Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2307.03123 · Physical Review A

Annealing for prediction of grand canonical crystal structures: Implementation of n -body atomic interactions

Yannick Couzinié, Yusuke Nishiya, Hirofumi Nishi, Taichi Kosugi, Hidetoshi Nishimori, Yu‐ichiro Matsushita

Published Mar 15, 2024• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose an annealing scheme usable on modern Ising machines for crystal structures prediction (CSP) by taking into account the general n -body atomic interactions and in particular three-body interactions which are necessary to simulate covalent bonds. The crystal structure is represented by discretizing a unit cell and placing binary variables which express the existence or nonexistence of an atom on every grid point. The resulting quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) or higher-order unconstrained binary optimization (HUBO) problems implement the CSP problem and is solved using simulated and quantum annealing. Using the example of Lennard-Jones clusters we show that it is not necessary to include the target atom number in the formulation allowing for simultaneous optimization of both the particle density and the configuration and argue that this is advantageous for use on annealing machines as it reduces the total amount of interactions. We further provide a scheme that allows for reduction of higher-order interaction terms that is inspired by the underlying physics. We show for a covalently bonded monolayer MoS2 crystal that we can simultaneously optimize for the particle density as well as the crystal structure using simulated annealing. We also show that we reproduce ground states of the interatomic potential with high probability that are not represented on the initial discretization of the unit cell. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/physreva.109.032416

Related papers

Molecular unfolding formulation with enhanced quantum annealing approach

Arit Kumar Bishwas, Arish Pitchai, Anuraj Som

Molecular docking is a crucial phase in drug discovery, involving the precise determination of the optimal spatial arrangement between two molecules when they bind. The such analysis, the 3D structure of molecules is a fundamental consideration, involving the manipulation of molecular representations based on their degrees of freedom, including rigid roto-translation and fragment rotations along rotatable bonds, to determine the preferred spatial arrangement when molecules bind to each other. In this paper, quantum annealing based solution to solve Molecular unfolding (MU) problem, a specific phase within molecular docking, is explored and compared with a state-of-the-art classical algorithm named "GeoDock". Molecular unfolding focuses on expanding a molecule to an unfolded state to simplify manipulation within the target cavity and optimize its configuration, typically by maximizing molecular area or internal atom distances. Molecular unfolding problem aims to find the torsional configuration that increases the inter-atomic distance within a molecule, which also increases the molecular area. Quantum annealing approach first encodes the problem into a Higher-order Unconstrained Binary Optimization (HUBO) equation which is pruned to an arbitrary percentage to improve the time efficiency and to be able to solve the equation using any quantum annealer. The resultant HUBO is then converted to a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization equation (QUBO), which is easily embedded on a D-wave annealing Quantum processor.

arXiv:2403.00507•Mar 1, 2024•9 citations

Accelerating optimal elemental configuration search in crystal using Ising machine

Kazuhide Ichikawa, Satoru Ohuchi, Koki Ueno +1 more

This research demonstrates that Ising machines can effectively solve optimal elemental configuration searches in crystals, with Au-Cu alloys serving as an example. The energy function is derived using the cluster expansion method in the form of a QUBO function, enabling efficient problem-solving via Ising machines. Using the third-generation Fujitsu's Digital Annealer, we have successfully obtained reasonable solutions for crystal structures consisting of over 10 000 atoms. Notably, we have also obtained plausible solutions for optimization problems with constrained solutions, such as situations where the composition ratio of atomic species is predetermined. These findings suggest that Ising machines can be valuable tools for addressing materials science challenges. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2305.19625•Physical Review Research•Sep 20, 2024•7 citations

Machine Learning Supported Annealing for Prediction of Grand Canonical Crystal Structures

Yannick Couzinié, Yuya Seki, Yusuke Nishiya +4 more

This study investigates the application of Factorization Machines with Quantum Annealing (FMQA) to address the crystal structure problem (CSP) in materials science. FMQA is a black-box optimization algorithm that combines machine learning with annealing machines to find samples to a black-box function that minimize a given loss. The CSP involves determining the optimal arrangement of atoms in a material based on its chemical composition, a critical challenge in materials science. We explore FMQA's ability to efficiently sample optimal crystal configurations by setting the loss function to the energy of the crystal configuration as given by a predefined interatomic potential. Further we investigate how well the energies of the various metastable configurations, or local minima of the potential, are learned by the algorithm. Our investigation reveals FMQA's potential in quick ground state sampling and in recovering relational order between local minima.

arXiv:2408.03556•Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Mar 24, 2025•16 citations

Optimization with Quantum Annealing Machines

Samuel Deleplanque

Quantum annealing is a method based on simulated annealing where temperature variations are replaced by quantum fluctuations that cause qubit state transitions. ISING problems and Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization problems (QUBO) can be tackled by quantum annealing-based machines. We can link the interconnected qubits of the machine and the binaries of our model: qubits are binary variables and each pair of them linked by a coupler has a strong impact on the equality or the non-equality of the two binaries of the associated pair. Quantum annealing is based on the fact that any system tends to seek its minimum energy state. Starting from qubits in a state of superposition where all the solutions to the problem are fairly represented, the machine will apply a magnetic field by targeting the qubits and couplers in such a way as to make their value energetically favorable in the direction of optimization (minimization). For the coupled qubits, it is the quadratic products of the binary variables that are considered here and the physical system will make it energetically favorable for them to take (or not) the same values. To work on these machines based on quantum annealing in order to solve optimization problems with constraints, the latter must be relaxed while penalizing the Objective function. After presenting the case of the Max-Cut problem, we will look at such constrained problems.

•Jul 3, 2022•0 citations

Constraint Solving by Quantum Annealing

Philippe Codognet

We present experiments in solving combinatorial optimization and constraint satisfaction problems by means of Quantum Annealing. We describe how to model classic constraint problems such as N-queens and Magic Square as well as hard combinatorial problems such as the Costas Array Problem or the Quadratic Assignment Problem in terms of QUBO (Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization). QUBO is the input language of quantum computers based on quantum annealing such as the D-Wave systems and of the ”quantum-inspired” but classical devices such as Fujitsu’s Digital Annealing Unit or Hitachi’s CMOS Annealing Machine. We present preliminary results for solving these combinatorial optimization and constraint satisfaction problems by implementation on the D-Wave quantum computer.

International Conference on Parallel Processing Workshops (ICPPW)•Aug 9, 2021•9 citations

Boosting quantum annealing performance through direct polynomial unconstrained binary optimization

Sebastian Nagies, Kevin T. Geier, Javed Akram +3 more

Abstract Quantum annealing aims at solving optimization problems of practical relevance using quantum-computing hardware. Problems of interest are typically formulated in terms of quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) Hamiltonians. However, many optimization problems are much more naturally formulated in terms of polynomial unconstrained binary optimization (PUBO) functions of higher order. As we show with various problem examples, leveraging the PUBO formulation can bring considerable savings in terms of required number of qubits. Moreover, in numerical benchmarks for the paradigmatic 3-SAT problem, we find scenarios where the scaling of the minimum energy gap during the optimization sweep differs significantly, suggesting the possibility of an exponentially faster annealing time when using the PUBO as compared to the QUBO formulation. This advantage persists even when considering the overhead caused by the higher-order interactions necessary for PUBO cost Hamiltonians. As an interesting side effect, the analysis on minimum energy gaps of different 3-SAT instance generators reveals different degrees of hardness, which will be of interest also for classical benchmark calculations. Our findings show a promising path to improving the resource efficiency and sweeping speed of quantum annealing protocols on both analog and digital platforms, which are important prerequisites when aiming at solving larger optimization problems with relevance to industry.

arXiv:2412.04398•Quantum Science and Technology•Apr 9, 2025•8 citations
We propose an annealing scheme usable on modern Ising machines for crystal structures prediction (CSP) by taking into account the general n -body atomic interactions and in particular three-body interactions which are necessary to simulate covalent bonds. The crystal structure is represented by discretizing a unit cell and placing binary variables which express the existence or nonexistence of an atom on every grid point. The resulting quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) or higher-order unconstrained binary optimization (HUBO) problems implement the CSP problem and is solved using simulated and quantum annealing. Using the example of Lennard-Jones clusters we show that it is not necessary to include the target atom number in the formulation allowing for simultaneous optimization of both the particle density and the configuration and argue that this is advantageous for use on annealing machines as it reduces the total amount of interactions. We further provide a scheme that allows for reduction of higher-order interaction terms that is inspired by the underlying physics. We show for a covalently bonded monolayer MoS2 crystal that we can simultaneously optimize for the particle density as well as the crystal structure using simulated annealing. We also show that we reproduce ground states of the interatomic potential with high probability that are not represented on the initial discretization of the unit cell. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Molecular docking is a crucial phase in drug discovery, involving the precise determination of the optimal spatial arrangement between two molecules when they bind. The such analysis, the 3D structure of molecules is a fundamental consideration, involving the manipulation of molecular representations based on their degrees of freedom, including rigid roto-translation and fragment rotations along rotatable bonds, to determine the preferred spatial arrangement when molecules bind to each other. In this paper, quantum annealing based solution to solve Molecular unfolding (MU) problem, a specific phase within molecular docking, is explored and compared with a state-of-the-art classical algorithm named "GeoDock". Molecular unfolding focuses on expanding a molecule to an unfolded state to simplify manipulation within the target cavity and optimize its configuration, typically by maximizing molecular area or internal atom distances. Molecular unfolding problem aims to find the torsional configuration that increases the inter-atomic distance within a molecule, which also increases the molecular area. Quantum annealing approach first encodes the problem into a Higher-order Unconstrained Binary Optimization (HUBO) equation which is pruned to an arbitrary percentage to improve the time efficiency and to be able to solve the equation using any quantum annealer. The resultant HUBO is then converted to a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization equation (QUBO), which is easily embedded on a D-wave annealing Quantum processor.
This research demonstrates that Ising machines can effectively solve optimal elemental configuration searches in crystals, with Au-Cu alloys serving as an example. The energy function is derived using the cluster expansion method in the form of a QUBO function, enabling efficient problem-solving via Ising machines. Using the third-generation Fujitsu's Digital Annealer, we have successfully obtained reasonable solutions for crystal structures consisting of over 10 000 atoms. Notably, we have also obtained plausible solutions for optimization problems with constrained solutions, such as situations where the composition ratio of atomic species is predetermined. These findings suggest that Ising machines can be valuable tools for addressing materials science challenges. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
This study investigates the application of Factorization Machines with Quantum Annealing (FMQA) to address the crystal structure problem (CSP) in materials science. FMQA is a black-box optimization algorithm that combines machine learning with annealing machines to find samples to a black-box function that minimize a given loss. The CSP involves determining the optimal arrangement of atoms in a material based on its chemical composition, a critical challenge in materials science. We explore FMQA's ability to efficiently sample optimal crystal configurations by setting the loss function to the energy of the crystal configuration as given by a predefined interatomic potential. Further we investigate how well the energies of the various metastable configurations, or local minima of the potential, are learned by the algorithm. Our investigation reveals FMQA's potential in quick ground state sampling and in recovering relational order between local minima.
Quantum annealing is a method based on simulated annealing where temperature variations are replaced by quantum fluctuations that cause qubit state transitions. ISING problems and Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization problems (QUBO) can be tackled by quantum annealing-based machines. We can link the interconnected qubits of the machine and the binaries of our model: qubits are binary variables and each pair of them linked by a coupler has a strong impact on the equality or the non-equality of the two binaries of the associated pair. Quantum annealing is based on the fact that any system tends to seek its minimum energy state. Starting from qubits in a state of superposition where all the solutions to the problem are fairly represented, the machine will apply a magnetic field by targeting the qubits and couplers in such a way as to make their value energetically favorable in the direction of optimization (minimization). For the coupled qubits, it is the quadratic products of the binary variables that are considered here and the physical system will make it energetically favorable for them to take (or not) the same values. To work on these machines based on quantum annealing in order to solve optimization problems with constraints, the latter must be relaxed while penalizing the Objective function. After presenting the case of the Max-Cut problem, we will look at such constrained problems.
We present experiments in solving combinatorial optimization and constraint satisfaction problems by means of Quantum Annealing. We describe how to model classic constraint problems such as N-queens and Magic Square as well as hard combinatorial problems such as the Costas Array Problem or the Quadratic Assignment Problem in terms of QUBO (Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization). QUBO is the input language of quantum computers based on quantum annealing such as the D-Wave systems and of the ”quantum-inspired” but classical devices such as Fujitsu’s Digital Annealing Unit or Hitachi’s CMOS Annealing Machine. We present preliminary results for solving these combinatorial optimization and constraint satisfaction problems by implementation on the D-Wave quantum computer.
Abstract Quantum annealing aims at solving optimization problems of practical relevance using quantum-computing hardware. Problems of interest are typically formulated in terms of quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) Hamiltonians. However, many optimization problems are much more naturally formulated in terms of polynomial unconstrained binary optimization (PUBO) functions of higher order. As we show with various problem examples, leveraging the PUBO formulation can bring considerable savings in terms of required number of qubits. Moreover, in numerical benchmarks for the paradigmatic 3-SAT problem, we find scenarios where the scaling of the minimum energy gap during the optimization sweep differs significantly, suggesting the possibility of an exponentially faster annealing time when using the PUBO as compared to the QUBO formulation. This advantage persists even when considering the overhead caused by the higher-order interactions necessary for PUBO cost Hamiltonians. As an interesting side effect, the analysis on minimum energy gaps of different 3-SAT instance generators reveals different degrees of hardness, which will be of interest also for classical benchmark calculations. Our findings show a promising path to improving the resource efficiency and sweeping speed of quantum annealing protocols on both analog and digital platforms, which are important prerequisites when aiming at solving larger optimization problems with relevance to industry.