Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2306.02836 · npj Quantum Information

Limitations of noisy quantum devices in computing and entangling power

Yuxuan Yan, Zhenyu Du, Junjie Chen, Xiongfeng Ma

Published Nov 28, 2025• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Finding solid and practical quantum advantages via noisy quantum devices without error correction is a critical but challenging problem. Conversely, comprehending the fundamental limitations of the state-of-the-art is equally crucial. In this work, we consider the class of strictly contractive unital noise and derive its analytical representation by decomposition. Under such noise, we observe the polynomial-time indistinguishability of n -qubit devices from random coins when circuit depths exceed $$\Omega (\log (n))$$ Ω ( log ( n ) ) . Even with classical processing, we demonstrate the absence of computational advantage in polynomial-time algorithms with super-logarithmic noisy circuit depths. These results impact variational quantum algorithms, error mitigation, and quantum simulation with polynomial depth. Furthermore, we consider noisy quantum devices with a restricted gate topology. For one-dimensional noisy qubit circuits, we rule out super-polynomial quantum advantages in all-depth regimes. We also establish upper limits on entanglement generation: $$O(\log (n))$$ O ( log ( n ) ) for one-dimensional circuits and $$O(\sqrt{n}\log (n))$$ O ( n log ( n ) ) for two-dimensional circuits. Our findings underscore the computational capacity and entanglement scalability constraints in noisy quantum devices.

DOI
10.1038/s41534-025-01136-4

Related papers

Efficient Noisy Quantum State and Process Tomography

Chenyang Li, Shengxin Zhuang, Yukun Zhang +4 more

Efficiently characterizing large quantum states and processes is a central yet notoriously challenging task in quantum information science, as conventional tomography methods typically require resources that grow exponentially with system size. Here, we introduce a structure-agnostic learning framework for noisy $n$-qubit quantum circuits under~i.i.d.~single-qubit noise. We first prove that quantum states with unital noise channels admit an efficient learnable representation in the logarithmic-depth regime. We then extend this framework to quantum process tomography under constant noise, deriving a unified protocol that applies to both unital and non-unital noisy channels and retains efficient guarantees for logarithmic-depth circuits. This process-learning formulation is input-agnostic and imposes no distributional assumptions on the input quantum states. We further study a more general regime with arbitrary noise strength. In this setting, low-weight Pauli propagation induces a terminal truncation whose threshold depends logarithmically on the inverse accuracy, leading to quasi-polynomial complexity and near-unit success probability in the average case. In contrast to the preceding two results, this arbitrary-noise guarantee does not impose any restriction on the circuit depth, and therefore covers arbitrary-depth circuits, including both the noiseless limit ($γ= 0$) and the strong-decoherence regime ($γ= Θ(1)$). Numerical simulations of two-dimensional Hamiltonian dynamics further demonstrate the accuracy and robustness of the approach, including for structured circuits beyond the random-circuit setting assumed in the theoretical analysis. These results provide a scalable and practically relevant route toward characterizing large-scale noisy quantum devices, addressing a key bottleneck in the development of quantum technologies.

quant-pharXiv:2603.01521•Quantum Science and Technology•Mar 3, 2026•2 citations

A polynomial-time classical sampler for noisy quantum circuits from statistical mechanics

Jon Nelson, Joel Rajakumar, Chao Yin +2 more

Developing classical simulation algorithms for noisy quantum circuits is essential to delineating the limits of quantum advantage. Existing classical sampling approaches for general circuits require circuit depths to grow logarithmically with system size, so that noise drives the global output state close to a trivial state. Here we show that local accumulation of noise at a depth independent of system size is already sufficient. Specifically, we prove that any geometrically local circuit composed of unital operations and interspersed with single-qubit depolarizing noise of strength $p$ after $Θ(p^{-1} \log p^{-1})$ depth can be approximately sampled from a polynomial-time classical computer. This generalizes existing results that impose anticoncentration assumptions or non-universal gate sets in order to obtain a classical sampler at such shallow depths. Our proof maps the output state of the circuit to a polymer model in statistical mechanics, and combines a convergent cluster expansion with hypercontractivity of the depolarizing channel.

quant-pharXiv:2610.00548•Oct 2, 2026•1 citation

Efficient classical simulation of noisy random quantum circuits in one dimension

Kyungjoo Noh, Liang Jiang, Bill Fefferman

Understanding the computational power of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices is of both fundamental and practical importance to quantum information science. Here, we address the question of whether error-uncorrected noisy quantum computers can provide computational advantage over classical computers. Specifically, we study noisy random circuit sampling in one dimension (or 1D noisy RCS) as a simple model for exploring the effects of noise on the computational power of a noisy quantum device. In particular, we simulate the real-time dynamics of 1D noisy random quantum circuits via matrix product operators (MPOs) and characterize the computational power of the 1D noisy quantum system by using a metric we call MPO entanglement entropy. The latter metric is chosen because it determines the cost of classical MPO simulation. We numerically demonstrate that for the two-qubit gate error rates we considered, there exists a characteristic system size above which adding more qubits does not bring about an exponential growth of the cost of classical MPO simulation of 1D noisy systems. Specifically, we show that above the characteristic system size, there is an optimal circuit depth, independent of the system size, where the MPO entanglement entropy is maximized. Most importantly, the maximum achievable MPO entanglement entropy is bounded by a constant that depends only on the gate error rate, not on the system size. We also provide a heuristic analysis to get the scaling of the maximum achievable MPO entanglement entropy as a function of the gate error rate. The obtained scaling suggests that although the cost of MPO simulation does not increase exponentially in the system size above a certain characteristic system size, it does increase exponentially as the gate error rate decreases, possibly making classical simulation practically not feasible even with state-of-the-art supercomputers.

arXiv:2003.13163•Quantum•Sep 11, 2020•120 citations

Polynomial-Time Classical Simulation of Noisy IQP Circuits with Constant Depth

Joel Rajakumar, James D. Watson, Yi-Kai Liu

Sampling from the output distributions of quantum computations comprising only commuting gates, known as instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) computations, is believed to be intractable for classical computers, and hence this task has become a leading candidate for testing the capabilities of quantum devices. Here we demonstrate that for an arbitrary IQP circuit undergoing dephasing or depolarizing noise, whose depth is greater than a critical O (1) threshold, the output distribution can be efficiently sampled by a classical computer. Unlike other simulation algorithms for quantum supremacy tasks, we do not require assumptions on the circuit’s architecture, on anti-concentration properties, nor do we require Ω(log (n )) circuit depth. We take advantage of the fact that IQP circuits have deep sections of diagonal gates, which allows the noise to build up predictably and induce a large-scale breakdown of entanglement within the circuit. Our results suggest that quantum supremacy experiments based on IQP circuits may be more susceptible to classical simulation than previously thought. Furthermore, we show that the critical depth threshold of our algorithm is tight, and below this threshold there are noisy IQP circuits which are hard to sample from. Thus we demonstrate that noisy IQP circuits exhibit a phase transition in the computational complexity of sampling, as circuit depth is increased.

arXiv:2403.14607•Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics eBooks•Jan 1, 2025•27 citations

Parallel classical simulation of noisy shallow circuits: no quantum advantage in 1D

Robert Koenig, Marco Tomamichel

We consider quantum circuits consisting of $d$ layers of nearest-neighbor two-qubit gates acting on $n$ qubits arranged on a line, where every qubit is independently depolarized with a constant probability before each layer. We describe a randomized parallel algorithm which samples from the output distribution of any such circuit to within total variation error $δ$, with parallel runtime $2^{O(d)}\log\log(n/δ)$ and $n 2^{O(d)}$ elementary real-arithmetic operations. Without noise, the same approach gives an exact sampler with parallel runtime $O(\log n)$. For constant depth, we further show that the input/output behavior of the noisy quantum circuit is reproduced up to a constant error by a randomized $\mathsf{AC}^0$-circuit, that is, a Boolean circuit of polynomial size and constant depth with unbounded fan-in AND and OR gates and NOT gates. Consequently, every relation problem solved by a noisy constant-depth quantum circuit in one dimension is also solved, with essentially the same success probability, by a randomized $\mathsf{AC}^0$-circuit. This rules out, for noisy circuits in one dimension, the unconditional quantum advantage established for noisy shallow circuits in two and three dimensions, where polynomial-size classical circuits over the same gate set require depth $Ω(\log n/\log\log n)$. Our algorithm exploits the fact that depolarizing noise cuts a one-dimensional circuit into independent pieces of logarithmic width, each of which can be sampled exactly in parallel.

quant-pharXiv:2609.39448•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

The Impact of Qubit Connectivity on Quantum Advantage in Noisy IQP Circuits

Leonardo Placidi, Enrico Rinaldi, Keisuke Fujii +1 more

Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial-time (IQP) circuits are a candidate for demonstrating near-term quantum advantage, as their sampling task is believed to be classically hard in the ideal theoretical setting under standard complexity-theoretic assumptions. In noisy implementations, however, this hardness can disappear once circuit depth exceeds a noise-dependent critical threshold. We show that qubit connectivity is a key parameter in this transition, since sparse architectures require additional routing to implement long-range interactions, thereby increasing compiled circuit depth. To make this explicit, we present a connectivity-aware analysis of compiled IQP circuits. For a fixed abstract IQP instance, different hardware connectivity graphs yield different compiled depths and thus different effective positions relative to the noisy-IQP simulatability boundary. We quantify this architecture-dependent shift using the compiled depth overhead and the corresponding simulatability margin. We combine analytic depth estimates for sparse geometries, including the two-dimensional grid, with native-gateset-aware compilation experiments across seven hardware-grounded experimental device models derived from publicly available topologies. To compare these device models under a unified empirical framework, we approximate the effective noise level primarily through reported two-qubit gate error rates. This lets us compare how much effective noise sparse and fully connected architectures can tolerate for the same position relative to the noisy-IQP simulatability boundary. Our results show that sparse connectivity requires a lower effective noise level to sustain the same margin relative to the noisy-IQP simulatability boundary, and they provide a quantitative framework for determining when compiled IQP experiments are likely to remain outside, or instead enter, the classically simulatable regime.

quant-pharXiv:2604.12635•Apr 15, 2026•6 citations
Abstract Finding solid and practical quantum advantages via noisy quantum devices without error correction is a critical but challenging problem. Conversely, comprehending the fundamental limitations of the state-of-the-art is equally crucial. In this work, we consider the class of strictly contractive unital noise and derive its analytical representation by decomposition. Under such noise, we observe the polynomial-time indistinguishability of n -qubit devices from random coins when circuit depths exceed Ω(log⁡(n))\Omega (\log (n))Ω(log(n)) Ω ( log ( n ) ) . Even with classical processing, we demonstrate the absence of computational advantage in polynomial-time algorithms with super-logarithmic noisy circuit depths. These results impact variational quantum algorithms, error mitigation, and quantum simulation with polynomial depth. Furthermore, we consider noisy quantum devices with a restricted gate topology. For one-dimensional noisy qubit circuits, we rule out super-polynomial quantum advantages in all-depth regimes. We also establish upper limits on entanglement generation: O(log⁡(n))O(\log (n))O(log(n)) O ( log ( n ) ) for one-dimensional circuits and O(nlog⁡(n))O(\sqrt{n}\log (n))O(n​log(n)) O ( n log ( n ) ) for two-dimensional circuits. Our findings underscore the computational capacity and entanglement scalability constraints in noisy quantum devices.
Efficiently characterizing large quantum states and processes is a central yet notoriously challenging task in quantum information science, as conventional tomography methods typically require resources that grow exponentially with system size. Here, we introduce a structure-agnostic learning framework for noisy nnn-qubit quantum circuits under~i.i.d.~single-qubit noise. We first prove that quantum states with unital noise channels admit an efficient learnable representation in the logarithmic-depth regime. We then extend this framework to quantum process tomography under constant noise, deriving a unified protocol that applies to both unital and non-unital noisy channels and retains efficient guarantees for logarithmic-depth circuits. This process-learning formulation is input-agnostic and imposes no distributional assumptions on the input quantum states. We further study a more general regime with arbitrary noise strength. In this setting, low-weight Pauli propagation induces a terminal truncation whose threshold depends logarithmically on the inverse accuracy, leading to quasi-polynomial complexity and near-unit success probability in the average case. In contrast to the preceding two results, this arbitrary-noise guarantee does not impose any restriction on the circuit depth, and therefore covers arbitrary-depth circuits, including both the noiseless limit (γ=0γ= 0γ=0) and the strong-decoherence regime (γ=Θ(1)γ= Θ(1)γ=Θ(1)). Numerical simulations of two-dimensional Hamiltonian dynamics further demonstrate the accuracy and robustness of the approach, including for structured circuits beyond the random-circuit setting assumed in the theoretical analysis. These results provide a scalable and practically relevant route toward characterizing large-scale noisy quantum devices, addressing a key bottleneck in the development of quantum technologies.
Developing classical simulation algorithms for noisy quantum circuits is essential to delineating the limits of quantum advantage. Existing classical sampling approaches for general circuits require circuit depths to grow logarithmically with system size, so that noise drives the global output state close to a trivial state. Here we show that local accumulation of noise at a depth independent of system size is already sufficient. Specifically, we prove that any geometrically local circuit composed of unital operations and interspersed with single-qubit depolarizing noise of strength ppp after Θ(p−1log⁡p−1)Θ(p^{-1} \log p^{-1})Θ(p−1logp−1) depth can be approximately sampled from a polynomial-time classical computer. This generalizes existing results that impose anticoncentration assumptions or non-universal gate sets in order to obtain a classical sampler at such shallow depths. Our proof maps the output state of the circuit to a polymer model in statistical mechanics, and combines a convergent cluster expansion with hypercontractivity of the depolarizing channel.
Understanding the computational power of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices is of both fundamental and practical importance to quantum information science. Here, we address the question of whether error-uncorrected noisy quantum computers can provide computational advantage over classical computers. Specifically, we study noisy random circuit sampling in one dimension (or 1D noisy RCS) as a simple model for exploring the effects of noise on the computational power of a noisy quantum device. In particular, we simulate the real-time dynamics of 1D noisy random quantum circuits via matrix product operators (MPOs) and characterize the computational power of the 1D noisy quantum system by using a metric we call MPO entanglement entropy. The latter metric is chosen because it determines the cost of classical MPO simulation. We numerically demonstrate that for the two-qubit gate error rates we considered, there exists a characteristic system size above which adding more qubits does not bring about an exponential growth of the cost of classical MPO simulation of 1D noisy systems. Specifically, we show that above the characteristic system size, there is an optimal circuit depth, independent of the system size, where the MPO entanglement entropy is maximized. Most importantly, the maximum achievable MPO entanglement entropy is bounded by a constant that depends only on the gate error rate, not on the system size. We also provide a heuristic analysis to get the scaling of the maximum achievable MPO entanglement entropy as a function of the gate error rate. The obtained scaling suggests that although the cost of MPO simulation does not increase exponentially in the system size above a certain characteristic system size, it does increase exponentially as the gate error rate decreases, possibly making classical simulation practically not feasible even with state-of-the-art supercomputers.
Sampling from the output distributions of quantum computations comprising only commuting gates, known as instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) computations, is believed to be intractable for classical computers, and hence this task has become a leading candidate for testing the capabilities of quantum devices. Here we demonstrate that for an arbitrary IQP circuit undergoing dephasing or depolarizing noise, whose depth is greater than a critical O (1) threshold, the output distribution can be efficiently sampled by a classical computer. Unlike other simulation algorithms for quantum supremacy tasks, we do not require assumptions on the circuit’s architecture, on anti-concentration properties, nor do we require Ω(log (n )) circuit depth. We take advantage of the fact that IQP circuits have deep sections of diagonal gates, which allows the noise to build up predictably and induce a large-scale breakdown of entanglement within the circuit. Our results suggest that quantum supremacy experiments based on IQP circuits may be more susceptible to classical simulation than previously thought. Furthermore, we show that the critical depth threshold of our algorithm is tight, and below this threshold there are noisy IQP circuits which are hard to sample from. Thus we demonstrate that noisy IQP circuits exhibit a phase transition in the computational complexity of sampling, as circuit depth is increased.
We consider quantum circuits consisting of ddd layers of nearest-neighbor two-qubit gates acting on nnn qubits arranged on a line, where every qubit is independently depolarized with a constant probability before each layer. We describe a randomized parallel algorithm which samples from the output distribution of any such circuit to within total variation error δδδ, with parallel runtime 2O(d)log⁡log⁡(n/δ)2^{O(d)}\log\log(n/δ)2O(d)loglog(n/δ) and n2O(d)n 2^{O(d)}n2O(d) elementary real-arithmetic operations. Without noise, the same approach gives an exact sampler with parallel runtime O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn). For constant depth, we further show that the input/output behavior of the noisy quantum circuit is reproduced up to a constant error by a randomized AC0\mathsf{AC}^0AC0-circuit, that is, a Boolean circuit of polynomial size and constant depth with unbounded fan-in AND and OR gates and NOT gates. Consequently, every relation problem solved by a noisy constant-depth quantum circuit in one dimension is also solved, with essentially the same success probability, by a randomized AC0\mathsf{AC}^0AC0-circuit. This rules out, for noisy circuits in one dimension, the unconditional quantum advantage established for noisy shallow circuits in two and three dimensions, where polynomial-size classical circuits over the same gate set require depth Ω(log⁡n/log⁡log⁡n)Ω(\log n/\log\log n)Ω(logn/loglogn). Our algorithm exploits the fact that depolarizing noise cuts a one-dimensional circuit into independent pieces of logarithmic width, each of which can be sampled exactly in parallel.
Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial-time (IQP) circuits are a candidate for demonstrating near-term quantum advantage, as their sampling task is believed to be classically hard in the ideal theoretical setting under standard complexity-theoretic assumptions. In noisy implementations, however, this hardness can disappear once circuit depth exceeds a noise-dependent critical threshold. We show that qubit connectivity is a key parameter in this transition, since sparse architectures require additional routing to implement long-range interactions, thereby increasing compiled circuit depth. To make this explicit, we present a connectivity-aware analysis of compiled IQP circuits. For a fixed abstract IQP instance, different hardware connectivity graphs yield different compiled depths and thus different effective positions relative to the noisy-IQP simulatability boundary. We quantify this architecture-dependent shift using the compiled depth overhead and the corresponding simulatability margin. We combine analytic depth estimates for sparse geometries, including the two-dimensional grid, with native-gateset-aware compilation experiments across seven hardware-grounded experimental device models derived from publicly available topologies. To compare these device models under a unified empirical framework, we approximate the effective noise level primarily through reported two-qubit gate error rates. This lets us compare how much effective noise sparse and fully connected architectures can tolerate for the same position relative to the noisy-IQP simulatability boundary. Our results show that sparse connectivity requires a lower effective noise level to sustain the same margin relative to the noisy-IQP simulatability boundary, and they provide a quantitative framework for determining when compiled IQP experiments are likely to remain outside, or instead enter, the classically simulatable regime.