Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2303.09423 · Physical Review A

Closed systems refuting quantum-speed-limit hypotheses

Niklas Hörnedal, Ole Sönnerborn

Published Nov 20, 2023• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many quantum speed limits for isolated systems can be generalized to also apply to closed systems. This is, for example, the case with the well-known Mandelstam-Tamm quantum speed limit. Margolus and Levitin derived an equally well-known and ostensibly related quantum speed limit, and it seems to be widely believed that the Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit can be similarly generalized to closed systems. However, a recent geometrical examination of this limit reveals that it differs significantly from most known quantum speed limits. In this paper, we show that, contrary to the common belief, the Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit does not extend to closed systems in an obvious way. More precisely, we show that for every hypothetical bound of Margolus-Levitin type, there are closed systems that evolve with a conserved normalized expected energy between states with any given fidelity in a time shorter than the bound. We also show that for isolated systems, the Mandelstam-Tamm quantum speed limit and a slightly weakened version of this limit that we call the Bhatia-Davies quantum speed limit always saturate simultaneously. Both of these evolution time estimates extend straightforwardly to closed systems. We demonstrate that there are closed systems that saturate the Mandelstam-Tamm but not the Bhatia-Davies quantum speed limit.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.108.052421

Related papers

Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit for an arbitrary fidelity

Niklas Hörnedal, Ole Sönnerborn

The Mandelstam-Tamm and Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limits are two well-known evolution time estimates for isolated quantum systems. These bounds are usually formulated for fully distinguishable initial and final states, but both have tight extensions to systems that evolve between states with an arbitrary fidelity. However, the foundations of these extensions differ in some essential respects. The extended Mandelstam-Tamm quantum speed limit has been proven analytically and has a clear geometric interpretation. Furthermore, which systems saturate the limit is known. The derivation of the extended Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit, on the other hand, is based on numerical estimates. Moreover, the limit lacks a geometric interpretation, and no complete characterization of the systems reaching it exists. In this paper, we derive the extended Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit analytically and describe the systems that saturate the limit in detail. We also provide the limit with a symplectic-geometric interpretation, which indicates that it is of a different character than most existing quantum speed limits. At the end of the paper, we analyze the maximum of the extended Mandelstam-Tamm and Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limits and derive a dual version of the extended Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit. The maximum limit is tight regardless of the fidelity of the initial and final states. However, the conditions under which the maximum limit is saturated differ depending on whether or not the initial state and the final state are fully distinguishable. The dual limit is also tight and follows from a time reversal argument. We describe the systems that saturate the dual quantum speed limit.

arXiv:2301.10063•Physical Review Research•Dec 12, 2023•19 citations

Note on the Margolus–Levitin quantum speed limit for arbitrary fidelity

Krzysztof Andrzejewski, Katarzyna Bolonek-Lasoń, Piotr Kosiński

Abstract For vanishing fidelity between initial and final states, two important quantum speed limits, the Mandelstam–Tamm limit (involving energy dispersion) and Margolus–Levitin one (involving excitation energy expectation value), have been derived. While the generalization of the former limit to the case of arbitrary fidelity is straightforward, the relevant generalization of the latter given in the seminal paper by Giovanetti et al. (Phys Rev A67:052109, 2003) was based on the conjectured equality of lower and upper bounds on the right-hand side of generalized Margolus–Levitin inequality, verified numerically up to seven digits. Only recently there appear two proofs of the conjecture. We provide below a very elementary new proof, based on the simplest tools from differential calculus. Thus, the generalized Margolus–Levitin speed limit can be derived much in the spirit of the original one valid for vanishing fidelity.

arXiv:2307.16854•Quantum Information Processing•May 2, 2024•2 citations

Quantum speed limit for thermal states

N. Il’in, Oleg Valentinovich Lychkovskiy

Quantum speed limits are rigorous estimates on how fast a state of a quantum system can depart from the initial state in the course of quantum evolution. Most known quantum speed limits, including the celebrated Mandelstam-Tamm and Margolus-Levitin ones, are general bounds applicable to arbitrary initial states. However, when applied to mixed states of many-body systems, they, as a rule, dramatically overestimate the speed of quantum evolution and fail to provide meaningful bounds in the thermodynamic limit. Here we derive a quantum speed limit for a closed system initially prepared in a thermal state and evolving under a time-dependent Hamiltonian. This quantum speed limit exploits the structure of the thermal state and, in particular, explicitly depends on the temperature. In a broad class of many-body setups it proves to be drastically stronger than general quantum speed limits.

arXiv:2005.06416•Physical Review A•Jun 1, 2021•21 citations

Comment on “Geometric derivation of the quantum speed limit”

Marcin Zwierz

Recently, Jones and Kok [Jones and Kok, Phys. Rev. A 82, 022107 (2010)] presented alternative geometric derivations of the Mandelstam-Tamm [Mandelstam and Tamm, J. Phys. (USSR) 9, 249 (1945)] and Margolus-Levitin [Margolus and Levitin, Phys. D 120, 188 (1998)] inequalities for the quantum speed of dynamical evolution. The Margolus-Levitin inequality followed from an upper bound on the rate of change of the statistical distance between two arbitrary pure quantum states. We show that the derivation of this bound is incorrect. Subsequently, we provide two upper bounds on the rate of change of the statistical distance, expressed in terms of the standard deviation of the generator $K$ and its expectation value above the ground state. The bounds lead to the Mandelstam-Tamm inequality and a quantum speed limit which is only slightly weaker than the Margolus-Levitin inequality.

arXiv:1207.2208•Physical Review A•Jul 9, 2012•71 citations

Quantum speed limits and optimal Hamiltonians for driven systems in mixed states

O Andersson, Hoshang Heydari

Inequalities of Mandelstam–Tamm (MT) and Margolus–Levitin (ML) type provide lower bounds on the time that it takes for a quantum system to evolve from one state into another. Knowledge of such bounds, called quantum speed limits, is of utmost importance in virtually all areas of physics, where determination of the minimum time required for a quantum process is of interest. Most MT and ML inequalities found in the literature have been derived from growth estimates for the Bures length, which is a statistical distance measure. In this paper we derive such inequalities by differential geometric methods, and we compare the quantum speed limits obtained with those involving the Bures length. We also characterize the Hamiltonians which optimize the evolution time for generic finite-level quantum systems.

arXiv:1312.6268•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 7, 2014•51 citations

A tight quantum speed limit for mixed qubit states

Maja Eliasson

Quantum speed limits describe how fast a system can evolve from one state to another. There are several well-known quantum speed limits such as the Mandelstam–Tamm and Margolus–Levitin bounds which were originally derived for pure states and are not always tight for mixed states. In this thesis a stronger bound is derived for mixed qubit states, which has been shown to be tight, by using additional information about the system. We chose to focus on a single qubit and use the Bloch representation to describe its evolution geometrically. Due to both the energy and the purity of the system being conserved under unitary time evolution, the Bloch vector moves in a circle. By expressing the fidelity between the initial and final state in terms of Bloch vectors, we can derive a stricter quantum speed limit for mixed qubit states. This new lower bound depends on both fidelity and purity and is tighter than the Margolus–Levitin bound. The result shows that taking conserved quantities like purity into account can lead to improved quantum speed limits and similar ideas might be useful for more complex systems as well.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
Many quantum speed limits for isolated systems can be generalized to also apply to closed systems. This is, for example, the case with the well-known Mandelstam-Tamm quantum speed limit. Margolus and Levitin derived an equally well-known and ostensibly related quantum speed limit, and it seems to be widely believed that the Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit can be similarly generalized to closed systems. However, a recent geometrical examination of this limit reveals that it differs significantly from most known quantum speed limits. In this paper, we show that, contrary to the common belief, the Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit does not extend to closed systems in an obvious way. More precisely, we show that for every hypothetical bound of Margolus-Levitin type, there are closed systems that evolve with a conserved normalized expected energy between states with any given fidelity in a time shorter than the bound. We also show that for isolated systems, the Mandelstam-Tamm quantum speed limit and a slightly weakened version of this limit that we call the Bhatia-Davies quantum speed limit always saturate simultaneously. Both of these evolution time estimates extend straightforwardly to closed systems. We demonstrate that there are closed systems that saturate the Mandelstam-Tamm but not the Bhatia-Davies quantum speed limit.
The Mandelstam-Tamm and Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limits are two well-known evolution time estimates for isolated quantum systems. These bounds are usually formulated for fully distinguishable initial and final states, but both have tight extensions to systems that evolve between states with an arbitrary fidelity. However, the foundations of these extensions differ in some essential respects. The extended Mandelstam-Tamm quantum speed limit has been proven analytically and has a clear geometric interpretation. Furthermore, which systems saturate the limit is known. The derivation of the extended Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit, on the other hand, is based on numerical estimates. Moreover, the limit lacks a geometric interpretation, and no complete characterization of the systems reaching it exists. In this paper, we derive the extended Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit analytically and describe the systems that saturate the limit in detail. We also provide the limit with a symplectic-geometric interpretation, which indicates that it is of a different character than most existing quantum speed limits. At the end of the paper, we analyze the maximum of the extended Mandelstam-Tamm and Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limits and derive a dual version of the extended Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit. The maximum limit is tight regardless of the fidelity of the initial and final states. However, the conditions under which the maximum limit is saturated differ depending on whether or not the initial state and the final state are fully distinguishable. The dual limit is also tight and follows from a time reversal argument. We describe the systems that saturate the dual quantum speed limit.
Abstract For vanishing fidelity between initial and final states, two important quantum speed limits, the Mandelstam–Tamm limit (involving energy dispersion) and Margolus–Levitin one (involving excitation energy expectation value), have been derived. While the generalization of the former limit to the case of arbitrary fidelity is straightforward, the relevant generalization of the latter given in the seminal paper by Giovanetti et al. (Phys Rev A67:052109, 2003) was based on the conjectured equality of lower and upper bounds on the right-hand side of generalized Margolus–Levitin inequality, verified numerically up to seven digits. Only recently there appear two proofs of the conjecture. We provide below a very elementary new proof, based on the simplest tools from differential calculus. Thus, the generalized Margolus–Levitin speed limit can be derived much in the spirit of the original one valid for vanishing fidelity.
Quantum speed limits are rigorous estimates on how fast a state of a quantum system can depart from the initial state in the course of quantum evolution. Most known quantum speed limits, including the celebrated Mandelstam-Tamm and Margolus-Levitin ones, are general bounds applicable to arbitrary initial states. However, when applied to mixed states of many-body systems, they, as a rule, dramatically overestimate the speed of quantum evolution and fail to provide meaningful bounds in the thermodynamic limit. Here we derive a quantum speed limit for a closed system initially prepared in a thermal state and evolving under a time-dependent Hamiltonian. This quantum speed limit exploits the structure of the thermal state and, in particular, explicitly depends on the temperature. In a broad class of many-body setups it proves to be drastically stronger than general quantum speed limits.
Recently, Jones and Kok [Jones and Kok, Phys. Rev. A 82, 022107 (2010)] presented alternative geometric derivations of the Mandelstam-Tamm [Mandelstam and Tamm, J. Phys. (USSR) 9, 249 (1945)] and Margolus-Levitin [Margolus and Levitin, Phys. D 120, 188 (1998)] inequalities for the quantum speed of dynamical evolution. The Margolus-Levitin inequality followed from an upper bound on the rate of change of the statistical distance between two arbitrary pure quantum states. We show that the derivation of this bound is incorrect. Subsequently, we provide two upper bounds on the rate of change of the statistical distance, expressed in terms of the standard deviation of the generator KKK and its expectation value above the ground state. The bounds lead to the Mandelstam-Tamm inequality and a quantum speed limit which is only slightly weaker than the Margolus-Levitin inequality.
Inequalities of Mandelstam–Tamm (MT) and Margolus–Levitin (ML) type provide lower bounds on the time that it takes for a quantum system to evolve from one state into another. Knowledge of such bounds, called quantum speed limits, is of utmost importance in virtually all areas of physics, where determination of the minimum time required for a quantum process is of interest. Most MT and ML inequalities found in the literature have been derived from growth estimates for the Bures length, which is a statistical distance measure. In this paper we derive such inequalities by differential geometric methods, and we compare the quantum speed limits obtained with those involving the Bures length. We also characterize the Hamiltonians which optimize the evolution time for generic finite-level quantum systems.
Quantum speed limits describe how fast a system can evolve from one state to another. There are several well-known quantum speed limits such as the Mandelstam–Tamm and Margolus–Levitin bounds which were originally derived for pure states and are not always tight for mixed states. In this thesis a stronger bound is derived for mixed qubit states, which has been shown to be tight, by using additional information about the system. We chose to focus on a single qubit and use the Bloch representation to describe its evolution geometrically. Due to both the energy and the purity of the system being conserved under unitary time evolution, the Bloch vector moves in a circle. By expressing the fidelity between the initial and final state in terms of Bloch vectors, we can derive a stricter quantum speed limit for mixed qubit states. This new lower bound depends on both fidelity and purity and is tighter than the Margolus–Levitin bound. The result shows that taking conserved quantities like purity into account can lead to improved quantum speed limits and similar ideas might be useful for more complex systems as well.