Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2210.15783 · IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control

Time-Domain Sensitivity of the Tracking Error

Sean P. O’Neil, S. G. Schirmer, Frank C. Langbein, Carrie Ann Weidner, EDMOND A. JONCKHEERE

Published Nov 9, 2023• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A strictly time-domain. formulation of the log-sensitivity of the error signal to structured plant uncertainty is presented and analyzed through simple but representative classical and quantum systems. Results demonstrate that across a wide range of physical systems, maximization of performance (minimization of the error signal) asymptotically or at a specific time comes at the cost of increased log-sensitivity, implying a time-domain constraint analogous to the frequency-domain identity$\mathbf {S(s) + T(s) = I}$. While of limited value in classical problems based on asymptotic stabilization or tracking, such a time-domain formulation is valuable in assessing the reduced robustness cost concomitant with high-fidelity quantum control schemes predicated on time-based performance measures.

DOI
10.1109/tac.2023.3331681

Related papers

Sensitivity Bounds for Quantum Control and Time-Domain Performance Guarantees

Sean P. O’Neil, EDMOND A. JONCKHEERE, S. G. Schirmer

Control of quantum systems via time-varying external fields optimized to maximize a fidelity measure at a given time is a mainstay in modern quantum control. However, save for specific systems, current analysis techniques for such quantum controllers provide no analytical robustness guarantees. In this letter we provide analytical bounds on the differential sensitivity of the gate fidelity error to structured uncertainties for a closed quantum system controlled by piecewise-constant, optimal control fields. We additionally determine those uncertainty structures that result in this worst-case maximal sensitivity. We then use these differential sensitivity bounds to provide conditions that guarantee performance, quantified by the fidelity error, in the face of parameter uncertainty.

arXiv:2310.17094•IEEE Control Systems Letters•Jan 1, 2024•2 citations

Robustness of dynamic quantum control: Differential sensitivity bounds

Sean P. O’Neil, Carrie Ann Weidner, EDMOND A. JONCKHEERE +2 more

Dynamic control via optimized, piecewise-constant pulses is a common paradigm for open-loop control to implement quantum gates. While numerous methods exist for the synthesis of such controls, there are many open questions regarding the robustness of the resulting control schemes in the presence of model uncertainty; unlike in classical control, there are generally no analytical guarantees on the control performance with respect to inexact modeling of the system. In this paper, a new robustness measure based on the differential sensitivity of the gate fidelity error to parametric (structured) uncertainties is introduced, and bounds on the differential sensitivity to parametric uncertainties are used to establish performance guarantees for optimal controllers for a variety of quantum gate types, system sizes, and control implementations. Specifically, it is shown how a maximum allowable perturbation over a set of Hamiltonian uncertainties that guarantees a given fidelity error can be reliably computed. This measure of robustness is inversely proportional to the upper bound on the differential sensitivity of the fidelity error evaluated under nominal operating conditions. Finally, the results show that the nominal fidelity error and differential sensitivity upper bound are positively correlated across a wide range of problems and control implementations, suggesting that in the high-fidelity control regime, rather than there being a trade-off between fidelity and robustness, higher nominal gate fidelities are positively correlated with increased robustness of the controls in the presence of parametric uncertainties.

arXiv:2401.00301•AVS Quantum Science•Jul 1, 2024•4 citations

Assessing optimality and robustness of control over quantum dynamics

Metin Demіralp, HERSCHEL A. RABITZ

This work presents a general framework for assessing the quality and robustness of control over quantum dynamics induced by an optical field $\mathcal{E}(t).$ The control process is expressed in terms of a cost functional, including the physical objectives, penalties, and constraints. The first variations of such cost functionals have traditionally been utilized to create designs for the controlling electric fields. Here, the second variation of the cost functional is analyzed to explore (i) whether such solutions are locally optimal, and (ii) their degree of robustness. Both issues may be assessed from the eigenvalues of the stability operator S whose kernel $K(t,\ensuremath{\tau})$ is related to $\ensuremath{\delta}\mathcal{E}(t)/\ensuremath{\delta}\mathcal{E}(\ensuremath{\tau}){|}_{c}$ for $0<t,$ $\ensuremath{\tau}<~T,$ where $T$ is the target control time. Here $c$ denotes the constraint that the field satisfies the optimal control dynamical equations. The eigenvalues \ensuremath{\sigma} of S satisfying $\ensuremath{\sigma}<1$ assure local optimality of the control solution, with $\ensuremath{\sigma}=1$ being the critical value separating optimal solutions from false solutions (i.e., those with negative second variational curvature of the cost functional). In turn, the maximally robust control solutions with the least sensitivity to field errors also correspond to $\ensuremath{\sigma}=1.$ Thus, sufficiently high sensitivity of the field at one time $t$ to the field at another time \ensuremath{\tau} (i.e., $\ensuremath{\sigma}>1$) will lead to a loss of local optimality. An expression is obtained for a bound on the stability operator, and this result is employed to qualitatively analyze control behavior. From this bound, the inclusion of an auxiliary operator (i.e., other than the target operator) is shown to act as a stabilizer of the control process. It is also shown that robust solutions are expected to exist in both the strong- and weak-field regimes.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1998•21 citations

Zero, pole and fragility of quantum systems

Masahiro Yanagisawa

New fundamental limits on design and control of linear quantum systems are presented. A main difference between quantum and classical systems comes from the fact that quantum signals are represented by operator-valued vectors. The transfer function representation is useful to describe a system in the quantum setting for the same reason as it is useful classically. It is shown that the noncommutative property of quantum signals can be characterized by a specific relation between zeros and poles of a quantum transfer function. Then, two quantum mechanical tradeoffs follows from the transfer function constraint. One is a well known tradeoff, Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation, and the other is a tradeoff between the ability of noise reduction and sensitivity to modeling error. While these tradeoffs hold at each frequency, quantum systems have another constraint between different frequencies based on Bode integral as classical systems usually do. In the quantum case, however, this constraint is also dependent on quantum mechanical parameters.

IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC)•Jan 1, 2007•2 citations

Robustness of Quantum Systems Subject to Decoherence: Structured Singular Value Analysis?

S. G. Schirmer, Frank C. Langbein, Carrie Ann Weidner +1 more

We study the problem of robust performance of quantum systems under structured uncertainties. A specific feature of closed (Hamiltonian) quantum systems is that their poles lie on the imaginary axis and that neither a coherent controller nor physically relevant structured uncertainties can alter this situation. This changes for open systems where decoherence ensures asymptotic stability and creates a unique landscape of pure performance robustness, with the distinctive feature that closed-loop stability is secured by the underlying physics and needs not be enforced. This stability, however, is often detrimental to quantum-enhanced performance, and additive perturbations of the Hamiltonian give rise to dynamic generators that are nonlinear in the perturbed parameters, invalidating classical paradigms to assess robustness to structured perturbations such as singular value analysis. This problem is addressed using a fixed-point iteration approach to determine a maximum perturbation strength δmaxthat ensures that the transfer function remains bounded, ║Tδ║−1for δmax.

arXiv:2110.05372•IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC)•Dec 14, 2021•2 citations

Time uncertainty and fundamental sensitivity limits in quantum sensing: application to optomechanical gravimetry

Salman Sajad Wani, Saif Al-Kuwari, Arshid Shabir +3 more

High-sensitivity accelerometers and gravimeters, achieving the ultimate limits of measurement sensitivity are key tools for advancing both fundamental and applied physics. While numerous platforms have been proposed to achieve this goal, from atom interferometers to optomechanical systems, all of these studies neglect the effects of intrinsic quantum uncertainty in time estimation. Starting from the Hamiltonian of a generic linear quantum sensor, we derive the two-parameter quantum Fisher information matrix and establish the corresponding Cram'er-Rao bound, treating time as an uncertain (nuisance) parameter. Our analysis reveals a fundamental coupling between time and signal estimation that inherently degrades measurement sensitivity, with the standard single-parameter quantum limit recovered only at specific interrogation times or under special decoupling conditions. We then apply these results to an optomechanical gravimeter and explicitly derive an optimal decoupling condition under which the effects of time uncertainty are averaged out in a continuous measurement scheme. Our approach is general and can be readily extended to a broad class of quantum sensors.

quant-pharXiv:2602.18524•Physical Review A•Feb 23, 2026•0 citations
A strictly time-domain. formulation of the log-sensitivity of the error signal to structured plant uncertainty is presented and analyzed through simple but representative classical and quantum systems. Results demonstrate that across a wide range of physical systems, maximization of performance (minimization of the error signal) asymptotically or at a specific time comes at the cost of increased log-sensitivity, implying a time-domain constraint analogous to the frequency-domain identityS(s)+T(s)=I\mathbf {S(s) + T(s) = I}S(s)+T(s)=I. While of limited value in classical problems based on asymptotic stabilization or tracking, such a time-domain formulation is valuable in assessing the reduced robustness cost concomitant with high-fidelity quantum control schemes predicated on time-based performance measures.
Control of quantum systems via time-varying external fields optimized to maximize a fidelity measure at a given time is a mainstay in modern quantum control. However, save for specific systems, current analysis techniques for such quantum controllers provide no analytical robustness guarantees. In this letter we provide analytical bounds on the differential sensitivity of the gate fidelity error to structured uncertainties for a closed quantum system controlled by piecewise-constant, optimal control fields. We additionally determine those uncertainty structures that result in this worst-case maximal sensitivity. We then use these differential sensitivity bounds to provide conditions that guarantee performance, quantified by the fidelity error, in the face of parameter uncertainty.
Dynamic control via optimized, piecewise-constant pulses is a common paradigm for open-loop control to implement quantum gates. While numerous methods exist for the synthesis of such controls, there are many open questions regarding the robustness of the resulting control schemes in the presence of model uncertainty; unlike in classical control, there are generally no analytical guarantees on the control performance with respect to inexact modeling of the system. In this paper, a new robustness measure based on the differential sensitivity of the gate fidelity error to parametric (structured) uncertainties is introduced, and bounds on the differential sensitivity to parametric uncertainties are used to establish performance guarantees for optimal controllers for a variety of quantum gate types, system sizes, and control implementations. Specifically, it is shown how a maximum allowable perturbation over a set of Hamiltonian uncertainties that guarantees a given fidelity error can be reliably computed. This measure of robustness is inversely proportional to the upper bound on the differential sensitivity of the fidelity error evaluated under nominal operating conditions. Finally, the results show that the nominal fidelity error and differential sensitivity upper bound are positively correlated across a wide range of problems and control implementations, suggesting that in the high-fidelity control regime, rather than there being a trade-off between fidelity and robustness, higher nominal gate fidelities are positively correlated with increased robustness of the controls in the presence of parametric uncertainties.
This work presents a general framework for assessing the quality and robustness of control over quantum dynamics induced by an optical field E(t).\mathcal{E}(t).E(t). The control process is expressed in terms of a cost functional, including the physical objectives, penalties, and constraints. The first variations of such cost functionals have traditionally been utilized to create designs for the controlling electric fields. Here, the second variation of the cost functional is analyzed to explore (i) whether such solutions are locally optimal, and (ii) their degree of robustness. Both issues may be assessed from the eigenvalues of the stability operator S whose kernel $K(t,\ensuremath{\tau})$ is related to $\ensuremath{\delta}\mathcal{E}(t)/\ensuremath{\delta}\mathcal{E}(\ensuremath{\tau}){|}_{c}$ for 0<t,0<t,0<t, $\ensuremath{\tau}<~T,$ where TTT is the target control time. Here ccc denotes the constraint that the field satisfies the optimal control dynamical equations. The eigenvalues \ensuremath{\sigma} of S satisfying $\ensuremath{\sigma}<1$ assure local optimality of the control solution, with $\ensuremath{\sigma}=1$ being the critical value separating optimal solutions from false solutions (i.e., those with negative second variational curvature of the cost functional). In turn, the maximally robust control solutions with the least sensitivity to field errors also correspond to $\ensuremath{\sigma}=1.$ Thus, sufficiently high sensitivity of the field at one time ttt to the field at another time \ensuremath{\tau} (i.e., $\ensuremath{\sigma}>1$) will lead to a loss of local optimality. An expression is obtained for a bound on the stability operator, and this result is employed to qualitatively analyze control behavior. From this bound, the inclusion of an auxiliary operator (i.e., other than the target operator) is shown to act as a stabilizer of the control process. It is also shown that robust solutions are expected to exist in both the strong- and weak-field regimes.
New fundamental limits on design and control of linear quantum systems are presented. A main difference between quantum and classical systems comes from the fact that quantum signals are represented by operator-valued vectors. The transfer function representation is useful to describe a system in the quantum setting for the same reason as it is useful classically. It is shown that the noncommutative property of quantum signals can be characterized by a specific relation between zeros and poles of a quantum transfer function. Then, two quantum mechanical tradeoffs follows from the transfer function constraint. One is a well known tradeoff, Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation, and the other is a tradeoff between the ability of noise reduction and sensitivity to modeling error. While these tradeoffs hold at each frequency, quantum systems have another constraint between different frequencies based on Bode integral as classical systems usually do. In the quantum case, however, this constraint is also dependent on quantum mechanical parameters.
We study the problem of robust performance of quantum systems under structured uncertainties. A specific feature of closed (Hamiltonian) quantum systems is that their poles lie on the imaginary axis and that neither a coherent controller nor physically relevant structured uncertainties can alter this situation. This changes for open systems where decoherence ensures asymptotic stability and creates a unique landscape of pure performance robustness, with the distinctive feature that closed-loop stability is secured by the underlying physics and needs not be enforced. This stability, however, is often detrimental to quantum-enhanced performance, and additive perturbations of the Hamiltonian give rise to dynamic generators that are nonlinear in the perturbed parameters, invalidating classical paradigms to assess robustness to structured perturbations such as singular value analysis. This problem is addressed using a fixed-point iteration approach to determine a maximum perturbation strength δmaxthat ensures that the transfer function remains bounded, ║Tδ║−1for δmax.
High-sensitivity accelerometers and gravimeters, achieving the ultimate limits of measurement sensitivity are key tools for advancing both fundamental and applied physics. While numerous platforms have been proposed to achieve this goal, from atom interferometers to optomechanical systems, all of these studies neglect the effects of intrinsic quantum uncertainty in time estimation. Starting from the Hamiltonian of a generic linear quantum sensor, we derive the two-parameter quantum Fisher information matrix and establish the corresponding Cram'er-Rao bound, treating time as an uncertain (nuisance) parameter. Our analysis reveals a fundamental coupling between time and signal estimation that inherently degrades measurement sensitivity, with the standard single-parameter quantum limit recovered only at specific interrogation times or under special decoupling conditions. We then apply these results to an optomechanical gravimeter and explicitly derive an optimal decoupling condition under which the effects of time uncertainty are averaged out in a continuous measurement scheme. Our approach is general and can be readily extended to a broad class of quantum sensors.