Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2211.13267 · Physical Review A

Comparison of quantum advantage experiments using random circuit sampling

Sangchul Oh, Sabre Kais

Published Feb 13, 2023• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Random circuit sampling, the task of sampling bit strings from a random unitary operator, has been implemented to demonstrate quantum advantage on the Sycamore quantum processor with 53 qubits and on the Zuchongzhi quantum processor with 56 and 61 qubits. Recently, it was claimed that classical computers using tensor network simulation could catch on to current noisy quantum processors for random circuit sampling. While the linear cross-entropy benchmark fidelity was used to certify all these claims, it may not capture statistical properties of outputs in detail. Here, we compare the bit strings sampled from classical computers using tensor network simulation by Pan et al. [F. Pan, K. Chen, and P. Zhang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 090502 (2022)] and by Kalachev et al. [G. Kalachev, P. Panteleev, P. Zhou, and M.-H. Yung, arXiv:2112.15083] with the bit strings from the Sycamore quantum processor. It is shown that all of Kalachev et al.'s samples passed the NIST random number tests. The heat maps of bit strings show that Pan et al.'s and Kalachev et al.'s samples are quite different from the Sycamore or Zuchongzhi samples. The analysis with the Marchenko-Pastur distribution and the Wasssertein distances demonstrates that Kalachev et al.'s samples are statistically closer to the Sycamore samples than Pan et al.'s while the three datasets have similar values for the linear cross-entropy fidelity. Our finding implies that further study is needed to certify or beat the claims of quantum advantage using random circuit sampling.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.107.022610

Related papers

Statistical analysis on random quantum circuit sampling by Sycamore and Zuchongzhi quantum processors

Sangchul Oh, Sabre Kais

Random quantum circuit sampling, a task to sample bit strings from a random quantum circuit, is considered a suitable benchmark task to demonstrate the outperformance of quantum computers even with noisy qubits. Recently, random quantum circuit sampling was performed on the Sycamore quantum processor with 53 qubits [Nature (London) 574, 505 (2019)] and on the Zuchongzhi quantum processor with 56 qubits [Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 180501 (2021)]. Here, we analyze and compare the statistical properties of the outputs of the random quantum circuit sampling by the Sycamore and Zuchongzhi processors. Using the Marchenko-Pastur law of random matrices of bit strings and the Wasssertein distances between bit strings, we find that the statistical properties of Sycamore bit strings are quite different from those of Zuchongzhi bit strings, while both processors score similar values of linear cross-entropy fidelity for random circuit sampling. Some bit strings sampled by the Zuchongzhi processor pass the NIST random number tests while both Sycamore and Zuchongzhi processors show similar patterns in the heat maps of bit strings. Zuchongzhi bit strings are much closer to classical uniform random bits than those of Sycamore. It is shown that the statistical properties of bit strings of both random quantum circuits change little as the depth of the random quantum circuits increases. Our findings raise a question about the computational reliability of noisy quantum processors because two quantum processors with similar noise levels and similar qubit structures produced statistically different outputs for the same random quantum circuit sampling.

arXiv:2204.05875•Physical Review A•Sep 28, 2022•4 citations

Quantum computational advantage in random-circuit sampling on IBM superconducting quantum computers

Tigran Sedrakyan, Yuxuan Zhang, Hovnatan Karapetyan +3 more

We report forward random-circuit sampling (RCS) on the 120-qubit Nighthawk r2 superconducting processor (ibm_phoenix) with square-lattice connectivity, using 61 qubits, native CZ gates, and the standard cloud execution stack with no benchmark-specific calibration. Two independent fidelity estimators---mirror benchmarking and three- and four-patch cross-entropy benchmarking (XEB)---agree with each other at every measured depth, the mirror from 4 to 40 cycles and the patched estimators from 20 to 40 cycles, across more than two orders of magnitude of fidelity decay, and exceed the first-generation Nighthawk r1 device by more than an order of magnitude at fixed depth. The 36-cycle circuits sit at the depth where tensor-network contraction cost saturates at system size: a contraction-cost estimator validated against the published Sycamore and Zuchongzhi networks places the single-amplitude cost at $\sim$$10^{22}$ complex operations. At $F_{\mathrm{XEB}}(36)=2.3\times10^{-3}$ under favorable memory assumptions this implies $1.2\times10^{27}$ machine operations within the bounded-fidelity rejection-sampling model --- more than a century of runtime on the Frontier supercomputer --- to collect a $10^{6}$-sample ensemble, which takes only 19\,s on Nighthawk r2. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of quantum advantage for a vanilla random-circuit sampling on a commercially and broadly accessible quantum processor that most non-expert quantum computer users can easily replicate.

quant-pharXiv:2609.28657•Sep 25, 2026•0 citations

Statistical Properties of Bit Strings Sampled from Sycamore Random Quantum Circuits

Sangchul Oh, Sabre Kais

Quantum supremacy has been recently reported for random circuit sampling on the Sycamore processor with 53 qubits. Here, we analyze the statistical properties of bit strings sampled from random quantum circuits. In contrast to classical random bit strings, bit strings sampled from Sycamore random circuits give rise to heat maps with stripe patterns at specific qubits, have more bit 1 than 0, and do not pass the NIST random number tests. The difference between the Sycamore bit strings and classical random bit strings is also demonstrated by the Marchenko-Pastur distribution and the Girko circular law of random matrices. The calculation of Wasserstein distances shows that the Sycamore bit strings are farther from bit strings sampled from Haar-measure random quantum circuits than classical random bit strings. Our results show that random matrices and Wasserstein distances could be used to analyze the performance of quantum computers.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters•Aug 8, 2022•4 citations

Leapfrogging Sycamore: harnessing 1432 GPUs for 7× faster quantum random circuit sampling

Xian-He Zhao, Han-Sen Zhong, Feng Pan +10 more

ABSTRACT Random quantum circuit sampling serves as a benchmark to demonstrate quantum computational advantage. Recent progress in classical algorithms, especially those based on tensor network methods, has significantly reduced the classical simulation time and challenged the claim of first-generation quantum advantage experiments. However, in terms of generating uncorrelated samples, time to solution and energy consumption, previous classical simulation experiments still underperform the Sycamore processor. Here we report an energy-efficient classical simulation algorithm, using 1432 GPUs to simulate quantum random circuit sampling that generates uncorrelated samples with a higher linear cross-entropy score and is 7$\times$ faster than the Sycamore 53-qubit experiment. We propose a post-processing algorithm to reduce the overall complexity, and integrate state-of-the-art high-performance general-purpose GPUs to achieve two orders of lower energy consumption compared to previous works. Our work provides the first unambiguous experimental evidence to refute Sycamore’s claim of quantum advantage, and redefines the boundary of quantum computational advantage using random circuit sampling.

arXiv:2406.18889•National Science Review•Sep 12, 2024•24 citations

Redefining the Quantum Supremacy Baseline With a New Generation Sunway Supercomputer

Xin Liu, Chu Guo, Yong Liu +11 more

A major milestone in the era of noisy intermediate scale quantum computers is \textit{quantum supremacy} [Nature \textbf{574}, 505 (2019)] claimed on the Sycamore quantum processor of $53$ qubits, which can perform a random circuit sampling task within $200$ seconds while the same task is estimated to require a runtime of $10,000$ years on Summit. This record has been renewed with two recent experiments on the Zuchongzhi $2.0$ ($56$ qubits) and Zuchongzhi $2.1$ ($60$ qubits) quantum processors. On the other front of quantum supremacy comparison, there has also been continuous improvements on both the classical simulation algorithm as well as the underlying hardware. And a fair justification of the computational advantages for those quantum supremacy experiments would require to practically simulate the same problems on current top supercomputers, which is still in lack. Here we report the full-scale simulations of these problems on new generation Sunway supercomputer, based on a customized tensor network contraction algorithm. Our benchmark shows that the most challenging sampling task performed on Sycamore can be accomplished within $1$ week, thus collapsing the quantum supremacy claim of Sycamore. Additionally, we show that the XEB fidelities of the \textit{quantum supremacy circuits} with up to $14$ cycles can be verified in minutes, which also provides strong consistency check for quantum supremacy experiments. Our results redefine quantum supremacy baseline using the new generation Sunway supercomputer.

arXiv:2111.01066•Nov 1, 2021•19 citations

Classical Sampling of Random Quantum Circuits with Bounded Fidelity

Gleb Vyacheslavovich Kalachev, Pavel Panteleev, Pengfei Zhou +1 more

Random circuit sampling has become a popular means for demonstrating the superiority of quantum computers over classical supercomputers. While quantum chips are evolving rapidly, classical sampling algorithms are also getting better and better. The major challenge is to generate bitstrings exhibiting an XEB fidelity above that of the quantum chips. Here we present a classical sampling algorithm for producing the probability distribution of any given random quantum circuit, where the fidelity can be rigorously bounded. Specifically, our algorithm performs rejection sampling after the introduced very recently multi-tensor contraction algorithm. We show that the fidelity can be controlled by partially contracting the dominant paths in the tensor network and by adjusting the number of batches used in the rejection sampling. As a demonstration, we classically produced 1 million samples with the fidelity bounded by 0.2%, based on the 20-cycle circuit of the Sycamore 53-qubit quantum chip. Though this task was initially estimated to take 10,000 years on the Summit supercomputer, it took about 14.5 days using our algorithm on a relatively small cluster with 32 GPUs (Tesla V100 16GB). Furthermore, we estimate that for the Zuchongzhi 56-qubit 20-cycle circuit one can produce 1M samples with fidelity 0.066% using the Selene supercomputer with 4480 GPUs (Tesla A100 80GB) in about 4 days.

arXiv:2112.15083•Dec 30, 2021•27 citations
Random circuit sampling, the task of sampling bit strings from a random unitary operator, has been implemented to demonstrate quantum advantage on the Sycamore quantum processor with 53 qubits and on the Zuchongzhi quantum processor with 56 and 61 qubits. Recently, it was claimed that classical computers using tensor network simulation could catch on to current noisy quantum processors for random circuit sampling. While the linear cross-entropy benchmark fidelity was used to certify all these claims, it may not capture statistical properties of outputs in detail. Here, we compare the bit strings sampled from classical computers using tensor network simulation by Pan et al. [F. Pan, K. Chen, and P. Zhang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 090502 (2022)] and by Kalachev et al. [G. Kalachev, P. Panteleev, P. Zhou, and M.-H. Yung, arXiv:2112.15083] with the bit strings from the Sycamore quantum processor. It is shown that all of Kalachev et al.'s samples passed the NIST random number tests. The heat maps of bit strings show that Pan et al.'s and Kalachev et al.'s samples are quite different from the Sycamore or Zuchongzhi samples. The analysis with the Marchenko-Pastur distribution and the Wasssertein distances demonstrates that Kalachev et al.'s samples are statistically closer to the Sycamore samples than Pan et al.'s while the three datasets have similar values for the linear cross-entropy fidelity. Our finding implies that further study is needed to certify or beat the claims of quantum advantage using random circuit sampling.
Random quantum circuit sampling, a task to sample bit strings from a random quantum circuit, is considered a suitable benchmark task to demonstrate the outperformance of quantum computers even with noisy qubits. Recently, random quantum circuit sampling was performed on the Sycamore quantum processor with 53 qubits [Nature (London) 574, 505 (2019)] and on the Zuchongzhi quantum processor with 56 qubits [Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 180501 (2021)]. Here, we analyze and compare the statistical properties of the outputs of the random quantum circuit sampling by the Sycamore and Zuchongzhi processors. Using the Marchenko-Pastur law of random matrices of bit strings and the Wasssertein distances between bit strings, we find that the statistical properties of Sycamore bit strings are quite different from those of Zuchongzhi bit strings, while both processors score similar values of linear cross-entropy fidelity for random circuit sampling. Some bit strings sampled by the Zuchongzhi processor pass the NIST random number tests while both Sycamore and Zuchongzhi processors show similar patterns in the heat maps of bit strings. Zuchongzhi bit strings are much closer to classical uniform random bits than those of Sycamore. It is shown that the statistical properties of bit strings of both random quantum circuits change little as the depth of the random quantum circuits increases. Our findings raise a question about the computational reliability of noisy quantum processors because two quantum processors with similar noise levels and similar qubit structures produced statistically different outputs for the same random quantum circuit sampling.
We report forward random-circuit sampling (RCS) on the 120-qubit Nighthawk r2 superconducting processor (ibm_phoenix) with square-lattice connectivity, using 61 qubits, native CZ gates, and the standard cloud execution stack with no benchmark-specific calibration. Two independent fidelity estimators---mirror benchmarking and three- and four-patch cross-entropy benchmarking (XEB)---agree with each other at every measured depth, the mirror from 4 to 40 cycles and the patched estimators from 20 to 40 cycles, across more than two orders of magnitude of fidelity decay, and exceed the first-generation Nighthawk r1 device by more than an order of magnitude at fixed depth. The 36-cycle circuits sit at the depth where tensor-network contraction cost saturates at system size: a contraction-cost estimator validated against the published Sycamore and Zuchongzhi networks places the single-amplitude cost at ∼\sim∼102210^{22}1022 complex operations. At FXEB(36)=2.3×10−3F_{\mathrm{XEB}}(36)=2.3\times10^{-3}FXEB​(36)=2.3×10−3 under favorable memory assumptions this implies 1.2×10271.2\times10^{27}1.2×1027 machine operations within the bounded-fidelity rejection-sampling model --- more than a century of runtime on the Frontier supercomputer --- to collect a 10610^{6}106-sample ensemble, which takes only 19\,s on Nighthawk r2. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of quantum advantage for a vanilla random-circuit sampling on a commercially and broadly accessible quantum processor that most non-expert quantum computer users can easily replicate.
Quantum supremacy has been recently reported for random circuit sampling on the Sycamore processor with 53 qubits. Here, we analyze the statistical properties of bit strings sampled from random quantum circuits. In contrast to classical random bit strings, bit strings sampled from Sycamore random circuits give rise to heat maps with stripe patterns at specific qubits, have more bit 1 than 0, and do not pass the NIST random number tests. The difference between the Sycamore bit strings and classical random bit strings is also demonstrated by the Marchenko-Pastur distribution and the Girko circular law of random matrices. The calculation of Wasserstein distances shows that the Sycamore bit strings are farther from bit strings sampled from Haar-measure random quantum circuits than classical random bit strings. Our results show that random matrices and Wasserstein distances could be used to analyze the performance of quantum computers.
ABSTRACT Random quantum circuit sampling serves as a benchmark to demonstrate quantum computational advantage. Recent progress in classical algorithms, especially those based on tensor network methods, has significantly reduced the classical simulation time and challenged the claim of first-generation quantum advantage experiments. However, in terms of generating uncorrelated samples, time to solution and energy consumption, previous classical simulation experiments still underperform the Sycamore processor. Here we report an energy-efficient classical simulation algorithm, using 1432 GPUs to simulate quantum random circuit sampling that generates uncorrelated samples with a higher linear cross-entropy score and is 7×\times× faster than the Sycamore 53-qubit experiment. We propose a post-processing algorithm to reduce the overall complexity, and integrate state-of-the-art high-performance general-purpose GPUs to achieve two orders of lower energy consumption compared to previous works. Our work provides the first unambiguous experimental evidence to refute Sycamore’s claim of quantum advantage, and redefines the boundary of quantum computational advantage using random circuit sampling.
A major milestone in the era of noisy intermediate scale quantum computers is \textit{quantum supremacy} [Nature \textbf{574}, 505 (2019)] claimed on the Sycamore quantum processor of 535353 qubits, which can perform a random circuit sampling task within 200200200 seconds while the same task is estimated to require a runtime of 10,00010,00010,000 years on Summit. This record has been renewed with two recent experiments on the Zuchongzhi 2.02.02.0 (565656 qubits) and Zuchongzhi 2.12.12.1 (606060 qubits) quantum processors. On the other front of quantum supremacy comparison, there has also been continuous improvements on both the classical simulation algorithm as well as the underlying hardware. And a fair justification of the computational advantages for those quantum supremacy experiments would require to practically simulate the same problems on current top supercomputers, which is still in lack. Here we report the full-scale simulations of these problems on new generation Sunway supercomputer, based on a customized tensor network contraction algorithm. Our benchmark shows that the most challenging sampling task performed on Sycamore can be accomplished within 111 week, thus collapsing the quantum supremacy claim of Sycamore. Additionally, we show that the XEB fidelities of the \textit{quantum supremacy circuits} with up to 141414 cycles can be verified in minutes, which also provides strong consistency check for quantum supremacy experiments. Our results redefine quantum supremacy baseline using the new generation Sunway supercomputer.
Random circuit sampling has become a popular means for demonstrating the superiority of quantum computers over classical supercomputers. While quantum chips are evolving rapidly, classical sampling algorithms are also getting better and better. The major challenge is to generate bitstrings exhibiting an XEB fidelity above that of the quantum chips. Here we present a classical sampling algorithm for producing the probability distribution of any given random quantum circuit, where the fidelity can be rigorously bounded. Specifically, our algorithm performs rejection sampling after the introduced very recently multi-tensor contraction algorithm. We show that the fidelity can be controlled by partially contracting the dominant paths in the tensor network and by adjusting the number of batches used in the rejection sampling. As a demonstration, we classically produced 1 million samples with the fidelity bounded by 0.2%, based on the 20-cycle circuit of the Sycamore 53-qubit quantum chip. Though this task was initially estimated to take 10,000 years on the Summit supercomputer, it took about 14.5 days using our algorithm on a relatively small cluster with 32 GPUs (Tesla V100 16GB). Furthermore, we estimate that for the Zuchongzhi 56-qubit 20-cycle circuit one can produce 1M samples with fidelity 0.066% using the Selene supercomputer with 4480 GPUs (Tesla A100 80GB) in about 4 days.