Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2306.00083 · Physical Review Letters

Bell Sampling from Quantum Circuits

Dominik Hangleiter, Michael J. Gullans

Published Jul 8, 2024• 59 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A central challenge in the verification of quantum computers is benchmarking their performance as a whole and demonstrating their computational capabilities. In this Letter, we find a universal model of quantum computation, Bell sampling, that can be used for both of those tasks and thus provides an ideal stepping stone toward fault tolerance. In Bell sampling, we measure two copies of a state prepared by a quantum circuit in the transversal Bell basis. We show that the Bell samples are classically intractable to produce and at the same time constitute what we call a "circuit shadow": from the Bell samples we can efficiently extract information about the quantum circuit preparing the state, as well as diagnose circuit errors. In addition to known properties that can be efficiently extracted from Bell samples, we give several new and efficient protocols: an estimator of state fidelity, an error-mitigated estimator of Pauli expectation values, a test for the depth of a circuit, and an algorithm to estimate a lower bound on the number of T gates in the circuit. With some additional measurements, the latter algorithm can be used to learn a full description of states prepared by circuits with low T count.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.133.020601

Related papers

Reconquering Bell sampling on qudits: stabilizer learning and testing, quantum pseudorandomness bounds, and more

Jonathan Allcock, João Fernando Doriguello, Gábor Ivanyos +1 more

Bell sampling is a simple yet powerful tool based on measuring two copies of a quantum state in the Bell basis, and has found applications in a plethora of problems related to stabiliser states and measures of magic. However, it was not known how to generalise the procedure from qubits to $d$-level systems -- qudits -- for all dimensions $d > 2$ in a useful way. Indeed, a prior work of the authors (arXiv'24) showed that the natural extension of Bell sampling to arbitrary dimensions fails to provide meaningful information about the quantum states being measured. In this paper, we overcome the difficulties encountered in previous works and develop a useful generalisation of Bell sampling to qudits of all $d\geq 2$. At the heart of our primitive is a new unitary, based on Lagrange's four-square theorem, that maps four copies of any stabiliser state $|\mathcal{S}\rangle$ to four copies of its complex conjugate $|\mathcal{S}^\ast\rangle$ (up to some Pauli operator), which may be of independent interest. We then demonstrate the utility of our new Bell sampling technique by lifting several known results from qubits to qudits for any $d\geq 2$: 1. Learning stabiliser states in $O(n^3)$ time with $O(n)$ samples; 2. Solving the Hidden Stabiliser Group Problem in $\tilde{O}(n^3/\varepsilon)$ time with $\tilde{O}(n/\varepsilon)$ samples; 3. Testing whether $|ψ\rangle$ has stabiliser size at least $d^t$ or is $\varepsilon$-far from all such states in $\tilde{O}(n^3/\varepsilon)$ time with $\tilde{O}(n/\varepsilon)$ samples; 4. Clifford circuits with at most $n/2$ single-qudit non-Clifford gates cannot prepare pseudorandom states; 5. Testing whether $|ψ\rangle$ has stabiliser fidelity at least $1-\varepsilon_1$ or at most $1-\varepsilon_2$ with $O(d^2\varepsilon_2/(\varepsilon_2-\varepsilon_1)^2)$ samples if $\varepsilon_1 = O(\varepsilon_2/d^{2})$.

arXiv:2510.06848•Oct 8, 2025•3 citations

A computationally efficient approach to quantum state reconstruction using robust classical shadows

Sanjay Sharma, Shyam Akashe, Govind Murari Upadhyay +1 more

Quantum state tomography is a fundamental technique for characterizing quantum systems, but its scalability remains a significant challenge. This paper investigates an efficient alternative using classical shadows to reconstruct a Bell state with high fidelity. Classical shadows provide a compressed representation of a quantum state using randomized measurements, reducing the measurement complexity compared to full quantum tomography when full state reconstruction is not required. We employed a quantum circuit to generate a Bell state and utilize 1000 snapshots to construct its classical shadow. The reconstructed density matrix is evaluated using fidelity and norm difference metrics against the ideal Bell state. Our analysis demonstrates that as the number of snapshots increases, the fidelity of reconstruction stabilizes around 0.98-1.0, with the norm difference decreasing accordingly. The results also confirm the convergence of reconstructed states towards the ideal Bell state, highlighting the efficiency and accuracy of classical shadows in quantum state estimation. Shallow shadow tomography uses shallow random circuits to estimate global quantum state properties on noisy hardware. By combining low-depth entangling gates with randomized measurements and noise-aware postprocessing, it reduces sample complexity compared to Pauli shadows while remaining experimentally feasible. Recent experiments on superconducting processors confirmed up to fivefold measurement savings.

Scientific Reports•Feb 2, 2026•0 citations

Verification and Testing Approaches for Quantum Circuits: A Comprehensive Study

Ritu

This research paper provides an in-depth examination of verification and testing approaches for quantum circuits, focusing on methodologies essential for ensuring the correctness, reliability and operational efficiency of quantum computing systems. Since quantum circuits function on the fundamental principles of superposition and entanglement, they present verification challenges that cannot be effectively addressed using conventional classical testing techniques. As a result, the development of specialized quantum-specific verification strategies has become critically important. The study highlights simulation-based verification as a foundational technique, wherein the outcomes of quantum circuit simulations are systematically compared with results obtained from physical quantum hardware. This process enables the identification of functional inconsistencies and supports iterative refinement of circuit designs. In addition, randomized benchmarking is examined as a key evaluation method for estimating circuit fidelity and quantifying error rates through the application of random gate sequences and performance comparisons against established benchmarks. To further improve system robustness, the research investigates fault-tolerant mechanisms, particularly quantum error correction codes, which play a vital role in minimizing the effects of noise, decoherence and hardware imperfections. The integration of advanced quantum metrology and characterization techniques is also explored, enabling precise measurement and detailed analysis of quantum system behavior. These techniques provide deeper insights into circuit performance and contribute significantly to validation processes. By combining simulation-based verification, randomized benchmarking, fault-tolerant protocols and quantum metrology, this study proposes a comprehensive and reliable framework for quantum circuit verification and testing. The findings contribute to the advancement of dependable quantum technologies and support their growing applications in areas such as cryptography, materials science and other emerging domains.

International Journal of Advanced Research and Multidisciplinary Trends (IJARMT)•Sep 24, 2025•0 citations

Efficient fidelity simulation of high-rate magic distillation circuits

Xiao Xiao, Dominik Hangleiter, J. Pablo Bonilla Ataides +4 more

Non-Clifford gates are essential for avoiding classical simulability under the Gottesman-Knill theorem. An error-corrected circuit with non-Clifford gates will therefore be an important element for realizing useful fault-tolerant quantum algorithms. However, accurately understanding the fault-tolerant performance of such circuits faces challenges due to the classical hardness of simulating these circuits. We avoid simulating logical measurements and develop exact and efficient classical methods for benchmarking circuits composed of X, CNOT, and diagonal gates in the Clifford hierarchy, including state and gate teleportation gadgets with feedforward. For circuits with third-level diagonal gates, our benchmarking algorithm efficiently samples syndrome statistics and estimates the output logical fidelity and expectation values of certain Clifford observables, including all Pauli observables. The evaluation of syndrome expectation values also extends to circuits with fourth-level diagonal gates. Our algorithm scales polynomially in the number of physical qubits n and circuit depth T, independent of the number of logical qubits. The benchmarking applications include IQP sampling and magic state preparation/cultivation. We demonstrate the practical utility of our simulation algorithms by using them to optimize high-rate magic state distillation factories based on three copies of a [[27,3,3]] tricycle code.

quant-pharXiv:2610.03605•Oct 5, 2026•3 citations

Fault-Tolerant Compiling of Classically Hard Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial Circuits on Hypercubes

Dominik Hangleiter, Marcin Kalinowski, Dolev Bluvstein +6 more

Realizing computationally complex quantum circuits in the presence of noise and imperfections is a challenging task. While fault-tolerant quantum computing provides a route to reducing noise, it requires a large overhead for generic algorithms. Here, we develop and analyze a hardware-efficient, fault-tolerant approach to realizing complex sampling circuits. We co-design the circuits with the appropriate quantum error-correcting codes for efficient implementation in a reconfigurable neutral atom-array architecture, constituting what we call a of the sampling algorithm. Specifically, we consider a family of ⟦ 2 D , D , 2 ⟧ quantum error-detecting codes whose transversal and permutation gate set can realize arbitrary degree- D instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) circuits. Using native operations of the code and the atom-array hardware, we compile a fault-tolerant and fast-scrambling family of such IQP circuits in a hypercube geometry, realized recently in the experiments by Bluvstein [Nature 626, 7997 (2024)]. We develop a theory of second-moment properties of degree- D IQP circuits for analyzing hardness and verification of random sampling by mapping to a statistical mechanics model. We provide strong evidence that sampling from these hypercube IQP circuits is classically hard to simulate even at relatively low depths. We analyze the linear cross-entropy benchmark (XEB) in comparison to the average fidelity and, depending on the local noise rate, find two different asymptotic regimes. To realize a fully scalable approach, we first show that Bell sampling from degree-4 IQP circuits is classically intractable and can be efficiently validated. We further devise new families of ⟦ O ( d D ) , D , d ⟧ color codes of increasing distance d , permitting exponential error suppression for transversal IQP sampling. Our results highlight fault-tolerant compiling as a powerful tool in co-designing algorithms with specific error-correcting codes and realistic hardware.

arXiv:2404.19005•PRX Quantum•May 28, 2025•25 citations

Learning stabilizer states by Bell sampling

Ashley Montanaro

We show that measuring pairs of qubits in the Bell basis can be used to obtain a simple quantum algorithm for efficiently identifying an unknown stabilizer state of n qubits. The algorithm uses O(n) copies of the input state and fails with exponentially small probability.

arXiv:1707.04012•Jul 13, 2017•145 citations
A central challenge in the verification of quantum computers is benchmarking their performance as a whole and demonstrating their computational capabilities. In this Letter, we find a universal model of quantum computation, Bell sampling, that can be used for both of those tasks and thus provides an ideal stepping stone toward fault tolerance. In Bell sampling, we measure two copies of a state prepared by a quantum circuit in the transversal Bell basis. We show that the Bell samples are classically intractable to produce and at the same time constitute what we call a "circuit shadow": from the Bell samples we can efficiently extract information about the quantum circuit preparing the state, as well as diagnose circuit errors. In addition to known properties that can be efficiently extracted from Bell samples, we give several new and efficient protocols: an estimator of state fidelity, an error-mitigated estimator of Pauli expectation values, a test for the depth of a circuit, and an algorithm to estimate a lower bound on the number of T gates in the circuit. With some additional measurements, the latter algorithm can be used to learn a full description of states prepared by circuits with low T count.
Bell sampling is a simple yet powerful tool based on measuring two copies of a quantum state in the Bell basis, and has found applications in a plethora of problems related to stabiliser states and measures of magic. However, it was not known how to generalise the procedure from qubits to ddd-level systems -- qudits -- for all dimensions d>2d > 2d>2 in a useful way. Indeed, a prior work of the authors (arXiv'24) showed that the natural extension of Bell sampling to arbitrary dimensions fails to provide meaningful information about the quantum states being measured. In this paper, we overcome the difficulties encountered in previous works and develop a useful generalisation of Bell sampling to qudits of all d≥2d\geq 2d≥2. At the heart of our primitive is a new unitary, based on Lagrange's four-square theorem, that maps four copies of any stabiliser state ∣S⟩|\mathcal{S}\rangle∣S⟩ to four copies of its complex conjugate ∣S∗⟩|\mathcal{S}^\ast\rangle∣S∗⟩ (up to some Pauli operator), which may be of independent interest. We then demonstrate the utility of our new Bell sampling technique by lifting several known results from qubits to qudits for any d≥2d\geq 2d≥2: 1. Learning stabiliser states in O(n3)O(n^3)O(n3) time with O(n)O(n)O(n) samples; 2. Solving the Hidden Stabiliser Group Problem in O~(n3/ε)\tilde{O}(n^3/\varepsilon)O~(n3/ε) time with O~(n/ε)\tilde{O}(n/\varepsilon)O~(n/ε) samples; 3. Testing whether ∣ψ⟩|ψ\rangle∣ψ⟩ has stabiliser size at least dtd^tdt or is ε\varepsilonε-far from all such states in O~(n3/ε)\tilde{O}(n^3/\varepsilon)O~(n3/ε) time with O~(n/ε)\tilde{O}(n/\varepsilon)O~(n/ε) samples; 4. Clifford circuits with at most n/2n/2n/2 single-qudit non-Clifford gates cannot prepare pseudorandom states; 5. Testing whether ∣ψ⟩|ψ\rangle∣ψ⟩ has stabiliser fidelity at least 1−ε11-\varepsilon_11−ε1​ or at most 1−ε21-\varepsilon_21−ε2​ with O(d2ε2/(ε2−ε1)2)O(d^2\varepsilon_2/(\varepsilon_2-\varepsilon_1)^2)O(d2ε2​/(ε2​−ε1​)2) samples if ε1=O(ε2/d2)\varepsilon_1 = O(\varepsilon_2/d^{2})ε1​=O(ε2​/d2).
Quantum state tomography is a fundamental technique for characterizing quantum systems, but its scalability remains a significant challenge. This paper investigates an efficient alternative using classical shadows to reconstruct a Bell state with high fidelity. Classical shadows provide a compressed representation of a quantum state using randomized measurements, reducing the measurement complexity compared to full quantum tomography when full state reconstruction is not required. We employed a quantum circuit to generate a Bell state and utilize 1000 snapshots to construct its classical shadow. The reconstructed density matrix is evaluated using fidelity and norm difference metrics against the ideal Bell state. Our analysis demonstrates that as the number of snapshots increases, the fidelity of reconstruction stabilizes around 0.98-1.0, with the norm difference decreasing accordingly. The results also confirm the convergence of reconstructed states towards the ideal Bell state, highlighting the efficiency and accuracy of classical shadows in quantum state estimation. Shallow shadow tomography uses shallow random circuits to estimate global quantum state properties on noisy hardware. By combining low-depth entangling gates with randomized measurements and noise-aware postprocessing, it reduces sample complexity compared to Pauli shadows while remaining experimentally feasible. Recent experiments on superconducting processors confirmed up to fivefold measurement savings.
This research paper provides an in-depth examination of verification and testing approaches for quantum circuits, focusing on methodologies essential for ensuring the correctness, reliability and operational efficiency of quantum computing systems. Since quantum circuits function on the fundamental principles of superposition and entanglement, they present verification challenges that cannot be effectively addressed using conventional classical testing techniques. As a result, the development of specialized quantum-specific verification strategies has become critically important. The study highlights simulation-based verification as a foundational technique, wherein the outcomes of quantum circuit simulations are systematically compared with results obtained from physical quantum hardware. This process enables the identification of functional inconsistencies and supports iterative refinement of circuit designs. In addition, randomized benchmarking is examined as a key evaluation method for estimating circuit fidelity and quantifying error rates through the application of random gate sequences and performance comparisons against established benchmarks. To further improve system robustness, the research investigates fault-tolerant mechanisms, particularly quantum error correction codes, which play a vital role in minimizing the effects of noise, decoherence and hardware imperfections. The integration of advanced quantum metrology and characterization techniques is also explored, enabling precise measurement and detailed analysis of quantum system behavior. These techniques provide deeper insights into circuit performance and contribute significantly to validation processes. By combining simulation-based verification, randomized benchmarking, fault-tolerant protocols and quantum metrology, this study proposes a comprehensive and reliable framework for quantum circuit verification and testing. The findings contribute to the advancement of dependable quantum technologies and support their growing applications in areas such as cryptography, materials science and other emerging domains.
Non-Clifford gates are essential for avoiding classical simulability under the Gottesman-Knill theorem. An error-corrected circuit with non-Clifford gates will therefore be an important element for realizing useful fault-tolerant quantum algorithms. However, accurately understanding the fault-tolerant performance of such circuits faces challenges due to the classical hardness of simulating these circuits. We avoid simulating logical measurements and develop exact and efficient classical methods for benchmarking circuits composed of X, CNOT, and diagonal gates in the Clifford hierarchy, including state and gate teleportation gadgets with feedforward. For circuits with third-level diagonal gates, our benchmarking algorithm efficiently samples syndrome statistics and estimates the output logical fidelity and expectation values of certain Clifford observables, including all Pauli observables. The evaluation of syndrome expectation values also extends to circuits with fourth-level diagonal gates. Our algorithm scales polynomially in the number of physical qubits n and circuit depth T, independent of the number of logical qubits. The benchmarking applications include IQP sampling and magic state preparation/cultivation. We demonstrate the practical utility of our simulation algorithms by using them to optimize high-rate magic state distillation factories based on three copies of a [[27,3,3]] tricycle code.
Realizing computationally complex quantum circuits in the presence of noise and imperfections is a challenging task. While fault-tolerant quantum computing provides a route to reducing noise, it requires a large overhead for generic algorithms. Here, we develop and analyze a hardware-efficient, fault-tolerant approach to realizing complex sampling circuits. We co-design the circuits with the appropriate quantum error-correcting codes for efficient implementation in a reconfigurable neutral atom-array architecture, constituting what we call a of the sampling algorithm. Specifically, we consider a family of ⟦ 2 D , D , 2 ⟧ quantum error-detecting codes whose transversal and permutation gate set can realize arbitrary degree- D instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) circuits. Using native operations of the code and the atom-array hardware, we compile a fault-tolerant and fast-scrambling family of such IQP circuits in a hypercube geometry, realized recently in the experiments by Bluvstein [Nature 626, 7997 (2024)]. We develop a theory of second-moment properties of degree- D IQP circuits for analyzing hardness and verification of random sampling by mapping to a statistical mechanics model. We provide strong evidence that sampling from these hypercube IQP circuits is classically hard to simulate even at relatively low depths. We analyze the linear cross-entropy benchmark (XEB) in comparison to the average fidelity and, depending on the local noise rate, find two different asymptotic regimes. To realize a fully scalable approach, we first show that Bell sampling from degree-4 IQP circuits is classically intractable and can be efficiently validated. We further devise new families of ⟦ O ( d D ) , D , d ⟧ color codes of increasing distance d , permitting exponential error suppression for transversal IQP sampling. Our results highlight fault-tolerant compiling as a powerful tool in co-designing algorithms with specific error-correcting codes and realistic hardware.