Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2211.16325 · Physical Review A

Interplay between disorder, local relaxation, and collective behavior for an ensemble of emitters outside versus inside a cavity

Zeyu Zhou, Hsing-Ta Chen, Joseph Eli Subotnik, Abraham Nitzan

Published Aug 9, 2023• 24 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The interplay between collective optical response and molecular static and dynamic disorder is studied using simple effective Hamiltonians for an ensemble of two-level emitters inside and outside a single-mode cavity. We model environmental disorder by randomly modulating the molecular transition frequencies and the coupling between the emitters and the electromagnetic field. We also consider the effects of intermolecular interactions and orientational disorder. We investigate how these effects lead to new features in the steady-state absorption (outside the cavity), transmission spectra (inside the cavity), and the yield of local molecular processes such as a unimolecular reaction. Outside the cavity, the collective behavior is manifested in the linewidth of the steady-state absorption, the emission spectrum, and the local chemical yield. Inside the cavity, however, the collective behavior primarily determines the Rabi splitting. The effects of intermolecular interactions under orientational disorder are also studied. For the most part, for all types of disorder, if we increase disorder, we find a reduction in the collective nature of the molecular response (smaller effective $N$) and therefore the Rabi splitting contraction occurs with orientational disorder. Moreover, we find that static disorder is more destructive to collective behavior than dynamic disorder.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.108.023708

Related papers

Molecular polaritonics in dense mesoscopic disordered ensembles

C. Sommer, M. Reitz, F. Mineo +1 more

We study the dependence of the vacuum Rabi splitting (VRS) on frequency disorder, vibrations, near-field effects, and density in molecular polaritonics. In the mesoscopic limit, static frequency disorder alone can already introduce a loss mechanism from polaritonic states into a dark state reservoir, which we quantitatively describe, providing an analytical scaling of the VRS with the level of disorder. Disorder additionally can split a molecular ensemble into donor-type and acceptor-type molecules and the combination of vibronic coupling, dipole-dipole interactions, and vibrational relaxation induces an incoherent FRET (F\"orster resonance energy transfer) migration of excitations within the collective molecular state. This is equivalent to a dissipative disorder and has the effect of saturating and even reducing the VRS in the mesoscopic, high-density limit. Overall, this analysis allows to quantify the crucial role played by dark states in cavity quantum electrodynamics with mesoscopic, disordered ensembles.

arXiv:2010.07155•Physical Review Research•Aug 11, 2021•38 citations

Collective dynamics of inhomogeneously broadened emitters coupled to an optical cavity with narrow linewidth

Kamanasish Debnath, Yuan Zhang, Klaus Mølmer

We study collective effects in an inhomogeneously broadened ensemble of two-level emitters coupled to an optical cavity with narrow linewidth. Using second-order mean-field theory we find that the emitters within a few times the cavity linewidth exhibit synchronous behavior and undergo collective Rabi oscillations. Under proper conditions, the synchronized oscillations give rise to a modulated intracavity field which can excite emitters detuned by many linewidths from the cavity resonance. To study the synchronization in further detail, we simplify the model and consider two ensembles and study steady-state properties when the emitters are subjected to an incoherent drive.

arXiv:1904.04877•Physical Review A•Nov 11, 2019•19 citations

A Theoretical Study of Collective Rabi Splitting in Nano-Lasers and — LEDs

Emil C. André, Игорь Евгеньевич Проценко, Alexander V. Uskov +2 more

Summary form only given. The interaction strength of light and matter can be greatly influenced by altering the environment of the emitters and the electric field. In a photonic cavity the emitter-field coupling strength may become sufficiently large that the emitters and the field can exchange an excitation multiple times before it decays, giving rise to Rabi oscillations. In a passive cavity with one (several) two-level emitter(s), this manifests itself as a (collective) Rabi splitting of the transmissions spectrum [1-3], and it has recently been shown that incoherently pumped single emitters in cavities may exhibit Rabi splitting of the emission spectrum at large coupling strengths [4,5]. We present a fully analytical model describing a large collection of incoherently pumped two-level emitters in a single-mode cavity (e.g. quantum dots in a nano-cavity) and show that collective Rabi splitting of the emission spectrum can occur in these systems as well [6]. We derive a condition in terms of system parameters for the splitting to occur, and show that this is different from the condition typically associated with strong emitter-field coupling. Moreover, we show that the collective Rabi splitting decreases with increasing pump rate P, giving a transition from the strong-coupling regime to the weak-coupling regime, and possibly lasing at large P (Fig. 1(a)).

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•Jun 1, 2019•0 citations

Nonlinear optical susceptibilities of disordered aggregates: A comparison of schemes to account for intermolecular interactions

Jasper Knoester

The performance of approximate theories for the collective nonlinear optical response of assemblies of interacting molecules is investigated by comparing their predictions to exact calculations. To this end, the nonlinear absorption coefficient of linear molecular aggregates with energetic disorder is studied with the aid of Monte Carlo simulations. It is shown that the well-known local-field approximation (LFA) cannot describe the near-resonance nonlinear absorption spectrum for disorder values up to the nearest-neighbor intermolecular interactions; surprisingly, it is found that the validity of the LFA does not at all improve with growing disorder. By contrast, the ``excitonic two-level system'' approximation, in which each collective one-photon transition (Frenkel exciton) of the assembly is treated as an independent two-level system, turns out to describe the collective nonlinear response of the aggregates in a much better way and, moreover, rapidly improves for growing disorder values. It is shown that both models correctly describe the linear optical response and that, within the framework of the LFA, a close connection exists between the rotating-wave approximation and the Heitler-London approximation.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1993•77 citations

Interplay between disorder and collective coherent response: Superradiance and spectral motional narrowing in the time domain

Hsing-Ta Chen, Zeyu Zhou, Maxim Sukharev +2 more

Typically, in molecular ensembles, the fast random modulation of transition frequencies is merely considered to result in molecular dephasing. In contrast, the authors here show that such modulation may actually recover collective superradiant emission.

arXiv:2204.02622•Physical Review A•Nov 2, 2022•31 citations

Enhanced optical nonlinearities under collective strong light-matter coupling

Raphael F. Ribeiro, Jorge A. Campos-Gonzalez-Angulo, Noel C. Giebink +2 more

Optical microcavities and metallic nanostructures have been shown to significantly modulate the dynamics and spectroscopic response of molecular systems. We present a study of the nonlinear optics of a model consisting of $N$ anharmonic multilevel systems (e.g., Morse oscillators) undergoing collective strong coupling with a resonant infrared microcavity. We find that, under experimentally accessible conditions, molecular systems in microcavities may have nonlinear phenomena significantly intensified due to the high quality of polariton resonances and the enhanced microcavity electromagnetic energy density relative to free space. Particularly large enhancement of multiphoton absorption happens when multipolariton states are resonant with bare molecule multiphoton transitions. In particular, our model predicts two-photon absorption cross-section enhancements by several orders of magnitude relative to free space when the Rabi splitting ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}_{R}$ is approximately equal to the molecular anharmonic shift $2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$. Our results provide rough upper bounds to resonant nonlinear-response enhancement factors as relaxation to dark states is treated phenomenologically. Notably, ensembles of two-level systems undergoing strong coupling with a cavity (described by the Tavis-Cummings model) show no such optical nonlinearity enhancements, highlighting the rich phenomenology afforded by multilevel anharmonic systems. Similar conclusions are expected to hold for excitonic systems that share features with our model (e.g., molecular dyes with accessible ${S}_{0}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{S}_{1}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{S}_{2}$ transitions) and strongly interact with a UV-visible cavity.

arXiv:2006.08519•Physical Review A•Jun 17, 2021•50 citations
The interplay between collective optical response and molecular static and dynamic disorder is studied using simple effective Hamiltonians for an ensemble of two-level emitters inside and outside a single-mode cavity. We model environmental disorder by randomly modulating the molecular transition frequencies and the coupling between the emitters and the electromagnetic field. We also consider the effects of intermolecular interactions and orientational disorder. We investigate how these effects lead to new features in the steady-state absorption (outside the cavity), transmission spectra (inside the cavity), and the yield of local molecular processes such as a unimolecular reaction. Outside the cavity, the collective behavior is manifested in the linewidth of the steady-state absorption, the emission spectrum, and the local chemical yield. Inside the cavity, however, the collective behavior primarily determines the Rabi splitting. The effects of intermolecular interactions under orientational disorder are also studied. For the most part, for all types of disorder, if we increase disorder, we find a reduction in the collective nature of the molecular response (smaller effective NNN) and therefore the Rabi splitting contraction occurs with orientational disorder. Moreover, we find that static disorder is more destructive to collective behavior than dynamic disorder.
We study the dependence of the vacuum Rabi splitting (VRS) on frequency disorder, vibrations, near-field effects, and density in molecular polaritonics. In the mesoscopic limit, static frequency disorder alone can already introduce a loss mechanism from polaritonic states into a dark state reservoir, which we quantitatively describe, providing an analytical scaling of the VRS with the level of disorder. Disorder additionally can split a molecular ensemble into donor-type and acceptor-type molecules and the combination of vibronic coupling, dipole-dipole interactions, and vibrational relaxation induces an incoherent FRET (F\"orster resonance energy transfer) migration of excitations within the collective molecular state. This is equivalent to a dissipative disorder and has the effect of saturating and even reducing the VRS in the mesoscopic, high-density limit. Overall, this analysis allows to quantify the crucial role played by dark states in cavity quantum electrodynamics with mesoscopic, disordered ensembles.
We study collective effects in an inhomogeneously broadened ensemble of two-level emitters coupled to an optical cavity with narrow linewidth. Using second-order mean-field theory we find that the emitters within a few times the cavity linewidth exhibit synchronous behavior and undergo collective Rabi oscillations. Under proper conditions, the synchronized oscillations give rise to a modulated intracavity field which can excite emitters detuned by many linewidths from the cavity resonance. To study the synchronization in further detail, we simplify the model and consider two ensembles and study steady-state properties when the emitters are subjected to an incoherent drive.
Summary form only given. The interaction strength of light and matter can be greatly influenced by altering the environment of the emitters and the electric field. In a photonic cavity the emitter-field coupling strength may become sufficiently large that the emitters and the field can exchange an excitation multiple times before it decays, giving rise to Rabi oscillations. In a passive cavity with one (several) two-level emitter(s), this manifests itself as a (collective) Rabi splitting of the transmissions spectrum [1-3], and it has recently been shown that incoherently pumped single emitters in cavities may exhibit Rabi splitting of the emission spectrum at large coupling strengths [4,5]. We present a fully analytical model describing a large collection of incoherently pumped two-level emitters in a single-mode cavity (e.g. quantum dots in a nano-cavity) and show that collective Rabi splitting of the emission spectrum can occur in these systems as well [6]. We derive a condition in terms of system parameters for the splitting to occur, and show that this is different from the condition typically associated with strong emitter-field coupling. Moreover, we show that the collective Rabi splitting decreases with increasing pump rate P, giving a transition from the strong-coupling regime to the weak-coupling regime, and possibly lasing at large P (Fig. 1(a)).
The performance of approximate theories for the collective nonlinear optical response of assemblies of interacting molecules is investigated by comparing their predictions to exact calculations. To this end, the nonlinear absorption coefficient of linear molecular aggregates with energetic disorder is studied with the aid of Monte Carlo simulations. It is shown that the well-known local-field approximation (LFA) cannot describe the near-resonance nonlinear absorption spectrum for disorder values up to the nearest-neighbor intermolecular interactions; surprisingly, it is found that the validity of the LFA does not at all improve with growing disorder. By contrast, the ``excitonic two-level system'' approximation, in which each collective one-photon transition (Frenkel exciton) of the assembly is treated as an independent two-level system, turns out to describe the collective nonlinear response of the aggregates in a much better way and, moreover, rapidly improves for growing disorder values. It is shown that both models correctly describe the linear optical response and that, within the framework of the LFA, a close connection exists between the rotating-wave approximation and the Heitler-London approximation.
Optical microcavities and metallic nanostructures have been shown to significantly modulate the dynamics and spectroscopic response of molecular systems. We present a study of the nonlinear optics of a model consisting of NNN anharmonic multilevel systems (e.g., Morse oscillators) undergoing collective strong coupling with a resonant infrared microcavity. We find that, under experimentally accessible conditions, molecular systems in microcavities may have nonlinear phenomena significantly intensified due to the high quality of polariton resonances and the enhanced microcavity electromagnetic energy density relative to free space. Particularly large enhancement of multiphoton absorption happens when multipolariton states are resonant with bare molecule multiphoton transitions. In particular, our model predicts two-photon absorption cross-section enhancements by several orders of magnitude relative to free space when the Rabi splitting ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}_{R}$ is approximately equal to the molecular anharmonic shift $2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$. Our results provide rough upper bounds to resonant nonlinear-response enhancement factors as relaxation to dark states is treated phenomenologically. Notably, ensembles of two-level systems undergoing strong coupling with a cavity (described by the Tavis-Cummings model) show no such optical nonlinearity enhancements, highlighting the rich phenomenology afforded by multilevel anharmonic systems. Similar conclusions are expected to hold for excitonic systems that share features with our model (e.g., molecular dyes with accessible ${S}_{0}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{S}_{1}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{S}_{2}$ transitions) and strongly interact with a UV-visible cavity.