Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2305.04579 · Physical Review Applied

Adaptive quantum tomography in an indistinct measurement system with superconducting circuits

Hyeok Hwang, JeaKyung Choi, Eunseong Kim

Published Dec 5, 2023• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Adaptive tomography has been widely investigated with the aim of achieving faster state tomography processing of quantum systems. Infidelity of the nearly pure states in a quantum information process generally scales as $O(1/\sqrt{N})$, which requires a large number of statistical ensembles in comparison to the infidelity scaling of $O(1/N)$ for mixed states. One previous report optimized the measurement basis in a photonic qubit system, whose state tomography uses projective measurements, to obtain an infidelity scaling of $O(1/N)$. However, this dramatic improvement cannot be applied to indistinct measurement systems in which two quantum states cannot be distinguished with perfect measurement fidelity. We introduce in this work an optimal measurement basis to achieve fast adaptive quantum state tomography and a minimum magnitude of infidelity in an indistinct measurement system. We expect that the adaptive quantum state tomography protocol can lead to a reduction in the number of required measurements of approximately 33.74% via analytical expectation without changing the $O(1/\sqrt{N})$ scaling. Experimentally, we find a 15.06% measurement number reduction in a superconducting circuit system.

DOI
10.1103/physrevapplied.20.064007

Related papers

Adaptive Quantum Tomography in Weak Measurement with Superconducting Circuits

Hyeok Hwang, JeaKyung Choi, Eunseong Kim

Adaptive tomography has been widely investigated to obtain faster state tomography process for quantum computation. Infidelity [1 − F(ρ,σ)] on nearly pure states in quantum information process scales generally as $O\left( {1/\sqrt N } \right)$, which requires a large number of statistical ensembles in comparison to the infidelity scaling on mixed states of O(1/N). Recently, optimization of a measurement basis in a photonic qubit system, whose state tomography uses projective measurements, reported improved infidelity scaled as O(1/N). However, this dramatic improvement cannot be applied to a weak-value based measurement system, which can be attributed to the fact that one cannot distinguish two quantum states with perfect measurement reliability. We introduce new optimal measurement basis to achieve a fast adaptive quantum state tomography and minimum magnitude of infidelity in this weak measurement system. This novel protocol allows us to accomplish approximately 80% error reduction without changing the scaling of $O\left( {1/\sqrt N } \right)$ in numerical simulations and realize approximately 90% error reduction in superconducting circuit QED experiments.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 1, 2022•0 citations

Adaptive quantum tomography of high-dimensional bipartite systems

G. I. Struchalin, E. V. Kovlakov, Stanislav S. Straupe +1 more

Adaptive measurements have recently been shown to significantly improve the performance of quantum state and process tomography. Adaptive tomography is especially useful in complicated experiments with low outcome generation rate, since it allows one to extract maximal information from a limited amount of data. However, the existing methods either cannot be simply applied to high-dimensional systems or are prohibitively computationally expensive. Here we propose and experimentally implement a tomographic protocol specially designed for the reconstruction of high-dimensional quantum states. The protocol shows qualitative improvement in infidelity scaling with the number of measurements and is fast enough to allow for complete state tomography of states with dimensionality up to 36.

arXiv:1804.05226•Physical Review A•Sep 26, 2018•21 citations

Experimental demonstration of real-time adaptive one-qubit quantum-state tomography

Qi Yin, Li Li, Xiao Xiang +3 more

Quantum-state tomography plays a pivotal role in quantum computation and information processing. To improve the accuracy in estimating an unknown state, carefully designed measurement schemes, such as adopting an adaptive strategy, are necessarily needed, which have gained great interest recently. In this work, based on the proposal of Sugiyama et al. [Phys. Rev. A 85, 052107 (2012)], we experimentally realize an adaptive quantum-state tomography for one qubit in an optical system. Since this scheme gives an analytical solution to the optimal measurement basis problem, our experiment is updated in real time and the infidelity between the real state and the estimated state is tracked with the detected photons. We observe an almost $1/N$ scaling rule of averaged infidelity against the overall number of photons, $N$, in our experiment, which outperforms $1/\sqrt{N}$ of nonadaptive schemes.

Physical Review A•Jan 20, 2017•7 citations

Adaptive Quantum State Tomography Improves Accuracy Quadratically

Dylan H. Mahler, Lee A. Rozema, Ardavan Darabi +3 more

We introduce a simple protocol for adaptive quantum state tomography, which reduces the worst-case infidelity [$1\ensuremath{-}F(\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}},\ensuremath{\rho})$] between the estimate and the true state from $O(1/\sqrt{N})$ to $O(1/N)$. It uses a single adaptation step and just one extra measurement setting. In a linear optical qubit experiment, we demonstrate a full order of magnitude reduction in infidelity (from 0.1% to 0.01%) for a modest number of samples ($N\ensuremath{\approx}3\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{4}$).

arXiv:1303.0436•Physical Review Letters•Oct 29, 2013•147 citations

Adaptive Quantum State Tomography

Phillip Cornett, Albert B. Dinkins V, Kwang‐Cheng Chen

Quantum state tomography (QST), a required technology for the characterization of quantum communication or computing systems, remains an active research area to increase the throughput of any quantum information system. Traditional fixed Pauli-basis routines take many measurement shots to reach the fidelities demanded by quantum calibration, communication, and sensing protocols. To address this problem for a single-qubit system, we propose a novel adaptive QST method that achieves optimally bounded measurements. Using a discretized Bloch sphere, we update a Bayesian posterior after each measurement to select a new measurement axis, determined by expected information gain. Such a method takes advantage of the infinite dimensionality of Hilbert space by including numerous measurement bases - far more than the standard Pauli triad - and uniquely motivating a search-space reduction method to discard unlikely states and uninformative bases, making the high basis count manageable. Our adaptive QST offers tunable convergence controls such that users can adapt according to required speed and accuracy, noise environments, and workload constraints. Large-scale simulations show our method rapidly approaches the best possible fidelity that closely track the Massar-Popescu optimal mean-fidelity curve with standard deviation scaling of$\mathcal {O}(1/N)$. A photonic experiment implementing QST over 13 candidate bases validates our multi-basis theory.

IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Practical adaptive quantum tomography

Christopher Granade, Christopher Ferrie, Steven T. Flammia

We introduce a fast and accurate heuristic for adaptive tomography that addresses many of the limitations of prior methods.Previous approaches were either too computationally intensive or tailored to handle special cases such as single qubits or pure states.By contrast, our approach combines the efficiency of online optimization with generally applicable and well-motivated data-processing techniques.We numerically demonstrate these advantages in several scenarios including mixed states, higher-dimensional systems, and restricted measurements.Quantum information processing (QIP) promises advantages in a wide range of different contexts, including machine learning [2-4], chemistry simulation [5][6][7], and number theory [8,9].As such, the experimental effort to build useful QIP devices has exploded in recent years.In the course of this effort, quantum tomography is a valuable tool for diagnosing and debugging small quantum devices, and has subsequently seen a variety of different advances.In particular, Bayesian approaches to tomography which are especially well suited to utilizing prior information and adapting to changing experimental conditions have developed significantly in recent years [10-13], presenting a useful experimental tool [14][15][16].In this paper we demonstrate the efficiency and accuracy of an adaptive tomography protocol that we call PAQT: practical adaptive quantum tomography.PAQT intelligently selects new measurements based on the outcomes of previous ones [10,[17][18][19][20][21].Adaptivity has been experimentally demonstrated [14,15,[22][23][24][25], but is not currently standard practice.Though adaptivity increases accuracy, the computational costs incurred outweigh that of simply repeating standard measurements many times.The PAQT approach employs a simple heuristic that can be efficiently computed between measurements, even with embedded hardware [26][27][28][29].The algorithm we propose is therefore compatible with modern experimental design and avoids an important limitation of previous approaches.We base our algorithm off of self-guided quantum tomography (SGQT), which treats adaptive tomography as a direct optimization problem rather than a new optimization problem between each measurement [30].Though this affords an efficient and easy to implement adaptive heuristic, SGQT is not without its limitations.It requires assuming that the target state is pure, and it does not return rich region estimates for a state.What PAQT achieves is to effectively combine SGQT with conventional and easily-implemented tomographic estimators, such as the Bayesian particle filter or least-squares fit (LSF) estimators.Under this approach, an experimentalist can collect data using SGQT (even if its assumptions are not met), and then post-process this data using particle filtering or LSF.The benefit of PAQT is two-fold.(1) From the point of view of traditional tomography, it gives an adaptive tomography protocol requiring only modest computational resources, as the bulk of the computational cost is offloaded to post-processing.(2) From the point of view of simulation-based optimization tomography (such as SGQT), it effectively augments the output with region estimation providing a statistically robust quantification of uncertainty.Thus, while we do not explicitly demonstrate that the improved scaling of Ferrie [30] remains in the more general case considered here, PAQT does provide a practical and efficient procedure for performing adaptive quantum tomography with rigorous statistical principles.

arXiv:1605.05039•New Journal of Physics•Sep 29, 2017•70 citations
Adaptive tomography has been widely investigated with the aim of achieving faster state tomography processing of quantum systems. Infidelity of the nearly pure states in a quantum information process generally scales as O(1/N)O(1/\sqrt{N})O(1/N​), which requires a large number of statistical ensembles in comparison to the infidelity scaling of O(1/N)O(1/N)O(1/N) for mixed states. One previous report optimized the measurement basis in a photonic qubit system, whose state tomography uses projective measurements, to obtain an infidelity scaling of O(1/N)O(1/N)O(1/N). However, this dramatic improvement cannot be applied to indistinct measurement systems in which two quantum states cannot be distinguished with perfect measurement fidelity. We introduce in this work an optimal measurement basis to achieve fast adaptive quantum state tomography and a minimum magnitude of infidelity in an indistinct measurement system. We expect that the adaptive quantum state tomography protocol can lead to a reduction in the number of required measurements of approximately 33.74% via analytical expectation without changing the O(1/N)O(1/\sqrt{N})O(1/N​) scaling. Experimentally, we find a 15.06% measurement number reduction in a superconducting circuit system.
Adaptive tomography has been widely investigated to obtain faster state tomography process for quantum computation. Infidelity [1 − F(ρ,σ)] on nearly pure states in quantum information process scales generally as O(1/N)O\left( {1/\sqrt N } \right)O(1/N​), which requires a large number of statistical ensembles in comparison to the infidelity scaling on mixed states of O(1/N). Recently, optimization of a measurement basis in a photonic qubit system, whose state tomography uses projective measurements, reported improved infidelity scaled as O(1/N). However, this dramatic improvement cannot be applied to a weak-value based measurement system, which can be attributed to the fact that one cannot distinguish two quantum states with perfect measurement reliability. We introduce new optimal measurement basis to achieve a fast adaptive quantum state tomography and minimum magnitude of infidelity in this weak measurement system. This novel protocol allows us to accomplish approximately 80% error reduction without changing the scaling of O(1/N)O\left( {1/\sqrt N } \right)O(1/N​) in numerical simulations and realize approximately 90% error reduction in superconducting circuit QED experiments.
Adaptive measurements have recently been shown to significantly improve the performance of quantum state and process tomography. Adaptive tomography is especially useful in complicated experiments with low outcome generation rate, since it allows one to extract maximal information from a limited amount of data. However, the existing methods either cannot be simply applied to high-dimensional systems or are prohibitively computationally expensive. Here we propose and experimentally implement a tomographic protocol specially designed for the reconstruction of high-dimensional quantum states. The protocol shows qualitative improvement in infidelity scaling with the number of measurements and is fast enough to allow for complete state tomography of states with dimensionality up to 36.
Quantum-state tomography plays a pivotal role in quantum computation and information processing. To improve the accuracy in estimating an unknown state, carefully designed measurement schemes, such as adopting an adaptive strategy, are necessarily needed, which have gained great interest recently. In this work, based on the proposal of Sugiyama et al. [Phys. Rev. A 85, 052107 (2012)], we experimentally realize an adaptive quantum-state tomography for one qubit in an optical system. Since this scheme gives an analytical solution to the optimal measurement basis problem, our experiment is updated in real time and the infidelity between the real state and the estimated state is tracked with the detected photons. We observe an almost 1/N1/N1/N scaling rule of averaged infidelity against the overall number of photons, NNN, in our experiment, which outperforms 1/N1/\sqrt{N}1/N​ of nonadaptive schemes.
We introduce a simple protocol for adaptive quantum state tomography, which reduces the worst-case infidelity [$1\ensuremath{-}F(\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}},\ensuremath{\rho})$] between the estimate and the true state from O(1/N)O(1/\sqrt{N})O(1/N​) to O(1/N)O(1/N)O(1/N). It uses a single adaptation step and just one extra measurement setting. In a linear optical qubit experiment, we demonstrate a full order of magnitude reduction in infidelity (from 0.1% to 0.01%) for a modest number of samples ($N\ensuremath{\approx}3\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{4}$).
Quantum state tomography (QST), a required technology for the characterization of quantum communication or computing systems, remains an active research area to increase the throughput of any quantum information system. Traditional fixed Pauli-basis routines take many measurement shots to reach the fidelities demanded by quantum calibration, communication, and sensing protocols. To address this problem for a single-qubit system, we propose a novel adaptive QST method that achieves optimally bounded measurements. Using a discretized Bloch sphere, we update a Bayesian posterior after each measurement to select a new measurement axis, determined by expected information gain. Such a method takes advantage of the infinite dimensionality of Hilbert space by including numerous measurement bases - far more than the standard Pauli triad - and uniquely motivating a search-space reduction method to discard unlikely states and uninformative bases, making the high basis count manageable. Our adaptive QST offers tunable convergence controls such that users can adapt according to required speed and accuracy, noise environments, and workload constraints. Large-scale simulations show our method rapidly approaches the best possible fidelity that closely track the Massar-Popescu optimal mean-fidelity curve with standard deviation scaling ofO(1/N)\mathcal {O}(1/N)O(1/N). A photonic experiment implementing QST over 13 candidate bases validates our multi-basis theory.
We introduce a fast and accurate heuristic for adaptive tomography that addresses many of the limitations of prior methods.Previous approaches were either too computationally intensive or tailored to handle special cases such as single qubits or pure states.By contrast, our approach combines the efficiency of online optimization with generally applicable and well-motivated data-processing techniques.We numerically demonstrate these advantages in several scenarios including mixed states, higher-dimensional systems, and restricted measurements.Quantum information processing (QIP) promises advantages in a wide range of different contexts, including machine learning [2-4], chemistry simulation [5][6][7], and number theory [8,9].As such, the experimental effort to build useful QIP devices has exploded in recent years.In the course of this effort, quantum tomography is a valuable tool for diagnosing and debugging small quantum devices, and has subsequently seen a variety of different advances.In particular, Bayesian approaches to tomography which are especially well suited to utilizing prior information and adapting to changing experimental conditions have developed significantly in recent years [10-13], presenting a useful experimental tool [14][15][16].In this paper we demonstrate the efficiency and accuracy of an adaptive tomography protocol that we call PAQT: practical adaptive quantum tomography.PAQT intelligently selects new measurements based on the outcomes of previous ones [10,[17][18][19][20][21].Adaptivity has been experimentally demonstrated [14,15,[22][23][24][25], but is not currently standard practice.Though adaptivity increases accuracy, the computational costs incurred outweigh that of simply repeating standard measurements many times.The PAQT approach employs a simple heuristic that can be efficiently computed between measurements, even with embedded hardware [26][27][28][29].The algorithm we propose is therefore compatible with modern experimental design and avoids an important limitation of previous approaches.We base our algorithm off of self-guided quantum tomography (SGQT), which treats adaptive tomography as a direct optimization problem rather than a new optimization problem between each measurement [30].Though this affords an efficient and easy to implement adaptive heuristic, SGQT is not without its limitations.It requires assuming that the target state is pure, and it does not return rich region estimates for a state.What PAQT achieves is to effectively combine SGQT with conventional and easily-implemented tomographic estimators, such as the Bayesian particle filter or least-squares fit (LSF) estimators.Under this approach, an experimentalist can collect data using SGQT (even if its assumptions are not met), and then post-process this data using particle filtering or LSF.The benefit of PAQT is two-fold.(1) From the point of view of traditional tomography, it gives an adaptive tomography protocol requiring only modest computational resources, as the bulk of the computational cost is offloaded to post-processing.(2) From the point of view of simulation-based optimization tomography (such as SGQT), it effectively augments the output with region estimation providing a statistically robust quantification of uncertainty.Thus, while we do not explicitly demonstrate that the improved scaling of Ferrie [30] remains in the more general case considered here, PAQT does provide a practical and efficient procedure for performing adaptive quantum tomography with rigorous statistical principles.