Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2308.15495 · Physical Review X

Defining Stable Phases of Open Quantum Systems

Tibor Rakovszky, Sarang Gopalakrishnan, Curt W. von Keyserlingk

Published Nov 4, 2024• 55 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The steady states of dynamical processes can exhibit stable nontrivial phases, which can also serve as fault-tolerant classical or quantum memories. For Markovian quantum (classical) dynamics, these steady states are extremal eigenvectors of the non-Hermitian operators that generate the dynamics, i.e., quantum channels (Markov chains). However, since these operators are non-Hermitian, their spectra are an unreliable guide to dynamical relaxation timescales or to stability against perturbations. We propose an alternative dynamical criterion for a steady state to be in a stable phase, which we name uniformity: Informally, our criterion amounts to requiring that, under sufficiently small local perturbations of the dynamics, the unperturbed and perturbed steady states are related to one another by a finite-time dissipative evolution. We show that this criterion implies many of the properties one would want from any reasonable definition of a phase. We prove that uniformity is satisfied in a canonical classical cellular automaton, and we provide numerical evidence that the gap determines the relaxation rate between nearby steady states in the same phase, a situation we conjecture holds generically whenever uniformity is satisfied. We further conjecture some sufficient conditions for a channel to exhibit uniformity and therefore stability. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/physrevx.14.041031

Related papers

Designing open quantum systems with known steady states: Davies generators and beyond

Jinkang Guo, Oliver Hart, Chi-Fang Chen +2 more

We provide a systematic framework for constructing generic models of nonequilibrium quantum dynamics with a target stationary (mixed) state. Our framework identifies (almost) all combinations of Hamiltonian and dissipative dynamics that relax to a steady state of interest, generalizing the Davies’ generator for dissipative relaxation at finite temperature to nonequilibrium dynamics targeting arbitrary stationary states. We focus on Gibbs states of stabilizer Hamiltonians, identifying local Lindbladians compatible therewith by constraining the rates of dissipative and unitary processes. Moreover, given terms in the Lindbladian not compatible with the target state, our formalism identifies the operations – including syndrome measurements and local feedback – one must apply to correct these errors. Our methods also reveal new models of quantum dynamics: for example, we provide a “measurement-induced phase transition” in which measurable two-point functions exhibit critical (power-law) scaling with distance at a critical ratio of the transverse field and rate of measurement and feedback. Time-reversal symmetry – defined naturally within our formalism – can be broken both in effectively classical and intrinsically quantum ways. Our framework provides a systematic starting point for exploring the landscape of dynamical universality classes in open quantum systems, as well as identifying new protocols for quantum error correction.

arXiv:2404.14538•Quantum•Jan 28, 2025•38 citations

Non-normality and dissipation in Markovian quantum dynamics: Implications for quantum simulation

Shakib Daryanoosh

Understanding the structure and stability of open quantum dynamics is increasingly important for both fundamental studies of nonequilibrium quantum systems and the development of quantum simulation algorithms. In this work, we introduce a structural framework for Markovian open quantum systems that characterizes Lindbladian generators in terms of two scalar quantities: the dissipative strength and the non-normality. We show that normal generators admit an exact decoupling between dissipative and norm-preserving dynamics, leading to purely exponential behavior governed by the dissipative scale. In contrast, non-normality is an intrinsically dissipative feature: it vanishes in the absence of dissipation but is not implied by it. Moreover, it is structurally constrained by the interplay between the Hermitian and anti-Hermitian components of the generator. For generic Markovian open quantum systems, we identify parametric regimes controlled by a dimensionless ratio between non-normality and dissipative strength, governing the onset of transient amplification. These structural features have direct implications for quantum simulation. While Hamiltonian and normal dissipative dynamics exhibit stable evolution with standard scaling behavior, non-normal generators can induce transient growth that amplifies numerical errors and increases simulation cost. Our results provide a unified generator-level perspective on irreversibility, stability, and quantum simulation of open quantum systems.

quant-pharXiv:2604.16869•Physical Review A•Apr 21, 2026•0 citations

Universal Time-Entanglement Trade-Off in Open Quantum Systems

Andrew Pocklington, Aashish A. Clerk

We demonstrate a surprising connection between pure steady-state entanglement and relaxation time scales in an extremely broad class of Markovian open systems, where two (possibly many-body) systems, A and B , interact locally with a common dissipative environment. This setup also encompasses a broad class of adaptive quantum dynamics based on continuous measurement and feedback. As steady-state entanglement increases, there is generically an emergent strong symmetry that leads to a dynamical slow-down. Using this, we can prove rigorous bounds on relaxation times set by steady-state entanglement. We also find that this time must necessarily diverge for maximal entanglement. To test our bound, we consider the dynamics of a random ensemble of local Lindbladians that support pure steady states, finding that the bound does an excellent job of predicting how the dissipative gap varies with the amount of entanglement. Our work provides general insights into how dynamics and entanglement are connected in open systems and has specific relevance to quantum reservoir engineering. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2404.03625•PRX Quantum•Oct 15, 2024•7 citations

Criteria for Davies irreducibility of Markovian quantum dynamics

Yikang Zhang, Thomas Barthel

Abstract The dynamics of Markovian open quantum systems are described by Lindblad master equations, generating a quantum dynamical semigroup. An important concept for such systems is (Davies) irreducibility, i.e. the question whether there exist non-trivial invariant subspaces. Steady states of irreducible systems are unique and faithful, i.e. they have full rank. In the 1970s, Frigerio showed that a system is irreducible if the Lindblad operators span a self-adjoint set with trivial commutant. We discuss a more general and powerful algebraic criterion, showing that a system is irreducible if and only if the multiplicative algebra generated by the Lindblad operators L a and the operator i H + ∑ a L a † L a , involving the Hamiltonian H , is the entire operator space. Examples for two-level systems, show that a change of Hamiltonian terms as well as the addition or removal of dissipators can render a reducible system irreducible and vice versa. Examples for many-body systems show that a large class of spin chains can be rendered irreducible by dissipators on just one or two sites. Additionally, we discuss the decisive differences between (Davies) reducibility and Evans reducibility for quantum channels and dynamical semigroups which has lead to some confusion in the recent physics literature, especially, in the context of boundary-driven systems. We give a criterion for quantum reducibility in terms of associated classical Markov processes and, lastly, discuss the relation of the main result to the stabilization of pure states and argue that systems with local Lindblad operators cannot stabilize pure Fermi-sea states.

arXiv:2310.17641•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Feb 16, 2024•25 citations

Signatures of dissipative quantum chaos

Lucas Sá

Understanding the far-from-equilibrium dynamics of dissipative quantum systems, where dissipation and decoherence coexist with unitary dynamics, is an enormous challenge with immense rewards. Often, the only realistic approach is to forgo a detailed microscopic description and search for signatures of universal behavior shared by collections of many distinct, yet sufficiently similar, complex systems. Quantum chaos provides a powerful statistical framework for addressing this question, relying on symmetries to obtain information not accessible otherwise. This thesis examines how to reconcile chaos with dissipation, proceeding along two complementary lines. In Part I, we apply non-Hermitian random matrix theory to open quantum systems with Markovian dissipation and discuss the relaxation timescales and steady states of three representative examples of increasing physical relevance: single-particle Lindbladians and Kraus maps, open free fermions, and dissipative Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) models. In Part II, we investigate the symmetries, correlations, and universality of many-body open quantum systems, classifying several models of dissipative quantum matter. From a theoretical viewpoint, this thesis lays out a generic framework for the study of the universal properties of realistic, chaotic, and dissipative quantum systems. From a practical viewpoint, it provides the concrete building blocks of dynamical dissipative evolution constrained by symmetry, with potential technological impact on the fabrication of complex quantum structures. (Full abstract in the thesis.)

arXiv:2311.01518•Nov 2, 2023•8 citations

Dynamical emergence of Markovianity in local time scheme

J. Jeknić-Dugić, M. Arsenijević, M. Dugić

Recently we pointed out the so-called local time scheme as a novel approach to quantum foundations that solves the preferred pointer-basis problem. In this paper, we introduce and analyse in depth a rather non-standard dynamical map that is imposed by the scheme. On the one hand, the map does not allow for introducing a properly defined generator of the evolution nor does it represent a quantum channel. On the other hand, the map is linear, positive, trace preserving and unital as well as completely positive, but is not divisible and therefore non-Markovian. Nevertheless, we provide quantitative criteria for dynamical emergence of time-coarse-grained Markovianity, for exact dynamics of an open system, as well as for operationally defined approximation of a closed or open many-particle system. A closed system never reaches a steady state, whereas an open system may reach a unique steady state given by the Lüders-von Neumann formula; where the smaller the open system, the faster a steady state is attained. These generic findings extend the standard open quantum systems theory and substantially tackle certain cosmological issues.

arXiv:1510.02913•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Jun 1, 2016•7 citations
The steady states of dynamical processes can exhibit stable nontrivial phases, which can also serve as fault-tolerant classical or quantum memories. For Markovian quantum (classical) dynamics, these steady states are extremal eigenvectors of the non-Hermitian operators that generate the dynamics, i.e., quantum channels (Markov chains). However, since these operators are non-Hermitian, their spectra are an unreliable guide to dynamical relaxation timescales or to stability against perturbations. We propose an alternative dynamical criterion for a steady state to be in a stable phase, which we name uniformity: Informally, our criterion amounts to requiring that, under sufficiently small local perturbations of the dynamics, the unperturbed and perturbed steady states are related to one another by a finite-time dissipative evolution. We show that this criterion implies many of the properties one would want from any reasonable definition of a phase. We prove that uniformity is satisfied in a canonical classical cellular automaton, and we provide numerical evidence that the gap determines the relaxation rate between nearby steady states in the same phase, a situation we conjecture holds generically whenever uniformity is satisfied. We further conjecture some sufficient conditions for a channel to exhibit uniformity and therefore stability. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We provide a systematic framework for constructing generic models of nonequilibrium quantum dynamics with a target stationary (mixed) state. Our framework identifies (almost) all combinations of Hamiltonian and dissipative dynamics that relax to a steady state of interest, generalizing the Davies’ generator for dissipative relaxation at finite temperature to nonequilibrium dynamics targeting arbitrary stationary states. We focus on Gibbs states of stabilizer Hamiltonians, identifying local Lindbladians compatible therewith by constraining the rates of dissipative and unitary processes. Moreover, given terms in the Lindbladian not compatible with the target state, our formalism identifies the operations – including syndrome measurements and local feedback – one must apply to correct these errors. Our methods also reveal new models of quantum dynamics: for example, we provide a “measurement-induced phase transition” in which measurable two-point functions exhibit critical (power-law) scaling with distance at a critical ratio of the transverse field and rate of measurement and feedback. Time-reversal symmetry – defined naturally within our formalism – can be broken both in effectively classical and intrinsically quantum ways. Our framework provides a systematic starting point for exploring the landscape of dynamical universality classes in open quantum systems, as well as identifying new protocols for quantum error correction.
Understanding the structure and stability of open quantum dynamics is increasingly important for both fundamental studies of nonequilibrium quantum systems and the development of quantum simulation algorithms. In this work, we introduce a structural framework for Markovian open quantum systems that characterizes Lindbladian generators in terms of two scalar quantities: the dissipative strength and the non-normality. We show that normal generators admit an exact decoupling between dissipative and norm-preserving dynamics, leading to purely exponential behavior governed by the dissipative scale. In contrast, non-normality is an intrinsically dissipative feature: it vanishes in the absence of dissipation but is not implied by it. Moreover, it is structurally constrained by the interplay between the Hermitian and anti-Hermitian components of the generator. For generic Markovian open quantum systems, we identify parametric regimes controlled by a dimensionless ratio between non-normality and dissipative strength, governing the onset of transient amplification. These structural features have direct implications for quantum simulation. While Hamiltonian and normal dissipative dynamics exhibit stable evolution with standard scaling behavior, non-normal generators can induce transient growth that amplifies numerical errors and increases simulation cost. Our results provide a unified generator-level perspective on irreversibility, stability, and quantum simulation of open quantum systems.
We demonstrate a surprising connection between pure steady-state entanglement and relaxation time scales in an extremely broad class of Markovian open systems, where two (possibly many-body) systems, A and B , interact locally with a common dissipative environment. This setup also encompasses a broad class of adaptive quantum dynamics based on continuous measurement and feedback. As steady-state entanglement increases, there is generically an emergent strong symmetry that leads to a dynamical slow-down. Using this, we can prove rigorous bounds on relaxation times set by steady-state entanglement. We also find that this time must necessarily diverge for maximal entanglement. To test our bound, we consider the dynamics of a random ensemble of local Lindbladians that support pure steady states, finding that the bound does an excellent job of predicting how the dissipative gap varies with the amount of entanglement. Our work provides general insights into how dynamics and entanglement are connected in open systems and has specific relevance to quantum reservoir engineering. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Abstract The dynamics of Markovian open quantum systems are described by Lindblad master equations, generating a quantum dynamical semigroup. An important concept for such systems is (Davies) irreducibility, i.e. the question whether there exist non-trivial invariant subspaces. Steady states of irreducible systems are unique and faithful, i.e. they have full rank. In the 1970s, Frigerio showed that a system is irreducible if the Lindblad operators span a self-adjoint set with trivial commutant. We discuss a more general and powerful algebraic criterion, showing that a system is irreducible if and only if the multiplicative algebra generated by the Lindblad operators L a and the operator i H + ∑ a L a † L a , involving the Hamiltonian H , is the entire operator space. Examples for two-level systems, show that a change of Hamiltonian terms as well as the addition or removal of dissipators can render a reducible system irreducible and vice versa. Examples for many-body systems show that a large class of spin chains can be rendered irreducible by dissipators on just one or two sites. Additionally, we discuss the decisive differences between (Davies) reducibility and Evans reducibility for quantum channels and dynamical semigroups which has lead to some confusion in the recent physics literature, especially, in the context of boundary-driven systems. We give a criterion for quantum reducibility in terms of associated classical Markov processes and, lastly, discuss the relation of the main result to the stabilization of pure states and argue that systems with local Lindblad operators cannot stabilize pure Fermi-sea states.
Understanding the far-from-equilibrium dynamics of dissipative quantum systems, where dissipation and decoherence coexist with unitary dynamics, is an enormous challenge with immense rewards. Often, the only realistic approach is to forgo a detailed microscopic description and search for signatures of universal behavior shared by collections of many distinct, yet sufficiently similar, complex systems. Quantum chaos provides a powerful statistical framework for addressing this question, relying on symmetries to obtain information not accessible otherwise. This thesis examines how to reconcile chaos with dissipation, proceeding along two complementary lines. In Part I, we apply non-Hermitian random matrix theory to open quantum systems with Markovian dissipation and discuss the relaxation timescales and steady states of three representative examples of increasing physical relevance: single-particle Lindbladians and Kraus maps, open free fermions, and dissipative Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) models. In Part II, we investigate the symmetries, correlations, and universality of many-body open quantum systems, classifying several models of dissipative quantum matter. From a theoretical viewpoint, this thesis lays out a generic framework for the study of the universal properties of realistic, chaotic, and dissipative quantum systems. From a practical viewpoint, it provides the concrete building blocks of dynamical dissipative evolution constrained by symmetry, with potential technological impact on the fabrication of complex quantum structures. (Full abstract in the thesis.)
Recently we pointed out the so-called local time scheme as a novel approach to quantum foundations that solves the preferred pointer-basis problem. In this paper, we introduce and analyse in depth a rather non-standard dynamical map that is imposed by the scheme. On the one hand, the map does not allow for introducing a properly defined generator of the evolution nor does it represent a quantum channel. On the other hand, the map is linear, positive, trace preserving and unital as well as completely positive, but is not divisible and therefore non-Markovian. Nevertheless, we provide quantitative criteria for dynamical emergence of time-coarse-grained Markovianity, for exact dynamics of an open system, as well as for operationally defined approximation of a closed or open many-particle system. A closed system never reaches a steady state, whereas an open system may reach a unique steady state given by the Lüders-von Neumann formula; where the smaller the open system, the faster a steady state is attained. These generic findings extend the standard open quantum systems theory and substantially tackle certain cosmological issues.