Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2307.08293 · Physical Review Research

Sensitivity versus selectivity in entanglement detection via collective witnesses

Vojtěch Trávníček, Jan Roik, Karol Bartkiewicz, Antonín Černoch, Paweł Horodecki, Karel Lemr

Published Jul 11, 2024• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we introduce a supervised learning technique that harnesses artificial neural networks, along with the outcomes of collective entanglement measurements, to estimate the negativity of quantum states in two-qubit and qubit-qutrit systems. The resulting deep-learned collective entanglement witnesses offer the unique capability of continuous sensitivity and selectivity tuning. This instrument enables us to explore the tradeoff between sensitivity and selectivity in entanglement detection, a dimension not accessible to previously employed analytical witnesses. In particular, we demonstrate that there are experimentally cost-effective methods (in terms of the number of measurements) where sensitivity can be significantly improved at a slight expense of the selectivity of entanglement detection. This chosen approach is also favored due to its high generality and potential for superior performance compared to other types of entanglement witnesses. Our findings may pave the way for the development of more efficient and accurate entanglement detection methods in complex quantum systems, especially when considering realistic experimental imperfections. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.6.033056

Related papers

Accuracy of Entanglement Detection via Artificial Neural Networks and Human-Designed Entanglement Witnesses

Jan Roik, Karol Bartkiewicz, Antonín Černoch +1 more

The detection of entangled states is essential in both fundamental and applied quantum physics. However, this task proves to be challenging, especially for general quantum states. One can execute full state tomography but this method is time demanding, especially in complex systems. Other approaches use entanglement witnesses: these methods tend to be less demanding but lack reliability. Here, we demonstrate that artificial neural networks (ANNs) provide a balance between the two approaches. In this paper, we make a comparison of ANN performance with witness-based methods for random general two-qubit quantum states without any prior information on the states. Furthermore, we apply our approach to a real experimental data set.

arXiv:2011.11340•Physical Review Applied•May 4, 2021•27 citations

Detecting Multipartite Entangled States with Machine Learning-Derived Witnesses

Alexander C. B. Greenwood

We are entering a time in which quantum channel capacity is becoming increasingly dependent on having high-dimensional entangled systems. However, existing methods of detecting high-dimensional entanglement are hindered by their need for an unwieldy amount of measurements and computational power. Indeed, the use of entanglement witnesses circumvents this problem by only considering a small subset of the entangled states in Hilbert Space. Although efficient witnesses for 2-qubit Bell States and 3-Qubit GHZ states are well-known, the predominant “fidelity method" witnesses used for detecting multipartite W states remain relatively complex in the amount of measurements that they require. The work outlined in this thesis aims to improve on existing entanglement witnesses by drawing their correspondence with supervised learning techniques, specifically Support Vector Machines. In doing so, one can derive entanglement witnesses whose features (observables obtained via local operations and classical communications) can be ranked according to their impact on the classification of entangled and separable states. This method allows us to derive W state witnesses that require fewer measurements than those derived via the fidelity method. The process of Recursive Feature Elimination is also presented, by which we can define witnesses that can be decomposed into fewer Pauli observables at the cost of inferior tolerance to noise. Finally, we present the practical utility of our derived witnesses through physical experiments performed on the superconducting qubit devices provided by IBM.

•Mar 1, 2023•0 citations

Entanglement detection with artificial neural networks

Naema Asif, Uman Khalid, Awais Khan +2 more

Quantum entanglement is one of the essential resources involved in quantum information processing tasks. However, its detection for usage remains a challenge. The Bell-type inequality for relative entropy of coherence serves as an entanglement witness for pure entangled states. However, it does not perform reliably for mixed entangled states. This paper constructs a classifier by employing the relationship between coherence and entanglement for supervised machine learning methods. This method encodes multiple Bell-type inequalities for the relative entropy of coherence into an artificial neural network to detect the entangled and separable states in a quantum dataset.

Scientific Reports•Jan 28, 2023•52 citations

Adaptive Negativity Estimation via Collective Measurements

Martin Zeman, Vojtěch Trávníček, Antonín Černoch +2 more

This paper explores an efficient method for entanglement quantification in two-qubit and qubit-qutrit quantum systems based upon the framework of collective measurements in conjunction with machine learning. We introduce an adaptive measurement procedure in which measurement settings are dynamically adjusted based on prior measurement outcomes aiming to optimize the inference precision given a limited number of these measurement settings. The procedure makes use of the Long Short-Term Memory networks to recurrently process collective measurements on two copies of the investigated states. Obtained results demonstrate the tangible benefits of the adaptive measurements in comparison to previously described non-adaptive strategies.

quant-pharXiv:2603.25560•Physical Review Research•Mar 27, 2026•0 citations

Finding semi-optimal measurements for entanglement detection using autoencoder neural networks

Mohammad Yosefpor, Mohammad Reza Mostaan, Sadegh Raeisi

Abstract Entanglement is one of the key resources of quantum information science which makes identification of entangled states essential to a wide range of quantum technologies and phenomena. This problem is however both computationally and experimentally challenging. Here we use autoencoder neural networks to find semi-optimal set of incomplete measurements that are most informative for the detection of entangled states . We show that it is possible to find high-performance entanglement detectors with as few as three measurements. Also, with the complete information of the state, we develop a neural network that can identify all two-qubits entangled states almost perfectly. This result paves the way for automatic development of efficient entanglement witnesses and entanglement detection using machine learning techniques.

arXiv:2003.07031•Quantum Science and Technology•Jul 6, 2020•14 citations

Detecting quantum entanglement with unsupervised learning

Yiwei Chen, Yu Pan, Guofeng Zhang +1 more

Abstract Quantum properties, such as entanglement and coherence, are indispensable resources in various quantum information processing tasks. However, there still lacks an efficient and scalable way to detecting these useful features especially for high-dimensional and multipartite quantum systems. In this work, we exploit the convexity of samples without the desired quantum features and design an unsupervised machine learning method to detect the presence of such features as anomalies. Particularly, in the context of entanglement detection, we propose a complex-valued neural network composed of pseudo-siamese network and generative adversarial net, and then train it with only separable states to construct non-linear witnesses for entanglement. It is shown via numerical examples, ranging from two-qubit to ten-qubit systems, that our network is able to achieve high detection accuracy which is above 97.5% on average. Moreover, it is capable of revealing rich structures of entanglement, such as partial entanglement among subsystems. Our results are readily applicable to the detection of other quantum resources such as Bell nonlocality and steerability, and thus our work could provide a powerful tool to extract quantum features hidden in multipartite quantum data.

arXiv:2103.04804•Quantum Science and Technology•Oct 19, 2021•65 citations
In this paper, we introduce a supervised learning technique that harnesses artificial neural networks, along with the outcomes of collective entanglement measurements, to estimate the negativity of quantum states in two-qubit and qubit-qutrit systems. The resulting deep-learned collective entanglement witnesses offer the unique capability of continuous sensitivity and selectivity tuning. This instrument enables us to explore the tradeoff between sensitivity and selectivity in entanglement detection, a dimension not accessible to previously employed analytical witnesses. In particular, we demonstrate that there are experimentally cost-effective methods (in terms of the number of measurements) where sensitivity can be significantly improved at a slight expense of the selectivity of entanglement detection. This chosen approach is also favored due to its high generality and potential for superior performance compared to other types of entanglement witnesses. Our findings may pave the way for the development of more efficient and accurate entanglement detection methods in complex quantum systems, especially when considering realistic experimental imperfections. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
The detection of entangled states is essential in both fundamental and applied quantum physics. However, this task proves to be challenging, especially for general quantum states. One can execute full state tomography but this method is time demanding, especially in complex systems. Other approaches use entanglement witnesses: these methods tend to be less demanding but lack reliability. Here, we demonstrate that artificial neural networks (ANNs) provide a balance between the two approaches. In this paper, we make a comparison of ANN performance with witness-based methods for random general two-qubit quantum states without any prior information on the states. Furthermore, we apply our approach to a real experimental data set.
We are entering a time in which quantum channel capacity is becoming increasingly dependent on having high-dimensional entangled systems. However, existing methods of detecting high-dimensional entanglement are hindered by their need for an unwieldy amount of measurements and computational power. Indeed, the use of entanglement witnesses circumvents this problem by only considering a small subset of the entangled states in Hilbert Space. Although efficient witnesses for 2-qubit Bell States and 3-Qubit GHZ states are well-known, the predominant “fidelity method" witnesses used for detecting multipartite W states remain relatively complex in the amount of measurements that they require. The work outlined in this thesis aims to improve on existing entanglement witnesses by drawing their correspondence with supervised learning techniques, specifically Support Vector Machines. In doing so, one can derive entanglement witnesses whose features (observables obtained via local operations and classical communications) can be ranked according to their impact on the classification of entangled and separable states. This method allows us to derive W state witnesses that require fewer measurements than those derived via the fidelity method. The process of Recursive Feature Elimination is also presented, by which we can define witnesses that can be decomposed into fewer Pauli observables at the cost of inferior tolerance to noise. Finally, we present the practical utility of our derived witnesses through physical experiments performed on the superconducting qubit devices provided by IBM.
Quantum entanglement is one of the essential resources involved in quantum information processing tasks. However, its detection for usage remains a challenge. The Bell-type inequality for relative entropy of coherence serves as an entanglement witness for pure entangled states. However, it does not perform reliably for mixed entangled states. This paper constructs a classifier by employing the relationship between coherence and entanglement for supervised machine learning methods. This method encodes multiple Bell-type inequalities for the relative entropy of coherence into an artificial neural network to detect the entangled and separable states in a quantum dataset.
This paper explores an efficient method for entanglement quantification in two-qubit and qubit-qutrit quantum systems based upon the framework of collective measurements in conjunction with machine learning. We introduce an adaptive measurement procedure in which measurement settings are dynamically adjusted based on prior measurement outcomes aiming to optimize the inference precision given a limited number of these measurement settings. The procedure makes use of the Long Short-Term Memory networks to recurrently process collective measurements on two copies of the investigated states. Obtained results demonstrate the tangible benefits of the adaptive measurements in comparison to previously described non-adaptive strategies.
Abstract Entanglement is one of the key resources of quantum information science which makes identification of entangled states essential to a wide range of quantum technologies and phenomena. This problem is however both computationally and experimentally challenging. Here we use autoencoder neural networks to find semi-optimal set of incomplete measurements that are most informative for the detection of entangled states . We show that it is possible to find high-performance entanglement detectors with as few as three measurements. Also, with the complete information of the state, we develop a neural network that can identify all two-qubits entangled states almost perfectly. This result paves the way for automatic development of efficient entanglement witnesses and entanglement detection using machine learning techniques.
Abstract Quantum properties, such as entanglement and coherence, are indispensable resources in various quantum information processing tasks. However, there still lacks an efficient and scalable way to detecting these useful features especially for high-dimensional and multipartite quantum systems. In this work, we exploit the convexity of samples without the desired quantum features and design an unsupervised machine learning method to detect the presence of such features as anomalies. Particularly, in the context of entanglement detection, we propose a complex-valued neural network composed of pseudo-siamese network and generative adversarial net, and then train it with only separable states to construct non-linear witnesses for entanglement. It is shown via numerical examples, ranging from two-qubit to ten-qubit systems, that our network is able to achieve high detection accuracy which is above 97.5% on average. Moreover, it is capable of revealing rich structures of entanglement, such as partial entanglement among subsystems. Our results are readily applicable to the detection of other quantum resources such as Bell nonlocality and steerability, and thus our work could provide a powerful tool to extract quantum features hidden in multipartite quantum data.