Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2303.04559

Manipulating fermionic mode entanglement in the presence of superselection rules

Ömer Tırınk, Gökhan Torun, Onur Pusuluk

Published Mar 8, 2023• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Superselection rules (SSRs), linked to the conservation of physical quantities such as parity or particle number, impose constraints on allowable physical operations in fermionic systems. This affects the amount of extractable mode entanglement possessed in a given state and its manipulation by the so-called entanglement-free operations. Here, we present a majorization-based algorithm for the mixed state transformations of bipartite mode entanglement, where the allowed operations (i.e., resource non-generating operations), that is, local operations and classical communication, are restricted by local SSRs. We then focus on the local parity SSR and investigate the possibility to relax the constraints imposed by it through a catalyst. In particular, we show that an ancillary mode system can catalyze the change in local parity. Finally, we discuss the application of our methodology to various problems in different fields. Accordingly, we propose that it may shed new light on the activation of orbital entanglement in chemical molecules and the manipulation of multipartite entanglement or quantum discord in distinguishable quantum systems.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2303.04559

Related papers

Quantum entanglement theory in the presence of superselection rules

Norbert Schuch, Frank Verstraete, J. I. Cirac

Superselection rules severely constrain the operations which can be implemented on a distributed quantum system. While the restriction to local operations and classical communication gives rise to entanglement as a nonlocal resource, particle number conservation additionally confines the possible operations and should give rise to a new resource. In Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 087904 (2004) we showed that this resource can be quantified by a single additional number, the superselection-induced variance $(\mathrm{SIV})$, without changing the concept of entanglement. In this paper, we give the results on pure states in greater detail; additionally, we provide a discussion of mixed-state nonlocality with superselection rules where we consider both formation and distillation. Finally, we demonstrate that $\mathrm{SIV}$ is indeed a resource, i.e., that it captures how well a state can be used to overcome the restrictions imposed by the superselection rule.

arXiv:quant-ph/0404079•Physical Review A•Oct 15, 2004•106 citations

Nonlocal Resources in the Presence of Superselection Rules

Norbert Schuch, Frank Verstraete, J. I. Cirac

Superselection rules severely alter the possible operations that can be implemented on a distributed quantum system. Whereas the restriction to local operations imposed by a bipartite setting gives rise to the notion of entanglement as a nonlocal resource, the superselection rule associated with particle number conservation leads to a new resource, the superselection induced variance of the local particle number. We show that, in the case of pure quantum states, one can quantify the nonlocal properties by only two additive measures, and that all states with the same measures can be asymptotically interconverted into each other by local operations and classical communication. Furthermore we discuss how superselection rules affect the concepts of majorization, teleportation, and mixed state entanglement.

arXiv:quant-ph/0310124•Physical Review Letters•Feb 27, 2004•104 citations

Entanglement and symmetry: A case study in superselection rules, reference frames, and beyond

S. J. Jones, Howard M. Wiseman, Stephen D. Bartlett +2 more

In recent years it has become apparent that constraints on possible quantum operations, such as those constraints imposed by superselection rules (SSRs), have a profound effect on quantum information theoretic concepts like bipartite entanglement. This paper concentrates on a particular example: the constraint that applies when the parties (Alice and Bob) cannot distinguish among certain quantum objects they have. This arises naturally in the context of ensemble quantum information processing such as in liquid NMR. We discuss how a SSR for the symmetric group can be applied, and show how the extractable entanglement can be calculated analytically in certain cases, with a maximum bipartite entanglement in an ensemble of $N$ Bell-state pairs scaling as $\mathrm{log}(N)$ as $N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. We discuss the apparent disparity with the asymptotic $(N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty})$ recovery of unconstrained entanglement for other sorts of superselection rules, and show that the disparity disappears when the correct notion of applying the symmetric group SSR to multiple copies is used. Next we discuss reference frames in the context of this SSR, showing the relation to the work of von Korff and Kempe [Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 260502 (2004)]. The action of a reference frame can be regarded as the analog of activation in mixed-state entanglement. We also discuss the analog of distillation: there exist states such that one copy can act as an imperfect reference frame for another copy. Finally we present an example of a stronger operational constraint, that operations must be noncollective as well as symmetric. Even under this stronger constraint we, nevertheless, show that Bell nonlocality (and hence entanglement) can be demonstrated for an ensemble of $N$ Bell-state pairs no matter how large $N$ is. This last work is a generalization of that of Mermin [Phys. Rev. D 22, 356 (1980)].

arXiv:quant-ph/0608056•Physical Review A•Dec 20, 2006•23 citations

FERRETING OUT THE FLUFFY BUNNIES: ENTANGLEMENT CONSTRAINED BY GENERALIZED SUPERSELECTION RULES

Howard M. Wiseman, Stephen D. Bartlett, John A. Vaccaro

Entanglement is a resource central to quantum information (QI). In particular, entanglement shared between two distant parties allows them to do certain tasks that would otherwise be impossible. In this context, we study the effect on the available entanglement of physical restrictions on the local operations that can be performed by the two parties. We enforce these physical restrictions by generalized superselection rules (SSRs), which we define to be associated with a given group of physical transformations. Specifically the generalized SSR is that the local operations must be covariant with respect to that group. Then we operationally define the entanglement constrained by a SSR, and show that it may be far below that expected on the basis of a naive (or ``fluffy bunny'') calculation. We consider two examples. The first is a particle number SSR. Using this we show that for a two-mode BEC (with Alice owning mode $A$ and Bob mode $B$), the useful entanglement shared by Alice and Bob is identically zero. The second, a SSR associated with the symmetric group, is applicable to ensemble QI processing such as in liquid-NMR. We prove that even for an ensemble comprising many pairs of qubits, with each pair described by a pure Bell state, the entanglement per pair constrained by this SSR goes to zero for a large ensemble.

arXiv:quant-ph/0309046•Laser Spectroscopy•Feb 1, 2004•30 citations

Entanglement in systems of indistinguishable fermions

Mari Carmen Bañuls, J. I. Cirac, Michael M. Wolf

The characterization of entanglement is a fundamental issue for Quantum Information Theory. But the definition of entanglement depends on the notion of locality, and thus on the tensor product structure of the state space of the composite system. This notion is affected by the presence of superselection rules that restrict the accessible Hilbert space to a direct sum of subspaces. Indistinguishability of particles imposes one such restriction, namely to totally symmetric or totally antisymmetric states. The entanglement can in this case be defined with respect to partitions of modes in the second quantization formalism. For fermionic systems the Fock space of m modes is isomorphic to the space of m qubits, but the action of creation and annihilation operators is not local, due to their anticommutation. Conservation of the parity of fermion number imposes another relevant superselection rule. It requires that local physical observables commute with the local parity operator. Taking into account the considerations above, it is possible to define the set of separable states or equivalently the concept of entanglement for fermionic systems in a number of ways. Here we analyze systematically these possibilities and the relation among the various sets of separable states. We also discuss the behavior of the different classes when taking several copies of the state, as well as the characterization of the sets in terms of the usual criteria regarding the tensor product.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2009•17 citations

Fermionic quantum theory and superselection rules for operational probabilistic theories

Giacomo Mauro, Paolo Perinotti, Alessandro Tosini

The anticommutation of Fermionic fields raises the problem of simulating the evolution of Fermionic systems by means of commuting quantum systems, say qubits. We tackle the issue considering local Fermionic modes as the elementary systems of an operational probabilistic theory. We show that the locality of Fermionic operations, namely operations on systems that are not causally connected must commute, implies the parity superselection rule, which inhibits the superposition of states with an even and an odd number of excitations. Accordingly we derive the largest probabilistic theory compatible with the parity superselection constraint and show that it lacks two distinctive traits of quantum theory, the local tomography and the monogamy of the entanglement. We generalize the notion of superselection rule to general probabilistic theories as sets of linear constraints on the convex set of states and prove a trade-off between the cardinality of the superselection rule and the degree of holism of the resulting theory. Within this scenario the Fermionic quantum theory and the real quantum theory can be regarded as superselected versions of the usual quantum theory. These results are published in Ref. [7] http://iopscience.iop.org/0295-5075/107/2/20009 and Ref. [8] http://www.worldscientific.com/doi/abs/10.1142/S0217751X14300257. In the last three decades the relation between Fermionic systems and other quantum systems has been throughly investigated from both the computational and the physical point of view. In particular the puzzling anti-commuting nature of the Fermionic systems casts a shadow on the possibility of simulating the physical evolution of a bunch of Fermionic systems by means of commuting quantum systems—say qubits. This issue was raised by R. P. Feynman in 1982 [9], when in his seminal work on physical computation he wondered about the possibility of simulating Fermions by local quantum systems in interaction—what we would call nowadays a quantum computer. The problem is that of encoding the evolution of Fermionic fields onto localized quantum systems. A well-known encoding of N Fermionic systems into N qubits is given by the Jordan-Wigner transform (JWT) [14]. Such an encoding, based on the identification between the Fock space of N Fermions and the Hilbert space of N qubits, provides a -algebra isomorphism between the Fermionic anticommuting algebra and the commuting algebra of qubits. Such a correspondence has been a valuable instrument in modern solid state physics for solving the one dimensional XY spin-chains [18, 15] and then for the understanding of superconductivity and the quantum Hall effect. Moreover, a time-adaptive JWT has been introduced in Ref. [19], which allows to contract Fermionic unitary circuits with the same complexity as for the corresponding spin model. In quantum information science the JWT has been used to extend to the Fermionic case notions as entanglement [1], the entropic area law [24], and universal computation [5]. More recently the JWT, which originally regards one dimensional chains of spin-1=2 systems, has been generalized to any spin [3] and lattice [13] dimension. Despite its computational power, the JWT fails to solve completely the issue established by Feynman: physically local Fermionic operations are mapped into nonlocal quantum ones and viceversa. As noticed by many authors this can lead to ambiguities in defining the partial trace [16, 4, 17, 10], and in assessing

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations
Superselection rules (SSRs), linked to the conservation of physical quantities such as parity or particle number, impose constraints on allowable physical operations in fermionic systems. This affects the amount of extractable mode entanglement possessed in a given state and its manipulation by the so-called entanglement-free operations. Here, we present a majorization-based algorithm for the mixed state transformations of bipartite mode entanglement, where the allowed operations (i.e., resource non-generating operations), that is, local operations and classical communication, are restricted by local SSRs. We then focus on the local parity SSR and investigate the possibility to relax the constraints imposed by it through a catalyst. In particular, we show that an ancillary mode system can catalyze the change in local parity. Finally, we discuss the application of our methodology to various problems in different fields. Accordingly, we propose that it may shed new light on the activation of orbital entanglement in chemical molecules and the manipulation of multipartite entanglement or quantum discord in distinguishable quantum systems.
Superselection rules severely constrain the operations which can be implemented on a distributed quantum system. While the restriction to local operations and classical communication gives rise to entanglement as a nonlocal resource, particle number conservation additionally confines the possible operations and should give rise to a new resource. In Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 087904 (2004) we showed that this resource can be quantified by a single additional number, the superselection-induced variance (SIV)(\mathrm{SIV})(SIV), without changing the concept of entanglement. In this paper, we give the results on pure states in greater detail; additionally, we provide a discussion of mixed-state nonlocality with superselection rules where we consider both formation and distillation. Finally, we demonstrate that SIV\mathrm{SIV}SIV is indeed a resource, i.e., that it captures how well a state can be used to overcome the restrictions imposed by the superselection rule.
Superselection rules severely alter the possible operations that can be implemented on a distributed quantum system. Whereas the restriction to local operations imposed by a bipartite setting gives rise to the notion of entanglement as a nonlocal resource, the superselection rule associated with particle number conservation leads to a new resource, the superselection induced variance of the local particle number. We show that, in the case of pure quantum states, one can quantify the nonlocal properties by only two additive measures, and that all states with the same measures can be asymptotically interconverted into each other by local operations and classical communication. Furthermore we discuss how superselection rules affect the concepts of majorization, teleportation, and mixed state entanglement.
In recent years it has become apparent that constraints on possible quantum operations, such as those constraints imposed by superselection rules (SSRs), have a profound effect on quantum information theoretic concepts like bipartite entanglement. This paper concentrates on a particular example: the constraint that applies when the parties (Alice and Bob) cannot distinguish among certain quantum objects they have. This arises naturally in the context of ensemble quantum information processing such as in liquid NMR. We discuss how a SSR for the symmetric group can be applied, and show how the extractable entanglement can be calculated analytically in certain cases, with a maximum bipartite entanglement in an ensemble of NNN Bell-state pairs scaling as log(N)\mathrm{log}(N)log(N) as $N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. We discuss the apparent disparity with the asymptotic $(N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty})$ recovery of unconstrained entanglement for other sorts of superselection rules, and show that the disparity disappears when the correct notion of applying the symmetric group SSR to multiple copies is used. Next we discuss reference frames in the context of this SSR, showing the relation to the work of von Korff and Kempe [Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 260502 (2004)]. The action of a reference frame can be regarded as the analog of activation in mixed-state entanglement. We also discuss the analog of distillation: there exist states such that one copy can act as an imperfect reference frame for another copy. Finally we present an example of a stronger operational constraint, that operations must be noncollective as well as symmetric. Even under this stronger constraint we, nevertheless, show that Bell nonlocality (and hence entanglement) can be demonstrated for an ensemble of NNN Bell-state pairs no matter how large NNN is. This last work is a generalization of that of Mermin [Phys. Rev. D 22, 356 (1980)].
Entanglement is a resource central to quantum information (QI). In particular, entanglement shared between two distant parties allows them to do certain tasks that would otherwise be impossible. In this context, we study the effect on the available entanglement of physical restrictions on the local operations that can be performed by the two parties. We enforce these physical restrictions by generalized superselection rules (SSRs), which we define to be associated with a given group of physical transformations. Specifically the generalized SSR is that the local operations must be covariant with respect to that group. Then we operationally define the entanglement constrained by a SSR, and show that it may be far below that expected on the basis of a naive (or ``fluffy bunny'') calculation. We consider two examples. The first is a particle number SSR. Using this we show that for a two-mode BEC (with Alice owning mode AAA and Bob mode BBB), the useful entanglement shared by Alice and Bob is identically zero. The second, a SSR associated with the symmetric group, is applicable to ensemble QI processing such as in liquid-NMR. We prove that even for an ensemble comprising many pairs of qubits, with each pair described by a pure Bell state, the entanglement per pair constrained by this SSR goes to zero for a large ensemble.
The characterization of entanglement is a fundamental issue for Quantum Information Theory. But the definition of entanglement depends on the notion of locality, and thus on the tensor product structure of the state space of the composite system. This notion is affected by the presence of superselection rules that restrict the accessible Hilbert space to a direct sum of subspaces. Indistinguishability of particles imposes one such restriction, namely to totally symmetric or totally antisymmetric states. The entanglement can in this case be defined with respect to partitions of modes in the second quantization formalism. For fermionic systems the Fock space of m modes is isomorphic to the space of m qubits, but the action of creation and annihilation operators is not local, due to their anticommutation. Conservation of the parity of fermion number imposes another relevant superselection rule. It requires that local physical observables commute with the local parity operator. Taking into account the considerations above, it is possible to define the set of separable states or equivalently the concept of entanglement for fermionic systems in a number of ways. Here we analyze systematically these possibilities and the relation among the various sets of separable states. We also discuss the behavior of the different classes when taking several copies of the state, as well as the characterization of the sets in terms of the usual criteria regarding the tensor product.
The anticommutation of Fermionic fields raises the problem of simulating the evolution of Fermionic systems by means of commuting quantum systems, say qubits. We tackle the issue considering local Fermionic modes as the elementary systems of an operational probabilistic theory. We show that the locality of Fermionic operations, namely operations on systems that are not causally connected must commute, implies the parity superselection rule, which inhibits the superposition of states with an even and an odd number of excitations. Accordingly we derive the largest probabilistic theory compatible with the parity superselection constraint and show that it lacks two distinctive traits of quantum theory, the local tomography and the monogamy of the entanglement. We generalize the notion of superselection rule to general probabilistic theories as sets of linear constraints on the convex set of states and prove a trade-off between the cardinality of the superselection rule and the degree of holism of the resulting theory. Within this scenario the Fermionic quantum theory and the real quantum theory can be regarded as superselected versions of the usual quantum theory. These results are published in Ref. [7] http://iopscience.iop.org/0295-5075/107/2/20009 and Ref. [8] http://www.worldscientific.com/doi/abs/10.1142/S0217751X14300257. In the last three decades the relation between Fermionic systems and other quantum systems has been throughly investigated from both the computational and the physical point of view. In particular the puzzling anti-commuting nature of the Fermionic systems casts a shadow on the possibility of simulating the physical evolution of a bunch of Fermionic systems by means of commuting quantum systems—say qubits. This issue was raised by R. P. Feynman in 1982 [9], when in his seminal work on physical computation he wondered about the possibility of simulating Fermions by local quantum systems in interaction—what we would call nowadays a quantum computer. The problem is that of encoding the evolution of Fermionic fields onto localized quantum systems. A well-known encoding of N Fermionic systems into N qubits is given by the Jordan-Wigner transform (JWT) [14]. Such an encoding, based on the identification between the Fock space of N Fermions and the Hilbert space of N qubits, provides a -algebra isomorphism between the Fermionic anticommuting algebra and the commuting algebra of qubits. Such a correspondence has been a valuable instrument in modern solid state physics for solving the one dimensional XY spin-chains [18, 15] and then for the understanding of superconductivity and the quantum Hall effect. Moreover, a time-adaptive JWT has been introduced in Ref. [19], which allows to contract Fermionic unitary circuits with the same complexity as for the corresponding spin model. In quantum information science the JWT has been used to extend to the Fermionic case notions as entanglement [1], the entropic area law [24], and universal computation [5]. More recently the JWT, which originally regards one dimensional chains of spin-1=2 systems, has been generalized to any spin [3] and lattice [13] dimension. Despite its computational power, the JWT fails to solve completely the issue established by Feynman: physically local Fermionic operations are mapped into nonlocal quantum ones and viceversa. As noticed by many authors this can lead to ambiguities in defining the partial trace [16, 4, 17, 10], and in assessing