Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2211.02042 · The Journal of Chemical Physics

Comparison of Matsubara dynamics with exact quantum dynamics for an oscillator coupled to a dissipative bath

Adam Přáda, Eszter S. Pós, Stuart C. Althorpe

Published Mar 15, 2023• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We report the first numerical calculations in which converged Matsubara dynamics is compared directly with exact quantum dynamics with no artificial damping of the time-correlation functions (TCFs). The system treated is a Morse oscillator coupled to a harmonic bath. We show that, when the system-bath coupling is sufficiently strong, the Matsubara calculations can be converged by explicitly including up to M = 200 Matsubara modes, with the remaining modes included as a harmonic "tail" correction. The resulting Matsubara TCFs are in near-perfect agreement with the exact quantum TCFs, for non-linear as well as linear operators, at a temperature at which the TCFs are dominated by quantum thermal fluctuations. These results provide compelling evidence that incoherent classical dynamics can arise in the condensed phase at temperatures at which the statistics are dominated by quantum (Boltzmann) effects, as a result of smoothing of imaginary-time Feynman paths. The techniques developed here may also lead to efficient methods for benchmarking system-bath dynamics in the overdamped regime.

DOI
10.1063/5.0138250

Related papers

Matsubara Dynamics for Open Quantum Systems

William Moore

We develop an exact quantum thermostat that generates the quantum Boltzmann distribution in path integral phase space and so correctly captures the imaginary position–momentum correlations. This extends beyond the capability of existing quantum thermostats such as the PILE thermostat, which can only achieve the marginal of this distribution in position, with the momentum acting purely as a sampling tool and satisfying classical Maxwell–Boltzmann statistics. The dynamics correspond to the treatment of the Caldeira–Leggett system–bath model with Matsubara dynamics, a theory for approximating nuclear quantum dynamics by propagating smooth imaginary-time Feynman paths in real time. A Matsubara generalised Langevin equation that obeys certain quantum fluctuation–dissipation relations is mapped onto a Markovian stochastic process by introducing auxiliary variables; this allows the construction of a corresponding Fokker–Planck equation from which the stationary distribution in the extended variable space is determined. We show that this corresponds to the joint quantum Boltzmann distribution in position and momentum, a finding that holds for any bath spectral density and for anharmonic systems. The sole approximation in Matsubara dynamics is the neglect of real-time quantum coherence; consequently, provided there is sufficient quantum decoherence, the dynamics of the exact quantum thermostat also well approximates the exact quantum dynamics of the system–bath. In the limit of infinite system–bath coupling, the level of real-time coherence becomes negligible and so the Matsubara dynamics of the thermostat tends to the exact dynamics. The quantum thermostat can therefore be used to study this limit exactly and, in so doing, we demonstrate the existence of a quantum mechanical overdamped regime analogous to its classical counterpart that is characterised by a Matsubara Smoluchowski equation. The drawback of the quantum thermostat is that one of its associated quantum fluctuation–dissipation relations is imaginary. This results in complex noise and dynamical instabilities that often preclude the numerical implementation of the thermostat. Instead, it primarily serves as a theoretical framework that can be used as a starting point for introducing approximations that yield more practical methods. One such approximation that results in real noise is considered here and leads to a practical approach for calculating linear time-correlation functions of bound open quantum systems. These exhibit good agreement with exact quantum mechanical calculations, particularly at strong system–bath coupling, where the real-time quantum coherence is increasingly suppressed.

•Sep 30, 2025•0 citations

Equilibrating continuous-variable open quantum systems using stochastic classical trajectories in path-integral space

William H. D. Moore, Stuart C. Althorpe

Beyond the weak-coupling limit, open quantum systems equilibrate to a highly entangled thermal state. For continuous-variable systems, this state can be written explicitly as an imaginary-time phase-space path integral, in which the positions are directly entangled with the bath, and the momenta are correlated with the positions through a phase term. Here, we ask to what extent this state can be reached by propagating stochastic classical trajectories in path-integral phase space. Surprisingly, we find that the trajectories equilibrate to the exact quantum equilibrium state, recovering the purely imaginary momentum-position correlation in the phase term. The trajectories are generated using a recently derived Matsubara generalized Langevin equation, which produces the imaginary correlations by evolving the stochastic variables into the complex plane. This makes the dynamics numerically unstable, but we are nonetheless able to demonstrate the equilibration of a quartic oscillator coupled to a white-noise bath. These unexpected findings could lead to new approximate methodologies for simulating continuous-variable open quantum systems.

quant-pharXiv:2606.10665•Jun 10, 2026•0 citations

Multi-time formulation of Matsubara dynamics

Kenneth A. Jung, Pablo E. Videla, Víctor S. Batista

Matsubara dynamics has recently emerged as the most general form of a quantum-Boltzmann-conserving classical dynamics theory for the calculation of single-time correlation functions. Here, we present a generalization of Matsubara dynamics for the evaluation of multitime correlation functions. We first show that the Matsubara approximation can also be used to approximate the two-time symmetrized double Kubo transformed correlation function. By a straightforward extension of these ideas to the multitime realm, a multitime Matsubara dynamics approximation can be obtained for the multitime fully symmetrized Kubo transformed correlation function. Although not a practical method, due to the presence of a phase-term, this multitime formulation of Matsubara dynamics represents a benchmark theory for future development of Boltzmann preserving semiclassical approximations to general higher order multitime correlation functions. It also reveals a connection between imaginary time-ordering in the path integral and the classical dynamics of multitime correlation functions.

arXiv:1810.01840•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 16, 2019•17 citations

Exploiting the path-integral radius of gyration in open quantum dynamics

Andrew C. Hunt, Stuart C. Althorpe

A major challenge in open quantum dynamics is the inclusion of Matsubara-decay terms in the memory kernel, which arise from the quantum-Boltzmann delocalisation of the bath modes. This delocalisation can be quantified by the radius of gyration squared ${\mathcal R}^2(ω)$ of the imaginary-time Feynman paths of the bath modes as a function of the frequency $ω$. In a Hierarchical Equations of Motion (HEOM) calculation with a Debye--Drude spectral density, ${\mathcal R}^2(ω)$ is the only quantity that is treated approximately (assuming convergence with respect to hierarchy depth). Here, we show that the well-known Ishizaki--Tanimura correction is equivalent to separating smooth from `Brownian' contributions to ${\mathcal R}^2(ω)$, and that modifying the correction leads to a more efficient HEOM in the case of fast baths. We also develop a simple `A4' adaptation of the `AAA' (Adaptive Antoulas--Anderson) algorithm in order to fit ${\mathcal R}^2(ω)$ to a sum over poles, which results in an extremely efficient implementation of the standard HEOM method at low temperatures.

quant-pharXiv:2602.14647•Feb 17, 2026•0 citations

Exact results for a damped quantum-mechanical harmonic oscillator

Peter S. Riseborough, Peter Hänggi A, Ulrich Weiß

Exact calculations for a quantum oscillator linearly coupled to a thermal reservoir are presented. Explicit results (variances and correlations) for the response and the spontaneous fluctuations are evaluated for two different models of the heat bath; a reservoir with a spectrum which is similar to that of acoustic phonons and another which is analogous to optic phonons. The low-temperature behavior is shown to depend sensitively on the spectral density of the thermal reservoir. The mass and the frequency of the oscillator become renormalized through the coupling to the bath. These renormalizations are intrinsically frequency dependent. Moreover, the commonly used form of Ehrenfest's equation for the dynamics of the linearly damped oscillator is shown to only be a reasonable approximation within certain frequency regimes.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1985•130 citations

A novel method for simulating quantum dissipative systems

Jianshu Cao, Lowell W. Ungar, Gregory A. Voth

An effective and flexible numerical scheme is proposed to simulate the dissipative quantum dynamics of a linearized system–bath Hamiltonian. Based on the observation that the Feynman path integrals for a Gaussian bath have a quadratic functional form, the bath average can be performed by directly sampling paths of the discretized harmonic modes and then propagating the system under the influence of quantum Gaussian force. The algorithm is amenable to all known quantum propagation methods and can thus be flexibly applied to study quantum dissipation in the condensed phase. Nontrivial numerical examples based on the spin-boson and damped quantum oscillator models are presented to demonstrate the application of the new algorithm.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 15, 1996•96 citations
We report the first numerical calculations in which converged Matsubara dynamics is compared directly with exact quantum dynamics with no artificial damping of the time-correlation functions (TCFs). The system treated is a Morse oscillator coupled to a harmonic bath. We show that, when the system-bath coupling is sufficiently strong, the Matsubara calculations can be converged by explicitly including up to M = 200 Matsubara modes, with the remaining modes included as a harmonic "tail" correction. The resulting Matsubara TCFs are in near-perfect agreement with the exact quantum TCFs, for non-linear as well as linear operators, at a temperature at which the TCFs are dominated by quantum thermal fluctuations. These results provide compelling evidence that incoherent classical dynamics can arise in the condensed phase at temperatures at which the statistics are dominated by quantum (Boltzmann) effects, as a result of smoothing of imaginary-time Feynman paths. The techniques developed here may also lead to efficient methods for benchmarking system-bath dynamics in the overdamped regime.
We develop an exact quantum thermostat that generates the quantum Boltzmann distribution in path integral phase space and so correctly captures the imaginary position–momentum correlations. This extends beyond the capability of existing quantum thermostats such as the PILE thermostat, which can only achieve the marginal of this distribution in position, with the momentum acting purely as a sampling tool and satisfying classical Maxwell–Boltzmann statistics. The dynamics correspond to the treatment of the Caldeira–Leggett system–bath model with Matsubara dynamics, a theory for approximating nuclear quantum dynamics by propagating smooth imaginary-time Feynman paths in real time. A Matsubara generalised Langevin equation that obeys certain quantum fluctuation–dissipation relations is mapped onto a Markovian stochastic process by introducing auxiliary variables; this allows the construction of a corresponding Fokker–Planck equation from which the stationary distribution in the extended variable space is determined. We show that this corresponds to the joint quantum Boltzmann distribution in position and momentum, a finding that holds for any bath spectral density and for anharmonic systems. The sole approximation in Matsubara dynamics is the neglect of real-time quantum coherence; consequently, provided there is sufficient quantum decoherence, the dynamics of the exact quantum thermostat also well approximates the exact quantum dynamics of the system–bath. In the limit of infinite system–bath coupling, the level of real-time coherence becomes negligible and so the Matsubara dynamics of the thermostat tends to the exact dynamics. The quantum thermostat can therefore be used to study this limit exactly and, in so doing, we demonstrate the existence of a quantum mechanical overdamped regime analogous to its classical counterpart that is characterised by a Matsubara Smoluchowski equation. The drawback of the quantum thermostat is that one of its associated quantum fluctuation–dissipation relations is imaginary. This results in complex noise and dynamical instabilities that often preclude the numerical implementation of the thermostat. Instead, it primarily serves as a theoretical framework that can be used as a starting point for introducing approximations that yield more practical methods. One such approximation that results in real noise is considered here and leads to a practical approach for calculating linear time-correlation functions of bound open quantum systems. These exhibit good agreement with exact quantum mechanical calculations, particularly at strong system–bath coupling, where the real-time quantum coherence is increasingly suppressed.
Beyond the weak-coupling limit, open quantum systems equilibrate to a highly entangled thermal state. For continuous-variable systems, this state can be written explicitly as an imaginary-time phase-space path integral, in which the positions are directly entangled with the bath, and the momenta are correlated with the positions through a phase term. Here, we ask to what extent this state can be reached by propagating stochastic classical trajectories in path-integral phase space. Surprisingly, we find that the trajectories equilibrate to the exact quantum equilibrium state, recovering the purely imaginary momentum-position correlation in the phase term. The trajectories are generated using a recently derived Matsubara generalized Langevin equation, which produces the imaginary correlations by evolving the stochastic variables into the complex plane. This makes the dynamics numerically unstable, but we are nonetheless able to demonstrate the equilibration of a quartic oscillator coupled to a white-noise bath. These unexpected findings could lead to new approximate methodologies for simulating continuous-variable open quantum systems.
Matsubara dynamics has recently emerged as the most general form of a quantum-Boltzmann-conserving classical dynamics theory for the calculation of single-time correlation functions. Here, we present a generalization of Matsubara dynamics for the evaluation of multitime correlation functions. We first show that the Matsubara approximation can also be used to approximate the two-time symmetrized double Kubo transformed correlation function. By a straightforward extension of these ideas to the multitime realm, a multitime Matsubara dynamics approximation can be obtained for the multitime fully symmetrized Kubo transformed correlation function. Although not a practical method, due to the presence of a phase-term, this multitime formulation of Matsubara dynamics represents a benchmark theory for future development of Boltzmann preserving semiclassical approximations to general higher order multitime correlation functions. It also reveals a connection between imaginary time-ordering in the path integral and the classical dynamics of multitime correlation functions.
A major challenge in open quantum dynamics is the inclusion of Matsubara-decay terms in the memory kernel, which arise from the quantum-Boltzmann delocalisation of the bath modes. This delocalisation can be quantified by the radius of gyration squared R2(ω){\mathcal R}^2(ω)R2(ω) of the imaginary-time Feynman paths of the bath modes as a function of the frequency ωωω. In a Hierarchical Equations of Motion (HEOM) calculation with a Debye--Drude spectral density, R2(ω){\mathcal R}^2(ω)R2(ω) is the only quantity that is treated approximately (assuming convergence with respect to hierarchy depth). Here, we show that the well-known Ishizaki--Tanimura correction is equivalent to separating smooth from `Brownian' contributions to R2(ω){\mathcal R}^2(ω)R2(ω), and that modifying the correction leads to a more efficient HEOM in the case of fast baths. We also develop a simple `A4' adaptation of the `AAA' (Adaptive Antoulas--Anderson) algorithm in order to fit R2(ω){\mathcal R}^2(ω)R2(ω) to a sum over poles, which results in an extremely efficient implementation of the standard HEOM method at low temperatures.
Exact calculations for a quantum oscillator linearly coupled to a thermal reservoir are presented. Explicit results (variances and correlations) for the response and the spontaneous fluctuations are evaluated for two different models of the heat bath; a reservoir with a spectrum which is similar to that of acoustic phonons and another which is analogous to optic phonons. The low-temperature behavior is shown to depend sensitively on the spectral density of the thermal reservoir. The mass and the frequency of the oscillator become renormalized through the coupling to the bath. These renormalizations are intrinsically frequency dependent. Moreover, the commonly used form of Ehrenfest's equation for the dynamics of the linearly damped oscillator is shown to only be a reasonable approximation within certain frequency regimes.
An effective and flexible numerical scheme is proposed to simulate the dissipative quantum dynamics of a linearized system–bath Hamiltonian. Based on the observation that the Feynman path integrals for a Gaussian bath have a quadratic functional form, the bath average can be performed by directly sampling paths of the discretized harmonic modes and then propagating the system under the influence of quantum Gaussian force. The algorithm is amenable to all known quantum propagation methods and can thus be flexibly applied to study quantum dissipation in the condensed phase. Nontrivial numerical examples based on the spin-boson and damped quantum oscillator models are presented to demonstrate the application of the new algorithm.