Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2305.06389 · Physical Review Research

Phase diagram of the three-dimensional subsystem toric code

Yaodong Li, Curt W. von Keyserlingk, Guanyu Zhu, Tomas Jochym-O’Connor

Published Oct 2, 2024• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Subsystem quantum error-correcting codes typically involve measuring a sequence of noncommuting parity check operators. They can sometimes exhibit greater fault tolerance than conventional codes, which use commuting checks. However, unlike subspace codes, it is unclear if subsystem codes—in particular their advantages—can be understood in terms of ground-state properties of a physical Hamiltonian. In this paper, we address this question for the three-dimensional subsystem toric code (3D STC), as recently constructed by Kubica and Vasmer [], which exhibits single-shot error correction. Motivated by a conjectured relation between single-shot properties and thermal stability, we study the zero- and finite-temperature phases of an associated noncommuting Hamiltonian. By mapping the Hamiltonian model to a pair of 3D Z 2 gauge theories coupled by a kinetic constraint, we find various phases at zero temperature, all separated by first-order transitions: There are 3D toric code-like phases with deconfined point-like excitations in the bulk, and there are phases with a confined bulk supporting a 2D toric code on the surface when appropriate boundary conditions are chosen. The latter is similar to the surface topological order present in 3D STC. However, the similarities between the single-shot correction in 3D STC and the confined phases are only partial: they share the same sets of degrees of freedom, but they are governed by different dynamical rules. Instead, we argue that the process of single-shot error correction can more suitably be associated with a path (rather than a point) in the zero-temperature phase diagram, a perspective, which inspires alternative measurement sequences enabling single-shot error correction. Moreover, since none of the above-mentioned phases survives at nonzero temperature, the single-shot error-correction property of the code does not imply thermal stability of the associated Hamiltonian phase. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.6.043007

Related papers

Lifting Topological Codes: Three-Dimensional Subsystem Codes from Two-Dimensional Anyon Models

Jacob C. Bridgeman, Aleksander Kubica, Michael Vasmer

Topological subsystem codes in three spatial dimensions allow for quantum error correction with no time overhead, even in the presence of measurement noise. The physical origins of this single-shot property remain elusive, in part due to the scarcity of known models. To address this challenge, we provide a systematic construction of a class of topological subsystem codes in three dimensions built from Abelian quantum double models in one fewer dimension. Our construction not only generalizes the recently introduced subsystem toric code [Kubica and Vasmer, Nat. Commun. , 6272 (2022)] but also provides a new perspective on several aspects of the original model, including the origin of the Gauss law for gauge flux, and boundary conditions for the code family. We then numerically study the performance of the first few codes in this class against phenomenological noise to verify their single-shot property. Lastly, we discuss Hamiltonians naturally associated with these codes, and argue that they may be gapless. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2305.06365•PRX Quantum•Apr 12, 2024•18 citations

Toric code made subsystem: a framework for topological subsystem codes using anticommuting quantum spin liquids

Vaibhav Sharma, Sumiran Pujari

We introduce a framework of constructing topological subsystem codes based on the class of anticommuting quantum spin liquids described in [Phys. Rev. B 113, 064402 (2026)]. A canonical model from this class can be considered as a spatial modification of the toric code that voids its stabilizer code property. Rather, these models contain an extensive set of anticommuting local conserved operators that lead to an extensive ground state degeneracy. This degeneracy forms the basis of the subsystem degrees of freedom in the associated quantum error correcting code. The code inherits the many-body topological order of the quantum spin liquid, making it a topological subsystem code. We present two concrete and detailed examples for constructing these codes on a square lattice and a kagome lattice geometry, requiring weight-4 and weight-3 local check operator measurements respectively. In contrast to other subsystem codes, a unique property of these codes is the presence of an extensive number of local gauge qubits that are left undisturbed by the check operators apart from the logical qubits. Our construction provides a template for generating this new category of topological subsystem codes on different lattice or graph geometries, suitable for implementation on various quantum hardware platforms.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2606.26226•Jun 26, 2026•0 citations

Single-shot quantum error correction with the three-dimensional subsystem toric code

Aleksander Kubica, Michael Vasmer

Abstract Fault-tolerant protocols and quantum error correction (QEC) are essential to building reliable quantum computers from imperfect components that are vulnerable to errors. Optimizing the resource and time overheads needed to implement QEC is one of the most pressing challenges. Here, we introduce a new topological quantum error-correcting code, the three-dimensional subsystem toric code (3D STC). The 3D STC can be realized with geometrically-local parity checks of weight at most three on the cubic lattice with open boundary conditions. We prove that one round of parity-check measurements suffices to perform reliable QEC with the 3D STC even in the presence of measurement errors. We also propose an efficient single-shot QEC decoding strategy for the 3D STC and numerically estimate the resulting storage threshold against independent bit-flip, phase-flip and measurement errors to bepSTC ≈ 1.045%. Such a high threshold together with local parity-check measurements make the 3D STC particularly appealing for realizing fault-tolerant quantum computing.

arXiv:2106.02621•Nature Communications•Oct 21, 2022•66 citations

Single-shot error correction on toric codes with high-weight stabilizers

Yingjia Lin, Shilin Huang, Kenneth R. Brown

For quantum error correction codes the required number of measurement rounds typically increases with the code distance when measurements are faulty. Single-shot error correction allows for an error threshold with only one round of noisy syndrome measurements regardless of the code size. Here we implement single-shot check operators for toric codes. The single-shot checks are constructed by Gaussian elimination following Campbell [Campbell, Quantum Sci. Technol. 4, 025006 (2019)]. The single-shot check operators result in a sustainable threshold at 5.62% for an error model with noisy measurements, outperforming the conventional toric code-check operators with multiple rounds of noisy measurement. The cost of the transformation is nonlocal high-weight stabilizer generators. We then consider a gate-based error model that leads to increased measurement error with stabilizer weight. Here we find no single-shot threshold behavior and instead find the code family will have an optimal code size for a fixed error rate. For this error model the conventional check operators with multiple measurements yields a lower logical error rate.

arXiv:2310.16160•Physical Review A•May 29, 2024•7 citations

Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computation Through Quantum Low-Density Parity-Check Codes

Weilei Zeng

Quantum computation has shown advantages in several problems over the corresponding classical algorithms. The noisy intermediate-size\n quantum devices with dozens of qubits make it more promising in the\n past decade, as the quantum advantage was demonstrated\n experimentally. Before entering the era of scalable quantum\n computation, one has to resolve the errors in a quantum many-body\n system, which is inevitable due to the environment interaction during\n quantum control processes. The goal of quantum error correction is to\n reduce such errors and increase decoherence time. The most successful candidates of quantum error correction codes are topological codes, especially surface codes, which were discovered by\n Alexei Kitaev. The ordered phase of the 2D\n Ising model on a torus ensures that toric codes are fault-tolerant\n below a critical error probability. Other than the FT threshold,\n the topological codes feature efficient encoding and\n decoding, local measurements, but suffer from asymptotically zero\n code rate. To encode more logical qubits with finite resources, one can loosen the condition on locality and extend to a broader class of quantum\n low-density parity-check (LDPC)codes. There are many known algebraic\n constructions for such codes, but only a precious few of them have\n finite code rates and meet the fault-tolerant condition:\n the stabilizer weight is bounded and the distance scales at least\n logarithmically with the code size. In this thesis, I construct the\n higher-dimensional quantum hypergraph product (HQHP) codes, which\n generalize quantum hypergraph product (QHP) codes and toric codes in\n all dimensions. The HQHP codes projected into a single space gives\n subsystem product codes, which can then be gauge fixed to\n concatenated codes or homological product codes. Those include some\n common CSS codes, like Shor’s codes, Bacon Shor’s codes, and\n subsystem QHP codes. The HQHP codes can be mapped to the tensor\n product of chain complexes, which provides an algebraic framework to\n construct quantum LDPC codes with finite code rates, square root\n distances, FT thresholds and single-shot properties with redundant\n checks. Meanwhile, their rich connection to other codes are very\n instructive and may lead to further optimizations. Regarding the\n remained procedures towards fault-tolerant universal quantum\n computation through quantum LDPC codes, I will discuss the\n fault-tolerant condition for each code, including distance,\n stabilizer weight, decoding, fault-tolerant gates and measurement\n protocols.\n

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Floquet implementation of a 3d fermionic toric code with full logical code space

Yoshito Watanabe, Bianca Bannenberg, Simon Trebst

Floquet quantum error-correcting codes provide an operationally economical route to fault tolerance by dynamically generating stabilizer structures using only two-body Pauli measurements. But while it is well established that stabilizer codes in higher spatial dimensions gain additional levels of intrinsic robustness, higher-dimensional Floquet codes have hitherto been explored only in limited scope. Here we introduce a 3d generalization of a Floquet code whose instantaneous stabilizer group realizes a 3d fermionic toric code, while crucially preserving all three logical qubits throughout the entire measurement sequence. One central ingredient is the identification of a 3d lattice geometry that generalizes the features of the Kekulé lattice underlying the 2d Hastings-Haah code - specifically, a structure where deleting any one edge color yields a two-color subgraph that decomposes into short, closed loops rather than homologically nontrivial chains. This loop property avoids the collapse of logical information that plagues naive sequential two-color measurement schedules on many 3d lattices. Although, for our lattice geometry, a simple 3-round cycle that sequentially measures the three types of parity checks does not expose the full error syndrome set, we show that one can append a measurement sequence to extract the missing syndromes without disturbing the logical subspace. Beyond code design, 3d tricoordinated lattice geometries define a family of 3d monitored Kitaev models, in which random measurements of the non-commuting parity checks give rise to dynamically created entangled phases with nontrivial topology. In discussing the general structure of their underlying phase diagrams and, in particular, the existence of certain quantum critical points, we again make a connection to the general preservation of logical information in time-ordered Floquet protocols.

quant-pharXiv:2602.12685•Feb 16, 2026•1 citation
Subsystem quantum error-correcting codes typically involve measuring a sequence of noncommuting parity check operators. They can sometimes exhibit greater fault tolerance than conventional codes, which use commuting checks. However, unlike subspace codes, it is unclear if subsystem codes—in particular their advantages—can be understood in terms of ground-state properties of a physical Hamiltonian. In this paper, we address this question for the three-dimensional subsystem toric code (3D STC), as recently constructed by Kubica and Vasmer [], which exhibits single-shot error correction. Motivated by a conjectured relation between single-shot properties and thermal stability, we study the zero- and finite-temperature phases of an associated noncommuting Hamiltonian. By mapping the Hamiltonian model to a pair of 3D Z 2 gauge theories coupled by a kinetic constraint, we find various phases at zero temperature, all separated by first-order transitions: There are 3D toric code-like phases with deconfined point-like excitations in the bulk, and there are phases with a confined bulk supporting a 2D toric code on the surface when appropriate boundary conditions are chosen. The latter is similar to the surface topological order present in 3D STC. However, the similarities between the single-shot correction in 3D STC and the confined phases are only partial: they share the same sets of degrees of freedom, but they are governed by different dynamical rules. Instead, we argue that the process of single-shot error correction can more suitably be associated with a path (rather than a point) in the zero-temperature phase diagram, a perspective, which inspires alternative measurement sequences enabling single-shot error correction. Moreover, since none of the above-mentioned phases survives at nonzero temperature, the single-shot error-correction property of the code does not imply thermal stability of the associated Hamiltonian phase. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Topological subsystem codes in three spatial dimensions allow for quantum error correction with no time overhead, even in the presence of measurement noise. The physical origins of this single-shot property remain elusive, in part due to the scarcity of known models. To address this challenge, we provide a systematic construction of a class of topological subsystem codes in three dimensions built from Abelian quantum double models in one fewer dimension. Our construction not only generalizes the recently introduced subsystem toric code [Kubica and Vasmer, Nat. Commun. , 6272 (2022)] but also provides a new perspective on several aspects of the original model, including the origin of the Gauss law for gauge flux, and boundary conditions for the code family. We then numerically study the performance of the first few codes in this class against phenomenological noise to verify their single-shot property. Lastly, we discuss Hamiltonians naturally associated with these codes, and argue that they may be gapless. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We introduce a framework of constructing topological subsystem codes based on the class of anticommuting quantum spin liquids described in [Phys. Rev. B 113, 064402 (2026)]. A canonical model from this class can be considered as a spatial modification of the toric code that voids its stabilizer code property. Rather, these models contain an extensive set of anticommuting local conserved operators that lead to an extensive ground state degeneracy. This degeneracy forms the basis of the subsystem degrees of freedom in the associated quantum error correcting code. The code inherits the many-body topological order of the quantum spin liquid, making it a topological subsystem code. We present two concrete and detailed examples for constructing these codes on a square lattice and a kagome lattice geometry, requiring weight-4 and weight-3 local check operator measurements respectively. In contrast to other subsystem codes, a unique property of these codes is the presence of an extensive number of local gauge qubits that are left undisturbed by the check operators apart from the logical qubits. Our construction provides a template for generating this new category of topological subsystem codes on different lattice or graph geometries, suitable for implementation on various quantum hardware platforms.
Abstract Fault-tolerant protocols and quantum error correction (QEC) are essential to building reliable quantum computers from imperfect components that are vulnerable to errors. Optimizing the resource and time overheads needed to implement QEC is one of the most pressing challenges. Here, we introduce a new topological quantum error-correcting code, the three-dimensional subsystem toric code (3D STC). The 3D STC can be realized with geometrically-local parity checks of weight at most three on the cubic lattice with open boundary conditions. We prove that one round of parity-check measurements suffices to perform reliable QEC with the 3D STC even in the presence of measurement errors. We also propose an efficient single-shot QEC decoding strategy for the 3D STC and numerically estimate the resulting storage threshold against independent bit-flip, phase-flip and measurement errors to bepSTC ≈ 1.045%. Such a high threshold together with local parity-check measurements make the 3D STC particularly appealing for realizing fault-tolerant quantum computing.
For quantum error correction codes the required number of measurement rounds typically increases with the code distance when measurements are faulty. Single-shot error correction allows for an error threshold with only one round of noisy syndrome measurements regardless of the code size. Here we implement single-shot check operators for toric codes. The single-shot checks are constructed by Gaussian elimination following Campbell [Campbell, Quantum Sci. Technol. 4, 025006 (2019)]. The single-shot check operators result in a sustainable threshold at 5.62% for an error model with noisy measurements, outperforming the conventional toric code-check operators with multiple rounds of noisy measurement. The cost of the transformation is nonlocal high-weight stabilizer generators. We then consider a gate-based error model that leads to increased measurement error with stabilizer weight. Here we find no single-shot threshold behavior and instead find the code family will have an optimal code size for a fixed error rate. For this error model the conventional check operators with multiple measurements yields a lower logical error rate.
Quantum computation has shown advantages in several problems over the corresponding classical algorithms. The noisy intermediate-size\n quantum devices with dozens of qubits make it more promising in the\n past decade, as the quantum advantage was demonstrated\n experimentally. Before entering the era of scalable quantum\n computation, one has to resolve the errors in a quantum many-body\n system, which is inevitable due to the environment interaction during\n quantum control processes. The goal of quantum error correction is to\n reduce such errors and increase decoherence time. The most successful candidates of quantum error correction codes are topological codes, especially surface codes, which were discovered by\n Alexei Kitaev. The ordered phase of the 2D\n Ising model on a torus ensures that toric codes are fault-tolerant\n below a critical error probability. Other than the FT threshold,\n the topological codes feature efficient encoding and\n decoding, local measurements, but suffer from asymptotically zero\n code rate. To encode more logical qubits with finite resources, one can loosen the condition on locality and extend to a broader class of quantum\n low-density parity-check (LDPC)codes. There are many known algebraic\n constructions for such codes, but only a precious few of them have\n finite code rates and meet the fault-tolerant condition:\n the stabilizer weight is bounded and the distance scales at least\n logarithmically with the code size. In this thesis, I construct the\n higher-dimensional quantum hypergraph product (HQHP) codes, which\n generalize quantum hypergraph product (QHP) codes and toric codes in\n all dimensions. The HQHP codes projected into a single space gives\n subsystem product codes, which can then be gauge fixed to\n concatenated codes or homological product codes. Those include some\n common CSS codes, like Shor’s codes, Bacon Shor’s codes, and\n subsystem QHP codes. The HQHP codes can be mapped to the tensor\n product of chain complexes, which provides an algebraic framework to\n construct quantum LDPC codes with finite code rates, square root\n distances, FT thresholds and single-shot properties with redundant\n checks. Meanwhile, their rich connection to other codes are very\n instructive and may lead to further optimizations. Regarding the\n remained procedures towards fault-tolerant universal quantum\n computation through quantum LDPC codes, I will discuss the\n fault-tolerant condition for each code, including distance,\n stabilizer weight, decoding, fault-tolerant gates and measurement\n protocols.\n
Floquet quantum error-correcting codes provide an operationally economical route to fault tolerance by dynamically generating stabilizer structures using only two-body Pauli measurements. But while it is well established that stabilizer codes in higher spatial dimensions gain additional levels of intrinsic robustness, higher-dimensional Floquet codes have hitherto been explored only in limited scope. Here we introduce a 3d generalization of a Floquet code whose instantaneous stabilizer group realizes a 3d fermionic toric code, while crucially preserving all three logical qubits throughout the entire measurement sequence. One central ingredient is the identification of a 3d lattice geometry that generalizes the features of the Kekulé lattice underlying the 2d Hastings-Haah code - specifically, a structure where deleting any one edge color yields a two-color subgraph that decomposes into short, closed loops rather than homologically nontrivial chains. This loop property avoids the collapse of logical information that plagues naive sequential two-color measurement schedules on many 3d lattices. Although, for our lattice geometry, a simple 3-round cycle that sequentially measures the three types of parity checks does not expose the full error syndrome set, we show that one can append a measurement sequence to extract the missing syndromes without disturbing the logical subspace. Beyond code design, 3d tricoordinated lattice geometries define a family of 3d monitored Kitaev models, in which random measurements of the non-commuting parity checks give rise to dynamically created entangled phases with nontrivial topology. In discussing the general structure of their underlying phase diagrams and, in particular, the existence of certain quantum critical points, we again make a connection to the general preservation of logical information in time-ordered Floquet protocols.