Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2305.09229 · Physical Review A

From entanglement to discord: A perspective based on partial transposition

Liang-Liang Sun, Xiang Zhou, Sixia Yu

Published Oct 18, 2023• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Here, we show that partial transposition, which is initially introduced to study entanglement, can also inspire many results on quantum discord, including (I) a discord criterion of a spectrum invariant under partial transposition, stating that one state must contain discord if its spectrum is changed by the action of partial transposition, and (II) an approach to estimate the geometric quantum discord and the one-way deficit based on the change of the spectrum. To compare with entanglement theory, we also lower bound the geometric quantum entanglement and the entanglement of relative entropy. Thus, on one hand, we illustrate an approach to specify and estimate discord based on partial transposition. On the other hand, we show that, entanglement and discord, two basic notions of nonclassical correlations, can be placed on the same ground such that their interplay and distinction can be illustrated within a universal framework.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.108.042417

Related papers

Note on quantum discord

Yiding Wang, Xiaofen Huang, Tinggui Zhang

Quantum discord goes beyond entanglement and exists in a wide range of quantum states that may be separable, playing a crucial role in quantum information tasks. In this paper, we firstly proposed a zero-discord criterion for two-qubit system based on the partial transposition of density matrix, and then extended it to the qubit–qudit system. By detailed examples we demonstrate the effectiveness of these criteria in detecting discord. Moreover, we provide an analytical lower bound of geometric quantum discord(GQD) using eigenvalue vectors of density matrix. Finally, we presented a one-way work deficit lower bound based on our lower bound of GQD.

arXiv:2408.05876•Results in Physics•Aug 5, 2024•3 citations

Comparison of the attempts of quantum discord and quantum entanglement to capture quantum correlations

Asma Al-Qasimi, Daniel F. V. James

Measurements of quantum systems disturb their states. To quantify this nonclassical characteristic, Zurek and Ollivier [Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 017901 (2001)] introduced the quantum discord, a quantum correlation that can be nonzero even when entanglement in the system is zero. Discord has aroused great interest as a resource that is more robust against the effects of decoherence and offers the exponential speed-up of certain computational algorithms. Here, we study general two-level bipartite systems and give general results on the relationship between discord, entanglement, and linear entropy. We also identify the states for which discord takes a maximal value for a given entropy or entanglement, thus placing strong bounds on entanglement-discord and entropy-discord relations. We find out that although discord and entanglement are identical for pure states, they differ when generalized to mixed states as a result of the difference in the method of generalization.

arXiv:1007.1814•Physical Review A•Mar 2, 2011•90 citations

Entanglement as minimal discord over state extensions

Shunlong Luo

The characterization and quantification of quantum correlations, which play an instrumental role in exploring and exploiting the quantum world, have been extensively and intensively studied in the past few decades. Of special prominence and significance are the concepts of entanglement and discord, which are usually regarded as very distinctive quantum correlations, with the latter going beyond the former. In this work we establish a direct and natural link between entanglement and discord via state extensions and reveal that entanglement is actually the intrinsic discord, by which we mean that entanglement is the irreducible residue of discord viewed from ambient spaces. Our approach, taking into account the contextuality of a quantum state and being of a global nature, stands in sharp contrast to the local operations and classical communication paradigm of entanglement, which focuses on the state itself via a local approach. Furthermore, we introduce a figure of merit which, on the one hand, captures the essence of entanglement, i.e., nonlocality and quantumness of correlations, and, on the other hand, leads to a quantitative decomposition of total correlations into classical correlations, dissonance, and entanglement. This demystifies the meaning of entanglement from the perspective of quantum measurements and provides a unified framework for the interplay of various correlations in terms of quantum measurements and mutual information.

Physical Review A•Sep 29, 2016•18 citations

Detecting quantum correlations by means of local noncommutativity

Yu Chen Guo, Jinchuan Hou

Quantum correlation is a key to our understanding of quantum physics. In particular, it is essential for the powerful applications to quantum information and quantum computation. There exist quantum correlations beyond entanglement, such as quantum discord (QD) and measurement-induced nonlocality (MiN) [Phys. Rev. Lett. \textbf{106}, 120401(2011)]. In [Phys. Rev. A \textbf{77}, 022113(2008)], a subclass of PPT states so-called strong positive partial transposition (SPPT) states was introduced and it was conjectured there that SPPT states are separable. However, it was illustrated with examples in [Phys. Rev. A \textbf{81}, 064101(2010)] that this conjecture is not true. Viewing the original SPPT as SPPT up to part B, in the present paper, we define SPPT state up to part A and B respectively and present a separable class of SPPT states, that is the super SPPT (SSPPT) states, in terms of local commutativity. In addition, classical-quantum (CQ) states and nullity of MiN are characterized via local commutativity. Based on CQ states, the geometric measure of quantum discord (GMQD) for infinite-dimensional case is proposed. Consequently, we highlight the relation among MiN, QD(GMQD), SSPPT and separability through a unified approach for both finite- and infinite-dimensional systems: zero MiN implies zero QD(GMQD), zero QD(GMQD) signals SSPPT and SSPPT guarantees separability, but the converses are not valid.

arXiv:1107.0355•Jul 2, 2011•8 citations

Correlation minor norms, entanglement detection and discord

Bar Y. Peled, Amit Te’eni, Avishy Carmi +1 more

In this paper we develop an approach for detecting entanglement, which is based on measuring quantum correlations and constructing a correlation matrix. The correlation matrix is then used for defining a family of parameters, named Correlation Minor Norms, which allow one to detect entanglement. This approach generalizes the computable cross-norm or realignment (CCNR) criterion, and moreover requires measuring a state-independent set of operators. Furthermore, we illustrate a scheme which yields for each Correlation Minor Norm a separable state that maximizes it. The proposed entanglement detection scheme is believed to be advantageous in comparison to other methods because correlations have a simple, intuitive meaning and in addition they can be directly measured in experiment. Moreover, it is demonstrated to be stronger than the CCNR criterion. We also illustrate the relation between the Correlation Minor Norm and entanglement entropy for pure states. Finally, we discuss the relation between the Correlation Minor Norm and quantum discord. We demonstrate that the CMN may be used to define a new measure for quantum discord.

arXiv:2005.12079•Scientific Reports•Feb 2, 2021•6 citations

Entanglement Irreversibility from Quantum Discord and Quantum Deficit

Marcio F. Cornelio, M. C. de Oliveira, F. F. Fanchini

We relate the problem of irreversibility of entanglement with the recently defined measures of quantum correlation--quantum discord and one-way quantum deficit. We show that the entanglement of formation is always strictly larger than the coherent information and the entanglement cost is also larger in most cases. We prove irreversibility of entanglement under local operations and classical communication for a family of entangled states. This family is a generalization of the maximally correlated states for which we also give an analytic expression for the distillable entanglement, the relative entropy of entanglement, the distillable secret key, and the quantum discord.

arXiv:1007.0228•Physical Review Letters•Jul 5, 2011•113 citations
Here, we show that partial transposition, which is initially introduced to study entanglement, can also inspire many results on quantum discord, including (I) a discord criterion of a spectrum invariant under partial transposition, stating that one state must contain discord if its spectrum is changed by the action of partial transposition, and (II) an approach to estimate the geometric quantum discord and the one-way deficit based on the change of the spectrum. To compare with entanglement theory, we also lower bound the geometric quantum entanglement and the entanglement of relative entropy. Thus, on one hand, we illustrate an approach to specify and estimate discord based on partial transposition. On the other hand, we show that, entanglement and discord, two basic notions of nonclassical correlations, can be placed on the same ground such that their interplay and distinction can be illustrated within a universal framework.
Quantum discord goes beyond entanglement and exists in a wide range of quantum states that may be separable, playing a crucial role in quantum information tasks. In this paper, we firstly proposed a zero-discord criterion for two-qubit system based on the partial transposition of density matrix, and then extended it to the qubit–qudit system. By detailed examples we demonstrate the effectiveness of these criteria in detecting discord. Moreover, we provide an analytical lower bound of geometric quantum discord(GQD) using eigenvalue vectors of density matrix. Finally, we presented a one-way work deficit lower bound based on our lower bound of GQD.
Measurements of quantum systems disturb their states. To quantify this nonclassical characteristic, Zurek and Ollivier [Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 017901 (2001)] introduced the quantum discord, a quantum correlation that can be nonzero even when entanglement in the system is zero. Discord has aroused great interest as a resource that is more robust against the effects of decoherence and offers the exponential speed-up of certain computational algorithms. Here, we study general two-level bipartite systems and give general results on the relationship between discord, entanglement, and linear entropy. We also identify the states for which discord takes a maximal value for a given entropy or entanglement, thus placing strong bounds on entanglement-discord and entropy-discord relations. We find out that although discord and entanglement are identical for pure states, they differ when generalized to mixed states as a result of the difference in the method of generalization.
The characterization and quantification of quantum correlations, which play an instrumental role in exploring and exploiting the quantum world, have been extensively and intensively studied in the past few decades. Of special prominence and significance are the concepts of entanglement and discord, which are usually regarded as very distinctive quantum correlations, with the latter going beyond the former. In this work we establish a direct and natural link between entanglement and discord via state extensions and reveal that entanglement is actually the intrinsic discord, by which we mean that entanglement is the irreducible residue of discord viewed from ambient spaces. Our approach, taking into account the contextuality of a quantum state and being of a global nature, stands in sharp contrast to the local operations and classical communication paradigm of entanglement, which focuses on the state itself via a local approach. Furthermore, we introduce a figure of merit which, on the one hand, captures the essence of entanglement, i.e., nonlocality and quantumness of correlations, and, on the other hand, leads to a quantitative decomposition of total correlations into classical correlations, dissonance, and entanglement. This demystifies the meaning of entanglement from the perspective of quantum measurements and provides a unified framework for the interplay of various correlations in terms of quantum measurements and mutual information.
Quantum correlation is a key to our understanding of quantum physics. In particular, it is essential for the powerful applications to quantum information and quantum computation. There exist quantum correlations beyond entanglement, such as quantum discord (QD) and measurement-induced nonlocality (MiN) [Phys. Rev. Lett. \textbf{106}, 120401(2011)]. In [Phys. Rev. A \textbf{77}, 022113(2008)], a subclass of PPT states so-called strong positive partial transposition (SPPT) states was introduced and it was conjectured there that SPPT states are separable. However, it was illustrated with examples in [Phys. Rev. A \textbf{81}, 064101(2010)] that this conjecture is not true. Viewing the original SPPT as SPPT up to part B, in the present paper, we define SPPT state up to part A and B respectively and present a separable class of SPPT states, that is the super SPPT (SSPPT) states, in terms of local commutativity. In addition, classical-quantum (CQ) states and nullity of MiN are characterized via local commutativity. Based on CQ states, the geometric measure of quantum discord (GMQD) for infinite-dimensional case is proposed. Consequently, we highlight the relation among MiN, QD(GMQD), SSPPT and separability through a unified approach for both finite- and infinite-dimensional systems: zero MiN implies zero QD(GMQD), zero QD(GMQD) signals SSPPT and SSPPT guarantees separability, but the converses are not valid.
In this paper we develop an approach for detecting entanglement, which is based on measuring quantum correlations and constructing a correlation matrix. The correlation matrix is then used for defining a family of parameters, named Correlation Minor Norms, which allow one to detect entanglement. This approach generalizes the computable cross-norm or realignment (CCNR) criterion, and moreover requires measuring a state-independent set of operators. Furthermore, we illustrate a scheme which yields for each Correlation Minor Norm a separable state that maximizes it. The proposed entanglement detection scheme is believed to be advantageous in comparison to other methods because correlations have a simple, intuitive meaning and in addition they can be directly measured in experiment. Moreover, it is demonstrated to be stronger than the CCNR criterion. We also illustrate the relation between the Correlation Minor Norm and entanglement entropy for pure states. Finally, we discuss the relation between the Correlation Minor Norm and quantum discord. We demonstrate that the CMN may be used to define a new measure for quantum discord.
We relate the problem of irreversibility of entanglement with the recently defined measures of quantum correlation--quantum discord and one-way quantum deficit. We show that the entanglement of formation is always strictly larger than the coherent information and the entanglement cost is also larger in most cases. We prove irreversibility of entanglement under local operations and classical communication for a family of entangled states. This family is a generalization of the maximally correlated states for which we also give an analytic expression for the distillable entanglement, the relative entropy of entanglement, the distillable secret key, and the quantum discord.