Given a vector-space $~V~$ which is the tensor product of vector-spaces $A$ and $B$, we reconstruct $A$ and $B$ from the family of simple tensors $a{\otimes}b$ within $V$. In an application to quantum mechanics, one would be reconstructing the component subsystems of a composite system from its unentangled pure states. Our constructions can be viewed as instances of the category-theoretic concepts of functor and natural isomorphism, and we use this to bring out the intuition behind these concepts, and also to critique them. Also presented are some suggestions for further work, including a hoped-for application to entanglement entropy in quantum field theory.
Given a vector-space V which is the tensor product of vector-spaces A and B, we reconstruct A and B from the family of simple tensors a⊗b within V. In an application to quantum mechanics, one would be reconstructing the component subsystems of a composite system from its unentangled pure states. Our constructions can be viewed as instances of the category-theoretic concepts of functor and natural isomorphism, and we use this to bring out the intuition behind these concepts, and also to critique them. Also presented are some suggestions for further work, including a hoped-for application to entanglement entropy in quantum field theory.
A recent general model of entanglement, [5], that goes much beyond the usual one based on tensor products of vector spaces is further developed here. It is shown that the usual Cartesian product can be seen as two extreme particular instances of non-entanglement. Also the recent approach to entanglement in [8] is incorporated in the general model in [5]. The idea pursued is that entanglement is by now far too important a phenomenon in Quantum Mechanics, in order to be left confined to its present exclusive modelling by tensor products. Once this is realized, it turns out that one can quite easily de-entangle entanglement from tensor products, and in fact, one can do so in a large variety of ways. Within such general settings the issue of entanglement becomes connected with the issue of "System versus Subsystem" in General Systems Theory, where synthesizing subsystems into a system may often be less difficult than identifying subsystems in a system.
One of the crucial differences between mathematical models of classical and quantum mechanics is the use of the tensor product of the state spaces of subsystems as the state space of the corresponding composite system. (To describe an ensemble of classical composite systems one uses random variables taking values in the Cartesian product of the state spaces of subsystems.) We show that, nevertheless, it is possible to establish a natural correspondence between the classical and quantum probabilistic descriptions of composite systems. Quantum averages for composite systems (including entangled) can be represented as averages with respect to classical random fields. It is essentially what Albert Einstein was dreamed of. Quantum mechanics is represented as classical statistical mechanics with infinite-dimensional phase space. While the mathematical construction is completely rigorous, its physical interpretation is a complicated problem (which will not be discussed in this paper).
Mathematical foundation of the novel concept of quantum tensor product by Zanardi et al is rigorously established. The concept of relative quantum entanglement is naturally introduced and its meaning is made clear both mathematically and physically. For a finite or an infinite dimensional vector space W the so called tensor product partition (TPP) is introduced on End(W), the set of endmorphisms of W, and a natural correspondence is constructed between the set of TPP's of End(W) and the set of tensor product structures (TPS's) of W. As a byproduct, it is shown that an arbitrarily given wave function belonging to an n-dimensional Hilbert space, n being not a prime number, can be interpreted as a separable state with respect to some man-made TPS, and thus a quantum entangled state of a many-body system with respect to the "God-given" TPS can be regarded as a quantum state without entanglement in some sense. The concept of standard set of observables is also introduced to probe the underlying structure of the object TPP and to establish its connection with practical physical measurement.
In Section 2.4 we learned that a composite quantum system, composed of two subsystems A and B , is associated with a tensor product space HA ? HB . Composite quantum systems have already played an important role in many instances in this text, especially in open systems and measurement models. In this chapter we dive deeper into tensor product spaces, discovering some strange implications of the quantum theory of composite quantum systems. As a result of its tensor product structure, quantum theory has embedded into it the phenomenon of entanglement , which is often seen as the foremost quantum feature. As early as in 1935 it puzzled Erwin Schrödinger, who introduced the German term Verschränkung [127] and Albert Einstein, who, together with Boris Podolski and Nathan Rosen, used the specific example of an entangled state to argue that quantum theory is incomplete [58]. In the 1960s John Bell demonstrated that the consequences of entanglement are incompatible with the Einstein– Podolsky–Rosen model of local realism [11], [12]. In recent years entanglement has been recognized as the resource for quantum information processing. Nowadays entanglement theory is a highly developed subject, and we can present only the mathematical basics. For the reader with a deeper interest in entanglement we recommend the recent reviews by Horodecki et al . [80] and Plenio et al . [118], which also cover the quantum information aspects of entanglement. To simplify our discussion we will assume that the Hilbert spaces are finite dimensional.
In the framework of quantum mechanics over a quadratic extension of the ultrametric field of p-adic numbers, we introduce a notion of tensor product of p-adic Hilbert spaces. To this end, following a standard approach, we first consider the algebraic tensor product of p-adic Hilbert spaces. We next define a suitable norm on this linear space. It turns out that, in the p-adic framework, this norm is the analogue of the projective norm associated with the tensor product of real or complex normed spaces. Eventually, by metrically completing the resulting p-adic normed space, and equipping it with a suitable inner product, we obtain the tensor product of p-adic Hilbert spaces. That this is indeed the correct p-adic counterpart of the tensor product of complex Hilbert spaces is also certified by establishing a natural isomorphism between this p-adic Hilbert space and the corresponding Hilbert–Schmidt class. Since the notion of subspace of a p-adic Hilbert space is highly nontrivial, we finally study the tensor product of subspaces, stressing both the analogies and the significant differences with respect to the standard complex case. These findings should provide us with the mathematical foundations necessary to explore quantum entanglement in the p-adic setting, with potential applications in the emerging field of p-adic quantum information theory.
This is Paper 005 in the Anaxiomatic Mechanics / pq-Spacetime stack. It develops the emergence of tensor-product structure and entanglement within Binary Mechanics. Building on the preceding treatment of effective Hilbert-space representation, it asks why composite quantum systems are represented by tensor products and why nonseparable, entangled states naturally appear. The central claim is that tensor products are not primitive assumptions. They arise when a finite binary-mechanical boundary problem can be decomposed into separately addressable boundary regions whose completion labels can be tracked independently. In that case, the joint completion structure is represented by the tensor product of the corresponding effective Hilbert spaces. Product states require a stronger condition: the underlying resolved graph histories and their phase counts must also factor across the chosen decomposition. Entanglement appears when completion labels remain separately addressable, but the underlying history ensemble does not factor. This non-factorization may be caused by cross-boundary graph structure, shared closure constraints, polarity consistency conditions, or other finite boundary restrictions. In this view, entanglement is the effective Hilbert-space expression of a shared finite history structure rather than a mysterious additional quantum postulate. The paper also distinguishes exact tensor products from physically effective tensor-product decompositions. Exact factorization is an ideal case; in physical applications, tensor-product structure is expected to hold when cross-boundary history constraints are negligible at the scale of description. The result is a finite, graph-history account of composite quantum structure: distinguishable completion channels give effective Hilbert bases, independently addressable labels give tensor-product spaces, factorizing histories give product states, and non-factorizing histories give entanglement.