The nature of emergence of complexity out of the underlying physics is a key issue in understanding the world around us (1). Genuine emergence can be claimed (2⇓–4) to depend on top-down causation, which enables higher emergent levels to direct the outcomes of causation at lower levels to fulfill higher-level causal requirements; for example, the needs of heart physiology at the systems level determine gene expression at the cellular level via gene regulatory networks (5) (Fig. 1). However, the idea of top-down causation has been denied by a number of commentators (e.g., refs. 6 and 7). The paper by Aharonov et al. (8) makes a strong contribution to this debate by giving quantum physics examples where top-down causation manifestly occurs. This physics result has strong implications for the philosophical debate about whether strong emergence is possible. Indeed, it gives specific examples where it occurs in a remarkably strong form.
Fig. 1.
Bottom-up and top-down causation from the quantum level up to the organism level and down again. Adapted with permission of Royal Society, from ref. 5; permission conveyed through Copyright Clearance Center, Inc.
Now, the word “causation” is regarded with suspicion by many philosophers of science, so to characterize what is happening one can perhaps rather use a number of different descriptions such as “whole–part constraint” or “top-down realization.” The key point remains the same, that higher levels can influence lower-level outcomes in many ways, and hence explain how strong emergence is possible. This occurs across science in general, and in physics in particular (3, 4). The latter point …
[↵][1]1Email: george.ellis{at}uct.ac.za.
[1]: #xref-corresp-1-1
The fundamental laws of physics are time-reversal invariant. The arrow of time and the definiteness of measurement outcomes are therefore usually attributed to assumptions outside the dynamics: coarse-graining with a low-entropy initial state, and a collapse postulate or an observer. We propose instead that irreversibility is itself a law of nature. Time evolution is a semigroup. An entry, once made, cannot be undone, and an earlier state can recur only through a new forward process, suppressed by
e−ΔS/kB. The entropy entered in the causal past forms a scalar memory field, which defines the direction of time at every event. We state the dynamical law without new dimensional constants. Entries occur where energy enters a quantum-chaotic subsystem and produces entropy. Their rate is bounded by the Thouless time. Free fields, integrable systems and matter in equilibrium are left unchanged. An entry selects an energy window with the Born weight and makes the time average within it final. The resulting dynamics is linear and completely positive on the joint space of state and record. It gives definite outcomes for measurements that transfer energy, without an observer. The theory predicts that, after an entry, even a perfect time reversal recovers the initial state only with a probability of order
e−ΔS/kB, whereas standard quantum mechanics predicts complete recovery. A model calculation confirms this as a proof of concept. If gravity is sourced by what has been entered, it neither entangles nor decoheres cold, freely falling masses. Elements still set by hand, and the open problems of the gravitational part, are stated explicitly.
Abstract Quantum mechanics is our most successful and versatile account of the basic constituents of matter, of their interaction and of their compounds. We introduce the theory via a sketch of its history and lay out its mathematical structure in some detail. Before this background we address the important and controversial question of how to interpret that structure. We contextualise our own position, which is linked to our account of ontological emergence as detailed in Chap. 2 , and which is mathematically best expressed in the Heisenberg picture of quantum dynamics. Indeterminism and irreversible processes are fundamental for our approach. We discuss the dialectics of the deterministic challenge to our position and argue that indeterminism in the form of quantum randomness has turned from a philosophical riddle to a technological resource. This claim is supported by a discussion of quantum information science, including some of its basic protocols. Towards the end of the chapter we argue that agency and quantum mechanics come as a package deal. For one, quantum mechanics describes the world as offering open possibilities for the future at a fundamental physical level, which is needed for real higher-order organisation, including agency. Of course, this does not in any way show that the actual existence of agents in our world is guaranteed. But it does show that general agency scepticism has no basis in physics. Second, we show that quantum mechanics is best understood as a theory that describes our agential interactions with nature, and not as a theory that represents nature from the point of view of an inert, detached observer.
The general view is that all fundamental physical laws should be formulated within the framework given by quantum mechanics (QM). In a sense, QM therefore has the character of a metaphysical theory. Consequently, if it is possible to derive QM from more basic principles, these principles should be of general, philosophical nature. Here, we derive the formalism of QM from well-motivated epistemic principles. A key assumption is that a physical theory that relies on entities or distinctions that are unknowable in principle gives rise to wrong predictions. First, an epistemic formalism is developed, using concepts like knowledge and potential knowledge, identifying a physical state
S with the potential knowledge of the physical world. It is demonstrated that QM emerges from this formalism. However, Hilbert spaces, wave functions and probabilities are defined in certain well-defined observational contexts only. This means that the epistemic formalism is broader than QM. In the fundamental layer of description, the physical state
S is a subset of a state space
S={Z}, such that
S always contains many elements
Z. These elements correspond to unattainable states of complete knowledge of the world. The evolution of
S cannot be determined in terms of the individual evolution of the elements
Z, unlike the evolution of an ensemble in classical phase space. The evolution of
S is described in terms of sequential time
n∈N, which is updated according to
n→n+1 each time an event occurs, each time potential knowledge changes. Sequential time
n can be separated from relational time
t, which describes distances between events in space-time. There is an entire space-time associated with each
n, in which
t represents the knowledge at sequential time
n about the temporal relations between present and past events.
Classical physics is generally regarded as deterministic, as opposed to quantum mechanics that is considered the first theory to have introduced genuine indeterminism into physics. We challenge this view by arguing that the alleged determinism of classical physics relies on the tacit, metaphysical assumption that there exists an actual value of every physical quantity, with its infinite predetermined digits (which we name principle of infinite precision). Building on recent information-theoretic arguments showing that the principle of infinite precision (which translates into the attribution of a physical meaning to mathematical real numbers) leads to unphysical consequences, we consider possible alternative indeterministic interpretations of classical physics. We also link those to well-known interpretations of quantum mechanics. In particular, we propose a model of classical indeterminism based on finite information quantities (FIQs). Moreover, we discuss the perspectives that an indeterministic physics could open (such as strong emergence), as well as some potential problematic issues. Finally, we make evident that any indeterministic interpretation of physics would have to deal with the problem of explaining how the indeterminate values become determinate, a problem known in the context of quantum mechanics as (part of) the ``quantum measurement problem.'' We discuss some similarities between the classical and the quantum measurement problems, and propose ideas for possible solutions (e.g., ``collapse models'' and ``top-down causation'').
Although the fundamental laws of physics explain a great deal of the material world, they often seem to contradict our immediate experience. For instance, as physicists we believe that all elementary interactions are reversible, but as people we are immersed in irreversibility. The collision of two atoms may well be reversible and predictable, but for us time flows in a definite direction and life is sometimes unpredictable. “What then is time? If no one asks me, I know what it is. If I wish to explain it to him who asks, I do not know. ” (Attributed to Augustine.) Nevertheless, as we try to explain in this section, one can include irreversibility, the true arrow of time, into quantum mechanics in a concise and elegant form put on solid mathematical ground in Lindblad's theorem (Lindblad, 1976). Having then understood the basics of irreversible quantum dynamics, life may not be quite the same any more.