Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2212.11666 · IEEE Transactions on Information Theory

Channel Simulation: Finite Blocklengths and Broadcast Channels

Michael X. Cao, Navneeth Ramakrishnan, Mario Berta, Marco Tomamichel

Published Aug 19, 2024• 18 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study channel simulation under common randomness assistance in the finite-blocklength regime and identify the smooth channel max-information as a linear program one-shot converse on the minimal simulation cost for fixed error tolerance. We show that this one-shot converse can be achieved exactly using no-signaling-assisted codes, and approximately achieved using common randomness-assisted codes. Our one-shot converse thus takes on an analogous role to the celebrated meta-converse in the complementary problem of channel coding, and we find tight relations between these two bounds. We asymptotically expand our bounds on the simulation cost for discrete memoryless channels, leading to the second-order as well as the moderate-deviation rate expansion, which can be expressed in terms of the channel capacity and channel dispersion known from noisy channel coding. Our bounds imply the well-known fact that the optimal asymptotic rate of one channel to simulate another under common randomness assistance is given by the ratio of their respective capacities. Additionally, our higher-order asymptotic expansion shows that this reversibility falls apart in the second order. Our techniques extend to discrete memoryless broadcast channels. In stark contrast to the elusive broadcast channel capacity problem, we show that the reverse problem of broadcast channel simulation under common randomness assistance allows for an efficiently computable single-letter characterization of the asymptotic rate region in terms of the broadcast channel’s multipartite mutual information.

DOI
10.1109/tit.2024.3445998

Related papers

Fine asymptotics for approximate simulation of symmetric channels

Valentinian Lungu, Aaron B. Wagner, Ioannis Kontoyiannis

We study the approximate channel simulation problem in the normal approximation regime. Our starting point is the fact established by Cao et al.~\cite{Cao_channel_simulation}, that the minimal codebook size $M_ε^*(W)$ for a fixed error tolerance $ε>0$ is closely related to the $ε$-smooth channel max-information, $I_{\max}^ε(W)$. Using this, we refine earlier large-blocklength approximations to $M_ε^*(W^{\otimes n})$ for discrete memoryless channels. Specifically, we provide tight third-order expansions for Gallager-symmetric channels and demonstrate that the third-order term is channel-dependent. As in corresponding channel coding expansions, we identify a substantial rate gap between singular and nonsingular channels. Notably, the direction of this gap is reversed relative to channel coding: The third-order term is $-\frac{1}{2}\log n$ for singular channels but $O(\log\log n)$ for nonsingular channels.

arXiv:2610.15877•Oct 11, 2026•1 citation

Exponents for Shared Randomness-Assisted Channel Simulation

Aadil Oufkir, Michael X. Cao, Hao–Chung Cheng +1 more

We determine the exact error and strong converse exponents of shared randomness-assisted channel simulation in worst case total-variation distance. Namely, we find that these exponents can be written as simple optimizations over the R´enyi channel mutual information. Strikingly, and in stark contrast to channel coding, there are no critical rates, allowing a tight characterization for arbitrary rates below and above the simulation capacity. We derive our results by asymptotically expanding the meta-converse for channel simulation [Caoet al., IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory (2024)], which corresponds to nonsignaling assisted codes. We prove this to be asymptotically tight by employing the approximation algorithms from [Bertaet al., Proc. IEEE ISIT (2024)], which show how to round any non-signaling assisted strategy to a strategy that only uses shared randomness. Notably, this implies that any additional quantum entanglement-assistance does not change the error or the strong converse exponents.

IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Feb 16, 2026•5 citations

Quantum Channel Simulation and the Channel's Smooth Max-Information

Kun Fang, Xin Wang, Marco Tomamichel +1 more

We study the general framework of quantum channel simulation, that is, the ability of a quantum channel to simulate another one using different classes of codes. Our main results are as follows. First, we show that the minimum error of simulation under non-signalling assisted codes is efficiently computable via semidefinite programming. The cost of simulating a channel via noiseless quantum channels under non-signalling assisted codes can also be characterized as a semidefinite program. Second, we introduce the channel's smooth max-information, which can be seen as a one-shot generalization of the channel's mutual information. We show that the one-shot quantum simulation cost under non-signalling assisted codes is exactly equal to the channel's smooth max-information. Due to the quantum reverse Shannon theorem, the channel's smooth max-information converges to the channel's mutual information in the independent and identically distributed asymptotic limit. Together with earlier findings on the (activated) non-signalling assisted one-shot capacity of channels [Wang et al., arXiv:1709.05258], this suggest that the operational min- and max-type one-shot analogues of the channel's mutual information are the channel's hypothesis testing relative entropy and the channel's smooth max-information, respectively.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 1, 2018•10 citations

Quantum Channel Simulation and the Channel’s Smooth Max-Information

Kun Fang, Xin Wang, Marco Tomamichel +1 more

We study the general framework of quantum channel simulation, that is, the ability of a quantum channel to simulate another one using different classes of codes. First, we show that the minimum error of simulation and the one-shot quantum simulation cost under no-signalling assisted codes are given by semidefinite programs. Second, we introduce the channel's smooth max-information, which can be seen as a one-shot generalization of the mutual information of a quantum channel. We provide an exact operational interpretation of the channel's smooth max-information as the one-shot quantum simulation cost under no-signalling assisted codes, which significantly simplifies the study of channel simulation and provides insights and bounds for the case under entanglement-assisted codes. Third, we derive the asymptotic equipartition property of the channel's smooth max-information; i.e., it converges to the quantum mutual information of the channel in the independent and identically distributed asymptotic limit. This implies the quantum reverse Shannon theorem in the presence of no-signalling correlations. Finally, we explore the simulation cost of various quantum channels.

arXiv:1807.05354•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Sep 27, 2019•69 citations

One-Shot Multiple Access Channel Simulation

Aditya Nema, Sreejith Sreekumar, Mario Berta

We consider the problem of shared randomness-assisted multiple access channel (MAC) simulation for product inputs and characterize the one-shot communication cost region via almost-matching inner and outer bounds in terms of the smooth max-information of the channel, featuring auxiliary random variables of bounded size. The achievability relies on a rejection-sampling algorithm to simulate an auxiliary channel between each sender and the decoder, and producing the final output based on the output of these intermediate channels. The converse follows via information-spectrum based arguments. To bound the cardinality of the auxiliary random variables, we employ the perturbation method from [Anantharamet al., IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory (2019)] in the one-shot setting. For the asymptotic setting and vanishing errors, our result expands to a tight single-letter rate characterization and consequently extends a special case of the simulation results of [Kurriet al., IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory (2022)] for fixed, independent and identically distributed (iid) product inputs to universal simulation for any product inputs. We broaden our discussion into the quantum realm by studying feedback simulation of quantum-to-classical (QC) MACs with product measurements [Atifet al., IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory (2022)]. For fixed product inputs and with shared randomness assistance, we give a quasi tight one-shot communication cost region with corresponding single-letter asymptotic iid expansion.

arXiv:2410.17198•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Jan 12, 2026•0 citations

Broadcast Channel Simulation

Michael X. Cao, Navneeth Ramakrishnan, Mario Berta +1 more

We study the problem of random-assisted simulation of discrete broadcast channel in one-shot and i.i.d. setups. We derive one-shot inner and outer bounds of the set of attainable message-size pairs for simulating WYZ|Xwithin some total variation distance (TVD) tolerance of ϵ. The inner bounds are based on the bipartite convex split lemma. Whereas the outer bounds are based on the properties of the multi-partite max information. Using these bounds, we establish a single-letter expression of the simulation region of a broadcast channel.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 25, 2023•4 citations
We study channel simulation under common randomness assistance in the finite-blocklength regime and identify the smooth channel max-information as a linear program one-shot converse on the minimal simulation cost for fixed error tolerance. We show that this one-shot converse can be achieved exactly using no-signaling-assisted codes, and approximately achieved using common randomness-assisted codes. Our one-shot converse thus takes on an analogous role to the celebrated meta-converse in the complementary problem of channel coding, and we find tight relations between these two bounds. We asymptotically expand our bounds on the simulation cost for discrete memoryless channels, leading to the second-order as well as the moderate-deviation rate expansion, which can be expressed in terms of the channel capacity and channel dispersion known from noisy channel coding. Our bounds imply the well-known fact that the optimal asymptotic rate of one channel to simulate another under common randomness assistance is given by the ratio of their respective capacities. Additionally, our higher-order asymptotic expansion shows that this reversibility falls apart in the second order. Our techniques extend to discrete memoryless broadcast channels. In stark contrast to the elusive broadcast channel capacity problem, we show that the reverse problem of broadcast channel simulation under common randomness assistance allows for an efficiently computable single-letter characterization of the asymptotic rate region in terms of the broadcast channel’s multipartite mutual information.
We study the approximate channel simulation problem in the normal approximation regime. Our starting point is the fact established by Cao et al.~\cite{Cao_channel_simulation}, that the minimal codebook size Mε∗(W)M_ε^*(W)Mε∗​(W) for a fixed error tolerance ε>0ε>0ε>0 is closely related to the εεε-smooth channel max-information, Imax⁡ε(W)I_{\max}^ε(W)Imaxε​(W). Using this, we refine earlier large-blocklength approximations to Mε∗(W⊗n)M_ε^*(W^{\otimes n})Mε∗​(W⊗n) for discrete memoryless channels. Specifically, we provide tight third-order expansions for Gallager-symmetric channels and demonstrate that the third-order term is channel-dependent. As in corresponding channel coding expansions, we identify a substantial rate gap between singular and nonsingular channels. Notably, the direction of this gap is reversed relative to channel coding: The third-order term is −12log⁡n-\frac{1}{2}\log n−21​logn for singular channels but O(log⁡log⁡n)O(\log\log n)O(loglogn) for nonsingular channels.
We determine the exact error and strong converse exponents of shared randomness-assisted channel simulation in worst case total-variation distance. Namely, we find that these exponents can be written as simple optimizations over the R´enyi channel mutual information. Strikingly, and in stark contrast to channel coding, there are no critical rates, allowing a tight characterization for arbitrary rates below and above the simulation capacity. We derive our results by asymptotically expanding the meta-converse for channel simulation [Caoet al., IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory (2024)], which corresponds to nonsignaling assisted codes. We prove this to be asymptotically tight by employing the approximation algorithms from [Bertaet al., Proc. IEEE ISIT (2024)], which show how to round any non-signaling assisted strategy to a strategy that only uses shared randomness. Notably, this implies that any additional quantum entanglement-assistance does not change the error or the strong converse exponents.
We study the general framework of quantum channel simulation, that is, the ability of a quantum channel to simulate another one using different classes of codes. Our main results are as follows. First, we show that the minimum error of simulation under non-signalling assisted codes is efficiently computable via semidefinite programming. The cost of simulating a channel via noiseless quantum channels under non-signalling assisted codes can also be characterized as a semidefinite program. Second, we introduce the channel's smooth max-information, which can be seen as a one-shot generalization of the channel's mutual information. We show that the one-shot quantum simulation cost under non-signalling assisted codes is exactly equal to the channel's smooth max-information. Due to the quantum reverse Shannon theorem, the channel's smooth max-information converges to the channel's mutual information in the independent and identically distributed asymptotic limit. Together with earlier findings on the (activated) non-signalling assisted one-shot capacity of channels [Wang et al., arXiv:1709.05258], this suggest that the operational min- and max-type one-shot analogues of the channel's mutual information are the channel's hypothesis testing relative entropy and the channel's smooth max-information, respectively.
We study the general framework of quantum channel simulation, that is, the ability of a quantum channel to simulate another one using different classes of codes. First, we show that the minimum error of simulation and the one-shot quantum simulation cost under no-signalling assisted codes are given by semidefinite programs. Second, we introduce the channel's smooth max-information, which can be seen as a one-shot generalization of the mutual information of a quantum channel. We provide an exact operational interpretation of the channel's smooth max-information as the one-shot quantum simulation cost under no-signalling assisted codes, which significantly simplifies the study of channel simulation and provides insights and bounds for the case under entanglement-assisted codes. Third, we derive the asymptotic equipartition property of the channel's smooth max-information; i.e., it converges to the quantum mutual information of the channel in the independent and identically distributed asymptotic limit. This implies the quantum reverse Shannon theorem in the presence of no-signalling correlations. Finally, we explore the simulation cost of various quantum channels.
We consider the problem of shared randomness-assisted multiple access channel (MAC) simulation for product inputs and characterize the one-shot communication cost region via almost-matching inner and outer bounds in terms of the smooth max-information of the channel, featuring auxiliary random variables of bounded size. The achievability relies on a rejection-sampling algorithm to simulate an auxiliary channel between each sender and the decoder, and producing the final output based on the output of these intermediate channels. The converse follows via information-spectrum based arguments. To bound the cardinality of the auxiliary random variables, we employ the perturbation method from [Anantharamet al., IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory (2019)] in the one-shot setting. For the asymptotic setting and vanishing errors, our result expands to a tight single-letter rate characterization and consequently extends a special case of the simulation results of [Kurriet al., IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory (2022)] for fixed, independent and identically distributed (iid) product inputs to universal simulation for any product inputs. We broaden our discussion into the quantum realm by studying feedback simulation of quantum-to-classical (QC) MACs with product measurements [Atifet al., IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory (2022)]. For fixed product inputs and with shared randomness assistance, we give a quasi tight one-shot communication cost region with corresponding single-letter asymptotic iid expansion.
We study the problem of random-assisted simulation of discrete broadcast channel in one-shot and i.i.d. setups. We derive one-shot inner and outer bounds of the set of attainable message-size pairs for simulating WYZ|Xwithin some total variation distance (TVD) tolerance of ϵ. The inner bounds are based on the bipartite convex split lemma. Whereas the outer bounds are based on the properties of the multi-partite max information. Using these bounds, we establish a single-letter expression of the simulation region of a broadcast channel.