Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2308.01964 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Signature of criticality in angular momentum resolved entanglement of scalar fields in d > 1

Mrinal Kanti Sarkar, Saranyo Moitra, Rajdeep Sensarma

Published Aug 13, 2024• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The scaling of entanglement entropy with subsystem size fails to distinguish between the gapped and the gapless ground states of a scalar field theory in $d>1$ dimensions. We show that the scaling of the angular momentum resolved entanglement entropy ${S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}$ with the subsystem radius $R$ can clearly distinguish between these states. For a massless theory with momentum cutoff $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}, {S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}\ensuremath{\sim}ln\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}[\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}R/\ensuremath{\ell}]$ for $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}R\ensuremath{\gg}\ensuremath{\ell}$, while ${S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}\ensuremath{\sim}{R}^{0}$ for the massive theory. In contrast, for a free Fermi gas with Fermi wave vector ${k}_{F}, {S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}\ensuremath{\sim}ln\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}[{k}_{F}R]$ for ${k}_{F}R\ensuremath{\gg}\ensuremath{\ell}$. We show how this leads to an ``area-log'' scaling of total entanglement entropy of fermions, while the extra factor of $\ensuremath{\ell}$ leads to a leading area law even for massless bosons. At finite temperatures, we find that there is a crossover in the scaling of ${S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}$ from the $T=0$ logarithmic scaling to a high $T$ linear scaling ${S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\pi}TR/3$. The logarithmic scaling exists for larger subsystem sizes for larger values of $\ensuremath{\ell}$. We provide estimates of temperatures and subsystem sizes where this critical scaling can be seen in experiments on ultracold atoms.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.110.075128

Related papers

Eigenstate Entanglement: Crossover from the Ground State to Volume Laws

Qiang Miao, Thomas Barthel

For the typical quantum many-body systems that obey the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH), we argue that the entanglement entropy of (almost) all energy eigenstates is described by a single crossover function. The ETH implies that the crossover functions can be deduced from subsystem entropies of thermal ensembles and have universal properties. These functions capture the full crossover from the ground-state entanglement regime at low energies and small subsystem size (area or log-area law) to the extensive volume-law regime at high energies or large subsystem size. For critical one-dimensional systems, a universal scaling function follows from conformal field theory and can be adapted for nonlinear dispersions. We use it to also deduce the crossover scaling function for Fermi liquids in d>1 dimensions. The analytical results are complemented by numerics for large noninteracting systems of fermions in d≤3 dimensions and have also been confirmed for bosonic systems and nonintegrable spin chains.

arXiv:1905.07760•Physical Review Letters•Jul 21, 2021•37 citations

Entanglement entropy of fermions in a strange metal

Santanu Singh, Surajit Bera, Chenyuan Li +2 more

The subsystem-size dependence of ground-state entanglement entropy and its crossover to thermal entropy as a function of temperature are well understood for one-dimensional (1D) gapless systems described by conformal field theory (CFT), and for free fermions with a Fermi surface in any dimension. However, little is known about the entanglement entropy for gapless fermionic systems without quasi-particles, such as a strange metal. Here we study the entanglement entropy of fermions in a solvable large-$N$ 1D lattice model akin to the Yukawa-Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (Yukawa SYK) model. In this model, two Fermi points are coupled to scalar bosons via spatially random Yukawa interactions, providing a solvable model of a strange metal when the bosons become critical at a quantum critical point. We exactly compute the second Rényi entropy of fermions in a spatial subregion in this model. Our results unravel crucial role of intra-subregion entanglement between fermionic and bosonic degrees of freedom along with the inter-subregion entanglement in understanding the ground states of such strongly coupled fermion-boson systems. We show that the crossover from thermal entropy to entanglement entropy, is captured by a single scaling ansatz, that collapses the second Rényi entropy of fermions for different subregion sizes and temperatures into a single universal curve. We further show that the universal scaling curve for the critical strange metal is well described by the standard CFT formula, albeit with an effective central charge substantially larger than the non-interacting value.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2608.04098•Aug 6, 2026•0 citations

Number Fluctuations and Entanglement-Spectrum Participation in Monitored Free Fermions

Enso O. Torres Alegre

On finite system sizes, monitored one-dimensional free-fermion chains display a broad crossover in entanglement scaling as the measurement rate increases, from sub-extensive behavior at weak monitoring toward an area law at strong monitoring. Analytical field theory and recent large-scale simulations indicate that this apparent change is not a finite-rate transition in the thermodynamic limit. I test, using trajectory-resolved correlation-matrix simulations (chains up to $L=96$ and up to 128 Born-rule trajectories per parameter point), whether two quantities built from the single-particle entanglement spectrum are useful finite-size diagnostics: the bipartite particle-number fluctuation $F_A=\sum_kν_k(1-ν_k)$ and a participation-style effective number of entangling modes, $\mathcal{M}_A=\exp[-\sum_k w_k\ln w_k]$, with $w_k\proptoν_k(1-ν_k)$. Both quantities track the crossover. However, for trajectory- and time-averaged steady-state values, $\mathcal{M}$ is nearly a deterministic function of $F$: a pooled curve explains 99.7\% of its variance across all rates, so $\mathcal{M}$ carries little independent information. Its main advantage is statistical: its trajectory-to-trajectory coefficient of variation is up to a factor of $\sim2$ smaller than that of the entropy or $F$ under strong monitoring. Subsystem-scaling comparisons at $L=48$--$96$ also show that a pure logarithmic law is not statistically preferred under weak monitoring; a small residual quasi-extensive component and a drifting logarithmic coefficient are instead consistent with a crossover rather than a critical phase. Thus, $F$ remains the natural experimentally motivated companion to the entropy, whereas $\mathcal{M}$ is best viewed as a variance-reduced numerical summary of essentially the same information.

quant-pharXiv:2607.16278•Jul 10, 2026•0 citations

Entanglement Scaling Laws and Eigenstate Thermalization in Many-Particle Systems

Kun Yang

law is enhanced by a logarithmic factor. In Ref. [1], we use multi-dimensional bosonization to provide a simple derivation of this result, and show that the logarithimic factor has a 1D origin. More importantly the bosonization technique allows us to take into account the Fermi liquid interactions, and obtain the leading scaling behavior of the entanglement entropy of Fermi liquids. The central result of our work is that Fermi liquid interactions do not alter the leading scaling behavior of the entanglement entropy, and the logarithmic enhancement of area law is a robust property of the Fermi liquid phase. In sharp contrast to the fermioic systems with Fermi surfaces, quantum critical (or gapless) bosonic systems do not violate the area law above 1D (except for the case discussed below). The fundamental difference lies in the fact that gapless excitations live near a single point (usually origin of momentum space) in such bosonic systems, while they live around an (extended) Fermi surface in Fermi liquids. In Ref. [2], we studied entanglement properties of some specific examples of the so called Bose metal states, in which bosons neither condense (and become a superfluid) nor localize (and insulate) at T=0. The system supports gapless excitations around “Bose surfaces,” instead of isolated points in momentum space. We showed that similar to free Fermi gas and Fermi liquids, these states violate the entanglement area law in a logarithmic fashion. Compared to ground states, much less is known concretely about entanglement in (highly) excited states. Going back to free fermion systems, in Ref. [3] we show that there exists a duality relation between ground and excited states, and the area law obeyed by ground state turns into a volume law for excited states, something widely expected but hard to prove. Most importantly, we find in appropriate limits the reduced density matrix of a subsystem takes the form of thermal density matrix, providing an explicit example of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis. Our work [3] explicitly demonstrates how statistical physics emerges from entanglement in a single eigenstate.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 4, 2015•0 citations

Scaling laws of entanglement entropy in fractal dimensions

Zheyu Cheng, Kailin Song, Jian-Wei Liu +5 more

Entanglement entropy scaling links geometry to quantum correlations and diagnoses quantum criticality. Fractal lattices extend this link to noninteger dimensions, where boundary and bulk dimensions are independent. It remains open which dimension governs entropy scaling and how strongly gap closing can enhance it. Nonlocal occupied-state projectors and the lack of translation symmetry obstruct standard methods. We overcome these obstacles and classify free-fermion entropy scaling with bounds set by the hopping across the subsystem boundary: an upper bound from its rank and the spectral gap, and a lower bound from how much it lowers the ground-state energy. With only negative-energy states filled and this energy lowering proportional to the boundary, the entanglement entropy obeys the boundary law $S_X=Θ\left(L_X^{d_{\mathrm b}}\right)$ under a uniform gap and satisfies $L_X^{d_{\mathrm b}}\lesssim S_X\lesssim L_X^{d_{\mathrm b}}\ln L_X$ when the gap closes no faster than algebraically. Here $L_X$ is the subsystem linear size and $d_{\mathrm b}$ the boundary dimension. Half occupation of the chiral zero modes gives a mixed-state entropy $S_X^{\mathrm{mix}}$ with $\max\left\{S_X,z_X\ln2\right\}\leqslant S_X^{\mathrm{mix}}\leqslant S_X+z_X\ln2$, where $z_X$ is the local zero-mode weight; an extensive $z_X$ thus makes $S_X^{\mathrm{mix}}$ follow the bulk dimension.

quant-pharXiv:2610.41761•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

Entanglement entropy scaling of the XXZ chain

Pochung Chen, Zhi-Long Xue, Ian P. McCulloch +3 more

We study the entanglement entropy scaling of the XXZ chain. While in the critical XY phase of the XXZ chain the entanglement entropy scales logarithmically with a coefficient that is determined by the associated conformal field theory, at the ferromagnetic point, however, the system is not conformally invariant yet the entanglement entropy still scales logarithmically albeit with a different coefficient. We investigate how such an nontrivial scaling at the ferromagnetic point influences the estimation of the central charge $c$ in the critical XY phase. In particular we use the entanglement scaling of the finite or infinite system, as well as the finite-size scaling of the ground state energy to estimate the value of $c$. In addition, the spin-wave velocity and the scaling dimension are also estimated. We show that in all methods the evaluations are influenced by the nearby ferromagnetic point and result in crossover behavior. Finally we discuss how to determine whether the central charge estimation is strongly influenced by the crossover behavior and how to properly evaluate the central charge.

arXiv:1306.5828•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Oct 11, 2013•13 citations
The scaling of entanglement entropy with subsystem size fails to distinguish between the gapped and the gapless ground states of a scalar field theory in d>1d>1d>1 dimensions. We show that the scaling of the angular momentum resolved entanglement entropy S\ensuremathℓ{S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}S\ensuremathℓ​ with the subsystem radius RRR can clearly distinguish between these states. For a massless theory with momentum cutoff \ensuremathΛ,S\ensuremathℓ\ensuremath∼ln[\ensuremathΛR/\ensuremathℓ]\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}, {S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}\ensuremath{\sim}ln\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}[\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}R/\ensuremath{\ell}]\ensuremathΛ,S\ensuremathℓ​\ensuremath∼ln[\ensuremathΛR/\ensuremathℓ] for \ensuremathΛR\ensuremath≫\ensuremathℓ\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}R\ensuremath{\gg}\ensuremath{\ell}\ensuremathΛR\ensuremath≫\ensuremathℓ, while S\ensuremathℓ\ensuremath∼R0{S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}\ensuremath{\sim}{R}^{0}S\ensuremathℓ​\ensuremath∼R0 for the massive theory. In contrast, for a free Fermi gas with Fermi wave vector kF,S\ensuremathℓ\ensuremath∼ln[kFR]{k}_{F}, {S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}\ensuremath{\sim}ln\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}[{k}_{F}R]kF​,S\ensuremathℓ​\ensuremath∼ln[kF​R] for kFR\ensuremath≫\ensuremathℓ{k}_{F}R\ensuremath{\gg}\ensuremath{\ell}kF​R\ensuremath≫\ensuremathℓ. We show how this leads to an ``area-log'' scaling of total entanglement entropy of fermions, while the extra factor of \ensuremathℓ\ensuremath{\ell}\ensuremathℓ leads to a leading area law even for massless bosons. At finite temperatures, we find that there is a crossover in the scaling of S\ensuremathℓ{S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}S\ensuremathℓ​ from the T=0T=0T=0 logarithmic scaling to a high TTT linear scaling S\ensuremathℓ\ensuremath∼\ensuremathπTR/3{S}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\pi}TR/3S\ensuremathℓ​\ensuremath∼\ensuremathπTR/3. The logarithmic scaling exists for larger subsystem sizes for larger values of \ensuremathℓ\ensuremath{\ell}\ensuremathℓ. We provide estimates of temperatures and subsystem sizes where this critical scaling can be seen in experiments on ultracold atoms.
For the typical quantum many-body systems that obey the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH), we argue that the entanglement entropy of (almost) all energy eigenstates is described by a single crossover function. The ETH implies that the crossover functions can be deduced from subsystem entropies of thermal ensembles and have universal properties. These functions capture the full crossover from the ground-state entanglement regime at low energies and small subsystem size (area or log-area law) to the extensive volume-law regime at high energies or large subsystem size. For critical one-dimensional systems, a universal scaling function follows from conformal field theory and can be adapted for nonlinear dispersions. We use it to also deduce the crossover scaling function for Fermi liquids in d>1 dimensions. The analytical results are complemented by numerics for large noninteracting systems of fermions in d≤3 dimensions and have also been confirmed for bosonic systems and nonintegrable spin chains.
The subsystem-size dependence of ground-state entanglement entropy and its crossover to thermal entropy as a function of temperature are well understood for one-dimensional (1D) gapless systems described by conformal field theory (CFT), and for free fermions with a Fermi surface in any dimension. However, little is known about the entanglement entropy for gapless fermionic systems without quasi-particles, such as a strange metal. Here we study the entanglement entropy of fermions in a solvable large-NNN 1D lattice model akin to the Yukawa-Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (Yukawa SYK) model. In this model, two Fermi points are coupled to scalar bosons via spatially random Yukawa interactions, providing a solvable model of a strange metal when the bosons become critical at a quantum critical point. We exactly compute the second Rényi entropy of fermions in a spatial subregion in this model. Our results unravel crucial role of intra-subregion entanglement between fermionic and bosonic degrees of freedom along with the inter-subregion entanglement in understanding the ground states of such strongly coupled fermion-boson systems. We show that the crossover from thermal entropy to entanglement entropy, is captured by a single scaling ansatz, that collapses the second Rényi entropy of fermions for different subregion sizes and temperatures into a single universal curve. We further show that the universal scaling curve for the critical strange metal is well described by the standard CFT formula, albeit with an effective central charge substantially larger than the non-interacting value.
On finite system sizes, monitored one-dimensional free-fermion chains display a broad crossover in entanglement scaling as the measurement rate increases, from sub-extensive behavior at weak monitoring toward an area law at strong monitoring. Analytical field theory and recent large-scale simulations indicate that this apparent change is not a finite-rate transition in the thermodynamic limit. I test, using trajectory-resolved correlation-matrix simulations (chains up to L=96L=96L=96 and up to 128 Born-rule trajectories per parameter point), whether two quantities built from the single-particle entanglement spectrum are useful finite-size diagnostics: the bipartite particle-number fluctuation FA=∑kνk(1−νk)F_A=\sum_kν_k(1-ν_k)FA​=∑k​νk​(1−νk​) and a participation-style effective number of entangling modes, MA=exp⁡[−∑kwkln⁡wk]\mathcal{M}_A=\exp[-\sum_k w_k\ln w_k]MA​=exp[−∑k​wk​lnwk​], with wk∝νk(1−νk)w_k\proptoν_k(1-ν_k)wk​∝νk​(1−νk​). Both quantities track the crossover. However, for trajectory- and time-averaged steady-state values, M\mathcal{M}M is nearly a deterministic function of FFF: a pooled curve explains 99.7\% of its variance across all rates, so M\mathcal{M}M carries little independent information. Its main advantage is statistical: its trajectory-to-trajectory coefficient of variation is up to a factor of ∼2\sim2∼2 smaller than that of the entropy or FFF under strong monitoring. Subsystem-scaling comparisons at L=48L=48L=48--969696 also show that a pure logarithmic law is not statistically preferred under weak monitoring; a small residual quasi-extensive component and a drifting logarithmic coefficient are instead consistent with a crossover rather than a critical phase. Thus, FFF remains the natural experimentally motivated companion to the entropy, whereas M\mathcal{M}M is best viewed as a variance-reduced numerical summary of essentially the same information.
law is enhanced by a logarithmic factor. In Ref. [1], we use multi-dimensional bosonization to provide a simple derivation of this result, and show that the logarithimic factor has a 1D origin. More importantly the bosonization technique allows us to take into account the Fermi liquid interactions, and obtain the leading scaling behavior of the entanglement entropy of Fermi liquids. The central result of our work is that Fermi liquid interactions do not alter the leading scaling behavior of the entanglement entropy, and the logarithmic enhancement of area law is a robust property of the Fermi liquid phase. In sharp contrast to the fermioic systems with Fermi surfaces, quantum critical (or gapless) bosonic systems do not violate the area law above 1D (except for the case discussed below). The fundamental difference lies in the fact that gapless excitations live near a single point (usually origin of momentum space) in such bosonic systems, while they live around an (extended) Fermi surface in Fermi liquids. In Ref. [2], we studied entanglement properties of some specific examples of the so called Bose metal states, in which bosons neither condense (and become a superfluid) nor localize (and insulate) at T=0. The system supports gapless excitations around “Bose surfaces,” instead of isolated points in momentum space. We showed that similar to free Fermi gas and Fermi liquids, these states violate the entanglement area law in a logarithmic fashion. Compared to ground states, much less is known concretely about entanglement in (highly) excited states. Going back to free fermion systems, in Ref. [3] we show that there exists a duality relation between ground and excited states, and the area law obeyed by ground state turns into a volume law for excited states, something widely expected but hard to prove. Most importantly, we find in appropriate limits the reduced density matrix of a subsystem takes the form of thermal density matrix, providing an explicit example of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis. Our work [3] explicitly demonstrates how statistical physics emerges from entanglement in a single eigenstate.
Entanglement entropy scaling links geometry to quantum correlations and diagnoses quantum criticality. Fractal lattices extend this link to noninteger dimensions, where boundary and bulk dimensions are independent. It remains open which dimension governs entropy scaling and how strongly gap closing can enhance it. Nonlocal occupied-state projectors and the lack of translation symmetry obstruct standard methods. We overcome these obstacles and classify free-fermion entropy scaling with bounds set by the hopping across the subsystem boundary: an upper bound from its rank and the spectral gap, and a lower bound from how much it lowers the ground-state energy. With only negative-energy states filled and this energy lowering proportional to the boundary, the entanglement entropy obeys the boundary law SX=Θ(LXdb)S_X=Θ\left(L_X^{d_{\mathrm b}}\right)SX​=Θ(LXdb​​) under a uniform gap and satisfies LXdb≲SX≲LXdbln⁡LXL_X^{d_{\mathrm b}}\lesssim S_X\lesssim L_X^{d_{\mathrm b}}\ln L_XLXdb​​≲SX​≲LXdb​​lnLX​ when the gap closes no faster than algebraically. Here LXL_XLX​ is the subsystem linear size and dbd_{\mathrm b}db​ the boundary dimension. Half occupation of the chiral zero modes gives a mixed-state entropy SXmixS_X^{\mathrm{mix}}SXmix​ with max⁡{SX,zXln⁡2}⩽SXmix⩽SX+zXln⁡2\max\left\{S_X,z_X\ln2\right\}\leqslant S_X^{\mathrm{mix}}\leqslant S_X+z_X\ln2max{SX​,zX​ln2}⩽SXmix​⩽SX​+zX​ln2, where zXz_XzX​ is the local zero-mode weight; an extensive zXz_XzX​ thus makes SXmixS_X^{\mathrm{mix}}SXmix​ follow the bulk dimension.
We study the entanglement entropy scaling of the XXZ chain. While in the critical XY phase of the XXZ chain the entanglement entropy scales logarithmically with a coefficient that is determined by the associated conformal field theory, at the ferromagnetic point, however, the system is not conformally invariant yet the entanglement entropy still scales logarithmically albeit with a different coefficient. We investigate how such an nontrivial scaling at the ferromagnetic point influences the estimation of the central charge ccc in the critical XY phase. In particular we use the entanglement scaling of the finite or infinite system, as well as the finite-size scaling of the ground state energy to estimate the value of ccc. In addition, the spin-wave velocity and the scaling dimension are also estimated. We show that in all methods the evaluations are influenced by the nearby ferromagnetic point and result in crossover behavior. Finally we discuss how to determine whether the central charge estimation is strongly influenced by the crossover behavior and how to properly evaluate the central charge.