Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2303.08031 · Epistemology & Philosophy of Science

Hartman Effect, Time-Delays, and the Non-spatial Nature of Quantum Particles

Massimiliano Sassoli de Bianchi

Published Jan 1, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The phenomenon of quantum tunneling challenges classical intuitions about particle behavior and offers profound insights into the nature of quantum entities. This article examines tunneling through the lens of an effect predicted by Thomas E. Hartman in 1962: the tunneling time-delay becomes independent of the barrier width as the latter increases, implying superluminal effective velocities that appear to conflict with relativistic constraints. Exploiting the inherent symmetries of transmitted and reflected time-delays, our analysis shows that a tunneling particle, like its reflected counterpart, completely avoids the barrier region. However, since it can be detected on the transmitted side of the barrier, the only logical conclusion is that the classical notion of spatiality is violated during the tunneling process. In other words, quantum tunneling and the associated Hartman effect strongly support the idea that quantum non-locality should be interpreted as quantum non-spatiality. The latter, according to the conceptuality interpretation of quantum mechanics, expresses the conceptual-like nature of quantum entities, which during measurement transition from an abstract state to a maximally concrete one, in full compatibility with the Hartman effect.

DOI
10.5840/eps202562465

Related papers

Relativistic tunneling through two successive barriers

Jose Tadeu Lunardi, Luiz A. Manzoni

We study the relativistic quantum mechanical problem of a Dirac particle tunneling through two successive electrostatic barriers. Our aim is to study the emergence of the so-called generalized Hartman effect, an effect observed in the context of nonrelativistic tunneling as well as in its electromagnetic counterparts and which is often associated with the possibility of superluminal velocities in the tunneling process. We discuss the behavior of both the phase (or group) tunneling time and the dwell time, and show that in the limit of opaque barriers the relativistic theory also allows the emergence of the generalized Hartman effect. We compare our results with the nonrelativistic ones and discuss their interpretation.

arXiv:0708.3507•Physical Review A•Oct 16, 2007•22 citations

Apparent superluminality and the generalized Hartman effect in double-barrier tunneling

Herbert G. Winful

Recent papers suggest that tunneling wave packets traverse the region of allowed propagation between two potential barriers with superluminal group velocity and in a time independent of barrier separation. This phenomenon has been termed the "generalized Hartman effect" and extended to multiple barriers. Here we show that this delay time is not a transit time but a cavity lifetime. It does not imply superluminal velocity. Reported experimental verifications of this effect are reinterpreted.

Physical Review E•Oct 18, 2005•33 citations

PHASE TIME FOR A TUNNELING PARTICLE

Swarnali Bandopadhyay, A. M. Jayannavar

We study the nature of tunneling phase time for various quantum mechanical structures such as networks and rings having potential barriers in their arms. We find the generic presence of the Hartman effect, with superluminal velocities as a consequence, in these systems. In quantum networks, it is possible to control the "super arrival" time in one of the arms by changing the parameters on another arm which is spatially separated from it. This is yet another quantum nonlocal effect. Negative time delays (time advancement) and "ultra Hartman effect" with negative saturation times have been observed in some parameter regimes. In the presence and absence of Aharonov-Bohm (AB) flux, quantum rings show the Hartman effect. We obtain the analytical expression for the saturated phase time. In the opaque barrier regime, this is independent of even the AB flux thereby generalizing the Hartman effect. We also briefly discuss the concept of "space collapse or space destroyer" by introducing a free space in between two barriers covering the ring. Further, we show in presence of absorption that the reflection phase time exhibits the Hartman effect in contrast to the transmission phase time.

arXiv:quant-ph/0511089•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Apr 20, 2007•8 citations

Do single photons tunnel faster than light?

Herbert G. Winful

Experiments done with single photons in the early 1990's produced a surprising result: that single photons pass through a photonic tunnel barrier with a group velocity faster than the vacuum speed of light. This result has stimulated intense discussions related to causality, the speed of information transfer, the nature of barrier tunneling and the meaning of group velocity. The superluminality of tunneling photons is now textbook material, although the authors note that controversy still remains. Another paradoxical result, known as the Hartman effect, is that the tunneling time of the photons becomes independent of barrier length in the limit of opaque barriers. In this paper we examine the meaning of group velocity in the context of barrier tunneling. We ask whether a single tunneling photon can be described by a group velocity and whether the short group delays imply superluminal group velocity. We resolve the paradox of the Hartman effect and show that the predicted and measured group delays are not transit times but photon lifetimes.

arXiv:0708.3889•Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 26, 2007•4 citations

Bounds and enhancements for negative scattering time delays

Juan Gonzalo Muga, I. L. Egusquiza, J. A. Damborenea +1 more

The time of passage of the transmitted wave packet in a tunneling collision of a quantum particle with a square potential barrier becomes independent of the barrier width in a range of barrier thickness. This is the Hartman effect, which has been frequently associated with ``superluminality.'' A fundamental limitation on the effect is set by nonrelativistic ``causality conditions.'' We demonstrate first that the causality conditions impose more restrictive bounds on the negative time delays (time advancements) when no bound states are present. These restrictive bounds are in agreement with a naive, and generally false, causality argument based on the positivity of the ``extrapolated phase time,'' one of the quantities proposed to characterize the duration of the barrier's traversal. Nevertheless, square wells may in fact lead to much larger advancements than square barriers. We point out that close to the thresholds of new bound states, the time advancement increases considerably, while, at the same time, the transmission probability is large, which facilitates the possible observation of the enhanced time advancement.

arXiv:quant-ph/0206181•Physical Review A•Oct 23, 2002•62 citations

Non‐Hermitian Hartman Effect

Stefano Longhi

Abstract The Hartman effect refers to the rather paradoxical result that the time spent by a quantum mechanical particle or a photon to tunnel through an opaque potential barrier becomes independent of barrier width for long barriers. Such an effect, which has been observed in different physical settings, raised a lively debate and some controversies, owing to the correct definition and interpretation of tunneling times and the apparent superluminal transmission. A rather open question is whether (and under which conditions) the Hartman effect persists for inelastic scattering, that is, when the potential becomes non‐Hermitian and the scattering matrix is not unitary. Here, tunneling through a heterojunction barrier in the tight‐binding picture is considered, where the barrier consists of a generally non‐Hermitian finite‐sized lattice attached to two semi‐infinite nearest‐neighbor Hermitian lattice leads. A simple and general condition is derived for the persistence of the Hartman effect in non‐Hermitian barriers, showing that it can be found rather generally when non‐Hermiticity arises from nonreciprocal couplings, that is, when the barrier displays the non‐Hermitian skin effect, without any special symmetry in the system.

arXiv:2207.08715•Annalen der Physik•Aug 5, 2022•13 citations
The phenomenon of quantum tunneling challenges classical intuitions about particle behavior and offers profound insights into the nature of quantum entities. This article examines tunneling through the lens of an effect predicted by Thomas E. Hartman in 1962: the tunneling time-delay becomes independent of the barrier width as the latter increases, implying superluminal effective velocities that appear to conflict with relativistic constraints. Exploiting the inherent symmetries of transmitted and reflected time-delays, our analysis shows that a tunneling particle, like its reflected counterpart, completely avoids the barrier region. However, since it can be detected on the transmitted side of the barrier, the only logical conclusion is that the classical notion of spatiality is violated during the tunneling process. In other words, quantum tunneling and the associated Hartman effect strongly support the idea that quantum non-locality should be interpreted as quantum non-spatiality. The latter, according to the conceptuality interpretation of quantum mechanics, expresses the conceptual-like nature of quantum entities, which during measurement transition from an abstract state to a maximally concrete one, in full compatibility with the Hartman effect.
We study the relativistic quantum mechanical problem of a Dirac particle tunneling through two successive electrostatic barriers. Our aim is to study the emergence of the so-called generalized Hartman effect, an effect observed in the context of nonrelativistic tunneling as well as in its electromagnetic counterparts and which is often associated with the possibility of superluminal velocities in the tunneling process. We discuss the behavior of both the phase (or group) tunneling time and the dwell time, and show that in the limit of opaque barriers the relativistic theory also allows the emergence of the generalized Hartman effect. We compare our results with the nonrelativistic ones and discuss their interpretation.
Recent papers suggest that tunneling wave packets traverse the region of allowed propagation between two potential barriers with superluminal group velocity and in a time independent of barrier separation. This phenomenon has been termed the "generalized Hartman effect" and extended to multiple barriers. Here we show that this delay time is not a transit time but a cavity lifetime. It does not imply superluminal velocity. Reported experimental verifications of this effect are reinterpreted.
We study the nature of tunneling phase time for various quantum mechanical structures such as networks and rings having potential barriers in their arms. We find the generic presence of the Hartman effect, with superluminal velocities as a consequence, in these systems. In quantum networks, it is possible to control the "super arrival" time in one of the arms by changing the parameters on another arm which is spatially separated from it. This is yet another quantum nonlocal effect. Negative time delays (time advancement) and "ultra Hartman effect" with negative saturation times have been observed in some parameter regimes. In the presence and absence of Aharonov-Bohm (AB) flux, quantum rings show the Hartman effect. We obtain the analytical expression for the saturated phase time. In the opaque barrier regime, this is independent of even the AB flux thereby generalizing the Hartman effect. We also briefly discuss the concept of "space collapse or space destroyer" by introducing a free space in between two barriers covering the ring. Further, we show in presence of absorption that the reflection phase time exhibits the Hartman effect in contrast to the transmission phase time.
Experiments done with single photons in the early 1990's produced a surprising result: that single photons pass through a photonic tunnel barrier with a group velocity faster than the vacuum speed of light. This result has stimulated intense discussions related to causality, the speed of information transfer, the nature of barrier tunneling and the meaning of group velocity. The superluminality of tunneling photons is now textbook material, although the authors note that controversy still remains. Another paradoxical result, known as the Hartman effect, is that the tunneling time of the photons becomes independent of barrier length in the limit of opaque barriers. In this paper we examine the meaning of group velocity in the context of barrier tunneling. We ask whether a single tunneling photon can be described by a group velocity and whether the short group delays imply superluminal group velocity. We resolve the paradox of the Hartman effect and show that the predicted and measured group delays are not transit times but photon lifetimes.
The time of passage of the transmitted wave packet in a tunneling collision of a quantum particle with a square potential barrier becomes independent of the barrier width in a range of barrier thickness. This is the Hartman effect, which has been frequently associated with ``superluminality.'' A fundamental limitation on the effect is set by nonrelativistic ``causality conditions.'' We demonstrate first that the causality conditions impose more restrictive bounds on the negative time delays (time advancements) when no bound states are present. These restrictive bounds are in agreement with a naive, and generally false, causality argument based on the positivity of the ``extrapolated phase time,'' one of the quantities proposed to characterize the duration of the barrier's traversal. Nevertheless, square wells may in fact lead to much larger advancements than square barriers. We point out that close to the thresholds of new bound states, the time advancement increases considerably, while, at the same time, the transmission probability is large, which facilitates the possible observation of the enhanced time advancement.
Abstract The Hartman effect refers to the rather paradoxical result that the time spent by a quantum mechanical particle or a photon to tunnel through an opaque potential barrier becomes independent of barrier width for long barriers. Such an effect, which has been observed in different physical settings, raised a lively debate and some controversies, owing to the correct definition and interpretation of tunneling times and the apparent superluminal transmission. A rather open question is whether (and under which conditions) the Hartman effect persists for inelastic scattering, that is, when the potential becomes non‐Hermitian and the scattering matrix is not unitary. Here, tunneling through a heterojunction barrier in the tight‐binding picture is considered, where the barrier consists of a generally non‐Hermitian finite‐sized lattice attached to two semi‐infinite nearest‐neighbor Hermitian lattice leads. A simple and general condition is derived for the persistence of the Hartman effect in non‐Hermitian barriers, showing that it can be found rather generally when non‐Hermiticity arises from nonreciprocal couplings, that is, when the barrier displays the non‐Hermitian skin effect, without any special symmetry in the system.