Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2301.10699 · Communications in Mathematical Physics

Testing Quantum Satisfiability

Ashley Montanaro, Changpeng Shao, Dominic Verdon

Published Sep 1, 2025• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Quantum k-SAT (the problem of determining whether a k-local Hamiltonian is frustration-free) is known to be QMA $$_1$$ 1 -complete for $$k\ge 3$$ k ≥ 3 , and hence likely hard for quantum computers to solve. Building on a classical result of Alon and Shapira, we show that quantum k-SAT can be solved in randomised polynomial time given the ‘property testing’ promise that the instance is either satisfiable (by any state) or far from satisfiable by a product state; by ‘far from satisfiable by a product state’ we mean that $$\epsilon n^k$$ ϵ n k constraints must be removed before a product state solution exists, for some fixed $$\epsilon >0$$ ϵ > 0 . The proof has two steps: we first show that for a satisfiable instance of quantum k-SAT, most subproblems on a constant number of qubits are satisfiable by a product state. We then show that for an instance of quantum k-SAT which is far from satisfiable by a product state, most subproblems are unsatisfiable by a product state. Given the promise, quantum k-SAT may therefore be solved by checking satisfiability by a product state on randomly chosen subsystems of constant size.

DOI
10.1007/s00220-025-05377-4

Related papers

Quantum 3-SAT Is QMA$_1$-Complete

David Gosset, Daniel Nagaj

Quantum satisfiability is a constraint satisfaction problem that generalizes classical boolean satisfiability. In the quantum $k$-SAT problem, each constraint is specified by a $k$-local projector and is satisfied by any state in its nullspace. Bravyi showed that quantum 2-SAT can be solved efficiently on a classical computer and that quantum $k$-SAT with $k\geq 4$ is QMA$_1$-complete [S. Bravyi, Efficient Algorithm for a Quantum Analogue of 2-SAT, eprint arXiv:quant-ph/0602108, 2006]. Quantum 3-SAT was known to be contained in QMA$_1$ [Bravyi, 2006], but its computational hardness was unknown until now. We prove that quantum 3-SAT is QMA$_1$-hard, and therefore complete for this complexity class.

SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2016•16 citations

Efficient algorithm for a quantum analogue of 2-SAT

Sergey B. Bravyi

Complexity of a quantum analogue of the satisfiability problem is studied. Quantum k-SAT is a problem of verifying whether there exists n-qubit pure state such that its k-qubit reduced density matrices have support on prescribed subspaces. We present a classical algorithm solving quantum 2-SAT in a polynomial time. It generalizes the well-known algorithm for the classical 2-SAT. Besides, we show that for any k>=4 quantum k-SAT is complete in the complexity class QMA with one-sided error.

arXiv:quant-ph/0602108•Contemporary mathematics - American Mathematical Society•Jan 1, 2011•179 citations

On Efficiently Solvable Cases of Quantum k-SAT

Marco Aldi, Niel de Beaudrap, Sevag Gharibian +1 more

Abstract Estimating ground state energies of local Hamiltonian models is a central problem in quantum physics. The question of whether a given local Hamiltonian is frustration-free, meaning the ground state is the simultaneous ground state of all local interaction terms, is known as the Quantum k-SAT (k-QSAT) problem. In analogy to its classical Boolean constraint satisfaction counterpart, the NP-complete problem k-SAT, Quantum k-SAT is $$\hbox {QMA}_1$$ QMA 1 -complete (for $$k\ge 3$$ k ≥ 3 , and where $$\hbox {QMA}_1$$ QMA 1 is a quantum generalization of NP with one-sided error), and thus likely intractable. But whereas k-SAT has been well-studied for special tractable cases, as well as from a “parameterized complexity” perspective, much less is known in similar settings for k-QSAT. Here, we study the open problem of computing satisfying assignments to k-QSAT instances which have a “dimer covering” or “matching”; such systems are known to be frustration-free, but it remains open whether one can efficiently compute a ground state. Our results fall into three directions, all of which relate to the “dimer covering” setting: (1) We give a polynomial-time classical algorithm for k-QSAT when all qubits occur in at most two interaction terms or clauses. (2) We give a “parameterized algorithm” for k-QSAT instances from a certain non-trivial class, which allows us to obtain exponential speedups over brute force methods in some cases. This is achieved by reducing the problem to solving for a single root of a single univariate polynomial. An explicit family of hypergraphs, denoted Crash, for which such a speedup is obtained is introduced. (3) We conduct a structural graph theoretic study of 3-QSAT interaction graphs which have a “dimer covering”. We remark that the results of (2), in particular, introduce a number of new tools to the study of Quantum SAT, including graph theoretic concepts such as transfer filtrations and blow-ups from algebraic geometry.

arXiv:1712.09617•Communications in Mathematical Physics•Dec 24, 2020•7 citations

Difficult Instances of the Counting Problem for 2-quantum-SAT are Very Atypical

Niel de Beaudrap

The problem 2-QUANTUM-SATISFIABILITY (QSAT[2]) is the generalisation of the 2-CNF-SAT problem to quantum bits, and is equivalent to determining whether or not a spin-1/2 Hamiltonian with two-body terms is frustration-free. imilarly to the classical problem #SAT[2], the counting problem #QSAT[2] of determining the size (i.e. the dimension) of the set of satisfying states is #P-complete. However, if we consider random instances of QSAT[2] in which constraints are sampled from the Haar measure, intractible instances have measure zero. An apparent reason for this is that almost all two-qubit constraints are entangled, which more readily give rise to long-range constraints. We investigate under which conditions product constraints also give rise to efficiently solvable families of #QSAT[2] instances. We consider #QSAT[2] involving only discrete distributions over tensor product operators, which interpolates between classical #SAT[2] and #QSAT[2] involving arbitrary product constraints. We find that such instances of #QSAT[2], defined on Erdös-Renyi graphs or bond-percolated lattices, are asymptotically almost surely efficiently solvable except to the extent that they are biased to resemble monotone instances of #SAT[2].

arXiv:1403.1588•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2014•3 citations

Quantum 3-SAT Is QMA1-Complete

David Gosset, Daniel Nagaj

Quantum satisfiability is a constraint satisfaction problem that generalizes classical boolean satisfiability. In the quantum k-SAT problem, each constraint is specified by a k-local projector and is satisfied by any state in its nullspace. Bravyi showed that quantum 2-SAT can be solved efficiently on a classical computer and that quantum k-SAT with k ≥ 4 is QMA1-complete [4]. Quantum 3-SAT was known to be contained in QMA1[4], but its computational hardness was unknown until now. We prove that quantum 3-SAT is QMA1-hard, and therefore complete for this complexity class.

arXiv:1302.0290•Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Oct 1, 2013•63 citations

Bounds on the quantum satisfiability threshold

Sergey B. Bravyi, Cristopher Moore, Alexander C. Russell

Quantum k-SAT is the problem of deciding whether there is a n-qubit state which is perpendicular to a set of vectors, each of which lies in the Hilbert space of k qubits. Equivalently, the problem is to decide whether a particular type of local Hamiltonian has a ground state with zero energy. We consider random quantum k-SAT formulas with n variables and m = αn clauses, and ask at what value of αthese formulas cease to be satisfiable. We show that the threshold for random quantum 3-SAT is at most 3.594. For comparison, convincing arguments from statistical physics suggest that the classical 3-SAT threshold is α\approx 4.267. For larger k, we show that the quantum threshold is a constant factor smaller than the classical one. Our bounds work by determining the generic rank of the satisfying subspace for certain gadgets, and then using the technique of differential equations to analyze various algorithms that partition the hypergraph into a collection of these gadgets. Our use of differential equation to establish upper bounds on a satisfiability threshold appears to be novel, and our techniques may apply to various classical problems as well.

arXiv:0907.1297•Jul 7, 2009•32 citations
Abstract Quantum k-SAT (the problem of determining whether a k-local Hamiltonian is frustration-free) is known to be QMA 1_11​ 1 -complete for k≥3k\ge 3k≥3 k ≥ 3 , and hence likely hard for quantum computers to solve. Building on a classical result of Alon and Shapira, we show that quantum k-SAT can be solved in randomised polynomial time given the ‘property testing’ promise that the instance is either satisfiable (by any state) or far from satisfiable by a product state; by ‘far from satisfiable by a product state’ we mean that ϵnk\epsilon n^kϵnk ϵ n k constraints must be removed before a product state solution exists, for some fixed ϵ>0\epsilon >0ϵ>0 ϵ > 0 . The proof has two steps: we first show that for a satisfiable instance of quantum k-SAT, most subproblems on a constant number of qubits are satisfiable by a product state. We then show that for an instance of quantum k-SAT which is far from satisfiable by a product state, most subproblems are unsatisfiable by a product state. Given the promise, quantum k-SAT may therefore be solved by checking satisfiability by a product state on randomly chosen subsystems of constant size.
Quantum 3-SAT Is QMA1_11​-Complete
Quantum satisfiability is a constraint satisfaction problem that generalizes classical boolean satisfiability. In the quantum kkk-SAT problem, each constraint is specified by a kkk-local projector and is satisfied by any state in its nullspace. Bravyi showed that quantum 2-SAT can be solved efficiently on a classical computer and that quantum kkk-SAT with k≥4k\geq 4k≥4 is QMA1_11​-complete [S. Bravyi, Efficient Algorithm for a Quantum Analogue of 2-SAT, eprint arXiv:quant-ph/0602108, 2006]. Quantum 3-SAT was known to be contained in QMA1_11​ [Bravyi, 2006], but its computational hardness was unknown until now. We prove that quantum 3-SAT is QMA1_11​-hard, and therefore complete for this complexity class.
Abstract Estimating ground state energies of local Hamiltonian models is a central problem in quantum physics. The question of whether a given local Hamiltonian is frustration-free, meaning the ground state is the simultaneous ground state of all local interaction terms, is known as the Quantum k-SAT (k-QSAT) problem. In analogy to its classical Boolean constraint satisfaction counterpart, the NP-complete problem k-SAT, Quantum k-SAT is QMA1\hbox {QMA}_1QMA1​ QMA 1 -complete (for k≥3k\ge 3k≥3 k ≥ 3 , and where QMA1\hbox {QMA}_1QMA1​ QMA 1 is a quantum generalization of NP with one-sided error), and thus likely intractable. But whereas k-SAT has been well-studied for special tractable cases, as well as from a “parameterized complexity” perspective, much less is known in similar settings for k-QSAT. Here, we study the open problem of computing satisfying assignments to k-QSAT instances which have a “dimer covering” or “matching”; such systems are known to be frustration-free, but it remains open whether one can efficiently compute a ground state. Our results fall into three directions, all of which relate to the “dimer covering” setting: (1) We give a polynomial-time classical algorithm for k-QSAT when all qubits occur in at most two interaction terms or clauses. (2) We give a “parameterized algorithm” for k-QSAT instances from a certain non-trivial class, which allows us to obtain exponential speedups over brute force methods in some cases. This is achieved by reducing the problem to solving for a single root of a single univariate polynomial. An explicit family of hypergraphs, denoted Crash, for which such a speedup is obtained is introduced. (3) We conduct a structural graph theoretic study of 3-QSAT interaction graphs which have a “dimer covering”. We remark that the results of (2), in particular, introduce a number of new tools to the study of Quantum SAT, including graph theoretic concepts such as transfer filtrations and blow-ups from algebraic geometry.
The problem 2-QUANTUM-SATISFIABILITY (QSAT[2]) is the generalisation of the 2-CNF-SAT problem to quantum bits, and is equivalent to determining whether or not a spin-1/2 Hamiltonian with two-body terms is frustration-free. imilarly to the classical problem #SAT[2], the counting problem #QSAT[2] of determining the size (i.e. the dimension) of the set of satisfying states is #P-complete. However, if we consider random instances of QSAT[2] in which constraints are sampled from the Haar measure, intractible instances have measure zero. An apparent reason for this is that almost all two-qubit constraints are entangled, which more readily give rise to long-range constraints. We investigate under which conditions product constraints also give rise to efficiently solvable families of #QSAT[2] instances. We consider #QSAT[2] involving only discrete distributions over tensor product operators, which interpolates between classical #SAT[2] and #QSAT[2] involving arbitrary product constraints. We find that such instances of #QSAT[2], defined on Erdös-Renyi graphs or bond-percolated lattices, are asymptotically almost surely efficiently solvable except to the extent that they are biased to resemble monotone instances of #SAT[2].
Quantum satisfiability is a constraint satisfaction problem that generalizes classical boolean satisfiability. In the quantum k-SAT problem, each constraint is specified by a k-local projector and is satisfied by any state in its nullspace. Bravyi showed that quantum 2-SAT can be solved efficiently on a classical computer and that quantum k-SAT with k ≥ 4 is QMA1-complete [4]. Quantum 3-SAT was known to be contained in QMA1[4], but its computational hardness was unknown until now. We prove that quantum 3-SAT is QMA1-hard, and therefore complete for this complexity class.
Quantum k-SAT is the problem of deciding whether there is a n-qubit state which is perpendicular to a set of vectors, each of which lies in the Hilbert space of k qubits. Equivalently, the problem is to decide whether a particular type of local Hamiltonian has a ground state with zero energy. We consider random quantum k-SAT formulas with n variables and m = αn clauses, and ask at what value of αthese formulas cease to be satisfiable. We show that the threshold for random quantum 3-SAT is at most 3.594. For comparison, convincing arguments from statistical physics suggest that the classical 3-SAT threshold is α\approx 4.267. For larger k, we show that the quantum threshold is a constant factor smaller than the classical one. Our bounds work by determining the generic rank of the satisfying subspace for certain gadgets, and then using the technique of differential equations to analyze various algorithms that partition the hypergraph into a collection of these gadgets. Our use of differential equation to establish upper bounds on a satisfiability threshold appears to be novel, and our techniques may apply to various classical problems as well.