Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2211.05074 · Physical review. E

Flexible class of exact Hubbard-Stratonovich transformations

Seher Karakuzu, Benjamin Cohen-Stead, Cristian D. Batista, Steven Johnston, Kipton M. Barros

Published May 4, 2023• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider a class of Hubbard-Stratonovich transformations suitable for treating Hubbard interactions in the context of quantum Monte Carlo simulations. A tunable parameter p allows us to continuously vary from a discrete Ising auxiliary field (p=∞) to a compact auxiliary field that couples to electrons sinusoidally (p=0). In tests on the single-band square and triangular Hubbard models, we find that the severity of the sign problem decreases systematically with increasing p. Selecting p finite, however, enables continuous sampling methods such as the Langevin or Hamiltonian Monte Carlo methods. We explore the tradeoffs between various simulation methods through numerical benchmarks.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.107.055301

Related papers

Benchmark study of an auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo technique for the Hubbard model with shifted-discrete Hubbard-Stratonovich transformations

Kazuhiro Seki, Sandro Sorella

Within the ground-state auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo technique, we introduce discrete Hubbard-Stratonovich transformations (HSTs) that are also suitable for spatially inhomogeneous trial functions. The discrete auxiliary fields introduced here are coupled to local spin or charge operators fluctuating around their Hartree-Fock values. The formalism can be considered a generalization of the discrete HSTs by J. E. Hirsch [Phys. Rev. B 28, 4059 (1983)] or a compactification of the shifted-contour auxiliary-field Monte Carlo formalism by N. Rom et al. [Chem. Phys. Lett. 270, 382 (1997)]. An improvement of the acceptance ratio is found for a real auxiliary field, while an improvement of the average sign is found for a purely imaginary auxiliary field. Efficiencies of the different HSTs are tested in the single-band Hubbard model at and away from half filling by studying the staggered magnetization and energy expectation values, respectively.

arXiv:1902.00321•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 8, 2019•11 citations

AUXILIARY FIELDS AND THE SIGN PROBLEM

J. H. Samson

The auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo method is reviewed. The Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation converts an interacting Hamiltonian into a non-interacting Hamiltonian in a time-dependent stochastic field, allowing calculation of the resulting functional integral by Monte Carlo methods. The method is presented in a sufficiently general form to be applicable to any Hamiltonian with one- and two-body terms, with special reference to the Heisenberg model and one- and many-band Hubbard models. Many physical correlation functions can be related to correlation functions of the auxiliary field; general results are given here. Issues relating to the choice of auxiliary fields are addressed; operator product identities change the relative dimensionalities of the attractive and repulsive parts of the interaction. Frequently the integrand is not positive-definite, rendering numerical evaluation unstable. If the auxiliary field violates time-reversal invariance, the integrand is complex and this sign problem becomes a phase problem. The origin of this sign or phase is examined from a number of geometrical and other viewpoints and illustrated by simple examples: the phase problem by the spin (1/2) Heisenberg model, and the sign problem by the attractive SU(N) Hubbard model on a triangular molecule with negative hopping integrals. In the latter case, widely studied in the Jahn-Teller literature, the sign is due neither to fermions nor spin, but to frustration. This system is used to illustrate a number of suggested interpretations of the sign problem.

International Journal of Modern Physics C•Jun 1, 1995•4 citations

Benchmark study of the two-dimensional Hubbard model with auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo method

Mingpu Qin, Hao Shi, Shiwei Zhang

Ground-state properties of the Hubbard model on a two-dimensional square lattice are studied by the auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo method. Accurate results for energy, double occupancy, effective hopping, magnetization, and momentum distribution are calculated for interaction strengths of $U/t$ from 2 to 8, for a range of densities including half-filling and $n=0.3,0.5,0.6,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}0.75$, and $0.875$. At half-filling, the results are numerically exact. Away from half-filling, the constrained path Monte Carlo method is employed to control the sign problem. Our results are obtained with several advances in the computational algorithm, which are described in detail. We discuss the advantages of generalized Hartree-Fock trial wave functions and its connection to pairing wave functions, as well as the interplay with different forms of Hubbard-Stratonovich decompositions. We study the use of different twist angle sets when applying the twist averaged boundary conditions. We propose the use of quasirandom sequences, which improves the convergence to the thermodynamic limit over pseudorandom and other sequences. With it and a careful finite size scaling analysis, we are able to obtain accurate values of ground-state properties in the thermodynamic limit. Detailed results for finite-sized systems up to $16\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}16$ are also provided for benchmark purposes.

arXiv:1605.09421•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 4, 2016•112 citations

Flow-Based Generative Sampling for the Auxiliary-Field Hubbard Model

Dominic Schuh

Understanding strongly correlated electron systems remains one of the central challenges in condensed matter physics. Finding ab initio descriptions of non-perturbative systems is of great importance for modeling carbon-based materials such as graphene or fullerenes. In this regime, computational methods become indispensable tools for performing simulations, making predictions, and ultimately comparing to experiments. The Hubbard model offers a minimal description of the dynamics of electrons in such materials. As exact methods are limited to small system sizes by the exponentially growing Hilbert space, larger-scale first-principle studies rely on numerical approaches. Alongside powerful Hamiltonian-based methods, the auxiliary-field description of the model offers a natural setting for Lagrangian-based Monte Carlo sampling. However, substantial challenges, such as lack of ergodicity and the numerical sign problem, arise in these approaches, leading to long autocorrelation times, biased results, and large statistical uncertainties. In recent years, generative models, especially normalizing flows, have been applied extensively to various theories to address shortcomings of traditional Monte Carlo-based algorithms, such as critical slowing down or topological freezing. While these approaches have shown promise in alleviating these issues, a poorly understood and unfavorable scaling of these methods has stalled their progress, and whether they can reach state-of-the-art system sizes in lattice quantum chromodynamics remains to be seen. This motivates the application of these methods to condensed matter systems, where physically relevant system sizes are reachable at substantially smaller scales. In this work, we study for the first time the application of generative models to the finite-temperature auxiliary-field Hubbard model. We begin by employing an equivariant normalizing flow that respects multiple symmetries inherent to the Boltzmann distribution, demonstrating a substantial improvement in sampling efficiency over Hybrid Monte Carlo and standard non-equivariant flows. We further develop Symmetry-Enforcing Stochastic Modulation (SESaMo), a more scalable algorithm capable of modeling both exact and broken symmetries in normalizing flows, and show that it achieves significantly higher effective sample sizes than traditional equivariant techniques at large system sizes. Equipped with SESaMo, we compute physical observables at half-filling in excellent agreement with exact diagonalization at substantially lower computational cost than Hybrid Monte Carlo. We then turn to the doped Hubbard model, where the theory exhibits a numerical sign problem. We introduce an annealing scheme to simulate the Hubbard model at finite chemical potential in the spin basis. Making use of the less severe sign problem in this description, the annealing scheme enables ergodic sampling of the multi-modal distribution, yielding more accurate results with substantially reduced uncertainties compared to state-of-the-art optimized Hybrid Monte Carlo. Lastly, we employ a masked autoencoder for distribution estimation to learn the Boltzmann distribution of the discrete auxiliary-field Hubbard model. Preliminary results show a significantly higher effective sample size compared to normalizing flows with continuous degrees of freedom, while also exhibiting a milder sign problem than the continuous spin basis.

•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations

QUANTUM MONTE CARLO SIMULATION BY AUXILIARY FIELDS

Sandro Sorella

The ground state properties of a many body hamiltonian H can be calculated by a recently developed technique, known as “the Projection Quantum Monte Carlo method”. Instead of simulating the many body system at finite temperature, one attempts to reach the zero temperature limit by applying to a trial wavefunction, suitably chosen, a many body propagator e − Ht . For large enough t - t playing a role of an effective inverse temperature- the ground state component of the trial state is filtered out usually much faster than the corresponding finite temperature method. The Hubbard Stratonovich transformation allows to formulate the many body propagation of the trial state as that of sampling a distribution. This distribution is constructed by propagating the trial wavefunction under the influence of a one-body time dependent external field. However this distribution may be not positive definite, especially for large t , and serious problems occur when the average sign of the distribution is too small. We introduce a symmetric Hubbard Stratonovich transformation that in principle may solve this problem with large enough computer time. We also discuss how to apply the “Projection Quantum Monte Carlo” technique to the infinite U Hubbard model in a simple way.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Dec 1, 1993•0 citations

Long-range interactions in auxiliary-field many-electron calculations

Donald R. Hamann, Stephen Fahy

The ground-state projection version of the Hubbard-Stratonovich auxiliary-field simulation method has been extended to Hubbard-style models with arbitrary range interactions between pairs of sites. For repulsive interactions, a transformation based on three auxiliary fields per site performs comparably to the usual single-field approach for local interactions. These fields have unit-variance Gaussian distributions, and couple to the number operators on each site through several matrices calculated from the original pairwise interaction matrix. Tests of this approach have been performed on small clusters of sites representing highly simplified models of atoms and molecules. Our recently introduced ``positive-projection'' approximation remains effective in controlling the ``sign problem.'' Comparisons to exact diagonalization demonstrate that accurate energies and correlation functions are obtained using this approach.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 15, 1993•5 citations
We consider a class of Hubbard-Stratonovich transformations suitable for treating Hubbard interactions in the context of quantum Monte Carlo simulations. A tunable parameter p allows us to continuously vary from a discrete Ising auxiliary field (p=∞) to a compact auxiliary field that couples to electrons sinusoidally (p=0). In tests on the single-band square and triangular Hubbard models, we find that the severity of the sign problem decreases systematically with increasing p. Selecting p finite, however, enables continuous sampling methods such as the Langevin or Hamiltonian Monte Carlo methods. We explore the tradeoffs between various simulation methods through numerical benchmarks.
Within the ground-state auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo technique, we introduce discrete Hubbard-Stratonovich transformations (HSTs) that are also suitable for spatially inhomogeneous trial functions. The discrete auxiliary fields introduced here are coupled to local spin or charge operators fluctuating around their Hartree-Fock values. The formalism can be considered a generalization of the discrete HSTs by J. E. Hirsch [Phys. Rev. B 28, 4059 (1983)] or a compactification of the shifted-contour auxiliary-field Monte Carlo formalism by N. Rom et al. [Chem. Phys. Lett. 270, 382 (1997)]. An improvement of the acceptance ratio is found for a real auxiliary field, while an improvement of the average sign is found for a purely imaginary auxiliary field. Efficiencies of the different HSTs are tested in the single-band Hubbard model at and away from half filling by studying the staggered magnetization and energy expectation values, respectively.
The auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo method is reviewed. The Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation converts an interacting Hamiltonian into a non-interacting Hamiltonian in a time-dependent stochastic field, allowing calculation of the resulting functional integral by Monte Carlo methods. The method is presented in a sufficiently general form to be applicable to any Hamiltonian with one- and two-body terms, with special reference to the Heisenberg model and one- and many-band Hubbard models. Many physical correlation functions can be related to correlation functions of the auxiliary field; general results are given here. Issues relating to the choice of auxiliary fields are addressed; operator product identities change the relative dimensionalities of the attractive and repulsive parts of the interaction. Frequently the integrand is not positive-definite, rendering numerical evaluation unstable. If the auxiliary field violates time-reversal invariance, the integrand is complex and this sign problem becomes a phase problem. The origin of this sign or phase is examined from a number of geometrical and other viewpoints and illustrated by simple examples: the phase problem by the spin (1/2) Heisenberg model, and the sign problem by the attractive SU(N) Hubbard model on a triangular molecule with negative hopping integrals. In the latter case, widely studied in the Jahn-Teller literature, the sign is due neither to fermions nor spin, but to frustration. This system is used to illustrate a number of suggested interpretations of the sign problem.
Ground-state properties of the Hubbard model on a two-dimensional square lattice are studied by the auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo method. Accurate results for energy, double occupancy, effective hopping, magnetization, and momentum distribution are calculated for interaction strengths of U/tU/tU/t from 2 to 8, for a range of densities including half-filling and n=0.3,0.5,0.6,0.75n=0.3,0.5,0.6,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}0.75n=0.3,0.5,0.6,0.75, and 0.8750.8750.875. At half-filling, the results are numerically exact. Away from half-filling, the constrained path Monte Carlo method is employed to control the sign problem. Our results are obtained with several advances in the computational algorithm, which are described in detail. We discuss the advantages of generalized Hartree-Fock trial wave functions and its connection to pairing wave functions, as well as the interplay with different forms of Hubbard-Stratonovich decompositions. We study the use of different twist angle sets when applying the twist averaged boundary conditions. We propose the use of quasirandom sequences, which improves the convergence to the thermodynamic limit over pseudorandom and other sequences. With it and a careful finite size scaling analysis, we are able to obtain accurate values of ground-state properties in the thermodynamic limit. Detailed results for finite-sized systems up to $16\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}16$ are also provided for benchmark purposes.
Understanding strongly correlated electron systems remains one of the central challenges in condensed matter physics. Finding ab initio descriptions of non-perturbative systems is of great importance for modeling carbon-based materials such as graphene or fullerenes. In this regime, computational methods become indispensable tools for performing simulations, making predictions, and ultimately comparing to experiments. The Hubbard model offers a minimal description of the dynamics of electrons in such materials. As exact methods are limited to small system sizes by the exponentially growing Hilbert space, larger-scale first-principle studies rely on numerical approaches. Alongside powerful Hamiltonian-based methods, the auxiliary-field description of the model offers a natural setting for Lagrangian-based Monte Carlo sampling. However, substantial challenges, such as lack of ergodicity and the numerical sign problem, arise in these approaches, leading to long autocorrelation times, biased results, and large statistical uncertainties. In recent years, generative models, especially normalizing flows, have been applied extensively to various theories to address shortcomings of traditional Monte Carlo-based algorithms, such as critical slowing down or topological freezing. While these approaches have shown promise in alleviating these issues, a poorly understood and unfavorable scaling of these methods has stalled their progress, and whether they can reach state-of-the-art system sizes in lattice quantum chromodynamics remains to be seen. This motivates the application of these methods to condensed matter systems, where physically relevant system sizes are reachable at substantially smaller scales. In this work, we study for the first time the application of generative models to the finite-temperature auxiliary-field Hubbard model. We begin by employing an equivariant normalizing flow that respects multiple symmetries inherent to the Boltzmann distribution, demonstrating a substantial improvement in sampling efficiency over Hybrid Monte Carlo and standard non-equivariant flows. We further develop Symmetry-Enforcing Stochastic Modulation (SESaMo), a more scalable algorithm capable of modeling both exact and broken symmetries in normalizing flows, and show that it achieves significantly higher effective sample sizes than traditional equivariant techniques at large system sizes. Equipped with SESaMo, we compute physical observables at half-filling in excellent agreement with exact diagonalization at substantially lower computational cost than Hybrid Monte Carlo. We then turn to the doped Hubbard model, where the theory exhibits a numerical sign problem. We introduce an annealing scheme to simulate the Hubbard model at finite chemical potential in the spin basis. Making use of the less severe sign problem in this description, the annealing scheme enables ergodic sampling of the multi-modal distribution, yielding more accurate results with substantially reduced uncertainties compared to state-of-the-art optimized Hybrid Monte Carlo. Lastly, we employ a masked autoencoder for distribution estimation to learn the Boltzmann distribution of the discrete auxiliary-field Hubbard model. Preliminary results show a significantly higher effective sample size compared to normalizing flows with continuous degrees of freedom, while also exhibiting a milder sign problem than the continuous spin basis.
The ground state properties of a many body hamiltonian H can be calculated by a recently developed technique, known as “the Projection Quantum Monte Carlo method”. Instead of simulating the many body system at finite temperature, one attempts to reach the zero temperature limit by applying to a trial wavefunction, suitably chosen, a many body propagator e − Ht . For large enough t - t playing a role of an effective inverse temperature- the ground state component of the trial state is filtered out usually much faster than the corresponding finite temperature method. The Hubbard Stratonovich transformation allows to formulate the many body propagation of the trial state as that of sampling a distribution. This distribution is constructed by propagating the trial wavefunction under the influence of a one-body time dependent external field. However this distribution may be not positive definite, especially for large t , and serious problems occur when the average sign of the distribution is too small. We introduce a symmetric Hubbard Stratonovich transformation that in principle may solve this problem with large enough computer time. We also discuss how to apply the “Projection Quantum Monte Carlo” technique to the infinite U Hubbard model in a simple way.
The ground-state projection version of the Hubbard-Stratonovich auxiliary-field simulation method has been extended to Hubbard-style models with arbitrary range interactions between pairs of sites. For repulsive interactions, a transformation based on three auxiliary fields per site performs comparably to the usual single-field approach for local interactions. These fields have unit-variance Gaussian distributions, and couple to the number operators on each site through several matrices calculated from the original pairwise interaction matrix. Tests of this approach have been performed on small clusters of sites representing highly simplified models of atoms and molecules. Our recently introduced ``positive-projection'' approximation remains effective in controlling the ``sign problem.'' Comparisons to exact diagonalization demonstrate that accurate energies and correlation functions are obtained using this approach.