Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2307.00812

Variational Equations-of-States for Interacting Quantum Hamiltonians

Wenxin Ding

Published Jul 3, 2023• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Variational methods are of fundamental importance and widely used in theoretical physics, especially for strongly interacting systems. In this work, we present a set of variational equations of state (VES) for pure states of an interacting quantum Hamiltonian. The VES can be expressed in terms of the variation of the density operators or static correlation functions. We derive the algebraic relationship between a known pure state density matrix and its variation, and obtain the VES by applying this relation to the averaged Heisenberg-equations-of-motion for the exact density matrix. Additionally, we provide a direct expression of the VES in terms of correlation functions to make it computable. We present three nontrivial applications of the VES: a perturbation calculation of correlation functions of the transverse field Ising model in arbitrary spatial dimensions, a study of a longitudinal field perturbation to the one-dimensional transverse field Ising model at the critical point and variational calculation of magnetization and ground state energy of the two-dimensional spin-1/2 Heisenberg model on a square lattice. For the second one, our results not only recover the scaling limit, but also indicate the possibility of continuous tuning of the critical exponents by adjusting the longitudinal fields differently from the scaling limit. For the Heisenberg model, we obtained results numerically comparable to established results with simple calculations. The VES approach provides a powerful and versatile tool for studying interacting quantum systems.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2307.00812

Related papers

Applications of Density Matrix Renormalization Group to Problems in Magnetism

G A Gehring, Robert J. Bursill, Tao Xiang

The application of real space renormalization group methods to quantum lattice models has become a topic of great interest following the development of the density matrix renormalization group by White.This method has been used to find the ground and low-lying excited state energies and wave functions of quantum spin models in which the form of the ground state is not clear, for instance because the interactions are frustrated.It has also been applied to fermion problems where the tendency for localization due to the strong Coulomb repulsion is opposed by the lowering of the kinetic energy which occurs as a result of electron transfer.The approach is particularly suitable for one-, or quasi-one-dimensional problems.The method involves truncating the Hilbert space in a systematic and optimised manner.Results for the ground state energy are thus variational bounds.The results for low-lying energies and correlation functions for one-dimensional systems have unprecedented accuracy and the method has become the method of choice for solving one-dimensional quantum spin problems.We review the method and results obtained for the spin-1 chain with biquadratic exchange as well as the spin-1/2 model with competing nearest and next nearest neighbour exchange will be described.More recently, the density matrix renormalization group has been applied to reformulate the coupling constant renormalization group approach which is appropriate for the study of critical properties.This approach has been applied to the anisotropic spin-1/2 Heisenberg chain.Finally, we discuss recent work which has borne promising applications in two dimensions -the Ising model and the two-dimensional Hubbard model.

arXiv:cond-mat/9608127•Acta Physica Polonica A•Jan 1, 1997•20 citations

Variational principles for particles and fields in Heisenberg matrix mechanics

Abraham Klein, Ching‐Teh Li, Moyez G. Vassanji

For many years we have advocated a form of quantum mechanics based on the application of sum rule methods (completeness) to the equations of motion and to the commutation relations, i.e., to Heisenberg matrix mechanics. Sporadically we have discussed or alluded to a variational foundation for this method. In this paper we present a series of variational principles applicable to a range of systems from one-dimensional quantum mechanics to quantum fields. The common thread is that the stationary quantity is the trace of the Hamiltonian over Hilbert space (or over a subspace of interest in an approximation) expressed as a functional of matrix elements of the elementary operators of the theory. These parameters are constrained by the kinematical relations of the theory introduced by the method of Lagrange multipliers. For the field theories, variational principles in which matrix elements of the density operators are chosen as fundamental are also developed. A qualitative discussion of applications is presented.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Oct 1, 1980•13 citations

A real-space renormalization-group calculation for the quantum Z 2 gauge theory on a square lattice

Steve T Paik

Abstract We revisit Fradkin and Raby’s real-space renormalization-group method to study the quantum Z 2 gauge theory defined on links forming a two-dimensional square lattice. Following an old suggestion of theirs, a systematic perturbation expansion developed by Hirsch and Mazenko is used to improve the algorithm to second order in an intercell coupling, thereby incorporating the effects of discarded higher energy states. A careful derivation of gauge-invariant effective operators is presented in the Hamiltonian formalism. Renormalization group equations are analyzed near the nontrivial fixed point, reaffirming old work by Hirsch on the dual transverse field Ising model. In addition to recovering Hirsch’s previous findings, critical exponents for the scaling of the spatial correlation length and energy gap in the electric free (deconfined) phase are compared. Unfortunately, their agreement is poor. The leading singular behavior of the ground state energy density is examined near the critical point: we compute both a critical exponent and estimate a critical amplitude ratio.

arXiv:2009.06983•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Exact and variational investigations of Hubbard rings

William Hodge

We study the one-dimensional Hubbard model for interacting electrons in a crystal lattice, using two methods: solution of the Lieb-Wu equations in the atomic limit of no intersite hopping, and variational techniques to obtain a lower bound for the ground state energy. From the Lieb-Wu equations we derive an exact expression for the ground state energy in the atomic limit. We obtain our result by exploiting the spin symmetry of the Hubbard Hamiltonian. Our energy is lower than that obtained by previous published results, and we are able to explain why our results differ. Our method also gives information about the magnetic ordering of the ground state as a function of the number of electrons. Our results are valid for arbitrary electron density values. The variational techniques we use are applied to the two-particle reduced-density matrix (2-RDM), because this quantity suffices to obtain expectation values of all one- and two-particle operators, and because it is less computationally intensive than obtaining the complete N -particle wave function. Because the 2-RDM must be positive semidefinite, we use an efficient programming algorithm known as the Semidefinite Programming Algorithm. A naive search through the space of two-particle matrices encounters a difficult problem, known as the " N -representability problem", which is to assure that the trial density matrices actually come from a wave function that has the required exchange symmetry. This problem is ameliorated by imposing constraints on the variational search that eliminate trial matrices with the incorrect exchange symmetry. These constraints express known physical properties of the ground state (for example its total spin and its translational symmetry) and the so-called D, Q , and G two-positivity conditions that express the required exchange symmetry. To calculate matrix elements, we use the two-particle eigenstates of the reduced Hubbard Hamiltonian; this choice of basis significantly decreases the number of matrix elements needed for energy calculations. After an optimal two-particle density matrix has been obtained, we calculate additional properties of the ground state, including spin correlation functions, chemical potentials, and the momentum distribution. We compare all of these properties to values obtained by exact numerical solution of the Schrödinger equation.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Variational-Correlations Approach to Quantum Many-body Problems

Arbel Haim, Richard Kueng, Gil Refael

We investigate an approach for studying the ground state of a quantum many-body Hamiltonian that is based on treating the correlation functions as variational parameters. In this approach, the challenge set by the exponentially-large Hilbert space is circumvented by approximating the positivity of the density matrix, order-by-order, in a way that keeps track of a limited set of correlation functions. In particular, the density-matrix description is replaced by a correlation matrix whose dimension is kept linear in system size, to all orders of the approximation. Unlike the conventional variational principle which provides an upper bound on the ground-state energy, in this approach one obtains a lower bound instead. By treating several one-dimensional spin $1/2$ Hamiltonians, we demonstrate the ability of this approach to produce long-range correlations, and a ground-state energy that converges to the exact result. Possible extensions, including to higher-excited states are discussed.

arXiv:2001.06510•Jan 17, 2020•29 citations

Two-dimensional layered Ising models: Exact variational formulation and analysis

Lev V. Mikheev, Michael Ellis Fisher

Ising models on the plane square lattice with an arbitrary variation of the bond strengths, ${\mathit{J}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\parallel}}}$(z) and ${\mathit{J}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\perp}}}$(z), with one of the two axial coordinates, z, are considered. The total entropy is exactly represented as a functional of contributions ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathit{q}}$(z) to the local energy density arising from the Onsager fermions with wave vector q parallel to the layer axis, y. The resulting explicit local expression provides an effective variational principle for the free energy and energy-density profiles. In the scaling limit the problem reduces to a set of independent second-order differential equations for each ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathit{q}}$(z). The power of the method is demonstrated by application to an interface between two uniform but distinct regions; this includes the problem of a wall with a surface field, ${\mathit{h}}_{1}$, as a special case. Previous results for the bulk and surface exponents and for the energy-energy correlation function are easily recovered. Near criticality the method yields, in addition, universal, scaled energy-density profiles, \ensuremath{\varepsilon}(z;T), which exhibit rich crossovers and nonmonotonic variation with z.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 1, 1994•27 citations
Variational methods are of fundamental importance and widely used in theoretical physics, especially for strongly interacting systems. In this work, we present a set of variational equations of state (VES) for pure states of an interacting quantum Hamiltonian. The VES can be expressed in terms of the variation of the density operators or static correlation functions. We derive the algebraic relationship between a known pure state density matrix and its variation, and obtain the VES by applying this relation to the averaged Heisenberg-equations-of-motion for the exact density matrix. Additionally, we provide a direct expression of the VES in terms of correlation functions to make it computable. We present three nontrivial applications of the VES: a perturbation calculation of correlation functions of the transverse field Ising model in arbitrary spatial dimensions, a study of a longitudinal field perturbation to the one-dimensional transverse field Ising model at the critical point and variational calculation of magnetization and ground state energy of the two-dimensional spin-1/2 Heisenberg model on a square lattice. For the second one, our results not only recover the scaling limit, but also indicate the possibility of continuous tuning of the critical exponents by adjusting the longitudinal fields differently from the scaling limit. For the Heisenberg model, we obtained results numerically comparable to established results with simple calculations. The VES approach provides a powerful and versatile tool for studying interacting quantum systems.
The application of real space renormalization group methods to quantum lattice models has become a topic of great interest following the development of the density matrix renormalization group by White.This method has been used to find the ground and low-lying excited state energies and wave functions of quantum spin models in which the form of the ground state is not clear, for instance because the interactions are frustrated.It has also been applied to fermion problems where the tendency for localization due to the strong Coulomb repulsion is opposed by the lowering of the kinetic energy which occurs as a result of electron transfer.The approach is particularly suitable for one-, or quasi-one-dimensional problems.The method involves truncating the Hilbert space in a systematic and optimised manner.Results for the ground state energy are thus variational bounds.The results for low-lying energies and correlation functions for one-dimensional systems have unprecedented accuracy and the method has become the method of choice for solving one-dimensional quantum spin problems.We review the method and results obtained for the spin-1 chain with biquadratic exchange as well as the spin-1/2 model with competing nearest and next nearest neighbour exchange will be described.More recently, the density matrix renormalization group has been applied to reformulate the coupling constant renormalization group approach which is appropriate for the study of critical properties.This approach has been applied to the anisotropic spin-1/2 Heisenberg chain.Finally, we discuss recent work which has borne promising applications in two dimensions -the Ising model and the two-dimensional Hubbard model.
For many years we have advocated a form of quantum mechanics based on the application of sum rule methods (completeness) to the equations of motion and to the commutation relations, i.e., to Heisenberg matrix mechanics. Sporadically we have discussed or alluded to a variational foundation for this method. In this paper we present a series of variational principles applicable to a range of systems from one-dimensional quantum mechanics to quantum fields. The common thread is that the stationary quantity is the trace of the Hamiltonian over Hilbert space (or over a subspace of interest in an approximation) expressed as a functional of matrix elements of the elementary operators of the theory. These parameters are constrained by the kinematical relations of the theory introduced by the method of Lagrange multipliers. For the field theories, variational principles in which matrix elements of the density operators are chosen as fundamental are also developed. A qualitative discussion of applications is presented.
Abstract We revisit Fradkin and Raby’s real-space renormalization-group method to study the quantum Z 2 gauge theory defined on links forming a two-dimensional square lattice. Following an old suggestion of theirs, a systematic perturbation expansion developed by Hirsch and Mazenko is used to improve the algorithm to second order in an intercell coupling, thereby incorporating the effects of discarded higher energy states. A careful derivation of gauge-invariant effective operators is presented in the Hamiltonian formalism. Renormalization group equations are analyzed near the nontrivial fixed point, reaffirming old work by Hirsch on the dual transverse field Ising model. In addition to recovering Hirsch’s previous findings, critical exponents for the scaling of the spatial correlation length and energy gap in the electric free (deconfined) phase are compared. Unfortunately, their agreement is poor. The leading singular behavior of the ground state energy density is examined near the critical point: we compute both a critical exponent and estimate a critical amplitude ratio.
We study the one-dimensional Hubbard model for interacting electrons in a crystal lattice, using two methods: solution of the Lieb-Wu equations in the atomic limit of no intersite hopping, and variational techniques to obtain a lower bound for the ground state energy. From the Lieb-Wu equations we derive an exact expression for the ground state energy in the atomic limit. We obtain our result by exploiting the spin symmetry of the Hubbard Hamiltonian. Our energy is lower than that obtained by previous published results, and we are able to explain why our results differ. Our method also gives information about the magnetic ordering of the ground state as a function of the number of electrons. Our results are valid for arbitrary electron density values. The variational techniques we use are applied to the two-particle reduced-density matrix (2-RDM), because this quantity suffices to obtain expectation values of all one- and two-particle operators, and because it is less computationally intensive than obtaining the complete N -particle wave function. Because the 2-RDM must be positive semidefinite, we use an efficient programming algorithm known as the Semidefinite Programming Algorithm. A naive search through the space of two-particle matrices encounters a difficult problem, known as the " N -representability problem", which is to assure that the trial density matrices actually come from a wave function that has the required exchange symmetry. This problem is ameliorated by imposing constraints on the variational search that eliminate trial matrices with the incorrect exchange symmetry. These constraints express known physical properties of the ground state (for example its total spin and its translational symmetry) and the so-called D, Q , and G two-positivity conditions that express the required exchange symmetry. To calculate matrix elements, we use the two-particle eigenstates of the reduced Hubbard Hamiltonian; this choice of basis significantly decreases the number of matrix elements needed for energy calculations. After an optimal two-particle density matrix has been obtained, we calculate additional properties of the ground state, including spin correlation functions, chemical potentials, and the momentum distribution. We compare all of these properties to values obtained by exact numerical solution of the Schrödinger equation.
We investigate an approach for studying the ground state of a quantum many-body Hamiltonian that is based on treating the correlation functions as variational parameters. In this approach, the challenge set by the exponentially-large Hilbert space is circumvented by approximating the positivity of the density matrix, order-by-order, in a way that keeps track of a limited set of correlation functions. In particular, the density-matrix description is replaced by a correlation matrix whose dimension is kept linear in system size, to all orders of the approximation. Unlike the conventional variational principle which provides an upper bound on the ground-state energy, in this approach one obtains a lower bound instead. By treating several one-dimensional spin 1/21/21/2 Hamiltonians, we demonstrate the ability of this approach to produce long-range correlations, and a ground-state energy that converges to the exact result. Possible extensions, including to higher-excited states are discussed.
Ising models on the plane square lattice with an arbitrary variation of the bond strengths, ${\mathit{J}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\parallel}}}$(z) and ${\mathit{J}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\perp}}}$(z), with one of the two axial coordinates, z, are considered. The total entropy is exactly represented as a functional of contributions ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathit{q}}$(z) to the local energy density arising from the Onsager fermions with wave vector q parallel to the layer axis, y. The resulting explicit local expression provides an effective variational principle for the free energy and energy-density profiles. In the scaling limit the problem reduces to a set of independent second-order differential equations for each ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathit{q}}$(z). The power of the method is demonstrated by application to an interface between two uniform but distinct regions; this includes the problem of a wall with a surface field, h1{\mathit{h}}_{1}h1​, as a special case. Previous results for the bulk and surface exponents and for the energy-energy correlation function are easily recovered. Near criticality the method yields, in addition, universal, scaled energy-density profiles, \ensuremath{\varepsilon}(z;T), which exhibit rich crossovers and nonmonotonic variation with z.