Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2305.02002 · Physical Review A

Fundamental limits on quantum cloning from the no-signaling principle

Yanglin Hu, Marco Tomamichel

Published Feb 16, 2024• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The no-cloning theorem is a cornerstone of quantum cryptography. Here we generalize and rederive in a unified framework various upper bounds on the maximum achievable fidelity of probabilistic and deterministic cloning machines. Building on ideas by Gisin [Phys. Lett. A 242, 1 (1998)], our result follows from the fact that remote state preparation is possible and the no-signaling principle holds. We apply our general theorem to several subsets of states that are of interest in quantum cryptography.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.109.022221

Related papers

No-signaling bounds for quantum cloning and metrology

Pavel Sekatski, Michalis Skotiniotis, Wolfgang Dür

The impossibility of superluminal communication is a fundamental principle of physics. Here we show that this principle underpins the performance of several fundamental tasks in quantum information processing and quantum metrology. In particular, we derive tight no-signaling bounds for probabilistic cloning and super-replication that coincide with the corresponding optimal achievable fidelities and rates known. In the context of quantum metrology, we derive the Heisenberg limit from the no-signaling principle for certain scenarios including reference frame alignment and maximum likelihood state estimation. We elaborate on the equivalence of assymptotic phase-covariant cloning and phase estimation for different figures of merit.

arXiv:1412.3361•Physical Review A•Aug 28, 2015•6 citations

High-dimensional quantum cloning and applications to quantum hacking

Frédéric Bouchard, Robert Fickler, Robert W. Boyd +1 more

Attempts at cloning a quantum system result in the introduction of imperfections in the state of the copies. This is a consequence of the no-cloning theorem, which is a fundamental law of quantum physics and the backbone of security for quantum communications. Although perfect copies are prohibited, a quantum state may be copied with maximal accuracy via various optimal cloning schemes. Optimal quantum cloning, which lies at the border of the physical limit imposed by the no-signaling theorem and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, has been experimentally realized for low-dimensional photonic states. However, an increase in the dimensionality of quantum systems is greatly beneficial to quantum computation and communication protocols. Nonetheless, no experimental demonstration of optimal cloning machines has hitherto been shown for high-dimensional quantum systems. We perform optimal cloning of high-dimensional photonic states by means of the symmetrization method. We show the universality of our technique by conducting cloning of numerous arbitrary input states and fully characterize our cloning machine by performing quantum state tomography on cloned photons. In addition, a cloning attack on a Bennett and Brassard (BB84) quantum key distribution protocol is experimentally demonstrated to reveal the robustness of high-dimensional states in quantum cryptography.

arXiv:1608.04396•Science Advances•Feb 3, 2017•144 citations

Universal quantum cloning beyond noncontextual theory

Min Namkung, Hyang-Tag Lim

Quantum theory fundamentally forbids the perfect copying of an arbitrary unknown quantum state, according to a principle known as the no-cloning theorem. Nevertheless, it is possible to construct a deterministic quantum map that produces multiple approximate copies of an unknown quantum state. This task is referred to as universal quantum cloning, further facilitating numerous quantum technologies such as quantum cryptography and quantum communication. In this work, we theoretically verify that the universal quantum cloning cannot be realized within a noncontextual theory, highlighting its intrinsically nonclassical nature. Our verification first {focuses on revealing that} $1\rightarrow2$ cloning scenario {is fully contextual}, and {further covers general examples to observe the contextual behavior of} $N\rightarrow M$ scenario. We believe that our results regarding quantum cloning serve a key role for understanding both quantum foundation and application.

quant-pharXiv:2607.05959•Jul 8, 2026•0 citations

Approximate Quantum Cloning

Dagmar Bruß, Chiara Macchiavello

This chapter describes approximate cloning transformations for different sets of input states and analyzes the corresponding optimal qualities in terms of fidelity. The topic of approximate quantum cloning is mainly of fundamental interest: for example, limits on the cloning fidelity imply limits on the security in quantum cryptography. One can learn about differences between classical and quantum information processing by studying cloning. It is interesting to ask whether a cloning process be used as a tool in quantum information processing. The chapter also reviews the no-cloning theorem and discusses the reasons for the impossibility of perfect quantum cloning. One of the reasons includes the impossibility of superluminal signaling. This arises in a relativistic theory and also in quantum mechanics, due to linearity of any physical transformation. The chapter concludes by focusing on experimental quantum cloning.

Wiley eBooks•Apr 18, 2016•2 citations

A principle behind no-cloning and no-imprinting theorems

Masato Koashi

Consider a situation in which a quantum system is secretly prepared in a state chosen from the known set of n states. We present a principle that gives a definite distinction between the operations that preserve the marginal states of the system and those that do not. Many types of no-cloning and no-imprinting conditions for mixed states and entangled states can easily be derived from this principle. The principle also gives a unified view on how various schemes of quantum cryptography work.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2001•0 citations

Deduction of an upper bound on the success probability of port-based teleportation from the no-cloning theorem and the no-signaling principle

Damián Pitalúa-García

In port-based teleportation, Alice teleports an unknown quantum state $|\ensuremath{\psi}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ to one of $N$ ports at Bob's site. Alice applies a measurement and sends Bob the outcome $k$. Bob only needs to select the $k$th port in order to obtain $|\ensuremath{\psi}\ensuremath{\rangle}$. We present a theorem in the spirit of the no-cloning theorem, which says that it is impossible to extract any information from an unknown quantum state if only a single copy of it is provided and if the state remains unchanged. We use this theorem and the no-signaling principle to prove an upper bound on the success probability of port-based teleportation.

arXiv:1206.4836•Physical Review A•Apr 12, 2013•7 citations
The no-cloning theorem is a cornerstone of quantum cryptography. Here we generalize and rederive in a unified framework various upper bounds on the maximum achievable fidelity of probabilistic and deterministic cloning machines. Building on ideas by Gisin [Phys. Lett. A 242, 1 (1998)], our result follows from the fact that remote state preparation is possible and the no-signaling principle holds. We apply our general theorem to several subsets of states that are of interest in quantum cryptography.
The impossibility of superluminal communication is a fundamental principle of physics. Here we show that this principle underpins the performance of several fundamental tasks in quantum information processing and quantum metrology. In particular, we derive tight no-signaling bounds for probabilistic cloning and super-replication that coincide with the corresponding optimal achievable fidelities and rates known. In the context of quantum metrology, we derive the Heisenberg limit from the no-signaling principle for certain scenarios including reference frame alignment and maximum likelihood state estimation. We elaborate on the equivalence of assymptotic phase-covariant cloning and phase estimation for different figures of merit.
Attempts at cloning a quantum system result in the introduction of imperfections in the state of the copies. This is a consequence of the no-cloning theorem, which is a fundamental law of quantum physics and the backbone of security for quantum communications. Although perfect copies are prohibited, a quantum state may be copied with maximal accuracy via various optimal cloning schemes. Optimal quantum cloning, which lies at the border of the physical limit imposed by the no-signaling theorem and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, has been experimentally realized for low-dimensional photonic states. However, an increase in the dimensionality of quantum systems is greatly beneficial to quantum computation and communication protocols. Nonetheless, no experimental demonstration of optimal cloning machines has hitherto been shown for high-dimensional quantum systems. We perform optimal cloning of high-dimensional photonic states by means of the symmetrization method. We show the universality of our technique by conducting cloning of numerous arbitrary input states and fully characterize our cloning machine by performing quantum state tomography on cloned photons. In addition, a cloning attack on a Bennett and Brassard (BB84) quantum key distribution protocol is experimentally demonstrated to reveal the robustness of high-dimensional states in quantum cryptography.
Quantum theory fundamentally forbids the perfect copying of an arbitrary unknown quantum state, according to a principle known as the no-cloning theorem. Nevertheless, it is possible to construct a deterministic quantum map that produces multiple approximate copies of an unknown quantum state. This task is referred to as universal quantum cloning, further facilitating numerous quantum technologies such as quantum cryptography and quantum communication. In this work, we theoretically verify that the universal quantum cloning cannot be realized within a noncontextual theory, highlighting its intrinsically nonclassical nature. Our verification first {focuses on revealing that} 1→21\rightarrow21→2 cloning scenario {is fully contextual}, and {further covers general examples to observe the contextual behavior of} N→MN\rightarrow MN→M scenario. We believe that our results regarding quantum cloning serve a key role for understanding both quantum foundation and application.
This chapter describes approximate cloning transformations for different sets of input states and analyzes the corresponding optimal qualities in terms of fidelity. The topic of approximate quantum cloning is mainly of fundamental interest: for example, limits on the cloning fidelity imply limits on the security in quantum cryptography. One can learn about differences between classical and quantum information processing by studying cloning. It is interesting to ask whether a cloning process be used as a tool in quantum information processing. The chapter also reviews the no-cloning theorem and discusses the reasons for the impossibility of perfect quantum cloning. One of the reasons includes the impossibility of superluminal signaling. This arises in a relativistic theory and also in quantum mechanics, due to linearity of any physical transformation. The chapter concludes by focusing on experimental quantum cloning.
In port-based teleportation, Alice teleports an unknown quantum state $|\ensuremath{\psi}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ to one of NNN ports at Bob's site. Alice applies a measurement and sends Bob the outcome kkk. Bob only needs to select the kkkth port in order to obtain $|\ensuremath{\psi}\ensuremath{\rangle}$. We present a theorem in the spirit of the no-cloning theorem, which says that it is impossible to extract any information from an unknown quantum state if only a single copy of it is provided and if the state remains unchanged. We use this theorem and the no-signaling principle to prove an upper bound on the success probability of port-based teleportation.