Abstract Photon Bose–Einstein condensation and photon thermalisation have been largely studied with molecular gain media in optical cavities. However, their observation with semiconductors has remained elusive despite a large body of experimental results and very well established theoretical models. In this work, these models are used to build a new theoretical framework that enables revisiting lasing to compare with photon Bose–Einstein condensation in the driven‐dissipative regime. The thermalisation figures of merit and the different experimental procedures to asses thermalization are discussed. Finally, the fluctuations of the system and their relation to the different regimes are explored.
Abstract Photon Bose–Einstein condensation and photon thermalisation have been largely studied with molecular gain media in optical cavities. However, their observation with semiconductors has remained elusive despite a large body of experimental results and very well established theoretical models. In this work, these models are used to build a new theoretical framework that enables revisiting lasing to compare with photon Bose–Einstein condensation in the driven‐dissipative regime. The thermalisation figures of merit and the different experimental procedures to asses thermalization are discussed. Finally, the fluctuations of the system and their relation to the different regimes are explored.
Abstract Many bosons can occupy a single quantum state without a limit. It is described by the quantum-mechanical Bose–Einstein statistic, which allows Bose–Einstein condensation at low temperatures and high particle densities. Photons, historically the first considered bosonic gas, were late to show this phenomenon, observed in rhodamine-filled microcavities and doped fibre cavities. These findings have raised the question of whether condensation is also common in other laser systems with potential technological applications. Here we show the Bose–Einstein condensation of photons in a broad-area vertical-cavity surface-emitting laser with a slight cavity-gain spectral detuning. We observed a Bose–Einstein condensate in the fundamental transversal optical mode at a critical phase-space density. The experimental results follow the equation of state for a two-dimensional gas of bosons in thermal equilibrium, although the extracted spectral temperatures were lower than the device’s. This is interpreted as originating from the driven-dissipative nature of the photon gas. In contrast, non-equilibrium lasing action is observed in the higher-order modes in more negatively detuned device. Our work opens the way for the potential exploration of superfluid physics of interacting photons mediated by semiconductor optical nonlinearities. It also shows great promise for enabling single-mode high-power emission from a large-aperture device.
Abstract Photon condensation in semiconductor microcavities is a transformative technique for engineering quantum states of light at room temperature by tailoring strong but incoherent light-matter interactions. While continuous-wave and electrical pumping offer exceptional prospects for miniaturized quantum photonic technologies, harnessing these requires conceptual advances in understanding non-equilibrium light-matter dynamics in semiconductors. We resolve this challenge through an ab initio quantum kinetic theory capturing how Coulomb interactions of optically excited carriers and phonon scattering mediate photon thermalization and condensation in semiconductors. Our microscopic model shows that at high carrier densities, thermalization is dominated by carrier–carrier Coulomb scattering, in clear contrast to the rovibrational relaxation that governs dye-based photon condensates. The theory predicts a rich nonequilibrium phase diagram with thermal, Bose-condensed, multimode, and lasing phases, quantitatively in agreement with recent experiments. Crucially, we identify how cavity detuning controls transitions between equilibrium and gain-dominated regimes, enabling tailored design of coherent light sources. This work thus provides the foundation for semiconductor-based quantum photonic devices operating beyond conventional laser paradigms.
Abstract Photon condensation was first experimentally realized in 2010 within a dye-filled microcavity at room temperature. Since then, interest in the field has increased significantly, as a photon Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) represents a prototypical driven-dissipative system. Here, we investigate how its inherent open nature influences the condensation process both quantitatively and qualitatively. To this end, we consider a mean-field model, which can be derived microscopically from a Lindblad master equation. The underlying rate equations depend on various external parameters such as emission and absorption rates of the dye molecules as well as the cavity photon loss rate. In steady state, we obtain an open-dissipative Bose-Einstein distribution for the mode occupations. The chemical potential of this distribution depends on the occupations of the dye molecules in both their ground and excited state and must therefore be determined self-consistently. We find that the resulting photon distribution is strongly influenced by the driven-dissipative parameters. Based on this result, we identify the main differences between a photonic BEC, an atomic BEC, and a laser.
We present a generic route to classical light condensation (LC) in linear photonic mode systems, such as cw lasers, with different grounds from regular Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC). LC is based on weighting the modes in a noisy environment (spontaneous emission, etc.) in a loss-gain scale, rather than in photon energy. It is characterized by a sharp transition from a multi- to single-mode oscillation. The study uses a linear multivariate Langevin formulation which gives a mode occupation hierarchy that functions like Bose-Einstein statistics. Condensation occurs when the spectral filtering has near the lowest-loss mode a power law dependence with exponent smaller than 1. We then discuss how condensation can occur in photon systems, its relation to lasing and the difficulties to observe regular photon-BEC in laser cavities. We raise the possibility that experiments on photon condensation in optical cavities fall in a classical LC or lasing category rather than being a thermal-quantum BEC phenomenon.
This paper provides, first, a succinct theoretical derivation of Bose-Einstein condensation in a grand-canonical ideal photon gas elaborating on previous results [M\"uller, Ann. Phys. 184, 219 (1988); Physica A (Amsterdam, Neth.) 139, 165 (1986)] additionally including new results on the condensate function and, second, applies this framework to consistently explain experimental findings on Bose-Einstein condensation of photons in an optical microcavity [Klaers, Schmitt, Vewinger, and Weitz, Nature 468, 545 (2010)]. A grand-canonical photon gas is realized by a steady state of a photon flux deviating from a canonical thermodynamic Planck equilibrium. The theoretical approach presented here invites to significantly widen the experimental framework for Bose-Einstein condensation of photons including three-dimensional photon resonators and thermalization mechanisms different from a dye medium in the cavity.
A system of identical bosons can exhibit a state of matter in which the ground state is macroscopically occupied. This special state is called Bose-Einstein condensation, and was predicted by Satyendra Nath Bose and Albert Einstein in 1924. It took some time before physicists achieved this experimentally, but in 1995 it was done by Eric Cornell and Carl Wieman. Since photons are also bosonic particles, they should be able to achieve Bose-Einstein condensation in thermal equilibrium. However this is not as easy for photons as it is for atoms, since the number of photons depends on the temperature. But in 2010 the group of Martin Weitz in Bonn was able to produce a photon Bose-Einstein condensate. This was done using a dye-filled microcavity which is optically pumped. The same principles are used in our setup. Photons inside the cavity thermalize with a fluorescent dye through multiple absorption and emission cycles. The effectively two-dimensional photon gas is trapped by a harmonic potential induced by the shape of the cavity mirrors. This results in photons with eigenenergies of the quantum harmonic oscillator. The minimal energy is determined by the cutoff frequency, set by the cavity length. The thermalization of the photon gas depends on this cutoff frequency, and the total pump power. Jonathan Keeling and Peter Kirton developed a theoretical model describing this system and its thermalization, and simulated it in one dimension.\nWe simulate the same model, in two dimensions using radially averaged photon modes. Threshold for Bose-Einstein condensation is determined for different cutoff frequencies. Our results show good agreement with those of Keeling and Kirton, below, at and above threshold. Multimode condensation and gain clamping of the molecular excitation density are observed above threshold. Comparison with experimental data can only be done qualitatively since it currently is uncalibrated.