Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2307.09593 · Quantum

Limitations for Quantum Algorithms to Solve Turbulent and Chaotic Systems

Dylan Lewis, Stephan Eidenbenz, Balasubramanya Nadiga, Yiğit Subaşı

Published Oct 24, 2024• 22 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the limitations of quantum computers for solving nonlinear dynamical systems. In particular, we tighten the worst-case bounds of the quantum Carleman linearisation (QCL) algorithm [Liu et al., PNAS 118, 2021] answering one of their open questions. We provide a further significant limitation for any quantum algorithm that aims to output a quantum state that approximates the normalized solution vector. Given a natural choice of coordinates for a dynamical system with one or more positive Lyapunov exponents and solutions that grow sub-exponentially, we prove that any such algorithm has complexity scaling at least exponentially in the integration time. As such, an efficient quantum algorithm for simulating chaotic systems or regimes is likely not possible.

DOI
10.22331/q-2024-10-24-1509

Related papers

Quantum algorithms for general nonlinear dynamics based on the Carleman embedding

David Jennings, Kamil Korzekwa, Matteo Lostaglio +3 more

Important nonlinear dynamics, such as those found in plasma and fluid systems, are typically hard to simulate on classical computers. Thus, if fault-tolerant quantum computers could efficiently solve such nonlinear problems, it would be a transformative change for many industries. In a recent breakthrough [Liu et al., PNAS 2021], the first efficient quantum algorithm for solving nonlinear differential equations was constructed, based on a single condition $R<1$, where $R$ characterizes the ratio of nonlinearity to dissipation. This result, however, is limited to the class of purely dissipative systems with negative log-norm, which excludes application to many important problems. In this work, we correct technical issues with this and other prior analysis, and substantially extend the scope of nonlinear dynamical systems that can be efficiently simulated on a quantum computer in a number of ways. Firstly, we extend the existing results from purely dissipative systems to a much broader class of stable systems, and show that every quadratic Lyapunov function for the linearized system corresponds to an independent $R$-number criterion for the convergence of the Carleman scheme. Secondly, we extend our stable system results to physically relevant settings where conserved polynomial quantities exist. Finally, we provide extensive results for the class of non-resonant systems. With this, we are able to show that efficient quantum algorithms exist for a much wider class of nonlinear systems than previously known, and prove the BQP-completeness of nonlinear oscillator problems of exponential size. In our analysis, we also obtain several results related to the Poincaré-Dulac theorem and diagonalization of the Carleman matrix, which could be of independent interest.

quant-pharXiv:2509.07155•Quantum•Sep 10, 2025•28 citations

Further improving quantum algorithms for nonlinear differential equations via higher-order methods and rescaling

Pedro C. S. Costa, Philipp Schleich, Mauro E. S. Morales +1 more

The solution of large systems of nonlinear differential equations is essential for many applications in science and engineering. We present three improvements to existing quantum algorithms based on the Carleman linearisation technique. First, we use a high-precision method for solving the linearised system that yields logarithmic dependence on the error and near-linear dependence on time. Second, we introduce a rescaling strategy that significantly reduces the cost, which would otherwise scale exponentially with the Carleman order, thus limiting quantum speedups for PDEs. Third, we derive tighter error bounds for Carleman linearisation. We apply our results to a class of discretised reaction-diffusion equations using higher-order finite differences for spatial resolution. We also show that enforcing a stability criterion independent of the discretisation can conflict with rescaling due to the mismatch between the max-norm and the 2-norm. Nonetheless, efficient quantum solutions remain possible when the number of discretisation points is constrained, as enabled by higher-order schemes.

arXiv:2312.09518•npj Quantum Information•Aug 18, 2025•47 citations

Quantum Algorithms for Nonlinear Differential Equations via Pivot-Shifted Carleman Linearization

Ke Wang, Zikang Jia, Shravan Veerapaneni +1 more

We develop a pivot-shifted Carleman linearization framework for quantum algorithms solving quadratic nonlinear ordinary differential equations. By shifting the dynamics by a pivot state prior to Carleman lifting, and combining this with a Lyapunov transform and rescaling, we enlarge the class of nonlinear systems that can be efficiently simulated on quantum computers. For systems that exhibit stability in the shifted coordinates, we establish long time convergence of the truncated Carleman embedding. We prove that the truncation order scales only logarithmically with the simulation time and target precision, and we derive end-to-end quantum query complexity bounds for preparing a state proportional to the final solution. By introducing a modified nonlinearity condition, this framework entirely removes the conventional lower bound requirement on the initial condition. For more general systems that remain unstable after shifting, we provide short time convergence guarantees that are similarly free from the initial condition constraints. Numerical experiments on the logistic and the Lotka-Volterra equations demonstrate that an appropriate pivot choice improves stability and accuracy, and yields exponential error decay with truncation order. These results show that pivot shifting provides a practical and theoretically justified route for extending Carleman-based quantum algorithms to a broader class of nonlinear dynamical systems.

quant-pharXiv:2605.20071•May 20, 2026•5 citations

Stable Quantum Computation of Unstable Classical Chaos

Bertrand Georgeot, Dima L. Shepelyansky

We show on the example of the Arnold cat map that classical chaotic systems can be simulated with exponential efficiency on a quantum computer. Although classical computer errors grow exponentially with time, the quantum algorithm with moderate imperfections is able to simulate accurately the unstable chaotic classical nonlinear dynamics for long times. The algorithm can be easily implemented on systems of a few qubits.

arXiv:quant-ph/0101004•Physical Review Letters•Jun 4, 2001•46 citations

Quantum computing for simulation of fluid dynamics

Claudio Sanavio, Sauro Succi

The implementation of quantum algorithms for the simulation of classical fluid dynamics poses a fundamental challenge due to the nonlinearity of the fluid equations. In this work, we provide a pedagogical introduction to quantum computing algorithms for simulating classical fluids, with a special focus on the Carleman-Lattice Boltzmann algorithm, which has captured significant attention in the last couple of years. While this algorithm demonstrates satisfactory convergence to analytical solutions for systems at low-to-moderate Reynolds numbers, it also shows an exponential depth of the corresponding quantum circuit. As a result much further analysis is needed to assess the availability of the Carleman-Lattice Boltzmann method on a quantum computer.

arXiv:2404.01302•IntechOpen eBooks•May 8, 2024•10 citations

Quantum simulation of classically chaotic systems

Asher Peres, Lawrence S. Schulman

The evolution of a classically chaotic Hamiltonian system is characterised by a computational complexity that increases exponentially with the time elapsed. Quantum systems do not exhibit such behaviour. It is therefore tempting to solve a classical problem by quantising it and following the motion of a small wavepacket. This paper shows that nothing can be gained by this subterfuge: an adequate quantum simulation requires a Hilbert space whose dimension increases exponentially with the planned duration of the simulation.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Oct 21, 1988•4 citations
We investigate the limitations of quantum computers for solving nonlinear dynamical systems. In particular, we tighten the worst-case bounds of the quantum Carleman linearisation (QCL) algorithm [Liu et al., PNAS 118, 2021] answering one of their open questions. We provide a further significant limitation for any quantum algorithm that aims to output a quantum state that approximates the normalized solution vector. Given a natural choice of coordinates for a dynamical system with one or more positive Lyapunov exponents and solutions that grow sub-exponentially, we prove that any such algorithm has complexity scaling at least exponentially in the integration time. As such, an efficient quantum algorithm for simulating chaotic systems or regimes is likely not possible.
Important nonlinear dynamics, such as those found in plasma and fluid systems, are typically hard to simulate on classical computers. Thus, if fault-tolerant quantum computers could efficiently solve such nonlinear problems, it would be a transformative change for many industries. In a recent breakthrough [Liu et al., PNAS 2021], the first efficient quantum algorithm for solving nonlinear differential equations was constructed, based on a single condition R<1R<1R<1, where RRR characterizes the ratio of nonlinearity to dissipation. This result, however, is limited to the class of purely dissipative systems with negative log-norm, which excludes application to many important problems. In this work, we correct technical issues with this and other prior analysis, and substantially extend the scope of nonlinear dynamical systems that can be efficiently simulated on a quantum computer in a number of ways. Firstly, we extend the existing results from purely dissipative systems to a much broader class of stable systems, and show that every quadratic Lyapunov function for the linearized system corresponds to an independent RRR-number criterion for the convergence of the Carleman scheme. Secondly, we extend our stable system results to physically relevant settings where conserved polynomial quantities exist. Finally, we provide extensive results for the class of non-resonant systems. With this, we are able to show that efficient quantum algorithms exist for a much wider class of nonlinear systems than previously known, and prove the BQP-completeness of nonlinear oscillator problems of exponential size. In our analysis, we also obtain several results related to the Poincaré-Dulac theorem and diagonalization of the Carleman matrix, which could be of independent interest.
The solution of large systems of nonlinear differential equations is essential for many applications in science and engineering. We present three improvements to existing quantum algorithms based on the Carleman linearisation technique. First, we use a high-precision method for solving the linearised system that yields logarithmic dependence on the error and near-linear dependence on time. Second, we introduce a rescaling strategy that significantly reduces the cost, which would otherwise scale exponentially with the Carleman order, thus limiting quantum speedups for PDEs. Third, we derive tighter error bounds for Carleman linearisation. We apply our results to a class of discretised reaction-diffusion equations using higher-order finite differences for spatial resolution. We also show that enforcing a stability criterion independent of the discretisation can conflict with rescaling due to the mismatch between the max-norm and the 2-norm. Nonetheless, efficient quantum solutions remain possible when the number of discretisation points is constrained, as enabled by higher-order schemes.
We develop a pivot-shifted Carleman linearization framework for quantum algorithms solving quadratic nonlinear ordinary differential equations. By shifting the dynamics by a pivot state prior to Carleman lifting, and combining this with a Lyapunov transform and rescaling, we enlarge the class of nonlinear systems that can be efficiently simulated on quantum computers. For systems that exhibit stability in the shifted coordinates, we establish long time convergence of the truncated Carleman embedding. We prove that the truncation order scales only logarithmically with the simulation time and target precision, and we derive end-to-end quantum query complexity bounds for preparing a state proportional to the final solution. By introducing a modified nonlinearity condition, this framework entirely removes the conventional lower bound requirement on the initial condition. For more general systems that remain unstable after shifting, we provide short time convergence guarantees that are similarly free from the initial condition constraints. Numerical experiments on the logistic and the Lotka-Volterra equations demonstrate that an appropriate pivot choice improves stability and accuracy, and yields exponential error decay with truncation order. These results show that pivot shifting provides a practical and theoretically justified route for extending Carleman-based quantum algorithms to a broader class of nonlinear dynamical systems.
The implementation of quantum algorithms for the simulation of classical fluid dynamics poses a fundamental challenge due to the nonlinearity of the fluid equations. In this work, we provide a pedagogical introduction to quantum computing algorithms for simulating classical fluids, with a special focus on the Carleman-Lattice Boltzmann algorithm, which has captured significant attention in the last couple of years. While this algorithm demonstrates satisfactory convergence to analytical solutions for systems at low-to-moderate Reynolds numbers, it also shows an exponential depth of the corresponding quantum circuit. As a result much further analysis is needed to assess the availability of the Carleman-Lattice Boltzmann method on a quantum computer.
The evolution of a classically chaotic Hamiltonian system is characterised by a computational complexity that increases exponentially with the time elapsed. Quantum systems do not exhibit such behaviour. It is therefore tempting to solve a classical problem by quantising it and following the motion of a small wavepacket. This paper shows that nothing can be gained by this subterfuge: an adequate quantum simulation requires a Hilbert space whose dimension increases exponentially with the planned duration of the simulation.