Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2306.12021 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Weak first-order phase transitions in the frustrated square lattice J1−J2 classical Ising model

Adil A. Gangat

Published Mar 19, 2024• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The classical ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ Ising model on the square lattice is a minimal model of frustrated magnetism whose phase boundaries have remained under scrutiny for decades. Signs of first-order phase transitions have appeared in some studies, but strong evidence remains lacking. The current consensus, based upon the numerical data and theoretical arguments in [S. Jin et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 045702 (2012)], is that first-order phase transitions are ruled out in the region $g={J}_{2}/|{J}_{1}|\ensuremath{\gtrsim}0.67$. We point out a loophole in the basis for this consensus, and we find strong evidence that the phase boundary is instead weak first order at $0.67\ensuremath{\lesssim}g<\ensuremath{\infty}$ such that it asymptotically becomes second order when $g\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. We also find strong evidence that the phase boundary is first order in the region $0.5<g\ensuremath{\lesssim}0.67$. We establish these results with adiabatic evolution of matrix product states directly in the thermodynamic limit, and with the theory of finite-entanglement scaling. We also find suggestive evidence that when $g\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0.{5}^{+}$, the phase boundary becomes of an anomalous first-order type wherein the correlation length is very large in one of the coexisting phases but very small in the other.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.109.104419

Related papers

Phase transitions in the frustrated Ising model on the square lattice

Songbo Jin, Arnab Sen, Wenan Guo +1 more

We consider the thermal phase transition from a paramagnetic to a stripe-antiferromagnetic phase in the frustrated two-dimensional square-lattice Ising model with competing interactions ${J}_{1}<0$ (nearest neighbor, ferromagnetic) and ${J}_{2}>0$ (second neighbor, antiferromagnetic). The striped phase breaks a ${Z}_{4}$ symmetry and is stabilized at low temperatures for $g={J}_{2}/|{J}_{1}|>1/2$. Despite the simplicity of the model, it has proved difficult to precisely determine the order and the universality class of the phase transitions. This was done convincingly only recently by Jin et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 045702 (2012)]. Here, we further elucidate the nature of these transitions and their anomalies by employing a combination of cluster mean-field theory, Monte Carlo simulations, and transfer-matrix calculations. The ${J}_{1}$-${J}_{2}$ model has a line of very weak first-order phase transitions in the whole region $1/2<g<{g}^{*}$, where ${g}^{*}=0.67\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.01$. Thereafter, the transitions from $g={g}^{*}$ to $g\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ are continuous and can be fully mapped, using universality arguments, to the critical line of the well-known Ashkin-Teller model from its four-state Potts point to the decoupled Ising limit. We also comment on the pseudo-first-order behavior at the Potts point and its neighborhood in the Ashkin-Teller model on finite lattices, which in turn leads to the appearance of similar effects in the vicinity of the multicritical point ${g}^{*}$ in the ${J}_{1}$-${J}_{2}$ model. The continuous transitions near ${g}^{*}$ can therefore be mistaken for first-order transitions, and this realization was the key to understanding the paramagnetic-striped transition for the full range of $g>1/2$. Most of our conclusions are based on Monte Carlo calculations, while the cluster mean-field and transfer-matrix results provide useful methodological benchmarks for weakly first-order behaviors and Ashkin-Teller criticality.

arXiv:1212.5339•Physical Review B•Apr 9, 2013•128 citations

Analysis of the phase transition for the Ising model on the frustrated square lattice

Ansgar Kalz, A. Honecker, Marion Moliner

We analyze the phase transition of the frustrated ${J}_{1}$-${J}_{2}$ Ising model with antiferromagnetic nearest- and strong next-nearest-neighbor interactions on the square lattice. Using extensive Monte Carlo simulations we show that the nature of the phase transition for $1/2<{J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\lesssim}1$ is not of the weakly universal type---as commonly believed---but we conclude from the clearly doubly peaked structure of the energy histograms that the transition is of weak first order. Motivated by these results, we analyze the phase transitions via field-theoretic methods; i.e., we calculate the central charge of the underlying field theory via transfer-matrix techniques and present, furthermore, a field-theoretic discussion on the phase-transition behavior of the model. Starting from the conformally invariant fixed point of two decoupled critical Ising models (${J}_{1}=0$), we calculate the effect of the nearest-neighbor coupling term perturbatively using operator product expansions. As an effective action we obtain the Ashkin-Teller model.

arXiv:1105.4836•Physical Review B•Nov 9, 2011•59 citations

Tensor network simulation for the frustrated J1−J2 Ising model on the square lattice

Hong Li, Li-Ping Yang

By using extensive tensor network calculations, we map out the phase diagram of the frustrated J_{1}-J_{2} Ising model on the square lattice. In particular, we focus on the cases with controversy in the phase diagram, especially the stripe transition in the regime g=|J_{2}/J_{1}|>1/2 (J_{2}>0,J_{1}<0). While recent studies claimed that the phase transition is of first order when 1/2<g<g^{*} (with the smallest g^{*} being 0.67), our simulations suggest that if there is such a first-order region, it is smaller than those found in earlier studies by other methods. Combining with the analysis of critical properties, we provide evidence that the classical J_{1}-J_{2} model evolves continuously from two decoupled Ising models (g→∞ with central charge c=1) to a point belonging to the tricritical Ising universality class (with c=0.7) as g decreases to g^{*}≃0.54.

arXiv:2103.09464•Physical review. E•Aug 16, 2021•38 citations

Quantum phase diagram of spin-1 J1−J2 Heisenberg model on the square lattice: An infinite projected entangled-pair state and density matrix renormalization group study

Reza Haghshenas, Wang-Wei Lan, Shou-Shu Gong +1 more

We study the spin-1 Heisenberg model on the square lattice with the antiferromagnetic nearest-neighbor ${J}_{1}$ and the next-nearest-neighbor ${J}_{2}$ couplings by using the infinite projected entangled-pair state (iPEPS) ansatz and the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) calculation. The iPEPS simulation, which studies the model directly in the thermodynamic limit, finds a crossing of the ground state from the N\'eel magnetic state to the stripe magnetic state at ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\simeq}0.549$, showing a direct phase transition. In the finite-size DMRG calculation on the cylinder geometry up to the cylinder width ${L}_{y}=10$, we find that around the same critical point the N\'eel and the stripe orders are strongly suppressed, which implies the absence of an intermediate phase. Both calculations identify that the stripe order comes with a first-order transition at ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\simeq}0.549$. Our results indicate that unlike the spin-1/2 ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ square model, quantum fluctuations in the spin-1 model may not be strong enough to stabilize an intermediate nonmagnetic phase.

arXiv:1802.00874•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 31, 2018•22 citations

Higher-order tensor renormalization group study of the J1−J2 Ising model on a square lattice

Kota Yoshiyama, Koji Hukushima

Phase transitions of the J_{1}-J_{2} Ising model on a square lattice are studied using the higher-order tensor renormalization group (HOTRG) method. This system involves a competition between the ferromagnetic interaction J_{1} and antiferromagnetic interaction J_{2}, and in previous studies, weak first-order and second-order transitions were observed near the ratio g=J_{2}/|J_{1}|=1/2. It has also been suggested that the universality class of the second-order phase transition connected to the first-order transition line for g>1/2 belongs to the Ashkin-Teller class, which is characterized by a continuously varying critical exponent with g, as predicted by field-theoretical and other studies. Our results, based on the HOTRG calculations for significantly larger sizes, indicate that the region of the first-order transition is marginally narrower than that in previous studies. Furthermore, it is suggested that the region where the critical exponent changes does not necessarily coincide with the Ashkin-Teller region.

arXiv:2303.07733•Physical review. E•Nov 15, 2023•26 citations

Meandering stripes in the frustrated $J_1$-$J_2$ Ising model on the honeycomb lattice

Denis Gessert, Martin Weigel, Wolfhard Janke E

We study the frustrated $J_1$-$J_2$ Ising model on the honeycomb lattice with ferromagnetic nearest-neighbor couplings fixed at $J_1=1$ and strong antiferromagnetic next-nearest-neighbor interactions, i.e., $J_2 \leq -1/4$. Little is known for this range of $J_2$, whereas for less negative values of $J_2$ the system orders ferromagnetically at low temperatures and appears to remain in the Ising universality class. In previous work it was shown that the model has a largely degenerate ground state, and it was conjectured that there is some kind of phase transition. We introduce a complex-valued nematic order parameter, which can differentiate between the high-temperature paramagnetic phase and the observed partially-disordered stripe phase at lower temperatures. Configurations in this phase consist of stripes of spins parallel with respect to one lattice direction, which collectively meander along the remaining two, producing partially disordered ground states. The sharp peaks in the specific heat observed in earlier work only appear when using periodic boundary conditions and are absent for free boundaries. Additionally, we reveal a striking dependence of the behavior on the aspect ratio of the considered samples. Ultimately, even a careful finite-size scaling analysis for $J_2 = -0.5$ and $J_2 = -1$ is unable to clearly discern between a crossover without any singularities and some form of continuous transition, including the possibility of an infinite-order transition of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) type. For $J_2=-1/4$ we find that the system remains disordered at all temperatures and that it exhibits a finite ground-state entropy per site, for which our simulations provide the accurate asymptotic estimate $S(T=0)/N = 0.230\,960\,93(14)$ in the thermodynamic limit $N\rightarrow\infty$.

arXiv:2608.21261•Aug 21, 2026•1 citation
The classical J1\ensuremath−J2{J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}J1​\ensuremath−J2​ Ising model on the square lattice is a minimal model of frustrated magnetism whose phase boundaries have remained under scrutiny for decades. Signs of first-order phase transitions have appeared in some studies, but strong evidence remains lacking. The current consensus, based upon the numerical data and theoretical arguments in [S. Jin et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 045702 (2012)], is that first-order phase transitions are ruled out in the region g=J2/∣J1∣\ensuremath≳0.67g={J}_{2}/|{J}_{1}|\ensuremath{\gtrsim}0.67g=J2​/∣J1​∣\ensuremath≳0.67. We point out a loophole in the basis for this consensus, and we find strong evidence that the phase boundary is instead weak first order at 0.67\ensuremath≲g<\ensuremath∞0.67\ensuremath{\lesssim}g<\ensuremath{\infty}0.67\ensuremath≲g<\ensuremath∞ such that it asymptotically becomes second order when g\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞g\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}g\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞. We also find strong evidence that the phase boundary is first order in the region 0.5<g\ensuremath≲0.670.5<g\ensuremath{\lesssim}0.670.5<g\ensuremath≲0.67. We establish these results with adiabatic evolution of matrix product states directly in the thermodynamic limit, and with the theory of finite-entanglement scaling. We also find suggestive evidence that when g\ensuremath→0.5+g\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0.{5}^{+}g\ensuremath→0.5+, the phase boundary becomes of an anomalous first-order type wherein the correlation length is very large in one of the coexisting phases but very small in the other.
We consider the thermal phase transition from a paramagnetic to a stripe-antiferromagnetic phase in the frustrated two-dimensional square-lattice Ising model with competing interactions J1<0{J}_{1}<0J1​<0 (nearest neighbor, ferromagnetic) and J2>0{J}_{2}>0J2​>0 (second neighbor, antiferromagnetic). The striped phase breaks a Z4{Z}_{4}Z4​ symmetry and is stabilized at low temperatures for g=J2/∣J1∣>1/2g={J}_{2}/|{J}_{1}|>1/2g=J2​/∣J1​∣>1/2. Despite the simplicity of the model, it has proved difficult to precisely determine the order and the universality class of the phase transitions. This was done convincingly only recently by Jin et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 045702 (2012)]. Here, we further elucidate the nature of these transitions and their anomalies by employing a combination of cluster mean-field theory, Monte Carlo simulations, and transfer-matrix calculations. The J1{J}_{1}J1​-J2{J}_{2}J2​ model has a line of very weak first-order phase transitions in the whole region 1/2<g<g∗1/2<g<{g}^{*}1/2<g<g∗, where ${g}^{*}=0.67\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.01$. Thereafter, the transitions from g=g∗g={g}^{*}g=g∗ to $g\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ are continuous and can be fully mapped, using universality arguments, to the critical line of the well-known Ashkin-Teller model from its four-state Potts point to the decoupled Ising limit. We also comment on the pseudo-first-order behavior at the Potts point and its neighborhood in the Ashkin-Teller model on finite lattices, which in turn leads to the appearance of similar effects in the vicinity of the multicritical point g∗{g}^{*}g∗ in the J1{J}_{1}J1​-J2{J}_{2}J2​ model. The continuous transitions near g∗{g}^{*}g∗ can therefore be mistaken for first-order transitions, and this realization was the key to understanding the paramagnetic-striped transition for the full range of g>1/2g>1/2g>1/2. Most of our conclusions are based on Monte Carlo calculations, while the cluster mean-field and transfer-matrix results provide useful methodological benchmarks for weakly first-order behaviors and Ashkin-Teller criticality.
We analyze the phase transition of the frustrated J1{J}_{1}J1​-J2{J}_{2}J2​ Ising model with antiferromagnetic nearest- and strong next-nearest-neighbor interactions on the square lattice. Using extensive Monte Carlo simulations we show that the nature of the phase transition for $1/2<{J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\lesssim}1$ is not of the weakly universal type---as commonly believed---but we conclude from the clearly doubly peaked structure of the energy histograms that the transition is of weak first order. Motivated by these results, we analyze the phase transitions via field-theoretic methods; i.e., we calculate the central charge of the underlying field theory via transfer-matrix techniques and present, furthermore, a field-theoretic discussion on the phase-transition behavior of the model. Starting from the conformally invariant fixed point of two decoupled critical Ising models (J1=0{J}_{1}=0J1​=0), we calculate the effect of the nearest-neighbor coupling term perturbatively using operator product expansions. As an effective action we obtain the Ashkin-Teller model.
By using extensive tensor network calculations, we map out the phase diagram of the frustrated J_{1}-J_{2} Ising model on the square lattice. In particular, we focus on the cases with controversy in the phase diagram, especially the stripe transition in the regime g=|J_{2}/J_{1}|>1/2 (J_{2}>0,J_{1}<0). While recent studies claimed that the phase transition is of first order when 1/2<g<g^{*} (with the smallest g^{*} being 0.67), our simulations suggest that if there is such a first-order region, it is smaller than those found in earlier studies by other methods. Combining with the analysis of critical properties, we provide evidence that the classical J_{1}-J_{2} model evolves continuously from two decoupled Ising models (g→∞ with central charge c=1) to a point belonging to the tricritical Ising universality class (with c=0.7) as g decreases to g^{*}≃0.54.
We study the spin-1 Heisenberg model on the square lattice with the antiferromagnetic nearest-neighbor J1{J}_{1}J1​ and the next-nearest-neighbor J2{J}_{2}J2​ couplings by using the infinite projected entangled-pair state (iPEPS) ansatz and the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) calculation. The iPEPS simulation, which studies the model directly in the thermodynamic limit, finds a crossing of the ground state from the N\'eel magnetic state to the stripe magnetic state at ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\simeq}0.549$, showing a direct phase transition. In the finite-size DMRG calculation on the cylinder geometry up to the cylinder width Ly=10{L}_{y}=10Ly​=10, we find that around the same critical point the N\'eel and the stripe orders are strongly suppressed, which implies the absence of an intermediate phase. Both calculations identify that the stripe order comes with a first-order transition at ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\simeq}0.549$. Our results indicate that unlike the spin-1/2 ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ square model, quantum fluctuations in the spin-1 model may not be strong enough to stabilize an intermediate nonmagnetic phase.
Phase transitions of the J_{1}-J_{2} Ising model on a square lattice are studied using the higher-order tensor renormalization group (HOTRG) method. This system involves a competition between the ferromagnetic interaction J_{1} and antiferromagnetic interaction J_{2}, and in previous studies, weak first-order and second-order transitions were observed near the ratio g=J_{2}/|J_{1}|=1/2. It has also been suggested that the universality class of the second-order phase transition connected to the first-order transition line for g>1/2 belongs to the Ashkin-Teller class, which is characterized by a continuously varying critical exponent with g, as predicted by field-theoretical and other studies. Our results, based on the HOTRG calculations for significantly larger sizes, indicate that the region of the first-order transition is marginally narrower than that in previous studies. Furthermore, it is suggested that the region where the critical exponent changes does not necessarily coincide with the Ashkin-Teller region.
Meandering stripes in the frustrated J1J_1J1​-J2J_2J2​ Ising model on the honeycomb lattice
We study the frustrated J1J_1J1​-J2J_2J2​ Ising model on the honeycomb lattice with ferromagnetic nearest-neighbor couplings fixed at J1=1J_1=1J1​=1 and strong antiferromagnetic next-nearest-neighbor interactions, i.e., J2≤−1/4J_2 \leq -1/4J2​≤−1/4. Little is known for this range of J2J_2J2​, whereas for less negative values of J2J_2J2​ the system orders ferromagnetically at low temperatures and appears to remain in the Ising universality class. In previous work it was shown that the model has a largely degenerate ground state, and it was conjectured that there is some kind of phase transition. We introduce a complex-valued nematic order parameter, which can differentiate between the high-temperature paramagnetic phase and the observed partially-disordered stripe phase at lower temperatures. Configurations in this phase consist of stripes of spins parallel with respect to one lattice direction, which collectively meander along the remaining two, producing partially disordered ground states. The sharp peaks in the specific heat observed in earlier work only appear when using periodic boundary conditions and are absent for free boundaries. Additionally, we reveal a striking dependence of the behavior on the aspect ratio of the considered samples. Ultimately, even a careful finite-size scaling analysis for J2=−0.5J_2 = -0.5J2​=−0.5 and J2=−1J_2 = -1J2​=−1 is unable to clearly discern between a crossover without any singularities and some form of continuous transition, including the possibility of an infinite-order transition of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) type. For J2=−1/4J_2=-1/4J2​=−1/4 we find that the system remains disordered at all temperatures and that it exhibits a finite ground-state entropy per site, for which our simulations provide the accurate asymptotic estimate S(T=0)/N=0.230 960 93(14)S(T=0)/N = 0.230\,960\,93(14)S(T=0)/N=0.23096093(14) in the thermodynamic limit N→∞N\rightarrow\inftyN→∞.