Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2310.01060 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Elementary building blocks for cluster Mott insulators

Vaishnavi Jayakumar, Ciarán Hickey

Published Jan 5, 2026• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Mott insulators, in which strong Coulomb interactions fully localize electrons on single atomic sites, play host to an incredibly rich and exciting array of strongly correlated physics. One can naturally extend this concept to cluster Mott insulators, wherein electrons localize not on single atoms but across clusters of atoms, forming "molecules in solids". The resulting localized degrees of freedom incorporate the full spectrum of electronic degrees of freedom, spin, orbital, and charge. These serve as the building blocks for cluster Mott insulators, and understanding them is an important first step toward understanding the many-body physics that emerges in candidate cluster Mott insulators. Here, we focus on elementary building blocks, neglecting some of the complexity present in real materials which can often obfuscate the underlying principles at play. Through an extensive set of exact theoretical calculations on clusters of varying geometry, number of orbitals, and number of electrons, we uncover some of the basic organizing principles of cluster Mott phases, particularly when interactions dominate and negate a simple single-particle picture. These include, for example, the identification of an additional "cluster Hund's rule", of cluster ground states that are best understood from a purely interacting perspective, and of several localized degrees of freedom which are protected by an unusual combination of discrete spatial or orbital symmetries. Finally, we discuss the impact of adding additional terms, relevant to material candidates, on the phase diagrams presented throughout, as well as the potential next steps in the journey to building a more complete picture of cluster Mott insulators.

DOI
10.1103/tssj-lg5b

Related papers

Magnetism and Superconductivity in the Two-Band Hubbard Model: A Variational Monte Carlo Perspective

Caterina De Franco

Mott insulators and high-temperature superconductivity: models and materialsBand theory was the first successful theoretical description of metals and insulators.Indeed, it was able to predict the metallic or insulating character of a given material by simple inspection of the electronic spectrum.The solution of the Schrödinger equation, in the presence of the periodic potential, generated by the lattice, gives rise to a band structure, namely a set of electronic states specified by E n (q) (where q is the momentum and n is an integer that labels the band) (Ashcroft and Mermin 2011).At zero temperature, the many-body ground state is obtained by populating the lowest-energy levels, in accordance with the Pauli principle.Then, the distinction between metals and insulators is determined by the filling of the electronic bands: whenever the highest occupied band is completely filled and there is a finite gap to the lowest unoccupied one, the system is an insulator; otherwise, in the presence of partially filled electronic bands, the system is a metal.The foundations of the band theory rely on a strong approximation in which electrons behave as independent particles.Here, the Coulomb interaction is replaced by an effective single-particle potential that represents the average (mean-field) interaction felt by each electrons and generated by all the other ones.In the early years of quantum mechanics the band picture was already well established, however, a few transition-metal 1 filling is considered.The breakdown of the band theory becomes clear when the electronelectron interaction is not negligible.Let us consider a single atom with an electron in the 1s orbital with energy at .When adding a second electron, the total energy turns out to be 2 at + U where U is the Coulomb interaction between the two electrons (see Fig. 1.1).These energy levels are fundamentally different from the usual single-electron spectrum.

•Oct 26, 2018•0 citations

Magnetism and structure of small clusters: An exact treatment of electron correlations

G. M. Pastor, R. Hirsch, Bernhard Mühlschlegel

The electronic, magnetic, and structural properties of small clusters are studied in the framework of the single-band Hubbard Hamiltonian. Results for various ground-state and excited-state many-body properties are presented, which were calculated exactly by means of Lanczos's numerical diagonalization method. A full geometry optimization is performed for N\ensuremath{\le}8 atoms by considering all possible nonequivalent cluster structures with fixed nearest-neighbor bond lengths. The most stable structure and the corresponding total spin S are obtained rigorously as a function of the Coulomb interaction strength U/t and number of electrons \ensuremath{\nu}. The resulting interplay between electron correlations, magnetism, and cluster structure is analyzed and the main trends as a function of N, U/t, and \ensuremath{\nu} are derived. The stability of cluster ferromagnetism is studied from two complementary points of view. First, for N\ensuremath{\le}8 and \ensuremath{\nu}=N+1, we determine exactly the stability of the ferromagnetic ground state with respect to electronic excitations and structural changes. It is shown that in small clusters the structural changes can be as important to the temperature dependence of the magnetization as the purely electronic excitations. Second, we determine the stability of the saturated ferromagnetic state with respect to single spin flips as a function of the band filling \ensuremath{\nu}/N. In this case a few selected larger clusters (7\ensuremath{\le}N\ensuremath{\le}43) in the strongly correlated limit (U/t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}+\ensuremath{\infty}) are considered. It is shown that the \ensuremath{\nu}/N dependence of the spin-flip energy \ensuremath{\Delta}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathrm{sf}}$ shows interesting electronic-shell-like oscillations, which reflect the characteristics of the single-particle energy-level structure and its dependence on the symmetry and size of the cluster. Finally, we conclude by discussing some of the limitations of the model together with relevant extensions. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 15, 1996•55 citations

Block orbital-selective Mott insulators: A spin excitation analysis

J. Herbrych, Gonzalo Álvarez, Adriana Moreo +1 more

We present a comprehensive study of the spin excitations---as measured by the dynamical spin structure factor $S(q,\ensuremath{\omega})$---of the so-called block-magnetic state of low-dimensional orbital-selective Mott insulators. We realize this state via both a multi-orbital Hubbard model and a generalized Kondo-Heisenberg Hamiltonian. Due to various competing energy scales present in the models, the system develops periodic ferromagnetic islands of various shapes and sizes, which are antiferromagnetically coupled. The $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2$ particular case was already found experimentally in the ladder material $\mathrm{Ba}{\mathrm{Fe}}_{2}{\mathrm{Se}}_{3}$ that becomes superconducting under pressure. Here we discuss the electronic density as well as Hubbard and Hund coupling dependence of $S(q,\ensuremath{\omega})$ using density matrix renormalization group method. Several interesting features were identified: (1) An acoustic (dispersive spin-wave) mode develops. (2) The spin-wave bandwidth establishes a new energy scale that is strongly dependent on the size of the magnetic island and becomes abnormally small for large clusters. (3) Optical (dispersionless spin excitation) modes are present for all block states studied here. In addition, a variety of phenomenological spin Hamiltonians have been investigated but none matches entirely our results that were obtained primarily at intermediate Hubbard $U$ strengths. Our comprehensive analysis provides theoretical guidance and motivation to crystal growers to search for appropriate candidate materials to realize the block states, and to neutron scattering experimentalists to confirm the exotic dynamical magnetic properties unveiled here, with a rich mixture of acoustic and optical features.

arXiv:2006.09495•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 16, 2020•21 citations

Visualizing the Mott transition

Rajarshi Tiwari

Correlated electronic systems involve strong shortrange repulsion. At integer filling, the primary effect of correlation is the emergence of an insulating state where band theory predicts a metal. Understanding the transition from a metal to this ‘Mott insulator’, as interaction strength is increased, and the effect of doping the Mott state, are classic problems in quantum many-body physics. They have been explored for decades, starting with the approximate solutions of Hubbard. The real breakthrough came in the 1990s with the advent of dynamical mean field theory, which mapped the correlated system to an embedded single site, and described the detailed spectral evolution across the Mott transition. The only deficiency in this approach is the neglect of spatial correlations, and, possibly, the lack of some ‘visual intuition’ about the transition. We discuss a complementary approach, which provides a reasonable description of Mott physics in a real-space setting and allows a certain degree of visualization. This article provides a pedagogical review of our approach and presents some illustrative results.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Strongly correlated electrons on the decorated honeycomb lattice studied with rotationally invariant slave-boson mean-field theory

H. L. Nourse

The single-orbital Hubbard model is often a good description of the low energy dynamics of strongly correlated electron systems. Importantly, the single-orbital Hubbard model at half-filling is able to capture the Mott metal-insulator transition that occurs in many materials. However, there are insulating phases (as well as other exotic phases) that occur due to strong electronic correlations in materials that are away from half-filling. In many cases, these additional phases occur because the constituent electrons of the material come from multi-orbital atomic environments that require more complicated descriptions such as the multi-orbital Hubbard model. In other cases, as we show in this thesis, the rich phase diagram arises from the underlying lattice because of special geometric features.For example, decorated lattices, which often occur in organometallics (e.g., metal-organic frameworks (MOFs)), have geometrical complexity due to the molecular structures that decorate the lattice. We argue that the effective description for many of these materials is the single-orbital Hubbard model. Yet, these materials still have rich phase diagrams because the molecular structures of the material cause effective multi-orbital interactions generated from the local Coulomb interaction.We investigate the single-orbital Hubbard model on the decorated honeycomb lattice at zero temperature using rotationally invariant slave-boson (RISB) theory in the mean-field approximation, at a range of fillings. Numerous metal-insulator transitions occur - the insulating phases include a real-space Mott insulator, a dimer Mott insulator, a trimer Mott insulator, flat-band ferromagnets, and a spin-1 Mott insulator, dominated by spin-triplet fluctuations. This menagerie of phases is caused by effective multi-orbital interactions arising from the interplay of electronic correlations, lattice structure, and band filling effects. For example, with only on-site Coulomb interactions, the spin-1 Mott insulator is driven by an effective Hund's coupling on a three-site ring that favors the formation of triplets when the three-site ring has four electrons. We argue that this exotic phase may be realized in layers of the organometallic molecular crystal Mo3S7(dmit)3.

•Feb 14, 2020•0 citations

Discovery of a Single-Band Mott Insulator in a van der Waals Flat-Band Compound

Shunye Gao, Shuai Zhang, Cuixiang Wang +31 more

The fundamental model for understanding Mott insulators is the single-band Hubbard model. An ideal realization of that model arises in Nb${}_{3}$Cl${}_{8}$, proving a powerful system for exploring Mott physics and other correlated states.

arXiv:2205.11462•Physical Review X•Dec 13, 2023•77 citations
Mott insulators, in which strong Coulomb interactions fully localize electrons on single atomic sites, play host to an incredibly rich and exciting array of strongly correlated physics. One can naturally extend this concept to cluster Mott insulators, wherein electrons localize not on single atoms but across clusters of atoms, forming "molecules in solids". The resulting localized degrees of freedom incorporate the full spectrum of electronic degrees of freedom, spin, orbital, and charge. These serve as the building blocks for cluster Mott insulators, and understanding them is an important first step toward understanding the many-body physics that emerges in candidate cluster Mott insulators. Here, we focus on elementary building blocks, neglecting some of the complexity present in real materials which can often obfuscate the underlying principles at play. Through an extensive set of exact theoretical calculations on clusters of varying geometry, number of orbitals, and number of electrons, we uncover some of the basic organizing principles of cluster Mott phases, particularly when interactions dominate and negate a simple single-particle picture. These include, for example, the identification of an additional "cluster Hund's rule", of cluster ground states that are best understood from a purely interacting perspective, and of several localized degrees of freedom which are protected by an unusual combination of discrete spatial or orbital symmetries. Finally, we discuss the impact of adding additional terms, relevant to material candidates, on the phase diagrams presented throughout, as well as the potential next steps in the journey to building a more complete picture of cluster Mott insulators.
Mott insulators and high-temperature superconductivity: models and materialsBand theory was the first successful theoretical description of metals and insulators.Indeed, it was able to predict the metallic or insulating character of a given material by simple inspection of the electronic spectrum.The solution of the Schrödinger equation, in the presence of the periodic potential, generated by the lattice, gives rise to a band structure, namely a set of electronic states specified by E n (q) (where q is the momentum and n is an integer that labels the band) (Ashcroft and Mermin 2011).At zero temperature, the many-body ground state is obtained by populating the lowest-energy levels, in accordance with the Pauli principle.Then, the distinction between metals and insulators is determined by the filling of the electronic bands: whenever the highest occupied band is completely filled and there is a finite gap to the lowest unoccupied one, the system is an insulator; otherwise, in the presence of partially filled electronic bands, the system is a metal.The foundations of the band theory rely on a strong approximation in which electrons behave as independent particles.Here, the Coulomb interaction is replaced by an effective single-particle potential that represents the average (mean-field) interaction felt by each electrons and generated by all the other ones.In the early years of quantum mechanics the band picture was already well established, however, a few transition-metal 1 filling is considered.The breakdown of the band theory becomes clear when the electronelectron interaction is not negligible.Let us consider a single atom with an electron in the 1s orbital with energy at .When adding a second electron, the total energy turns out to be 2 at + U where U is the Coulomb interaction between the two electrons (see Fig. 1.1).These energy levels are fundamentally different from the usual single-electron spectrum.
The electronic, magnetic, and structural properties of small clusters are studied in the framework of the single-band Hubbard Hamiltonian. Results for various ground-state and excited-state many-body properties are presented, which were calculated exactly by means of Lanczos's numerical diagonalization method. A full geometry optimization is performed for N\ensuremath{\le}8 atoms by considering all possible nonequivalent cluster structures with fixed nearest-neighbor bond lengths. The most stable structure and the corresponding total spin S are obtained rigorously as a function of the Coulomb interaction strength U/t and number of electrons \ensuremath{\nu}. The resulting interplay between electron correlations, magnetism, and cluster structure is analyzed and the main trends as a function of N, U/t, and \ensuremath{\nu} are derived. The stability of cluster ferromagnetism is studied from two complementary points of view. First, for N\ensuremath{\le}8 and \ensuremath{\nu}=N+1, we determine exactly the stability of the ferromagnetic ground state with respect to electronic excitations and structural changes. It is shown that in small clusters the structural changes can be as important to the temperature dependence of the magnetization as the purely electronic excitations. Second, we determine the stability of the saturated ferromagnetic state with respect to single spin flips as a function of the band filling \ensuremath{\nu}/N. In this case a few selected larger clusters (7\ensuremath{\le}N\ensuremath{\le}43) in the strongly correlated limit (U/t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}+\ensuremath{\infty}) are considered. It is shown that the \ensuremath{\nu}/N dependence of the spin-flip energy \ensuremath{\Delta}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathrm{sf}}$ shows interesting electronic-shell-like oscillations, which reflect the characteristics of the single-particle energy-level structure and its dependence on the symmetry and size of the cluster. Finally, we conclude by discussing some of the limitations of the model together with relevant extensions. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
We present a comprehensive study of the spin excitations---as measured by the dynamical spin structure factor $S(q,\ensuremath{\omega})$---of the so-called block-magnetic state of low-dimensional orbital-selective Mott insulators. We realize this state via both a multi-orbital Hubbard model and a generalized Kondo-Heisenberg Hamiltonian. Due to various competing energy scales present in the models, the system develops periodic ferromagnetic islands of various shapes and sizes, which are antiferromagnetically coupled. The $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2$ particular case was already found experimentally in the ladder material BaFe2Se3\mathrm{Ba}{\mathrm{Fe}}_{2}{\mathrm{Se}}_{3}BaFe2​Se3​ that becomes superconducting under pressure. Here we discuss the electronic density as well as Hubbard and Hund coupling dependence of $S(q,\ensuremath{\omega})$ using density matrix renormalization group method. Several interesting features were identified: (1) An acoustic (dispersive spin-wave) mode develops. (2) The spin-wave bandwidth establishes a new energy scale that is strongly dependent on the size of the magnetic island and becomes abnormally small for large clusters. (3) Optical (dispersionless spin excitation) modes are present for all block states studied here. In addition, a variety of phenomenological spin Hamiltonians have been investigated but none matches entirely our results that were obtained primarily at intermediate Hubbard UUU strengths. Our comprehensive analysis provides theoretical guidance and motivation to crystal growers to search for appropriate candidate materials to realize the block states, and to neutron scattering experimentalists to confirm the exotic dynamical magnetic properties unveiled here, with a rich mixture of acoustic and optical features.
Correlated electronic systems involve strong shortrange repulsion. At integer filling, the primary effect of correlation is the emergence of an insulating state where band theory predicts a metal. Understanding the transition from a metal to this ‘Mott insulator’, as interaction strength is increased, and the effect of doping the Mott state, are classic problems in quantum many-body physics. They have been explored for decades, starting with the approximate solutions of Hubbard. The real breakthrough came in the 1990s with the advent of dynamical mean field theory, which mapped the correlated system to an embedded single site, and described the detailed spectral evolution across the Mott transition. The only deficiency in this approach is the neglect of spatial correlations, and, possibly, the lack of some ‘visual intuition’ about the transition. We discuss a complementary approach, which provides a reasonable description of Mott physics in a real-space setting and allows a certain degree of visualization. This article provides a pedagogical review of our approach and presents some illustrative results.
The single-orbital Hubbard model is often a good description of the low energy dynamics of strongly correlated electron systems. Importantly, the single-orbital Hubbard model at half-filling is able to capture the Mott metal-insulator transition that occurs in many materials. However, there are insulating phases (as well as other exotic phases) that occur due to strong electronic correlations in materials that are away from half-filling. In many cases, these additional phases occur because the constituent electrons of the material come from multi-orbital atomic environments that require more complicated descriptions such as the multi-orbital Hubbard model. In other cases, as we show in this thesis, the rich phase diagram arises from the underlying lattice because of special geometric features.For example, decorated lattices, which often occur in organometallics (e.g., metal-organic frameworks (MOFs)), have geometrical complexity due to the molecular structures that decorate the lattice. We argue that the effective description for many of these materials is the single-orbital Hubbard model. Yet, these materials still have rich phase diagrams because the molecular structures of the material cause effective multi-orbital interactions generated from the local Coulomb interaction.We investigate the single-orbital Hubbard model on the decorated honeycomb lattice at zero temperature using rotationally invariant slave-boson (RISB) theory in the mean-field approximation, at a range of fillings. Numerous metal-insulator transitions occur - the insulating phases include a real-space Mott insulator, a dimer Mott insulator, a trimer Mott insulator, flat-band ferromagnets, and a spin-1 Mott insulator, dominated by spin-triplet fluctuations. This menagerie of phases is caused by effective multi-orbital interactions arising from the interplay of electronic correlations, lattice structure, and band filling effects. For example, with only on-site Coulomb interactions, the spin-1 Mott insulator is driven by an effective Hund's coupling on a three-site ring that favors the formation of triplets when the three-site ring has four electrons. We argue that this exotic phase may be realized in layers of the organometallic molecular crystal Mo3S7(dmit)3.
The fundamental model for understanding Mott insulators is the single-band Hubbard model. An ideal realization of that model arises in Nb3{}_{3}3​Cl8{}_{8}8​, proving a powerful system for exploring Mott physics and other correlated states.