Abstract Consider a free Schrödinger particle inside an interval with walls characterized by the Dirichlet boundary condition. Choose a parabola as the normalized state of the particle that satisfies this boundary condition. To calculate the variance of the Hamiltonian in that state, one needs to calculate the mean value of the Hamiltonian and that of its square. If one uses the standard formula to calculate these mean values, one obtains both results without difficulty, but the variance unexpectedly takes an imaginary value. If one uses the same expression to calculate these mean values but first writes the Hamiltonian and its square in terms of their respective eigenfunctions and eigenvalues, one obtains the same result as above for the mean value of the Hamiltonian but a different value for its square (in fact, it is not zero); hence, the variance takes an acceptable value. From whence do these contradictory results arise? The latter paradox has been presented in the literature as an example of a problem that can only be properly solved by making use of certain fundamental concepts within the general theory of linear operators in Hilbert spaces. Here, we carefully review those concepts and apply them in a detailed way to resolve the paradox. Our results are formulated within the natural framework of wave mechanics, and to avoid inconveniences that the use of Dirac’s symbolic formalism could bring, we avoid the use of that formalism throughout the article. In addition, we obtain a resolution of the paradox in an entirely formal way without addressing the restrictions imposed by the domains of the operators involved. We think that the content of this paper will be useful to undergraduate and graduate students as well as to their instructors.
Abstract Consider a free Schrödinger particle inside an interval with walls characterized by the Dirichlet boundary condition. Choose a parabola as the normalized state of the particle that satisfies this boundary condition. To calculate the variance of the Hamiltonian in that state, one needs to calculate the mean value of the Hamiltonian and that of its square. If one uses the standard formula to calculate these mean values, one obtains both results without difficulty, but the variance unexpectedly takes an imaginary value. If one uses the same expression to calculate these mean values but first writes the Hamiltonian and its square in terms of their respective eigenfunctions and eigenvalues, one obtains the same result as above for the mean value of the Hamiltonian but a different value for its square (in fact, it is not zero); hence, the variance takes an acceptable value. From whence do these contradictory results arise? The latter paradox has been presented in the literature as an example of a problem that can only be properly solved by making use of certain fundamental concepts within the general theory of linear operators in Hilbert spaces. Here, we carefully review those concepts and apply them in a detailed way to resolve the paradox. Our results are formulated within the natural framework of wave mechanics, and to avoid inconveniences that the use of Dirac’s symbolic formalism could bring, we avoid the use of that formalism throughout the article. In addition, we obtain a resolution of the paradox in an entirely formal way without addressing the restrictions imposed by the domains of the operators involved. We think that the content of this paper will be useful to undergraduate and graduate students as well as to their instructors.
One of the possible versions of quantum mechanics, known as Kuryshkin-Wodkiewicz quantum mechanics, is considered. In this version, the quantum distribution function is positive, but, as a retribution for this, the von Neumann quantization rule is replaced by a more complicated rule, in which an observed value AA is associated with a pseudodifferential operator O^(A){\hat{O}(A)}. This version is an example of a dissipative quantum system and, therefore, it was expected that the eigenvalues of the Hamiltonian should have imaginary parts. However, the discrete spectrum of the Hamiltonian of a hydrogen-like atom in this theory turned out to be real-valued. In this paper, we propose the following explanation for this paradox. It is traditionally assumed that in some state ψ{\psi} the quantity AA is equal to λ{\lambda} if ψ{\psi} is an eigenfunction of the operator O^(A){\hat{O}(A)}. In this case, the variance O^((A-λ)2)ψ{\hat{O}((A-\lambda)2)\psi} is zero in the standard version of quantum mechanics, but nonzero in Kuryshkins mechanics. Therefore, it is possible to consider such a range of values and states corresponding to them for which the variance O^((A-λ)2){\hat{O}((A-\lambda)2)} is zero. The spectrum of the quadratic pencil O^(A2)-2O^(A)λ+λ2E^{\hat{O}(A2)-2\hat{O}(A)\lambda + \lambda 2 \hat{E}} is studied by the methods of perturbation theory under the assumption of small variance D^(A)=O^(A2)-O^(A)2{\hat{D}(A) = \hat{O}(A2) - \hat{O}(A) 2} of the observable AA. It is shown that in the neighborhood of the real eigenvalue λ{\lambda} of the operator O^(A){\hat{O}(A)}, there are two eigenvalues of the operator pencil, which differ in the first order of perturbation theory by ±i⟨D^⟩{\pm i \sqrt{\langle \hat{D} \rangle}}.
For real potentials and for arbitrary boundary conditions we point to previously noted paradoxes in applications of the Ehrenfest and Hellmann-Feynman theorems, their resolution and their role on the consistency of quantum mechanical uncertainty relations. The paradoxes originate from a hidden non-Hermitian character of the kinetic energy operator and are resolved if the proper boundary terms (almost always discarded in the literature) are taken seriously. These non-Hermitian contributions (reflections at a deeper level of topological anomalies) follow their own patterns (for any dimensionality, for both Schroedinger and Dirac/Weyl Hamiltonians and for either continuous or lattice (tight-binding) models): they can always be written as global fluxes of certain generalized current densities. In continuous nonrelativistic cases, these have the forms that had earlier been used by Chemists to describe atomic fragments of polyatomic molecules - while for Dirac/Weyl or lattice models they appear to have the corresponding relativistic forms. In spite of the fact that these boundary terms originate from a deep mathematical anomaly, we point out examples where such non-Hermiticities have physical significance in Quantum Condensed Matter Physics (for both conventional and topologically nontrivial materials). In all stationary state examples considered, these non-Hermitian boundary terms have turned out to be quantized, this quantization being either of conventional or of a topological (Quantum Hall Effect (QHE)-type) origin. The latter claim is substantiated through direct application to a simple QHE arrangement (2-D Landau system in an external electric field). Finally, the non-Hermitian terms are also shown to be crucial for the consistency of the standard uncertainty relations (of Kennard/Robertson-type) in multiply-connected space or, generally, in any system that satisfies a Bloch theorem.
By a series of simple examples, we illustrate how the lack of mathematical concern can readily lead to surprising mathematical contradictions in wave mechanics. The basic mathematical notions allowing for a precise formulation of the theory are then summarized and it is shown how they lead to an elucidation and deeper understanding of the aforementioned problems. After stressing the equivalence between wave mechanics and the other formulations of quantum mechanics, i.e. matrix mechanics and Dirac's abstract Hilbert space formulation, we devote the second part of our paper to the latter approach: we discuss the problems and shortcomings of this formalism as well as those of the bra and ket notation introduced by Dirac in this context. In conclusion, we indicate how all of these problems can be solved or at least avoided. Dedicated to the memory of Tanguy Altherr (1963-94). I dedicate these notes to the memory of Tanguy Altherr who left us very unexpectedly in the mountains which he loved so much (and where I had some pleasant trips with him). As to the subject of these notes (which I had the pleasure to discuss with him), Tanguy greatly appreciated Dirac's formalism and certainly knew how to apply it to real physical problems (such as the ones he worked on with an impressive enthusiasm, energy and productivity). Even if he did not share my preoccupations in this field, he liked to discuss the problems related to the general formalism of quantum physics.
For real potentials and for arbitrary boundary conditions we point to previously noted paradoxes in applications of the Ehrenfest and Hellmann-Feynman theorems, their resolution and the role played on the consistency of quantum mechanical uncertainty relations. The paradoxes originate from a hidden non-Hermitian character of the kinetic energy operator and are resolved if the proper boundary terms (almost always discarded in the literature) are taken seriously. These non-Hermitian contributions (reflections at a deeper level of topological anomalies) follow their own patterns (for any dimensionality, for both Schroedinger and Dirac/Weyl Hamiltonians and for either continuous or lattice (tight-binding) models): they can always be written as global fluxes of certain generalized current densities. In continuous nonrelativistic cases, these have the forms that had earlier been used by Chemists to describe atomic parts of polyatomic molecules while for Dirac/Weyl or lattice models they appear to have the corresponding relativistic forms. In spite of the fact that these boundary terms originate from a deep mathematical anomaly, we point out examples where such non-Hermiticities have physical significance in Quantum Condensed Matter Physics (for both conventional and topologically nontrivial materials). In all stationary state examples considered, these non-Hermitian boundary terms have turned out to be quantized, this quantization being either of conventional or of a topological (Quantum Hall Effect (QHE)-type) origin. The latter claim is substantiated through direct application to a simple QHE arrangement (2-D Landau system in an external electric field). Finally, the non-Hermitian terms are also shown to be crucial for the consistency of the standard uncertainty relations (of Kennard/Robertson type) in multiply-connected space or, generally, in any system that satisfies the Bloch theorem.
We calculate formal time derivatives of the mean values of the standard position, velocity, and mechanical momentum operators, i. e., the Ehrenfest theorem for a one-dimensional Dirac particle in the coordinate representation.We show that these derivatives contain boundary terms that essentially depend on the values taken there by characteristic bilinear densities.We do not automatically take the boundary terms to vanish (as is usually done); nevertheless, we relate the boundary terms to similar terms that must be zero if one requires the hermiticity of certain specific unbounded operators.Throughout the article, we thoroughly discuss and illustrate all these aspects, which include the relations to certain boundary conditions.To clarify, we call our approach formal because all operations involving operators (for example, some operators products) are performed without respecting the restrictions imposed by the sets of functions on which the self-adjoint operators can act.Moreover, the Dirac Hamiltonian that we consider in our calculations contains a potential that is the time component of a Lorentz two-vector; nevertheless, we also obtain and concisely discuss the Ehrenfest theorem for a Hamiltonian with the most general Lorentz potential in (1+1) dimensions.
We analyze the problem of a free 1D Klein-Fock-Gordon-Majorana (KFGM) particle in an interval. By free, we mean that there is no potential within the interval and that its walls are penetrable; hence, the pertinent energy current density does not vanish at the walls. Certainly, quantization in an interval is not trivial because certain restrictions imposed by the domains of the operators involved arise. Here, our objective is to obtain the Hamiltonian for these particles. In practice, the Feshbach-Villars (FV)--free Hamiltonian is the proper operator for characterizing them and is a function of the momentum operator. Additionally, a Majorana condition must also be imposed on the wavefunctions on which these two operators can act. Thus, we start by calculating the pseudo self-adjoint momentum operator. A three-parameter set of boundary conditions (BCs) constitutes its domain. Up to this point, the domain of the Hamiltonian is induced by the domain of the momentum operator; however, we ensure that only the BCs for which the energy current density has the same value at each end of the interval are in its domain. All these BCs essentially belong to a one-parameter set of BCs. Moreover, because the FV equation is invariant under the operation of parity, the parity-transformed wavefunction is also a solution of this equation, which further restricts the domain of the free FV Hamiltonian. Finally, knowing the most general three-parameter set of BCs for the pseudo self-adjoint FV Hamiltonian for a 1D KFGM particle in an interval, we find that only two BCs can remain within the domain of the FV--free Hamiltonian: the periodic BC and the antiperiodic BC. These BCs are satisfied by both the two-component FV wavefunction, with these components being related, and the one-component KFG wavefunction, which can be real or imaginary.