Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2303.04410 · Physical Review Research

Determining the validity of cumulant expansions for central spin models

Piper Fowler-Wright, Kristín B. Arnardóttir, Peter Kirton, Brendon W. Lovett, Jonathan Keeling

Published Sep 1, 2023• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

For a model with many-to-one connectivity it is widely expected that mean-field theory captures the exact many-particle $N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ limit, and that higher-order cumulant expansions of the Heisenberg equations converge to this same limit whilst providing improved approximations at finite $N$. Here we show that this is in fact not always the case. Instead, whether mean-field theory correctly describes the large-$N$ limit depends on how the model parameters scale with $N$, and the convergence of cumulant expansions may be nonuniform across even and odd orders. Further, even when a higher-order cumulant expansion does recover the correct limit, the error is not monotonic with $N$ and may exceed that of mean-field theory.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.5.033148

Related papers

The Phase Transition in Z(N) Potts Spin Model: An Analytical Analysis

Young-Suk Song, Iu W

We study the phase transition in Z(N) Pots spin model by an analytical approach—the generalized cumulant expansion with mean field approximation. As a test, we perform the expansion to the third order correction for Z(3), Z(4), Z(5) and Z(6) cases. The critical points turn out to be closer to the exact values when higher order corrections are taken into account.

•Jan 1, 1992•0 citations

Variational cumulant expansion for the Heisenberg model with the critical temperature determined to third order

Ruijie Liu, T. L. Chen

The variational-cumulant-expansion (VCE) method is adopted to calculate the Heisenberg model. The free energy of the model is expanded to the third order, and the analytical formulas for the critical temperature ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$ are given for each order. The first order of VCE corresponds to the mean-field theory, the second order gives the same result for ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$ as the 1/z expansion, and the third order gives a more complicated correction. As a comparison, the results of the two-dimensional (2D) Ising model for VCE to the seventh order are shown. We carry out a trial to predict the critical temperature of the infinite order of the VCE, and get a very accurate result for the 2D Ising model. A prediction of ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$ for the Heisenberg model is also made.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 1, 1994•9 citations

The Cumulant Expansion Approach: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly

Johannes Kerber, Helmut Ritsch, Laurin Ostermann

The configuration space, i.e. the Hilbert space, of compound quantum systems grows exponentially with the number of its subsystems: its dimensionality is given by the product of the dimensions of its constituents. Therefore a full quantum treatment is rarely possible analytically and can be carried out numerically for fairly small systems only. Fortunately, in order to obtain interesting physics, approximations often very well suffice. One of these approximations is given by the cumulants expansion, where expectation values of products of operators are approximated by products of expectation values of said operators, neglecting higher-order correlations. The lowest order of this approximation is widely known as the mean field approximation and used routinely throughout quantum physics. Despite its ubiquitous presence, a general criterion for applicability and convergence properties of higher order cumulants expansions remains to be found. In this paper, we discuss two problems in quantum electrodynamics and quantum information, namely the collective radiative dissipation of a dipole-dipole interacting chain of atoms and the factorization of a bi-prime by annealing in an adiabatic quantum simulator. In the first case we find smooth, convergence behavior, where the approximation performs increasingly better with higher orders, while in the latter going beyond mean field turns out useless and, even for small system sizes, we are puzzled by numerically challenging and partly non-physical solutions.

quant-pharXiv:2511.20115•Nov 26, 2025•9 citations

How to expand around mean-field theory using high-temperature expansions

Antoine Georges, Jonathan S. Yedidia

High-temperature expansions performed at a fixed-order parameter provide a simple and systematic way to derive and correct mean-field theories for statistical mechanical models. For models like spin glasses which have general couplings between spins, the authors show that these expansions generate the Thouless-Anderson-Palmer equations at low order. They explicitly calculate the corrections to TAP theory for these models. For ferromagnetic models, they show that their expansions can easily be converted into 1/d expansions around mean-field theory, where d is the number of spatial dimensions. Only a small finite number of graphs need to be calculated to generate each order in 1/d for thermodynamic quantities like free energy or magnetization. Unlike previous 1/d expansions, the expansions are valid in the low-temperature phases of the models considered. They consider alternative ways to expand around mean-field theory besides 1/d expansions. In contrast to the 1/d expansion for the critical temperature, which is presumably asymptotic, these schemes can be used to devise convergent expansions for the critical temperature. They also appear to give convergent series for thermodynamic quantities and critical exponents. They test the schemes using the spherical model, where their properties can be studied using exact expressions.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•May 1, 1991•161 citations

The cumulant expansion in renormalization group transformations: the convergence question and the dependence upon cell size

Per Chr. Hemmer, Manuel G. Velárde

The Niemeijer-van Leeuwen (1973) cumulant expansion for calculation of renormalized interactions is carried to third order for the Ising model on the triangular lattice. Kadanoff cells containing three spins are used. Five types of pair interactions and three types of four-spin interaction enter the calculations. The renormalization equations have one non-trivial fixed point. The accuracy of the result for the corresponding relevant eigenvalues is, however, less than in second order. The idea that the cumulant expansion is an asymptotic expansion has thus been given numerical support.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Oct 1, 1976•6 citations

Infinite-order cumulant expansion for spins

Michele Parrinello, Tadashi Arai

The cumulant expansion for spins developed previously is rearranged and extended up to an infinite order in perturbation. A pair of spin-deviation lines is considered as a propagator and, as an additional propagator appears and interacts with the original one, that part of the diagram is defined as a self-energy correction. All cumulant corrections are decomposed and added to the corresponding self-energy corrections, so that self-energy corrections and their cumulant corrections are automatically calculated together exactly. The contribution of a self-energy correction to a diagram depends on the geometry of the incoming and outgoing spin-deviation lines of the self-energy diagram, yielding a new type of perturbation expansion. Numerical results suggest that the nature of the spin-spin correlation in the spin-1/2 case is distinct from that in other cases and that spins behave like fermions rather than bosons in this limit.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Jul 1, 1974•41 citations
For a model with many-to-one connectivity it is widely expected that mean-field theory captures the exact many-particle N\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}N\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞ limit, and that higher-order cumulant expansions of the Heisenberg equations converge to this same limit whilst providing improved approximations at finite NNN. Here we show that this is in fact not always the case. Instead, whether mean-field theory correctly describes the large-NNN limit depends on how the model parameters scale with NNN, and the convergence of cumulant expansions may be nonuniform across even and odd orders. Further, even when a higher-order cumulant expansion does recover the correct limit, the error is not monotonic with NNN and may exceed that of mean-field theory.
The variational-cumulant-expansion (VCE) method is adopted to calculate the Heisenberg model. The free energy of the model is expanded to the third order, and the analytical formulas for the critical temperature Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​ are given for each order. The first order of VCE corresponds to the mean-field theory, the second order gives the same result for Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​ as the 1/z expansion, and the third order gives a more complicated correction. As a comparison, the results of the two-dimensional (2D) Ising model for VCE to the seventh order are shown. We carry out a trial to predict the critical temperature of the infinite order of the VCE, and get a very accurate result for the 2D Ising model. A prediction of Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​ for the Heisenberg model is also made.
The configuration space, i.e. the Hilbert space, of compound quantum systems grows exponentially with the number of its subsystems: its dimensionality is given by the product of the dimensions of its constituents. Therefore a full quantum treatment is rarely possible analytically and can be carried out numerically for fairly small systems only. Fortunately, in order to obtain interesting physics, approximations often very well suffice. One of these approximations is given by the cumulants expansion, where expectation values of products of operators are approximated by products of expectation values of said operators, neglecting higher-order correlations. The lowest order of this approximation is widely known as the mean field approximation and used routinely throughout quantum physics. Despite its ubiquitous presence, a general criterion for applicability and convergence properties of higher order cumulants expansions remains to be found. In this paper, we discuss two problems in quantum electrodynamics and quantum information, namely the collective radiative dissipation of a dipole-dipole interacting chain of atoms and the factorization of a bi-prime by annealing in an adiabatic quantum simulator. In the first case we find smooth, convergence behavior, where the approximation performs increasingly better with higher orders, while in the latter going beyond mean field turns out useless and, even for small system sizes, we are puzzled by numerically challenging and partly non-physical solutions.
High-temperature expansions performed at a fixed-order parameter provide a simple and systematic way to derive and correct mean-field theories for statistical mechanical models. For models like spin glasses which have general couplings between spins, the authors show that these expansions generate the Thouless-Anderson-Palmer equations at low order. They explicitly calculate the corrections to TAP theory for these models. For ferromagnetic models, they show that their expansions can easily be converted into 1/d expansions around mean-field theory, where d is the number of spatial dimensions. Only a small finite number of graphs need to be calculated to generate each order in 1/d for thermodynamic quantities like free energy or magnetization. Unlike previous 1/d expansions, the expansions are valid in the low-temperature phases of the models considered. They consider alternative ways to expand around mean-field theory besides 1/d expansions. In contrast to the 1/d expansion for the critical temperature, which is presumably asymptotic, these schemes can be used to devise convergent expansions for the critical temperature. They also appear to give convergent series for thermodynamic quantities and critical exponents. They test the schemes using the spherical model, where their properties can be studied using exact expressions.
The Niemeijer-van Leeuwen (1973) cumulant expansion for calculation of renormalized interactions is carried to third order for the Ising model on the triangular lattice. Kadanoff cells containing three spins are used. Five types of pair interactions and three types of four-spin interaction enter the calculations. The renormalization equations have one non-trivial fixed point. The accuracy of the result for the corresponding relevant eigenvalues is, however, less than in second order. The idea that the cumulant expansion is an asymptotic expansion has thus been given numerical support.
The cumulant expansion for spins developed previously is rearranged and extended up to an infinite order in perturbation. A pair of spin-deviation lines is considered as a propagator and, as an additional propagator appears and interacts with the original one, that part of the diagram is defined as a self-energy correction. All cumulant corrections are decomposed and added to the corresponding self-energy corrections, so that self-energy corrections and their cumulant corrections are automatically calculated together exactly. The contribution of a self-energy correction to a diagram depends on the geometry of the incoming and outgoing spin-deviation lines of the self-energy diagram, yielding a new type of perturbation expansion. Numerical results suggest that the nature of the spin-spin correlation in the spin-1/2 case is distinct from that in other cases and that spins behave like fermions rather than bosons in this limit.