Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2308.02496 · Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Classifying deviation from standard quantum behavior using the Kullback-Leibler divergence

Salman Sajad Wani, Saif M. Al-Kuwari, Xiaoping Shi, Yiting Chen, Abrar Ahmed Naqash, Seemin Rubab, Mir Faizal, S. Kannan

Published Dec 1, 2023• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract In this letter, we propose a novel statistical method to measure which system is better suited to probe small deviations from the usual quantum behavior. Such deviations are motivated by a number of theoretical and phenomenological motivations, and various systems have been proposed to test them. We propose that measuring deviations from quantum mechanics for a system would be easier if it had a higher Kullback-Leibler divergence. We show this explicitly for a non-local Scrödinger equation and argue that it will hold for any modification to standard quantum behavior. Thus, the results of this letter can be used to classify a wide range of theoretical and phenomenological models.

DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/ad1414

Related papers

Kullback-Leibler divergence between quantum distributions, and its upper-bound

Vincenzo Bonnici

This work presents an upper-bound to value that the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence can reach for a class of probability distributions called quantum distributions (QD). The aim is to find a distribution $U$ which maximizes the KL divergence from a given distribution $P$ under the assumption that $P$ and $U$ have been generated by distributing a given discrete quantity, a quantum. Quantum distributions naturally represent a wide range of probability distributions that are used in practical applications. Moreover, such a class of distributions can be obtained as an approximation of any probability distribution. The retrieving of an upper-bound for the entropic divergence is here shown to be possible under the condition that the compared distributions are quantum distributions over the same quantum value, thus they become comparable. Thus, entropic divergence acquires a more powerful meaning when it is applied to comparable distributions. This aspect should be taken into account in future developments of divergences. The theoretical findings are used for proposing a notion of normalized KL divergence that is empirically shown to behave differently from already known measures.

arXiv:2008.05932•Aug 13, 2020•9 citations

Nonadditive generalization of the quantum Kullback-Leibler divergence for measuring the degree of purification

Sumiyoshi Abe

The Kullback-Leibler divergence offers an information-theoretic basis for measuring the difference between two given distributions. Its quantum analog, however, fails to play a corresponding role for comparing two density matrices, if the reference states are pure states. Here it is shown that nonadditive quantum information theory inspired by nonextensive statistical mechanics is free from such a difficulty and the associated quantity, termed the quantum q-divergence, can in fact be a good information-theoretic measure of the degree of state purification. The correspondence relation between the ordinary divergence and the q-divergence is violated for the pure reference states, in general.

arXiv:quant-ph/0301136•Physical Review A•Sep 10, 2003•68 citations

A maximum value for the Kullback-Leibler divergence between quantum discrete distributions

Vincenzo Bonnici

This work presents an upper-bound for the maximum value that the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence can reach for a newly introduced class of probability distributions, called quantum distributions (QD). In particular, the aim is to find a discrete distribution $U$ which maximize the finite KL divergence from a given $P$ under the assumption that $P$ and $U$ have been generated by distributing a fixed discretized quantity. The theoretical findings are used for proposing a notion of normalized KL divergence that is empirically shown to behave differently from already known measures.

•Aug 13, 2020•0 citations

Canonical Divergence for Measuring Classical and Quantum Complexity

Domenico Felice, Stefano Mancini, Nihat Ay

A new canonical divergence is put forward for generalizing an information-geometric measure of complexity for both classical and quantum systems. On the simplex of probability measures, it is proved that the new divergence coincides with the Kullback-Leibler divergence, which is used to quantify how much a probability measure deviates from the non-interacting states that are modeled by exponential families of probabilities. On the space of positive density operators, we prove that the same divergence reduces to the quantum relative entropy, which quantifies many-party correlations of a quantum state from a Gibbs family.

arXiv:1903.09797•Entropy•Apr 24, 2019•10 citations

Nonclassicality tests by classical bounds on the statistics of multiple outcomes

Alfredo Luis

We derive simple practical tests revealing the quantum nature of states by the violation of classical upper bounds on the statistics of multiple outcomes of an observable. These criteria can be expressed in terms of the Kullback-Leibler divergence (or relative entropy). Nonclassicality tests for multiple outcomes can be satisfied by states that do not fulfill the corresponding single-outcome criteria.

Physical Review A•Aug 18, 2010•3 citations

Quantum information criteria for model selection in quantum state estimation

Hiroshi Yano, Naoki Yamamoto

Abstract Quantum state estimation (or state tomography) is an indispensable task in quantum information processing. Because full state tomography that determines all elements of the density matrix is computationally demanding, one usually takes the strategy of assuming a certain model of quantum states and identifying the model parameters. However, it is difficult to make a valid assumption given little prior knowledge on a quantum state of interest, and thus we need a reasonable model selection method for quantum state estimation. Actually, in the classical statistical estimation theory, several types of information criteria have been established and widely used in practice for appropriately choosing a classical statistical model. In this study, we propose quantum information criteria for evaluating the quality of the estimated quantum state in terms of the quantum relative entropy, which is a natural quantum analogue of the classical information criterion defined in terms of Kullback–Leibler divergence. In particular, we derive two quantum information criteria depending on the type of an estimator for the quantum relative entropy; one uses the log-likelihood and the other uses the classical shadow. The general role of information criteria is to predict the performance of an estimated model for unseen data, although it is a function of only sampled data; this generalization capability of the proposed quantum information criteria is evaluated in numerical simulations.

arXiv:2304.10949•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Sep 6, 2023•4 citations
Abstract In this letter, we propose a novel statistical method to measure which system is better suited to probe small deviations from the usual quantum behavior. Such deviations are motivated by a number of theoretical and phenomenological motivations, and various systems have been proposed to test them. We propose that measuring deviations from quantum mechanics for a system would be easier if it had a higher Kullback-Leibler divergence. We show this explicitly for a non-local Scrödinger equation and argue that it will hold for any modification to standard quantum behavior. Thus, the results of this letter can be used to classify a wide range of theoretical and phenomenological models.
This work presents an upper-bound to value that the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence can reach for a class of probability distributions called quantum distributions (QD). The aim is to find a distribution UUU which maximizes the KL divergence from a given distribution PPP under the assumption that PPP and UUU have been generated by distributing a given discrete quantity, a quantum. Quantum distributions naturally represent a wide range of probability distributions that are used in practical applications. Moreover, such a class of distributions can be obtained as an approximation of any probability distribution. The retrieving of an upper-bound for the entropic divergence is here shown to be possible under the condition that the compared distributions are quantum distributions over the same quantum value, thus they become comparable. Thus, entropic divergence acquires a more powerful meaning when it is applied to comparable distributions. This aspect should be taken into account in future developments of divergences. The theoretical findings are used for proposing a notion of normalized KL divergence that is empirically shown to behave differently from already known measures.
The Kullback-Leibler divergence offers an information-theoretic basis for measuring the difference between two given distributions. Its quantum analog, however, fails to play a corresponding role for comparing two density matrices, if the reference states are pure states. Here it is shown that nonadditive quantum information theory inspired by nonextensive statistical mechanics is free from such a difficulty and the associated quantity, termed the quantum q-divergence, can in fact be a good information-theoretic measure of the degree of state purification. The correspondence relation between the ordinary divergence and the q-divergence is violated for the pure reference states, in general.
This work presents an upper-bound for the maximum value that the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence can reach for a newly introduced class of probability distributions, called quantum distributions (QD). In particular, the aim is to find a discrete distribution UUU which maximize the finite KL divergence from a given PPP under the assumption that PPP and UUU have been generated by distributing a fixed discretized quantity. The theoretical findings are used for proposing a notion of normalized KL divergence that is empirically shown to behave differently from already known measures.
A new canonical divergence is put forward for generalizing an information-geometric measure of complexity for both classical and quantum systems. On the simplex of probability measures, it is proved that the new divergence coincides with the Kullback-Leibler divergence, which is used to quantify how much a probability measure deviates from the non-interacting states that are modeled by exponential families of probabilities. On the space of positive density operators, we prove that the same divergence reduces to the quantum relative entropy, which quantifies many-party correlations of a quantum state from a Gibbs family.
Abstract Quantum state estimation (or state tomography) is an indispensable task in quantum information processing. Because full state tomography that determines all elements of the density matrix is computationally demanding, one usually takes the strategy of assuming a certain model of quantum states and identifying the model parameters. However, it is difficult to make a valid assumption given little prior knowledge on a quantum state of interest, and thus we need a reasonable model selection method for quantum state estimation. Actually, in the classical statistical estimation theory, several types of information criteria have been established and widely used in practice for appropriately choosing a classical statistical model. In this study, we propose quantum information criteria for evaluating the quality of the estimated quantum state in terms of the quantum relative entropy, which is a natural quantum analogue of the classical information criterion defined in terms of Kullback–Leibler divergence. In particular, we derive two quantum information criteria depending on the type of an estimator for the quantum relative entropy; one uses the log-likelihood and the other uses the classical shadow. The general role of information criteria is to predict the performance of an estimated model for unseen data, although it is a function of only sampled data; this generalization capability of the proposed quantum information criteria is evaluated in numerical simulations.