Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2306.13409 · Condensed Matter Physics

The fifty-year quest for universality in percolation theory in high dimensions

T. S. Ellis, Ralph Kenna B, Bertrand Berche

Published Jan 1, 2023• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Although well described by mean-field theory in the thermodynamic limit, scaling has long been puzzling for finite systems in high dimensions. This raised questions about the efficacy of the renormalization group and foundational concepts such as universality, finite-size scaling and hyperscaling, until recently believed not to be applicable above the upper critical dimension. Significant theoretical progress has been made resolving these issues, and tested in numerous simulational studies of spin models. This progress rests upon superlinearity of correlation length, a notion that for a long time encountered resistance but is now broadly accepted. Percolation theory brings added complications such as proliferation of interpenetrating clusters in apparent conflict with suggestions coming from random-graph asymptotics and a dearth of reliable simulational guidance. Here we report on recent theoretical progress in percolation theory in the renormalization group framework in high dimensions that accommodates superlinear correlation and renders most of the above concepts mutually compatible under different boundary conditions. Results from numerical simulations for free and periodic boundary conditions which differentiate between previously competing theories are also presented. Although still fragmentary, these Monte Carlo results support the new framework which restores the renormalization group and foundational concepts on which it rests.

DOI
10.5488/cmp.26.33606

Related papers

Universal finite-size scaling for percolation theory in high dimensions

Ralph Kenna B, Bertrand Berche

Abstract We present a unifying, consistent, finite-size-scaling picture for percolation theory bringing it into the framework of a general, renormalization-group-based, scaling scheme for systems above their upper critical dimensions d c . Behaviour at the critical point is non-universal in d > d c = 6 dimensions. Proliferation of the largest clusters, with fractal dimension 4, is associated with the breakdown of hyperscaling there when free boundary conditions are used. But when the boundary conditions are periodic, the maximal clusters have dimension D = 2 d /3, and obey random-graph asymptotics. Universality is instead manifested at the pseudocritical point, where the failure of hyperscaling in its traditional form is universally associated with random-graph-type asymptotics for critical cluster sizes, independent of boundary conditions.

arXiv:1606.00315•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 11, 2017•33 citations

Phase transitions above the upper critical dimension

Bertrand Berche, Tim Ellis, Yurij V. Holovatch +1 more

These lecture notes provide an overview of the renormalization group (RG) as a successful framework to understand critical phenomena above the upper critical dimension d_{uc} d u c . After an introduction to the scaling picture of continuous phase transitions, we discuss the apparent failure of the Gaussian fixed point to capture scaling for Landau mean-field theory, which should hold in the thermodynamic limit above d_{uc} d u c . We recount how Fisher’s dangerous-irrelevant-variable formalism applied to thermodynamic functions partially repairs the situation but at the expense of hyperscaling and finite-size scaling, both of which were, until recently, believed not to apply above d_{uc} d u c . We recall limitations of various attempts to match the RG with analytical and numerical results for Ising systems. We explain how the extension of dangerous irrelevancy to the correlation sector is key to marrying the above concepts into a comprehensive RG scaling picture that renders hyperscaling and finite-size scaling valid in all dimensions. We collect what we believe is the current status of the theory, including some new insights and results. This paper is in grateful memory of Michael Fisher who introduced many of the concepts discussed and who, half a century later, contributed to their advancement.

arXiv:2204.04761•SciPost Physics Lecture Notes•Aug 12, 2022•38 citations

Scaling and Finite-Size Scaling above the Upper Critical Dimension

Ralph Kenna B, Bertrand Berche

In the 1960's, four famous scaling relations were developed which relate the six standard critical exponents describing continuous phase transitions in the thermodynamic limit of statistical physics models. They are well understood at a fundamental level through the renormalization group. They have been verified in multitudes of theoretical, computational and experimental studies and are firmly established and profoundly important for our understanding of critical phenomena. One of the scaling relations, hyperscaling, fails above the upper critical dimension. There, critical phenomena are governed by Gaussian fixed points in the renormalization-group formalism. Dangerous irrelevant variables are required to deliver the mean-field and Landau values of the critical exponents, which are deemed valid by the Ginzburg criterion. Also above the upper critical dimension, the standard picture is that, unlike for low-dimensional systems, finite-size scaling is non-universal. Here we report on new developments which indicate that the current paradigm is flawed and incomplete. In particular, the introduction of a new exponent characterising the finite-size correlation length allows one to extend hyperscaling beyond the upper critical dimension. Moreover, finite-size scaling is shown to be universal provided the correct scaling window is chosen. These recent developments also lead to the introduction of a new scaling relation analogous to one introduced by Fisher 50 years ago.

arXiv:2404.09190•WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 19, 2015•11 citations

Interplay of the complete-graph and Gaussian fixed-point asymptotics in finite-size scaling of percolation above the upper critical dimension

Mingzhong Lu, Sheng Fang, Zongzheng Zhou +1 more

For statistical mechanical systems with continuous phase transitions, there are two closely related but subtly different mean-field treatments, the Gaussian fixed point (GFP) in the renormalization group framework and the Landau mean-field theory or the complete-graph (CG) asymptotics. By large-scale Monte Carlo simulations, we systematically study the interplay of the GFP and CG effects to the finite-size scaling of percolation above the upper critical dimension d_{c}=6 with periodic and cylindrical boundary conditions. Our results suggest that, with periodic boundaries, the unwrapped correlation length scales as L^{d/6} at the critical point, diverging faster than L above d_{c}. As a consequence, the scaling behaviors of macroscopic quantities with respect to the linear system size L follow the CG asymptotics. The distance-dependent properties, such as the short-distance behavior of the two-point correlation function and the Fourier transformed quantities with nonzero modes, are still controlled by the GFP. With cylindrical boundaries, due to the interplay of the GFP and CG effects, the correlation length along the axial direction of the cylinder scales as ξ_{L}∼L^{(d-1)/5} within the critical window of size O(L^{-2(d-1)/5}), distinct from periodic boundary. A field-theoretical calculation for deriving the scaling of ξ_{L} is also presented. Moreover, the one-point surface correlation function along the axial direction of the cylinder is observed to scale as τ^{(1-d)/2} when the distance τ is short, but then enter a plateau of order L^{-3(d-1)/5} before it decays significantly fast.

arXiv:2308.04238•Physical review. E•Oct 28, 2024•5 citations

Universal finite-size scaling functions for percolation on three-dimensional lattices

Chai‐Yu Lin, Chin‐Kun Hu

Using a histogram Monte Carlo simulation method (HMCSM), Hu, Lin, and Chen found that bond and site percolation models on planar lattices have universal finite-size scaling functions for the existence probability ${E}_{p},$ the percolation probability $P,$ and the probability ${W}_{n}$ for the appearance of $n$ percolating clusters in these models. In this paper we extend above study to percolation on three-dimensional lattices with various linear dimensions $L.$ Using the HMCSM, we calculate the existence probability ${E}_{p}$ and the percolation probability $P$ for site and bond percolation on a simple-cubic (sc) lattice, and site percolation on body-centered-cubic and face-centered-cubic lattices; each lattice has the same linear dimension in three dimensions. Using the data of ${E}_{p}$ and $P$ in a percolation renormalization group method, we find that the critical exponents obtained are quite consistent with the universality of critical exponents. Using a small number of nonuniversal metric factors, we find that ${E}_{p}$ and $P$ have universal finite-size scaling functions. This implies that the critical ${E}_{p}$ is a universal quantity, which is $0.265\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.005$ for free boundary conditions and $0.924\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.005$ for periodic boundary conditions. We also find that ${W}_{n}$ for site and bond percolation on sc lattices have universal finite-size scaling functions.

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Aug 1, 1998•49 citations

Universality of the complete-graph Potts model with 0 < q ≤ 2

Zirui Peng, Sheng Fang, Hao Hu +1 more

Universality is a fundamental concept in modern physics. For the q-state Potts model, the critical exponents are merely determined by the order-parameter symmetry S_{q}, spatial dimensionality and interaction range, independent of microscopic details. In a simplest and mean-field treatment, i.e., the Potts model on complete graph (CG), the phase transition is further established to be of percolation universality for the range of 0<q<2. By simulating the CG Potts model in the random-cluster representation, we numerically demonstrate such a hyperuniversality that the critical exponents are the same for 0<q<2 and, moreover, the Ising system (q=2) exhibits a variety of critical geometric properties in percolation universality. On the other hand, many other universal properties in the finite-size scaling (FSS) theory, including Binder-like ratios and distribution function of the order parameter, are observed to be q dependent. Meanwhile, we have made improvements to the Monte Carlo algorithms for efficiently simulating the CG Potts model. Our finding provides valuable insights for the study of critical phenomena in finite spatial dimensions, particularly when the FSS theory is utilized.

arXiv:2501.16930•Physical review. E•May 23, 2025•0 citations
Although well described by mean-field theory in the thermodynamic limit, scaling has long been puzzling for finite systems in high dimensions. This raised questions about the efficacy of the renormalization group and foundational concepts such as universality, finite-size scaling and hyperscaling, until recently believed not to be applicable above the upper critical dimension. Significant theoretical progress has been made resolving these issues, and tested in numerous simulational studies of spin models. This progress rests upon superlinearity of correlation length, a notion that for a long time encountered resistance but is now broadly accepted. Percolation theory brings added complications such as proliferation of interpenetrating clusters in apparent conflict with suggestions coming from random-graph asymptotics and a dearth of reliable simulational guidance. Here we report on recent theoretical progress in percolation theory in the renormalization group framework in high dimensions that accommodates superlinear correlation and renders most of the above concepts mutually compatible under different boundary conditions. Results from numerical simulations for free and periodic boundary conditions which differentiate between previously competing theories are also presented. Although still fragmentary, these Monte Carlo results support the new framework which restores the renormalization group and foundational concepts on which it rests.
Abstract We present a unifying, consistent, finite-size-scaling picture for percolation theory bringing it into the framework of a general, renormalization-group-based, scaling scheme for systems above their upper critical dimensions d c . Behaviour at the critical point is non-universal in d > d c = 6 dimensions. Proliferation of the largest clusters, with fractal dimension 4, is associated with the breakdown of hyperscaling there when free boundary conditions are used. But when the boundary conditions are periodic, the maximal clusters have dimension D = 2 d /3, and obey random-graph asymptotics. Universality is instead manifested at the pseudocritical point, where the failure of hyperscaling in its traditional form is universally associated with random-graph-type asymptotics for critical cluster sizes, independent of boundary conditions.
These lecture notes provide an overview of the renormalization group (RG) as a successful framework to understand critical phenomena above the upper critical dimension d_{uc} d u c . After an introduction to the scaling picture of continuous phase transitions, we discuss the apparent failure of the Gaussian fixed point to capture scaling for Landau mean-field theory, which should hold in the thermodynamic limit above d_{uc} d u c . We recount how Fisher’s dangerous-irrelevant-variable formalism applied to thermodynamic functions partially repairs the situation but at the expense of hyperscaling and finite-size scaling, both of which were, until recently, believed not to apply above d_{uc} d u c . We recall limitations of various attempts to match the RG with analytical and numerical results for Ising systems. We explain how the extension of dangerous irrelevancy to the correlation sector is key to marrying the above concepts into a comprehensive RG scaling picture that renders hyperscaling and finite-size scaling valid in all dimensions. We collect what we believe is the current status of the theory, including some new insights and results. This paper is in grateful memory of Michael Fisher who introduced many of the concepts discussed and who, half a century later, contributed to their advancement.
In the 1960's, four famous scaling relations were developed which relate the six standard critical exponents describing continuous phase transitions in the thermodynamic limit of statistical physics models. They are well understood at a fundamental level through the renormalization group. They have been verified in multitudes of theoretical, computational and experimental studies and are firmly established and profoundly important for our understanding of critical phenomena. One of the scaling relations, hyperscaling, fails above the upper critical dimension. There, critical phenomena are governed by Gaussian fixed points in the renormalization-group formalism. Dangerous irrelevant variables are required to deliver the mean-field and Landau values of the critical exponents, which are deemed valid by the Ginzburg criterion. Also above the upper critical dimension, the standard picture is that, unlike for low-dimensional systems, finite-size scaling is non-universal. Here we report on new developments which indicate that the current paradigm is flawed and incomplete. In particular, the introduction of a new exponent characterising the finite-size correlation length allows one to extend hyperscaling beyond the upper critical dimension. Moreover, finite-size scaling is shown to be universal provided the correct scaling window is chosen. These recent developments also lead to the introduction of a new scaling relation analogous to one introduced by Fisher 50 years ago.
For statistical mechanical systems with continuous phase transitions, there are two closely related but subtly different mean-field treatments, the Gaussian fixed point (GFP) in the renormalization group framework and the Landau mean-field theory or the complete-graph (CG) asymptotics. By large-scale Monte Carlo simulations, we systematically study the interplay of the GFP and CG effects to the finite-size scaling of percolation above the upper critical dimension d_{c}=6 with periodic and cylindrical boundary conditions. Our results suggest that, with periodic boundaries, the unwrapped correlation length scales as L^{d/6} at the critical point, diverging faster than L above d_{c}. As a consequence, the scaling behaviors of macroscopic quantities with respect to the linear system size L follow the CG asymptotics. The distance-dependent properties, such as the short-distance behavior of the two-point correlation function and the Fourier transformed quantities with nonzero modes, are still controlled by the GFP. With cylindrical boundaries, due to the interplay of the GFP and CG effects, the correlation length along the axial direction of the cylinder scales as ξ_{L}∼L^{(d-1)/5} within the critical window of size O(L^{-2(d-1)/5}), distinct from periodic boundary. A field-theoretical calculation for deriving the scaling of ξ_{L} is also presented. Moreover, the one-point surface correlation function along the axial direction of the cylinder is observed to scale as τ^{(1-d)/2} when the distance τ is short, but then enter a plateau of order L^{-3(d-1)/5} before it decays significantly fast.
Using a histogram Monte Carlo simulation method (HMCSM), Hu, Lin, and Chen found that bond and site percolation models on planar lattices have universal finite-size scaling functions for the existence probability Ep,{E}_{p},Ep​, the percolation probability P,P,P, and the probability Wn{W}_{n}Wn​ for the appearance of nnn percolating clusters in these models. In this paper we extend above study to percolation on three-dimensional lattices with various linear dimensions L.L.L. Using the HMCSM, we calculate the existence probability Ep{E}_{p}Ep​ and the percolation probability PPP for site and bond percolation on a simple-cubic (sc) lattice, and site percolation on body-centered-cubic and face-centered-cubic lattices; each lattice has the same linear dimension in three dimensions. Using the data of Ep{E}_{p}Ep​ and PPP in a percolation renormalization group method, we find that the critical exponents obtained are quite consistent with the universality of critical exponents. Using a small number of nonuniversal metric factors, we find that Ep{E}_{p}Ep​ and PPP have universal finite-size scaling functions. This implies that the critical Ep{E}_{p}Ep​ is a universal quantity, which is $0.265\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.005$ for free boundary conditions and $0.924\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.005$ for periodic boundary conditions. We also find that Wn{W}_{n}Wn​ for site and bond percolation on sc lattices have universal finite-size scaling functions.
Universality is a fundamental concept in modern physics. For the q-state Potts model, the critical exponents are merely determined by the order-parameter symmetry S_{q}, spatial dimensionality and interaction range, independent of microscopic details. In a simplest and mean-field treatment, i.e., the Potts model on complete graph (CG), the phase transition is further established to be of percolation universality for the range of 0<q<2. By simulating the CG Potts model in the random-cluster representation, we numerically demonstrate such a hyperuniversality that the critical exponents are the same for 0<q<2 and, moreover, the Ising system (q=2) exhibits a variety of critical geometric properties in percolation universality. On the other hand, many other universal properties in the finite-size scaling (FSS) theory, including Binder-like ratios and distribution function of the order parameter, are observed to be q dependent. Meanwhile, we have made improvements to the Monte Carlo algorithms for efficiently simulating the CG Potts model. Our finding provides valuable insights for the study of critical phenomena in finite spatial dimensions, particularly when the FSS theory is utilized.