Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2302.10139 · Symmetry

Reply to Perk, J.H.H. Comment on “Zhang, D. Exact Solution for Three-Dimensional Ising Model. Symmetry 2021, 13, 1837”

Degang Zhang

Published Jan 31, 2023• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this reply, I point out that the comment by Jacques H. H. Perk [...]
DOI
10.3390/sym15020375

Related papers

Comment on "Exact Solution for Three-Dimensional Ising Model" by Degang Zhang followed by Response to the Reply by Degang Zhang

Jacques H. H. Perk

We show that Zhang Degang's claimed solution of the three-dimensional Ising model [arXiv:2110.11233] has fatal irreparable errors.

arXiv:2202.03136•Dec 29, 2021•3 citations

Comment on a recent conjectured solution of the three-dimensional Ising model

Fa Yueh Wu, Barry M. McCoy, Michael Ellis Fisher +1 more

In a recent paper published in Philosophical Magazine [Z.-D. Zhang, Phil. Mag. 87 (2007) p.5309], the author advances a conjectured solution for various properties of the three-dimensional Ising model. Here, we disprove the conjecture and point out the flaws in the arguments leading to the conjectured expressions.

The Philosophical Magazine A Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics•Sep 11, 2008•27 citations

Comment on a recent conjectured solution of the three-dimensional Ising model arXiv:0705.1045

Fa Yueh Wu, Barry M. McCoy, Michael Ellis Fisher +1 more

In a recent paper published in the Philosophical Magazine [Z.-D. Zhang, Phil. Mag. 87, 5309-5419 (2007), arXiv:0705.1045], the author advances a conjectured solution for various properties of the three-dimensional Ising model. Here we disprove the conjecture and point out the flaws in the arguments leading to the conjectured expressions.

arXiv:0811.3876•Nov 24, 2008•6 citations

Rejoinder to the Response to the Comment on ‘Conjectures on exact solution of three-dimensional (3D) simple orthorhombic Ising lattices’

Jacques H. H. Perk

It is shown that the arguments in the reply of Z.-D. Zhang defending his conjectures are invalid. His conjectures have been thoroughly disproved.

arXiv:0901.2935•The Philosophical Magazine A Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics•Mar 18, 2009•8 citations

Response to the Comment on ‘Conjectures on exact solution of three-dimensional (3D) simple orthorhombic Ising lattices’

Zhang Zhi-dong

The error of Equation (15b) in my article [Z.D. Zhang, Phil. Mag. 87 (2007) p.5309] in the application of the Jordan–Wigner transformation does not affect the validity of the putative exact solution, since the solution is not derived directly from that equation. Other objections of Perk's comment [J.H.H. Perk, Phil. Mag. 89 (2009) p.761] are the same as those in Wu et al.'s comments [F.Y. Wu et al., Phil. Mag. 88 (2008) p.3093; p.3103], which do not stand on solid ground and which I have sought to refute in my previous response [Z.D. Zhang, Phil. Mag. 88 (2008) p.3097]. The conjectured solution can be utilized to understand critical phenomena in various systems, whereas the conjectures are open to rigorous proof.

arXiv:0812.0194•The Philosophical Magazine A Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics•Mar 18, 2009•14 citations

Response to arXiv:1209.0731 'Erroneous solution of three-dimensional (3D) simple orthorhombic Ising lattices' by Perk

Zhang Zhi-dong, Norman Henry March

This paper is a Response to Professor J.H.H. Perk's recent Comment (arXiv:1209.0731v1). We point out that the singularities of the reduced free energy βf, the free energy per site f and the free energy F of the 3D Ising model differ at β = 0. The rigorous proof presented in the Perk's Comment is only for the analyticity of the reduced free energy βf, which loses its definition at β = 0. Therefore, all of his objections lose the mathematical basis, which are thoroughly disproved. This means that the series expansions cannot serve as a standard for judging the correctness of the exact solution of the 3D Ising model. Furthermore, we note that there have been no comments on the topology-based approach developed by Zhang for the exact solution of the 3D Ising model. A Rejoinder to Professor J.H.H. Perk's open letter in arXiv:1209.0731v2 is added. We show that the analyticity in β of both the hard-core and Ising models is proved for β > 0, not for β = 0. Furthermore, the free energy per site f and the reduced free energy βf lose their definitions at β = 0, and thus either of them could have two different forms for high-temperature series expansions at/below infinite temperature. Three independent Virasoro algebras for 3D conformal field theory can be written within the 3+1 dimensional space (i.e., 3-sphere) with weight factors.

arXiv:1209.3247•Sep 12, 2012•4 citations
The error of Equation (15b) in my article [Z.D. Zhang, Phil. Mag. 87 (2007) p.5309] in the application of the Jordan–Wigner transformation does not affect the validity of the putative exact solution, since the solution is not derived directly from that equation. Other objections of Perk's comment [J.H.H. Perk, Phil. Mag. 89 (2009) p.761] are the same as those in Wu et al.'s comments [F.Y. Wu et al., Phil. Mag. 88 (2008) p.3093; p.3103], which do not stand on solid ground and which I have sought to refute in my previous response [Z.D. Zhang, Phil. Mag. 88 (2008) p.3097]. The conjectured solution can be utilized to understand critical phenomena in various systems, whereas the conjectures are open to rigorous proof.
This paper is a Response to Professor J.H.H. Perk's recent Comment (arXiv:1209.0731v1). We point out that the singularities of the reduced free energy βf, the free energy per site f and the free energy F of the 3D Ising model differ at β = 0. The rigorous proof presented in the Perk's Comment is only for the analyticity of the reduced free energy βf, which loses its definition at β = 0. Therefore, all of his objections lose the mathematical basis, which are thoroughly disproved. This means that the series expansions cannot serve as a standard for judging the correctness of the exact solution of the 3D Ising model. Furthermore, we note that there have been no comments on the topology-based approach developed by Zhang for the exact solution of the 3D Ising model. A Rejoinder to Professor J.H.H. Perk's open letter in arXiv:1209.0731v2 is added. We show that the analyticity in β of both the hard-core and Ising models is proved for β > 0, not for β = 0. Furthermore, the free energy per site f and the reduced free energy βf lose their definitions at β = 0, and thus either of them could have two different forms for high-temperature series expansions at/below infinite temperature. Three independent Virasoro algebras for 3D conformal field theory can be written within the 3+1 dimensional space (i.e., 3-sphere) with weight factors.