Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2307.08792 · Physical Review A

Quantum coherence and the principle of microscopic reversibility

K. Khan, W. F. Magalhães, J. S. Araújo, Bertúlio de Lima Bernardo, G. H. Aguilar

Published Nov 15, 2023• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The principle of microscopic reversibility is a fundamental element in the formulation of fluctuation relations and Onsager reciprocal relations. As such, a clear description of whether and how this principle is adapted to the quantum-mechanical scenario might be essential for a better understanding of nonequilibrium quantum processes. Here, we propose a quantum generalization of this principle which highlights the role played by coherence in the symmetry relations involving the probability of observing a quantum transition and that of the corresponding time-reversed process. We study the implications of our findings in the framework of a qubit system interacting with a thermal reservoir and implement an optical experiment that simulates the dynamics. Our theoretical and experimental results show that the influence of coherence is more decisive at low temperatures and that the maximum departure from the classical case does not take place for maximally coherent states. Classical predictions are recovered in the appropriate limits.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.108.052215

Related papers

Demonstrating Quantum Microscopic Reversibility Using Coherent States of Light

Marco Bellini, Hyukjoon Kwon, Nicola Biagi +3 more

The principle of microscopic reversibility lies at the core of fluctuation theorems, which have extended our understanding of the second law of thermodynamics to the statistical level. In the quantum regime, however, this elementary principle should be amended as the system energy cannot be sharply determined at a given quantum phase space point. In this Letter, we propose and experimentally test a quantum generalization of the microscopic reversibility when a quantum system interacts with a heat bath through energy-preserving unitary dynamics. Quantum effects can be identified by noting that the backward process is less likely to happen in the existence of quantum coherence between the system's energy eigenstates. The experimental demonstration has been realized by mixing coherent and thermal states in a beam splitter, followed by heterodyne detection in an optical setup. We verify that the quantum modification for the principle of microscopic reversibility is critical in the low-temperature limit, while the quantum-to-classical transition is observed as the temperature of the thermal field gets higher.

arXiv:2205.13089•Physical Review Letters•Oct 20, 2022•10 citations

The fluctuation theorem for currents in open quantum systems

David Andrieux, Pierre Gaspard, Takaaki Monnai +1 more

A quantum-mechanical framework is set up to describe the full counting statistics of particles flowing between reservoirs in an open system under time-dependent driving. A symmetry relation is obtained, which is the consequence of microreversibility for the probability of the nonequilibrium work and the transfer of particles and energy between the reservoirs. In some appropriate long-time limit, the symmetry relation leads to a steady-state quantum fluctuation theorem for the currents between the reservoirs. On this basis, relationships are deduced which extend the Onsager–Casimir reciprocity relations to the nonlinear response coefficients.

arXiv:0811.3687•New Journal of Physics•Apr 7, 2009•214 citations

Irreversibility and symmetry principles in quantum information

Cristina Cîrstoiu

Symmetry principles have played a crucial role in the development of modern physics and underpin our most fundamental theories of nature. The present thesis is concerned with the analysis of symmetries in the context of quantum information theory. Whenever a quantum mechanical system interacts with its environment it is subjected to decoherence, a process that is typically irreversible and most generally treated abstractly using the concept of quantum operations. If there is an underlying symmetry principle, additional structures emerge. The central question we address is, What are the consequences of global or local gauge symmetry on the structure of many-body quantum processes?This leads us to a diagrammatic framework of decomposing quantum operations into terms that respond to the symmetry principle in particular ways and respect the causal structures involved. We present two core applications. First, we address the interplay between irreversibility and repeatable use of coherent resources under symmetry constraints. Second, we give an information-theoretic perspective on gauging globally symmetric dynamics to a local symmetry applicable even in the presence of irreversibility and thus it goes beyond the usual Lagrangian formulation. Finally, we analyse the departure from conservation laws under symmetric dynamics subject to decoherence.

•Dec 1, 2018•0 citations

The role of reversibility in quantum thermodynamics and the foundations of quantum theory

Jonathan G. Richens

The first half of this thesis is dedicated to the study of generalizations of probability theory which include quantum theory and many of its alternatives. This research program seeks to understand quantum theory by exploring it ‘from the outside’, where it sits within a landscape of all operationally defined theories. We approach this problem with a new perspective: generalized decoherence. Quantum theory recovers classical theory via decoherence, where a ‘classical limit’ is achieved by a quantum system interacting with its environment, losing its quantum coherence. Typically it is the emergence of the classical world from the quantum that is studied. We reverse this paradigm and ask - how does the existence of a classical limit define the structure of quantum theory, or any other post-classical theory? We derive the existence of entangled states as a necessary feature of any theory that allows for the emergence of the classical world in this way. We then use our framework for generalized decoherence to explore the properties of theories that can ‘hyperdecohere’ to quantum theory. We find that any such theory must be very exotic compared to quantum theory, violating either the postulate of tomographic locality, reversibility, causality or purity. In the second half of this thesis we turn our attention to the second law of thermodynamics. We present a framework for deriving the second law under general constraints and explore two pertinent examples, constraining the fluctuations in work and constraining the size of the thermal bath and deriving the second law in these cases. Bounding fluctuations results in a unified free energy that contains the single-shot and Helmholtz free energies as limiting cases. Bounding the size of the thermal bath results in a finite-bath second law that is more general that previous attempts and draws connections between non-asymptotic thermodynamics and second-order information theory.

•Nov 1, 2018•0 citations

The resource theory of quantum thermodynamics

Matteo Lostaglio

Planck found, when attempting to describe the way in which hot bodies glow, that energy at microscopic scales often comes in discrete chunks. Thus began the long and intimate relationship between the field of thermodynamics, which explores our ability to manipulate heat and other energy transfers between macroscopic systems, and quantum mechanics, which explains the dynamics of individual microscopic systems. Even as both our technology and our theoretical investigations have extended to ever-smaller devices, our understanding of quantum effects on thermodynamics has remained almost exclusively limited to the quantized nature of energy. There is much more, however, to quantum theory than energy quantization. In this thesis we focus on the property of quantum coherence, the ability of quantum systems to emulate Schrodinger’s cat and somehow be neither dead nor alive, but something completely different altogether. We provide a simple and elegant formulation for the processing of coherence in thermodynamics, relying on the fact that thermodynamical processes possess an underlying time-translation symmetry. This fact allows us to quantify the ways in which coherence can play an active role, facilitating otherwise impossible thermodynamic transformations. We argue that coherence should be thought of as a distinctly quantum-mechanical thermodynamic resource. By considering an isolated quantum system connected, for some period of time, to a thermal bath, we give fundamental limitations on how coherence can be irreversibly manipulated. These limitations are related to those dictated on energy transfer by the second law of thermodynamics. Others topics that are investigated here is what is the role of correlations at the smallest scales and the conversion of quantum coherence into work. It has long been appreciated that thermodynamics is subtly interlinked with the notion of information. This work provides evidence that, to apply the laws of thermodynamics to the smallest systems around us, we must develop deeper insights into the nature of quantum information.

•Aug 1, 2016•10 citations

Maximum entropy production rate in quantum thermodynamics

Gian Paolo Beretta

In the framework of the recent quest for well-behaved nonlinear extensions of the traditional Schrödinger-von Neumann unitary dynamics that could provide fundamental explanations of recent experimental evidence of loss of quantum coherence at the microscopic level, a recent paper [Gheorghiu-Svirschevski 2001 Phys. Rev. A 63 054102] reproposes the nonlinear equation of motion proposed by the present author [see Beretta G P 1987 Found. Phys. 17 365 and references therein] for quantum (thermo)dynamics of a single isolated indivisible constituent system, such as a single particle, qubit, qudit, spin or atomic system, or a Bose-Einstein or Fermi-Dirac field. As already proved, such nonlinear dynamics entails a fundamental unifying microscopic proof and extension of Onsager's reciprocity and Callen's fluctuation-dissipation relations to all nonequilibrium states, close and far from thermodynamic equilibrium. In this paper we propose a brief but self-contained review of the main results already proved, including the explicit geometrical construction of the equation of motion from the steepest-entropy-ascent ansatz and its exact mathematical and conceptual equivalence with the maximal-entropy-generation variational-principle formulation presented in Gheorghiu-Svirschevski S 2001 Phys. Rev. A 63 022105. Moreover, we show how it can be extended to the case of a composite system to obtain the general form of the equation of motion, consistent with the demanding requirements of strong separability and of compatibility with general thermodynamics principles. The irreversible term in the equation of motion describes the spontaneous attraction of the state operator in the direction of steepest entropy ascent, thus implementing the maximum entropy production principle in quantum theory. The time rate at which the path of steepest entropy ascent is followed has so far been left unspecified. As a step towards the identification of such rate, here we propose a possible, well-behaved and intriguing, general closure of the dynamics, compatible with the nontrivial requirements of strong separability. Based on the time–energy Heisenberg uncertainty relation, we derive a lower bound to the internal-relaxation-time functionals that determine the rate of entropy generation. This bound entails an upper bound to the rate of entropy generation. By this extreme maximal-entropy-generation-rate ansatz, each indivisible subsystem follows the direction of steepest locally perceived entropy ascent at the highest rate compatible with the time– energy uncertainty principle.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2010•47 citations
The principle of microscopic reversibility is a fundamental element in the formulation of fluctuation relations and Onsager reciprocal relations. As such, a clear description of whether and how this principle is adapted to the quantum-mechanical scenario might be essential for a better understanding of nonequilibrium quantum processes. Here, we propose a quantum generalization of this principle which highlights the role played by coherence in the symmetry relations involving the probability of observing a quantum transition and that of the corresponding time-reversed process. We study the implications of our findings in the framework of a qubit system interacting with a thermal reservoir and implement an optical experiment that simulates the dynamics. Our theoretical and experimental results show that the influence of coherence is more decisive at low temperatures and that the maximum departure from the classical case does not take place for maximally coherent states. Classical predictions are recovered in the appropriate limits.
The principle of microscopic reversibility lies at the core of fluctuation theorems, which have extended our understanding of the second law of thermodynamics to the statistical level. In the quantum regime, however, this elementary principle should be amended as the system energy cannot be sharply determined at a given quantum phase space point. In this Letter, we propose and experimentally test a quantum generalization of the microscopic reversibility when a quantum system interacts with a heat bath through energy-preserving unitary dynamics. Quantum effects can be identified by noting that the backward process is less likely to happen in the existence of quantum coherence between the system's energy eigenstates. The experimental demonstration has been realized by mixing coherent and thermal states in a beam splitter, followed by heterodyne detection in an optical setup. We verify that the quantum modification for the principle of microscopic reversibility is critical in the low-temperature limit, while the quantum-to-classical transition is observed as the temperature of the thermal field gets higher.
A quantum-mechanical framework is set up to describe the full counting statistics of particles flowing between reservoirs in an open system under time-dependent driving. A symmetry relation is obtained, which is the consequence of microreversibility for the probability of the nonequilibrium work and the transfer of particles and energy between the reservoirs. In some appropriate long-time limit, the symmetry relation leads to a steady-state quantum fluctuation theorem for the currents between the reservoirs. On this basis, relationships are deduced which extend the Onsager–Casimir reciprocity relations to the nonlinear response coefficients.
Symmetry principles have played a crucial role in the development of modern physics and underpin our most fundamental theories of nature. The present thesis is concerned with the analysis of symmetries in the context of quantum information theory. Whenever a quantum mechanical system interacts with its environment it is subjected to decoherence, a process that is typically irreversible and most generally treated abstractly using the concept of quantum operations. If there is an underlying symmetry principle, additional structures emerge. The central question we address is, What are the consequences of global or local gauge symmetry on the structure of many-body quantum processes?This leads us to a diagrammatic framework of decomposing quantum operations into terms that respond to the symmetry principle in particular ways and respect the causal structures involved. We present two core applications. First, we address the interplay between irreversibility and repeatable use of coherent resources under symmetry constraints. Second, we give an information-theoretic perspective on gauging globally symmetric dynamics to a local symmetry applicable even in the presence of irreversibility and thus it goes beyond the usual Lagrangian formulation. Finally, we analyse the departure from conservation laws under symmetric dynamics subject to decoherence.
The first half of this thesis is dedicated to the study of generalizations of probability theory which include quantum theory and many of its alternatives. This research program seeks to understand quantum theory by exploring it ‘from the outside’, where it sits within a landscape of all operationally defined theories. We approach this problem with a new perspective: generalized decoherence. Quantum theory recovers classical theory via decoherence, where a ‘classical limit’ is achieved by a quantum system interacting with its environment, losing its quantum coherence. Typically it is the emergence of the classical world from the quantum that is studied. We reverse this paradigm and ask - how does the existence of a classical limit define the structure of quantum theory, or any other post-classical theory? We derive the existence of entangled states as a necessary feature of any theory that allows for the emergence of the classical world in this way. We then use our framework for generalized decoherence to explore the properties of theories that can ‘hyperdecohere’ to quantum theory. We find that any such theory must be very exotic compared to quantum theory, violating either the postulate of tomographic locality, reversibility, causality or purity. In the second half of this thesis we turn our attention to the second law of thermodynamics. We present a framework for deriving the second law under general constraints and explore two pertinent examples, constraining the fluctuations in work and constraining the size of the thermal bath and deriving the second law in these cases. Bounding fluctuations results in a unified free energy that contains the single-shot and Helmholtz free energies as limiting cases. Bounding the size of the thermal bath results in a finite-bath second law that is more general that previous attempts and draws connections between non-asymptotic thermodynamics and second-order information theory.
Planck found, when attempting to describe the way in which hot bodies glow, that energy at microscopic scales often comes in discrete chunks. Thus began the long and intimate relationship between the field of thermodynamics, which explores our ability to manipulate heat and other energy transfers between macroscopic systems, and quantum mechanics, which explains the dynamics of individual microscopic systems. Even as both our technology and our theoretical investigations have extended to ever-smaller devices, our understanding of quantum effects on thermodynamics has remained almost exclusively limited to the quantized nature of energy. There is much more, however, to quantum theory than energy quantization. In this thesis we focus on the property of quantum coherence, the ability of quantum systems to emulate Schrodinger’s cat and somehow be neither dead nor alive, but something completely different altogether. We provide a simple and elegant formulation for the processing of coherence in thermodynamics, relying on the fact that thermodynamical processes possess an underlying time-translation symmetry. This fact allows us to quantify the ways in which coherence can play an active role, facilitating otherwise impossible thermodynamic transformations. We argue that coherence should be thought of as a distinctly quantum-mechanical thermodynamic resource. By considering an isolated quantum system connected, for some period of time, to a thermal bath, we give fundamental limitations on how coherence can be irreversibly manipulated. These limitations are related to those dictated on energy transfer by the second law of thermodynamics. Others topics that are investigated here is what is the role of correlations at the smallest scales and the conversion of quantum coherence into work. It has long been appreciated that thermodynamics is subtly interlinked with the notion of information. This work provides evidence that, to apply the laws of thermodynamics to the smallest systems around us, we must develop deeper insights into the nature of quantum information.
In the framework of the recent quest for well-behaved nonlinear extensions of the traditional Schrödinger-von Neumann unitary dynamics that could provide fundamental explanations of recent experimental evidence of loss of quantum coherence at the microscopic level, a recent paper [Gheorghiu-Svirschevski 2001 Phys. Rev. A 63 054102] reproposes the nonlinear equation of motion proposed by the present author [see Beretta G P 1987 Found. Phys. 17 365 and references therein] for quantum (thermo)dynamics of a single isolated indivisible constituent system, such as a single particle, qubit, qudit, spin or atomic system, or a Bose-Einstein or Fermi-Dirac field. As already proved, such nonlinear dynamics entails a fundamental unifying microscopic proof and extension of Onsager's reciprocity and Callen's fluctuation-dissipation relations to all nonequilibrium states, close and far from thermodynamic equilibrium. In this paper we propose a brief but self-contained review of the main results already proved, including the explicit geometrical construction of the equation of motion from the steepest-entropy-ascent ansatz and its exact mathematical and conceptual equivalence with the maximal-entropy-generation variational-principle formulation presented in Gheorghiu-Svirschevski S 2001 Phys. Rev. A 63 022105. Moreover, we show how it can be extended to the case of a composite system to obtain the general form of the equation of motion, consistent with the demanding requirements of strong separability and of compatibility with general thermodynamics principles. The irreversible term in the equation of motion describes the spontaneous attraction of the state operator in the direction of steepest entropy ascent, thus implementing the maximum entropy production principle in quantum theory. The time rate at which the path of steepest entropy ascent is followed has so far been left unspecified. As a step towards the identification of such rate, here we propose a possible, well-behaved and intriguing, general closure of the dynamics, compatible with the nontrivial requirements of strong separability. Based on the time–energy Heisenberg uncertainty relation, we derive a lower bound to the internal-relaxation-time functionals that determine the rate of entropy generation. This bound entails an upper bound to the rate of entropy generation. By this extreme maximal-entropy-generation-rate ansatz, each indivisible subsystem follows the direction of steepest locally perceived entropy ascent at the highest rate compatible with the time– energy uncertainty principle.