Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2211.00299 · Journal of Mathematical Physics

Ground state degeneracy on torus in a family of ZN toric code

Haruki Watanabe, Meng Cheng, Yohei Fuji

Published May 1, 2023• 43 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Topologically ordered phases in 2 + 1 dimensions are generally characterized by three mutually related features: fractionalized (anyonic) excitations, topological entanglement entropy, and robust ground state degeneracy that does not require symmetry protection or spontaneous symmetry breaking. Such a degeneracy is known as topological degeneracy and can be usually seen under the periodic boundary condition regardless of the choice of the system sizes L1 and L2 in each direction. In this work, we introduce a family of extensions of the Kitaev toric code to N level spins (N ≥ 2). The model realizes topologically ordered phases or symmetry-protected topological phases depending on the parameters in the model. The most remarkable feature of topologically ordered phases is that the ground state may be unique, depending on L1 and L2, despite that the translation symmetry of the model remains unbroken. Nonetheless, the topological entanglement entropy takes the nontrivial value. We argue that this behavior originates from the nontrivial action of translations permuting anyon species.

DOI
10.1063/5.0134010

Related papers

Toric Code for Pedestrians

We study a quantum spin liquid called Kitaev’s toric code, which exhibits topological order [4-6]. This system is attractive since many of its properties can be analytically explored. As in the BCS and fractional quantum Hall cases, one first guesses the correct trial wave function for the ground state and then constructs quasiparticle excitations. In the toric code, some of these excitations exhibit Abelian anyon (semion) statistics. The topological entanglement entropy of this phase is finite, equal to ln 2. Moreover, the ground state is four-fold degenerate in a torus topology. (Note that the Laughlin state at filling factor 1/3 has degeneracy 3 and the superconducting state has degeneracy 4.) Some of these properties of the toric code, especially the appearance of a pair of non-local excitations, are similar to those of interacting disordered zigzag nanoribbons and the reader is encouraged to study this chapter carefully. The presentation of this chapter is somewhat heuristic. For a more refined treatment, see, for example Refs. [2, 3].

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 1, 2023•0 citations

Hall-on-Toric State: Descendant Laughlin State in the Chiral Z p Toric Code

Robin Schäfer, Claudio Chamon, Chris R. Laumann

We demonstrate that the chiral Z_{p} toric code-the quintessential model of topological order-hosts additional, emergent topological phases when perturbed: descendant fractional quantum Hall-like states, which we term Hall-on-Toric. These hierarchical states feature fractionalized Z_{p} charges and increased topological ground-state degeneracy. The Hall-on-Toric phases appear in the vicinity of the transitions between deconfined Z_{p} phases with different background charge per unit cell, in a fixed nontrivial flux background. We confirm their existence through extensive infinite density matrix renormalization group (iDMRG) simulations, analyzing the topological entanglement entropy, entanglement spectra, and a generalized Hall conductance. Remarkably, the Hall-on-Toric states remain robust even in the absence of U(1) symmetry. Our findings reinforce the foundational interpretation of star and plaquette defects as magnetic and electric excitations, and reveal that this perspective extends to a much deeper level.

arXiv:2507.02035•Physical Review Letters•Mar 11, 2026•1 citation

Unveiling UV/IR mixing via symmetry defects: A view from topological entanglement entropy

Jintae Kim, Yun-Tak Oh, Daniel Bulmash +1 more

Some topological lattice models in two spatial dimensions exhibit intricate lattice size dependence in their ground state degeneracy (GSD). This and other features such as the position-dependent anyonic excitations are manifestations of UV/IR mixing. In the first part of this paper, we perform an exact calculation of the topological entanglement entropy (TEE) for a specific model, the rank-2 toric code. This analysis includes both contractible and non-contractible boundaries, with the minimum entropy states identified specifically for non-contractible boundaries. Our results show that TEE for a contractible boundary remains independent of lattice size, whereas TEE for non-contractible boundaries, similarly to the GSD, shows intricate lattice-size dependence. In the latter part of the paper we focus on the fact that the rank-2 toric code is an example of a translation symmetry-enriched topological phase, and show that viewing distinct lattice size as a consequence of different translation symmetry defects can explain both our TEE results and the GSD of the rank-2 toric code. Our work establishes the translation symmetry defect framework as a robust description of the UV/IR mixing in topological lattice models.

arXiv:2310.09425•SciPost Physics•Mar 25, 2025•9 citations

Robust topological degeneracy of classical theories

Mohammad-Sadegh Vaezi, Gerardo Ortíz, Zohar Nussinov

We challenge the hypothesis that the ground states of a physical system whose degeneracy depends on topology must necessarily realize topological quantum order and display nonlocal entanglement. To this end, we introduce and study a classical rendition of the Toric Code model embedded on Riemann surfaces of different genus numbers. We find that the minimal ground state degeneracy (and those of all levels) depends on the topology of the embedding surface alone. As the ground states of this classical system may be distinguished by local measurements, a characteristic of Landau orders, this example illustrates that topological degeneracy is not a sufficient condition for topological quantum order. This conclusion is generic and, as shown, it applies to many other models. We also demonstrate that certain lattice realizations of these models, and other theories, display a ground state entropy (and those of all levels) that is ``holographic'', i.e., extensive in the system boundary. We find that clock and $U(1)$ gauge theories display topological (in addition to gauge) degeneracies.

arXiv:1511.07867•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 9, 2016•5 citations

Gaining insights on anyon condensation and 1-form symmetry breaking across a topological phase transition in a deformed toric code model

Joe Huxford, Dung Xuan Nguyen, Yong Baek Kim

We examine the condensation and confinement mechanisms exhibited by a deformed toric code model proposed in [Castelnovo and Chamon, Phys. Rev. B 77, 054433 (2008)]. The model describes both sides of a phase transition from a topological phase to a trivial phase. Our findings reveal an unconventional confinement mechanism that governs the behavior of the toric code excitations within the trivial phase. Specifically, the confined magnetic charge can still be displaced without any energy cost, albeit only via the application of non-unitary operators that reduce the norm of the state. This peculiar phenomenon can be attributed to a previously known feature of the model: It maintains the non-trivial ground state degeneracy of the toric code throughout the transition. We describe how this degeneracy arises in both phases in terms of spontaneous symmetry breaking of a generalized (1-form) symmetry and explain why such symmetry breaking is compatible with the trivial phase. The present study implies the existence of subtle considerations that must be addressed in the context of recently posited connections between topological phases and broken higher-form symmetries.

arXiv:2305.07063•SciPost Physics•Dec 22, 2023•13 citations

Lattice models that realize Zn -1 symmetry-protected topological states for even n

Lokman Tsui, Xiao-Gang Wen

Higher symmetries can emerge at low energies in a topologically ordered state with no symmetry, when some topological excitations have very high-energy scales while other topological excitations have low energies. The low-energy properties of topological orders in this limit, with the emergent higher symmetries, may be described by higher symmetry-protected topological order. This motivates us, as a simplest example, to study a lattice model of ${\mathbb{Z}}_{n}$-1 symmetry-protected topological (1-SPT) states in $3+1$ dimensions for even $n$. We write an exactly solvable lattice model and study its boundary transformation. On the boundary, we show the existence of anyons with nontrivial self-statistics. For the $n=2$ case, where the bulk classification is given by an integer $m$ mod 4, we show that the boundary can be gapped with double-semion topological order for $m=1$ and toric code for $m=2$. The bulk ground-state wave-function amplitude is given in terms of the linking numbers of loops in the dual lattice. Our construction can be generalized to arbitrary 1-SPT protected by finite unitary symmetry.

arXiv:1908.02613•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 2, 2020•64 citations
Topologically ordered phases in 2 + 1 dimensions are generally characterized by three mutually related features: fractionalized (anyonic) excitations, topological entanglement entropy, and robust ground state degeneracy that does not require symmetry protection or spontaneous symmetry breaking. Such a degeneracy is known as topological degeneracy and can be usually seen under the periodic boundary condition regardless of the choice of the system sizes L1 and L2 in each direction. In this work, we introduce a family of extensions of the Kitaev toric code to N level spins (N ≥ 2). The model realizes topologically ordered phases or symmetry-protected topological phases depending on the parameters in the model. The most remarkable feature of topologically ordered phases is that the ground state may be unique, depending on L1 and L2, despite that the translation symmetry of the model remains unbroken. Nonetheless, the topological entanglement entropy takes the nontrivial value. We argue that this behavior originates from the nontrivial action of translations permuting anyon species.
We study a quantum spin liquid called Kitaev’s toric code, which exhibits topological order [4-6]. This system is attractive since many of its properties can be analytically explored. As in the BCS and fractional quantum Hall cases, one first guesses the correct trial wave function for the ground state and then constructs quasiparticle excitations. In the toric code, some of these excitations exhibit Abelian anyon (semion) statistics. The topological entanglement entropy of this phase is finite, equal to ln 2. Moreover, the ground state is four-fold degenerate in a torus topology. (Note that the Laughlin state at filling factor 1/3 has degeneracy 3 and the superconducting state has degeneracy 4.) Some of these properties of the toric code, especially the appearance of a pair of non-local excitations, are similar to those of interacting disordered zigzag nanoribbons and the reader is encouraged to study this chapter carefully. The presentation of this chapter is somewhat heuristic. For a more refined treatment, see, for example Refs. [2, 3].
We demonstrate that the chiral Z_{p} toric code-the quintessential model of topological order-hosts additional, emergent topological phases when perturbed: descendant fractional quantum Hall-like states, which we term Hall-on-Toric. These hierarchical states feature fractionalized Z_{p} charges and increased topological ground-state degeneracy. The Hall-on-Toric phases appear in the vicinity of the transitions between deconfined Z_{p} phases with different background charge per unit cell, in a fixed nontrivial flux background. We confirm their existence through extensive infinite density matrix renormalization group (iDMRG) simulations, analyzing the topological entanglement entropy, entanglement spectra, and a generalized Hall conductance. Remarkably, the Hall-on-Toric states remain robust even in the absence of U(1) symmetry. Our findings reinforce the foundational interpretation of star and plaquette defects as magnetic and electric excitations, and reveal that this perspective extends to a much deeper level.
Some topological lattice models in two spatial dimensions exhibit intricate lattice size dependence in their ground state degeneracy (GSD). This and other features such as the position-dependent anyonic excitations are manifestations of UV/IR mixing. In the first part of this paper, we perform an exact calculation of the topological entanglement entropy (TEE) for a specific model, the rank-2 toric code. This analysis includes both contractible and non-contractible boundaries, with the minimum entropy states identified specifically for non-contractible boundaries. Our results show that TEE for a contractible boundary remains independent of lattice size, whereas TEE for non-contractible boundaries, similarly to the GSD, shows intricate lattice-size dependence. In the latter part of the paper we focus on the fact that the rank-2 toric code is an example of a translation symmetry-enriched topological phase, and show that viewing distinct lattice size as a consequence of different translation symmetry defects can explain both our TEE results and the GSD of the rank-2 toric code. Our work establishes the translation symmetry defect framework as a robust description of the UV/IR mixing in topological lattice models.
We challenge the hypothesis that the ground states of a physical system whose degeneracy depends on topology must necessarily realize topological quantum order and display nonlocal entanglement. To this end, we introduce and study a classical rendition of the Toric Code model embedded on Riemann surfaces of different genus numbers. We find that the minimal ground state degeneracy (and those of all levels) depends on the topology of the embedding surface alone. As the ground states of this classical system may be distinguished by local measurements, a characteristic of Landau orders, this example illustrates that topological degeneracy is not a sufficient condition for topological quantum order. This conclusion is generic and, as shown, it applies to many other models. We also demonstrate that certain lattice realizations of these models, and other theories, display a ground state entropy (and those of all levels) that is ``holographic'', i.e., extensive in the system boundary. We find that clock and U(1)U(1)U(1) gauge theories display topological (in addition to gauge) degeneracies.
We examine the condensation and confinement mechanisms exhibited by a deformed toric code model proposed in [Castelnovo and Chamon, Phys. Rev. B 77, 054433 (2008)]. The model describes both sides of a phase transition from a topological phase to a trivial phase. Our findings reveal an unconventional confinement mechanism that governs the behavior of the toric code excitations within the trivial phase. Specifically, the confined magnetic charge can still be displaced without any energy cost, albeit only via the application of non-unitary operators that reduce the norm of the state. This peculiar phenomenon can be attributed to a previously known feature of the model: It maintains the non-trivial ground state degeneracy of the toric code throughout the transition. We describe how this degeneracy arises in both phases in terms of spontaneous symmetry breaking of a generalized (1-form) symmetry and explain why such symmetry breaking is compatible with the trivial phase. The present study implies the existence of subtle considerations that must be addressed in the context of recently posited connections between topological phases and broken higher-form symmetries.
Higher symmetries can emerge at low energies in a topologically ordered state with no symmetry, when some topological excitations have very high-energy scales while other topological excitations have low energies. The low-energy properties of topological orders in this limit, with the emergent higher symmetries, may be described by higher symmetry-protected topological order. This motivates us, as a simplest example, to study a lattice model of Zn{\mathbb{Z}}_{n}Zn​-1 symmetry-protected topological (1-SPT) states in 3+13+13+1 dimensions for even nnn. We write an exactly solvable lattice model and study its boundary transformation. On the boundary, we show the existence of anyons with nontrivial self-statistics. For the n=2n=2n=2 case, where the bulk classification is given by an integer mmm mod 4, we show that the boundary can be gapped with double-semion topological order for m=1m=1m=1 and toric code for m=2m=2m=2. The bulk ground-state wave-function amplitude is given in terms of the linking numbers of loops in the dual lattice. Our construction can be generalized to arbitrary 1-SPT protected by finite unitary symmetry.