Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2307.14330 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Effective Hamiltonian theory: An approximation to the equilibrium state of open quantum systems

Nicholas Anto-Sztrikacs, Brett Min, Marlon Brenes, Dvira Segal

Published Sep 29, 2023• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We extend and benchmark the recently developed Effective-Hamiltonian (EFFH) method [PRX Quantum 4, 020307 (2023)] as an approximation to the equilibrium state (``mean-force Gibbs state'') of a quantum system at strong coupling to a thermal bath. The EFFH method is an approximate framework. Through a combination of the reaction-coordinate mapping, a polaron transformation, and a controlled truncation, it imprints the system-bath coupling parameters into the system's Hamiltonian. First, we develop a variational EFFH technique. In this method, the system's parameters are renormalized by both the system-bath coupling parameters (as in the original EFFH approach) and bath temperature. Second, adopting the generalized spin-boson model, we benchmark the equilibrium state from the EFFH treatment against numerically exact simulations and demonstrate a good agreement for both polarization and coherences using the Brownian spectral function. Third, we contrast the (normal and variational) EFFH approach with the familiar (normal and variational) polaron treatment. We show that the two methods predict a similar structure for the equilibrium state, albeit the EFFH approach offers the advantage of simpler calculations and closed-form analytical results. Altogether, we argue that for temperatures comparable to the system's frequencies, the EFFH methodology provides a good approximation for the mean-force Gibbs state in the full range of system-bath coupling, from ultraweak to ultrastrong.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.108.115437

Related papers

Bath-induced interactions and transient dynamics in open quantum systems at strong coupling: Effective Hamiltonian approach

Marlon Brenes, Brett Min, Nicholas Anto-Sztrikacs +2 more

Understanding the dynamics of dissipative quantum systems, particularly beyond the weak coupling approximation, is central to various quantum applications. While numerically exact methods provide accurate solutions, they often lack the analytical insight provided by theoretical approaches. In this study, we employ the recently developed method dubbed the effective Hamiltonian theory to understand the dynamics of system-bath configurations without resorting to a perturbative description of the system-bath coupling energy. Through a combination of mapping steps and truncation, the effective Hamiltonian theory offers both analytical insights into signatures of strong couplings in open quantum systems and a straightforward path for numerical simulations. To validate the accuracy of the method, we apply it to two canonical models: a single spin immersed in a bosonic bath and two noninteracting spins in a common bath. In both cases, we study the transient regime and the steady state limit at nonzero temperature and spanning system-bath interactions from the weak to the strong regime. By comparing the results of the effective Hamiltonian theory with numerically exact simulations, we show that although the former overlooks non-Markovian features in the transient equilibration dynamics, it correctly captures non-perturbative bath-generated couplings between otherwise non-interacting spins, as observed in their synchronization dynamics and correlations. Altogether, the effective Hamiltonian theory offers a powerful approach for understanding strong coupling dynamics and thermodynamics, capturing the signatures of such interactions in both relaxation dynamics and in the steady state limit.

arXiv:2403.03386•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jun 25, 2024•18 citations

Analytical derivation of equilibrium state for open quantum system

Andrius Gelžinis, Leonas Valkūnas

Calculation of the equilibrium state of an open quantum system interacting with a bath remains a challenge to this day, mostly due to a huge number of bath degrees of freedom. Here, we present an analytical expression for the reduced density operator in terms of an effective Hamiltonian for a high temperature case. Comparing with numerically exact results, we show that our theory is accurate for slow baths and up to intermediate system-bath coupling strengths. Our results demonstrate that the equilibrium state does not depend on the shape of spectral density in the slow bath regime. The key quantity in our theory is the effective coupling between the states, which depends exponentially on the ratio of the reorganization energy to temperature and, thus, has opposite temperature dependence than could be expected from the small polaron transformation.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 5, 2020•24 citations

Effective-Hamiltonian Theory of Open Quantum Systems at Strong Coupling

Nicholas Anto-Sztrikacs, Ahsan Nazir, Dvira Segal

A new technique for open quantum dynamics, combining reaction coordinate mappings and the polaron transform, allows for efficient description of strong system-bath couplings, opening the way for novel applications in nanoscale transport and thermodynamics.

arXiv:2211.05701•PRX Quantum•Apr 13, 2023•73 citations

Open quantum systems with noncommuting coupling operators: An analytic approach

Jakub Garwoła, Dvira Segal

We present an analytic approach to treat open quantum systems strongly coupled to multiple environments via noncommuting system operators: a prime example is a qubit concurrently coupled to both decohering and dissipative baths. Our approach, which accommodates strong system-bath couplings, generalizes the recently developed reaction-coordinate polaron transform method [N. Anto-Sztrikacs et al., PRX Quantum 4, 020307 (2023)] to handle couplings to baths via noncommuting system operators. Our approach creates an effective Hamiltonian that reveals the cooperative effect of the baths on the system. For a spin impurity coupled to both dissipative and decohering environments, the effective Hamiltonian predicts the suppression of relaxation by decoherence, a phenomenon previously observed in simulations but lacking so far a theoretical foundation. We also apply the method to an ensemble of spins coupled to local baths through noncommuting operators, demonstrating the engineering of the Kitaev XY spin chain interaction. Noncommutativity is a feature of quantum systems; future prospects of our approach include the study of thermal machines that leverage such genuine quantum effects.

arXiv:2408.01865•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 12, 2024•16 citations

Local Harmonic Approximation to Quantum Mean Force Gibbs State

Kumar, Prem

When the strength of interaction between a quantum system and bath is non-negligible, the equilibrium state can deviate from the Gibbs state. But the expression of such a mean force Gibbs state in an arbitrary parameter regime is unknown and is numerically challenging to determine. In this work, we first review the local harmonic approximation to this problem [Maier et al., Phys. Rev. E 81, 021107 (2010)], which can accurately determine the mean force Gibbs state when either the system-bath coupling or the temperature is large, or when the third and higher derivatives of the potential are small compared to certain system-bath specific parameters. In the appropriate limit, we show that the local harmonic approximation reduces to the ultra-strong coupling and high temperature results recently derived in the literature. After deriving an estimate for the error induced by this method, we apply it to study some systems, like a quartic oscillator and a particle in a quartic double-well potential. We also apply this method to analyze the proton tunneling problem in a DNA recently studied in literature [Slocombe et al., Comm. Phys., vol. 5, no. 1, p. 109, 2022], where our results suggest the equilibrium value of the probability of mutation to be orders of magnitude lower than the steady state value obtained there ($10^{-8}$ vs $10^{-4}$).

arXiv:2401.11595•Jan 21, 2024•1 citation

Thermalization of open quantum systems with pseudomodes

R. Kevin Kessing, Thibaut Lacroix, Susana F. Huelga +1 more

Pseudomode approaches allow for an exact and unapproximated description of a quantum system interacting arbitrarily strongly with a bath. In general, a system coupled to pseudomodes will not thermalize to the system's Gibbs state: This is to be expected when the system-bath coupling is non-perturbative, but conflicts with common thermodynamic intuition when the system-bath coupling is asymptotically weak. We explore under which circumstances pseudomode models satisfy detailed balance (and subsequently thermalize to the system Gibbs state) and how specific choices of parameters can force "weak" detailed balance that is restricted to a limited frequency range. A combination of Hermitian and non-Hermitian pseudomodes that yields a flat effective-temperature profile is also considered. The results and criteria established here are relevant for the construction of pseudomode models in contexts where thermodynamic consistency is required.

quant-pharXiv:2608.02517•Aug 4, 2026•0 citations
We extend and benchmark the recently developed Effective-Hamiltonian (EFFH) method [PRX Quantum 4, 020307 (2023)] as an approximation to the equilibrium state (``mean-force Gibbs state'') of a quantum system at strong coupling to a thermal bath. The EFFH method is an approximate framework. Through a combination of the reaction-coordinate mapping, a polaron transformation, and a controlled truncation, it imprints the system-bath coupling parameters into the system's Hamiltonian. First, we develop a variational EFFH technique. In this method, the system's parameters are renormalized by both the system-bath coupling parameters (as in the original EFFH approach) and bath temperature. Second, adopting the generalized spin-boson model, we benchmark the equilibrium state from the EFFH treatment against numerically exact simulations and demonstrate a good agreement for both polarization and coherences using the Brownian spectral function. Third, we contrast the (normal and variational) EFFH approach with the familiar (normal and variational) polaron treatment. We show that the two methods predict a similar structure for the equilibrium state, albeit the EFFH approach offers the advantage of simpler calculations and closed-form analytical results. Altogether, we argue that for temperatures comparable to the system's frequencies, the EFFH methodology provides a good approximation for the mean-force Gibbs state in the full range of system-bath coupling, from ultraweak to ultrastrong.
Understanding the dynamics of dissipative quantum systems, particularly beyond the weak coupling approximation, is central to various quantum applications. While numerically exact methods provide accurate solutions, they often lack the analytical insight provided by theoretical approaches. In this study, we employ the recently developed method dubbed the effective Hamiltonian theory to understand the dynamics of system-bath configurations without resorting to a perturbative description of the system-bath coupling energy. Through a combination of mapping steps and truncation, the effective Hamiltonian theory offers both analytical insights into signatures of strong couplings in open quantum systems and a straightforward path for numerical simulations. To validate the accuracy of the method, we apply it to two canonical models: a single spin immersed in a bosonic bath and two noninteracting spins in a common bath. In both cases, we study the transient regime and the steady state limit at nonzero temperature and spanning system-bath interactions from the weak to the strong regime. By comparing the results of the effective Hamiltonian theory with numerically exact simulations, we show that although the former overlooks non-Markovian features in the transient equilibration dynamics, it correctly captures non-perturbative bath-generated couplings between otherwise non-interacting spins, as observed in their synchronization dynamics and correlations. Altogether, the effective Hamiltonian theory offers a powerful approach for understanding strong coupling dynamics and thermodynamics, capturing the signatures of such interactions in both relaxation dynamics and in the steady state limit.
Calculation of the equilibrium state of an open quantum system interacting with a bath remains a challenge to this day, mostly due to a huge number of bath degrees of freedom. Here, we present an analytical expression for the reduced density operator in terms of an effective Hamiltonian for a high temperature case. Comparing with numerically exact results, we show that our theory is accurate for slow baths and up to intermediate system-bath coupling strengths. Our results demonstrate that the equilibrium state does not depend on the shape of spectral density in the slow bath regime. The key quantity in our theory is the effective coupling between the states, which depends exponentially on the ratio of the reorganization energy to temperature and, thus, has opposite temperature dependence than could be expected from the small polaron transformation.
We present an analytic approach to treat open quantum systems strongly coupled to multiple environments via noncommuting system operators: a prime example is a qubit concurrently coupled to both decohering and dissipative baths. Our approach, which accommodates strong system-bath couplings, generalizes the recently developed reaction-coordinate polaron transform method [N. Anto-Sztrikacs et al., PRX Quantum 4, 020307 (2023)] to handle couplings to baths via noncommuting system operators. Our approach creates an effective Hamiltonian that reveals the cooperative effect of the baths on the system. For a spin impurity coupled to both dissipative and decohering environments, the effective Hamiltonian predicts the suppression of relaxation by decoherence, a phenomenon previously observed in simulations but lacking so far a theoretical foundation. We also apply the method to an ensemble of spins coupled to local baths through noncommuting operators, demonstrating the engineering of the Kitaev XY spin chain interaction. Noncommutativity is a feature of quantum systems; future prospects of our approach include the study of thermal machines that leverage such genuine quantum effects.
When the strength of interaction between a quantum system and bath is non-negligible, the equilibrium state can deviate from the Gibbs state. But the expression of such a mean force Gibbs state in an arbitrary parameter regime is unknown and is numerically challenging to determine. In this work, we first review the local harmonic approximation to this problem [Maier et al., Phys. Rev. E 81, 021107 (2010)], which can accurately determine the mean force Gibbs state when either the system-bath coupling or the temperature is large, or when the third and higher derivatives of the potential are small compared to certain system-bath specific parameters. In the appropriate limit, we show that the local harmonic approximation reduces to the ultra-strong coupling and high temperature results recently derived in the literature. After deriving an estimate for the error induced by this method, we apply it to study some systems, like a quartic oscillator and a particle in a quartic double-well potential. We also apply this method to analyze the proton tunneling problem in a DNA recently studied in literature [Slocombe et al., Comm. Phys., vol. 5, no. 1, p. 109, 2022], where our results suggest the equilibrium value of the probability of mutation to be orders of magnitude lower than the steady state value obtained there (10−810^{-8}10−8 vs 10−410^{-4}10−4).
Pseudomode approaches allow for an exact and unapproximated description of a quantum system interacting arbitrarily strongly with a bath. In general, a system coupled to pseudomodes will not thermalize to the system's Gibbs state: This is to be expected when the system-bath coupling is non-perturbative, but conflicts with common thermodynamic intuition when the system-bath coupling is asymptotically weak. We explore under which circumstances pseudomode models satisfy detailed balance (and subsequently thermalize to the system Gibbs state) and how specific choices of parameters can force "weak" detailed balance that is restricted to a limited frequency range. A combination of Hermitian and non-Hermitian pseudomodes that yields a flat effective-temperature profile is also considered. The results and criteria established here are relevant for the construction of pseudomode models in contexts where thermodynamic consistency is required.