Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2305.02117 · Scientific Reports

Asymmetric quantum decision-making

Honoka Shiratori, Hiroaki Shinkawa, André Röhm, Nicolas Chauvet, Etsuo Segawa, Jonathan Laurent, Guillaume Bachelier, Tomoki Yamagami, Ryoichi Horisaki, Makoto Naruse

Published Sep 5, 2023• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Collective decision-making plays a crucial role in information and communication systems. However, decision conflicts among agents often impede the maximization of potential utilities within the system. Quantum processes have shown promise in achieving conflict-free joint decisions between two agents through the entanglement of photons or the quantum interference of orbital angular momentum (OAM). Nonetheless, previous studies have shown symmetric resultant joint decisions, which, while preserving equality, fail to address disparities. In light of global challenges such as ethics and equity, it is imperative for decision-making systems to not only maintain existing equality but also address and resolve disparities. In this study, we investigate asymmetric collective decision-making theoretically and numerically using quantum interference of photons carrying OAM or entangled photons. We successfully demonstrate the realization of asymmetry; however, it should be noted that a certain degree of photon loss is inevitable in the proposed models. We also provide an analytical formulation for determining the available range of asymmetry and describe a method for obtaining the desired degree of asymmetry.

DOI
10.1038/s41598-023-41715-z

Related papers

Conflict-free collective stochastic decision making by orbital angular momentum of photons through quantum interference

Takashi Amakasu, Nicolas Chauvet, Guillaume Bachelier +3 more

In recent cross-disciplinary studies involving both optics and computing, single-photon-based decision-making has been demonstrated by utilizing the wave-particle duality of light to solve multi-armed bandit problems. Furthermore, entangled-photon-based decision-making has managed to solve a competitive multi-armed bandit problem in such a way that conflicts of decisions among players are avoided while ensuring equality. However, as these studies are based on the polarization of light, the number of available choices is limited to two, corresponding to two orthogonal polarization states. Here we propose a scalable principle to solve competitive decision-making situations by using the orbital angular momentum of photons based on its high dimensionality, which theoretically allows an unlimited number of arms. Moreover, by extending the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect to more than two states, we theoretically establish an experimental configuration able to generate multi-photon states with orbital angular momentum and conditions that provide conflict-free selections at every turn. We numerically examine total rewards regarding three-armed bandit problems, for which the proposed strategy accomplishes almost the theoretical maximum, which is greater than a conventional mixed strategy intending to realize Nash equilibrium. This is thanks to the quantum interference effect that achieves no-conflict selections, even in the exploring phase to find the best arms.

arXiv:2107.00877•Scientific Reports•Oct 26, 2021•16 citations

Conflict-Free Joint Sampling for Preference Satisfaction through Quantum Interference

Hiroaki Shinkawa, Nicolas Chauvet, André Röhm +4 more

Collective decision making is vital for recent information and communications technologies. In our previous research, we mathematically derived conflict-free joint decision making that optimally satisfies players' probabilistic preference profiles. However, two problems exist regarding the optimal joint decision-making method. First, as the number of choices increases, the computational cost of calculating the optimal joint selection probability matrix explodes. Second, to derive the optimal joint selection probability matrix, all players must disclose their probabilistic preferences. Now, it is noteworthy that explicit calculation of the joint probability distribution is not necessarily needed; what is necessary for collective decisions is sampling. This study examines several sampling methods that converge to heuristic joint selection probability matrices that satisfy players' preferences. We show that they can significantly reduce the above problems of computational cost and confidentiality. We analyze the probability distribution each of the sampling methods converges to, as well as the computational cost required and the confidentiality secured. In particular, we introduce two conflict-free joint sampling methods through the quantum interference of photons. The first system allows the players to hide their choices while satisfying the players' preferences almost perfectly when they have the same preferences. The second system, where the physical nature of light replaces the expensive computational cost, also conceals their choices under the assumption that they have a trusted third party.

arXiv:2208.03082•Physical Review Applied•Dec 7, 2022•5 citations

Entanglement of very high orbital angular momentum

Robert Fickler, Peizhe Li, Radek Łapkiewicz +5 more

Orbital angular momentum (OAM) of single photons represents a new optical degree of freedom for the entanglement of photons [1,2]. One physical realization of OAM carrying light beams are the so called Laguerre-Gaussian modes of light with the required helical phase structure. One big advantage over the well known polarization degree of freedom is the possibility of realizing entanglement between two photons with very high quantum numbers. However, the creation of photonic OAM entanglement using the widely used spontaneous parametric downconversion process is limited by the strongly reduced efficiency for higher momenta [3]. We have realized a novel method to create entanglement between two photons with a very high difference in their OAM quantum number and momentum respectively. Furthermore we have explored hybrid entanglement of photons in the OAM and polarization degree of freedom.

Frontiers in Optics•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Quantum entanglement of orbital angular momentum

Martin P. van Exter, E. R. Eliel, J. P. Woerdman

Introduction In this chapter, we will be concerned with entangled states of light. Historically, quantum states of light, i.e., photons, have played a dominant role in the experimental study of quantum entanglement. For instance, the first Bell tests and the first realizations of quantum teleportation were performed using two-dimensional polarization-entangled twophoton states [3]. From an experimental point of view these states are readily prepared and manipulated using conventional polarization optics. Recently, however, both theoretical and experimental efforts have shifted towards entanglement in more than two modes , which is often referred to as high-dimensional entanglement. This is much richer than two-dimensional entanglement, as is, for instance, reflected in stronger violations of various measures of nonlocality which reveal the complexity of high-dimensional Hilbert spaces [4–7]. Also, from an applications perspective, it promises a larger channel capacity [8, 9] and improved security for quantum communication [10, 11]. There are several ways to implement high-dimensional two-photon entanglement. One can exploit the temporal [12], frequency [13], or spatial [14–18] degrees of freedom of the optical field. A promising way to implement high-dimensional two-photon entanglement is to use the orbital-angular-momentum (OAM) degree of freedom of light. Light beams that carry OAM have a helical wavefront that spirals around the optical axis during propagation [19]. The winding number m , which characterizes the OAM eigenmodes, can adopt any integer value between −∞ and ∞; since all coaxial OAM modes are orthogonal they can thus span a very high-dimensional Hilbert space.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 8, 2012•2 citations

The evolution of OAM-entanglement between two qutrits in turbulence

Alpha Hamadou Ibrahim, Filippus Stefanus Roux, Sandeep K. Goyal +3 more

The use of Higher-dimensional entangled systems have been proved to signi cantly improve many quantum in- formation tasks. For instance, it has been shown that the use of higher-dimensional entangled systems provides a higher information capacity and an increased security in quantum cryptography. The orbital angular momentum (OAM) state of light is a potential candidate for the implementation of higher-dimensional entangled systems and has thus been considered for free-space quantum communication. However, atmospheric turbulence severely affects the OAM state of photons. In this work, we study the evolution of the OAM entanglement between two qutrits (three-dimensional quantum systems) in atmospheric turbulence both numerically and experimentally. The qutrits are photons entangled in their orbital angular momentum (OAM) states generated by spontaneous parametric down conversion. We propagate one of the photons through turbulence while leaving the other undis- turbed. To compare our results with previous work, we simulate the turbulent atmosphere with a single phase screen based on the Kolmogorov theory of turbulence and we use the tangle to quantify the amount of entangle- ment between the two qutrits. We compare our results with the evolution of OAM entanglement between two qubits.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Feb 25, 2014•0 citations

Increasing the orbital angular momentum bandwidth of entangled photons

Jacquiline Romero, Daniel Giovannini, Sonja Franke‐Arnold +2 more

The bandwidth of any communication system, classical or quantum, is limited by the number of orthogonal states in which the information can be encoded. Quantum key distribution systems available commercially rely on the two-dimensional polarisation state of photons. Quantum computation has also been largely designed on the basis of qubits. However, a photon is endowed with other degrees of freedom, such as orbital angular momentum (OAM). OAM is an attractive basis to be used for quantum information because it is discrete and theoretically infinite-dimensional. This promises a higher information capacity per photon which can lead to more complex quantum computation protocols and more security and robustness for quantum cryptography. Entanglement of OAM naturally arises from spontaneous parametric down-conversion (SPDC). However, any practical experiment utilising the innately high-dimensional entanglement of the orbital angular momentum (OAM) state space of photons is subject to the modal capacity of the detection system. Only a finite subset of this space is accessible experimentally. Given such a constraint, we show that the number of measured, entangled OAM modes in photon pairs generated by SPDC can be increased by tuning the phase-matching conditions in the SPDC process. We achieve this by tuning the orientation angle of the nonlinear crystal generating the entangled photons.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Nov 19, 2012•0 citations
Collective decision-making plays a crucial role in information and communication systems. However, decision conflicts among agents often impede the maximization of potential utilities within the system. Quantum processes have shown promise in achieving conflict-free joint decisions between two agents through the entanglement of photons or the quantum interference of orbital angular momentum (OAM). Nonetheless, previous studies have shown symmetric resultant joint decisions, which, while preserving equality, fail to address disparities. In light of global challenges such as ethics and equity, it is imperative for decision-making systems to not only maintain existing equality but also address and resolve disparities. In this study, we investigate asymmetric collective decision-making theoretically and numerically using quantum interference of photons carrying OAM or entangled photons. We successfully demonstrate the realization of asymmetry; however, it should be noted that a certain degree of photon loss is inevitable in the proposed models. We also provide an analytical formulation for determining the available range of asymmetry and describe a method for obtaining the desired degree of asymmetry.
In recent cross-disciplinary studies involving both optics and computing, single-photon-based decision-making has been demonstrated by utilizing the wave-particle duality of light to solve multi-armed bandit problems. Furthermore, entangled-photon-based decision-making has managed to solve a competitive multi-armed bandit problem in such a way that conflicts of decisions among players are avoided while ensuring equality. However, as these studies are based on the polarization of light, the number of available choices is limited to two, corresponding to two orthogonal polarization states. Here we propose a scalable principle to solve competitive decision-making situations by using the orbital angular momentum of photons based on its high dimensionality, which theoretically allows an unlimited number of arms. Moreover, by extending the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect to more than two states, we theoretically establish an experimental configuration able to generate multi-photon states with orbital angular momentum and conditions that provide conflict-free selections at every turn. We numerically examine total rewards regarding three-armed bandit problems, for which the proposed strategy accomplishes almost the theoretical maximum, which is greater than a conventional mixed strategy intending to realize Nash equilibrium. This is thanks to the quantum interference effect that achieves no-conflict selections, even in the exploring phase to find the best arms.
Collective decision making is vital for recent information and communications technologies. In our previous research, we mathematically derived conflict-free joint decision making that optimally satisfies players' probabilistic preference profiles. However, two problems exist regarding the optimal joint decision-making method. First, as the number of choices increases, the computational cost of calculating the optimal joint selection probability matrix explodes. Second, to derive the optimal joint selection probability matrix, all players must disclose their probabilistic preferences. Now, it is noteworthy that explicit calculation of the joint probability distribution is not necessarily needed; what is necessary for collective decisions is sampling. This study examines several sampling methods that converge to heuristic joint selection probability matrices that satisfy players' preferences. We show that they can significantly reduce the above problems of computational cost and confidentiality. We analyze the probability distribution each of the sampling methods converges to, as well as the computational cost required and the confidentiality secured. In particular, we introduce two conflict-free joint sampling methods through the quantum interference of photons. The first system allows the players to hide their choices while satisfying the players' preferences almost perfectly when they have the same preferences. The second system, where the physical nature of light replaces the expensive computational cost, also conceals their choices under the assumption that they have a trusted third party.
Orbital angular momentum (OAM) of single photons represents a new optical degree of freedom for the entanglement of photons [1,2]. One physical realization of OAM carrying light beams are the so called Laguerre-Gaussian modes of light with the required helical phase structure. One big advantage over the well known polarization degree of freedom is the possibility of realizing entanglement between two photons with very high quantum numbers. However, the creation of photonic OAM entanglement using the widely used spontaneous parametric downconversion process is limited by the strongly reduced efficiency for higher momenta [3]. We have realized a novel method to create entanglement between two photons with a very high difference in their OAM quantum number and momentum respectively. Furthermore we have explored hybrid entanglement of photons in the OAM and polarization degree of freedom.
Introduction In this chapter, we will be concerned with entangled states of light. Historically, quantum states of light, i.e., photons, have played a dominant role in the experimental study of quantum entanglement. For instance, the first Bell tests and the first realizations of quantum teleportation were performed using two-dimensional polarization-entangled twophoton states [3]. From an experimental point of view these states are readily prepared and manipulated using conventional polarization optics. Recently, however, both theoretical and experimental efforts have shifted towards entanglement in more than two modes , which is often referred to as high-dimensional entanglement. This is much richer than two-dimensional entanglement, as is, for instance, reflected in stronger violations of various measures of nonlocality which reveal the complexity of high-dimensional Hilbert spaces [4–7]. Also, from an applications perspective, it promises a larger channel capacity [8, 9] and improved security for quantum communication [10, 11]. There are several ways to implement high-dimensional two-photon entanglement. One can exploit the temporal [12], frequency [13], or spatial [14–18] degrees of freedom of the optical field. A promising way to implement high-dimensional two-photon entanglement is to use the orbital-angular-momentum (OAM) degree of freedom of light. Light beams that carry OAM have a helical wavefront that spirals around the optical axis during propagation [19]. The winding number m , which characterizes the OAM eigenmodes, can adopt any integer value between −∞ and ∞; since all coaxial OAM modes are orthogonal they can thus span a very high-dimensional Hilbert space.
The use of Higher-dimensional entangled systems have been proved to signi cantly improve many quantum in- formation tasks. For instance, it has been shown that the use of higher-dimensional entangled systems provides a higher information capacity and an increased security in quantum cryptography. The orbital angular momentum (OAM) state of light is a potential candidate for the implementation of higher-dimensional entangled systems and has thus been considered for free-space quantum communication. However, atmospheric turbulence severely affects the OAM state of photons. In this work, we study the evolution of the OAM entanglement between two qutrits (three-dimensional quantum systems) in atmospheric turbulence both numerically and experimentally. The qutrits are photons entangled in their orbital angular momentum (OAM) states generated by spontaneous parametric down conversion. We propagate one of the photons through turbulence while leaving the other undis- turbed. To compare our results with previous work, we simulate the turbulent atmosphere with a single phase screen based on the Kolmogorov theory of turbulence and we use the tangle to quantify the amount of entangle- ment between the two qutrits. We compare our results with the evolution of OAM entanglement between two qubits.
The bandwidth of any communication system, classical or quantum, is limited by the number of orthogonal states in which the information can be encoded. Quantum key distribution systems available commercially rely on the two-dimensional polarisation state of photons. Quantum computation has also been largely designed on the basis of qubits. However, a photon is endowed with other degrees of freedom, such as orbital angular momentum (OAM). OAM is an attractive basis to be used for quantum information because it is discrete and theoretically infinite-dimensional. This promises a higher information capacity per photon which can lead to more complex quantum computation protocols and more security and robustness for quantum cryptography. Entanglement of OAM naturally arises from spontaneous parametric down-conversion (SPDC). However, any practical experiment utilising the innately high-dimensional entanglement of the orbital angular momentum (OAM) state space of photons is subject to the modal capacity of the detection system. Only a finite subset of this space is accessible experimentally. Given such a constraint, we show that the number of measured, entangled OAM modes in photon pairs generated by SPDC can be increased by tuning the phase-matching conditions in the SPDC process. We achieve this by tuning the orientation angle of the nonlinear crystal generating the entangled photons.