Bohmian mechanics constitute very valuable heuristic tools for identifying informative weak values or functions thereof. To illustrate these points, we present a case study concerning quantum thermalization. We show that certain weak values, singled out by Bohmian mechanics as physically relevant, play a crucial role in elucidating the thermalization time of certain systems, whereas standard expectation values are “blind” to the onset of thermalization.
Bohmian mechanics (BM) is a popular interpretation of quantum mechanics (QM) in which particles have real positions. The velocity of a point x in configuration space is defined as the standard probability current j ( x ) divided by the probability density P ( x ). However, this 'standard' j is in fact only one of infinitely many that transform correctly and satisfy . In this paper, I show that a particular j is singled out if one requires that j be determined experimentally as a weak value , using a technique that would make sense to a physicist with no knowledge of QM. This 'naively observable' j seems the most natural way to define j operationally. Moreover, I show that this operationally defined j equals the standard j , so, assuming , one obtains the dynamics of BM. It follows that the possible Bohmian paths are naively observable from a large enough ensemble. Furthermore, this justification for the Bohmian law of motion singles out x as the hidden variable, because (for example) the analogously defined momentum current is in general incompatible with the evolution of the momentum distribution. Finally I discuss how, in this setting, the usual quantum probabilities can be motivated from a Bayesian standpoint, via the principle of indifference.
The standard, or Copenhagen, formulation of quantum mechanics postulates that the complete specification of a quantum state is given by the corresponding state vector (completeness). A different approach is possible, assuming instead the incompleteness of the theory. Additional parameters, called “hidden variables” since they are not empirically known, would be needed to completely characterize the quantum state. The knowledge of these hidden variables would allow the precise determination of the values for the observables of the quantum system. In 1952 David Bohm, starting from such an assumption, has proposed a hidden variables formulation of quantum mechanics that is empirically equivalent to standard quantum mechanics, but offers a more rational and coherent picture of reality. Bohm's model integrates the ordinary quantum theory by introducing particle coordinates as hidden variables. Therefore, particles are distinguishable and describe trajectories in space or in configuration space that are causally determinate. In this context it is possible to explain double slit experiments and interference phenomena in terms of particle trajectories. Quantum probabilities become epistemic: the probabilistic nature of physical predictions is not an intrinsic characteristic of nature, but depends on our ignorance of the exact value of the hidden variables. Since Bohm's interpretation is, both epistemologically and ontologically, a natural extension of classical mechanics to the quantum domain, the visualization of physical processes is still possible, and the corresponding picture of reality is more intuitive. Bohm's interpretation clearly also presents limits and weaknesses: a Lorentz invariant formulation of the model is still lacking, and all the observables result to be dependent on the global context (contextuality), with the only exception of position observables.
Weak values have been shown to be helpful especially when considering them as the outcomes of weak measurements. In this paper we show that, in principle, the real and imaginary parts of the weak value of any operator may be elucidated from expectation values of suitably defined density, flux, and Hermitian commutator operators. Expectation values are the outcomes of strong (projective) measurements, implying that weak values are general properties of operators in association with pre- and postselection and they need not be preferentially associated with weak measurements. They should be considered as an important measurable property which provides added information compared with the ``standard'' diagonal expectation value of an operator. As the first specific example we consider the determination of the real and imaginary parts of the weak value of the momentum operator employing projective time-of-flight experiments. Then the results are analyzed from the point of view of Bohmian mechanics. Finally, we consider recent neutron interferometry experiments used to determine the weak values of the neutron spin.
Summary form only given. Measurements are the very basis of Physics, especially in Quantum Mechanics, where they assume even a more fundamental role because of wave function collapse after a “strong” (projective) measurement. Furthermore, measuring a quantum-mechanical observable completely erases the information on its conjugate one (e.g. measurement of position erases information on momentum, and vice-versa). Nevertheless, in Quantum Mechanics other kinds of measurement are possible. For example, wave function collapse can be overcome through Weak Measurements, i.e. measurements performed with an interaction sufficiently weak not to collapse the original state, featuring several interesting properties. An example of these are weak values [1-3], realised for the first time in [4-6], that have been used for addressing fundamental questions [7-12] as Contextuality and are also a tool for Quantum Metrology [13-19]. One of the most intriguing properties of Weak Measurements is that, since they are not affected by wave function collapse, they can allow gathering simultaneous information on non-commuting observables [20], impossible with the standard (projective) measurement protocols. A second example is offered by Protective Measurements [21], a new technique able to extract information on the expectation value of an observable even measuring a single particle. In this talk, after a general introduction to WMs, we present the first realisation of sequential weak value measurements [22], i.e. a joint measurement of the weak value of (incompatible) polarizations on a single photon. Then, we present an experiment addressed to explore the connection between anomalous weak values and Contextuality [23], showing a clear violation of the inequality proposed in [12] while satisfying all the additional theoretical requests, unequivocally demonstrating the contextual nature of weak values. Finally, we present and discuss the first implementation of Protective Measurements, showing unprecedented measurement capability and demonstrating how the expectation value of an observable can be obtained with a single measurement on a single particle.
The so-called eigenvalue-eigenstate link states that no property can be associated to a quantum system unless it is in an eigenstate of the corresponding operator. This precludes the assignation of properties to unmeasured quantum systems in general. This arbitrary limitation of orthodox quantum mechanics generates many puzzling situations such as for example the impossibility to uniquely define a work distribution, an essential building block of quantum thermodynamics. Alternatively, modal theories (e.g., Bohmian mechanics) provide an ontology that always allows one to define intrinsic properties, i.e., properties of quantum systems that are detached from any possible measuring context. We prove here that Aharonov, Albert, and Vaidman's notion of a weak value can always be identified with an intrinsic dynamical property of a quantum system defined in a certain modal theory. Furthermore, the fact that weak values are experimentally accessible (as an ensemble average of weak measurements which are postselected by a strong measurement) strengthens the idea that understanding the intrinsic (unperturbed) dynamics of quantum systems is possible and useful in a given modal theory. As examples of the physical soundness of these intrinsic properties, we discuss three intrinsic Bohmian properties, viz., the dwell time, the work distribution, and the quantum noise at high frequencies.
The highly speculative nature of the pilot-wave theory is obvious and acknowledged even by its keenest supporters. But many physicists, including those who do not believe it is a true description of what exists, may well find it useful when trying to interpret quantum theory. Hidden-variables theories are not the only theories susceptible of being interpreted as faithful descriptions of "what exists" (so-called ontological theories). In particular, several physicists investigated the possibility of building up ontological theories in which the state vector would constitute the complete specification of the physical state of the system. Within such an approach the main difficulty is of course the one linked with the reduction of the wave packet. In any ontologically interpretable theory elements must be added to standard quantum mechanics in order that objective states of individual physical systems can be defined. The models reviewed in this chapter are a sample of what has been proposed in the domain of ontologically interpretable theories.