Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2210.14338 · Journal of Physics G Nuclear and Particle Physics

Proton-neutron entanglement in the nuclear shell model

Calvin W. Johnson, Oliver C. Gorton

Published Feb 24, 2023• 57 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract We compute the proton-neutron entanglement entropy in the interacting nuclear shell model for a variety of nuclides and interactions. Some results make intuitive sense, for example, that the shell structure, as governed by single-particle and monopole energies, strongly affects the energetically available space and thus the entanglement entropy. We also find a surprising result: that the entanglement entropy at low excitation energy tends to decrease for nuclides when N ≠ Z. While we provide evidence this arises from the physical nuclear force by contrasting with random two-body interactions which shows no such decrease, the exact mechanism is unclear. Nonetheless, the low entanglement suggests that in models of neutron-rich nuclides, the coupling between protons and neutrons may be less computationally demanding than one might otherwise expect.

DOI
10.1088/1361-6471/acbece

Related papers

Weak entanglement approximation for nuclear structure

Oliver C. Gorton, Calvin W. Johnson

The interacting shell model, a configuration-interaction method, is a venerable approach for low-lying nuclear structure calculations, but it is hampered by the exponential growth of its basis dimension as one increases the single-particle space and/or the number of active particles. Recent, quantum-information-inspired work has demonstrated that the proton and neutron sectors of a nuclear wave function are weakly entangled. Furthermore, the entanglement is smaller for nuclides away from $N=Z$, such as heavy, neutron-rich nuclides. Here we implement a weak entanglement approximation to bipartite configuration-interaction wave functions, approximating low-lying levels by coupling a relatively small number of many-proton and many-neutron states. This truncation scheme, which we present in the context of past approaches, reduces the basis dimension by many orders of magnitude while preserving essential features of nuclear spectra.

arXiv:2406.10120•Physical Review C•Sep 4, 2024•25 citations

A weak entanglement approximation for nuclear structure: A progress report

Calvin W. Johnson, Oliver C. Gorton

We report on a recently proposed approach, inspired by quantum information theory, for calculating low-energy nuclear structure in the framework of the configuration-interaction shell-model. Empirical evidence has demonstrated that the many-proton and many-neutron partitions of nuclear configuration-interaction wave functions are weakly entangled, especially away from N = Z . This has been developed into a practical methodology, the Proton And Neutron Approximate Shell-model (PANASh). We review the basic ideas and present recent results. We also discuss some technical developments in calculations.

arXiv:2504.00273•Journal of subatomic particles and cosmology.•May 5, 2025•6 citations

Quantum entanglement patterns in the structure of atomic nuclei within the nuclear shell model

Axel Pérez-Obiol, Sergi Masot-Llima, A. M. Romero +4 more

Abstract Quantum entanglement offers a unique perspective into the underlying structure of strongly-correlated systems such as atomic nuclei. In this paper, we use quantum information tools to analyze the structure of light and medium-mass berillyum, oxygen, neon and calcium isotopes within the nuclear shell model. We use different entanglement metrics, including single-orbital entanglement, mutual information, and von Neumann entropies for different equipartitions of the shell-model valence space and identify mode-entanglement patterns related to the energy, angular momentum and isospin of the nuclear single-particle orbitals. We observe that the single-orbital entanglement is directly related to the number of valence nucleons and the energy structure of the shell, while the mutual information highlights signatures of proton–proton and neutron–neutron pairing, as well as nuclear deformation. Proton and neutron orbitals are weakly entangled by all measures, and in fact have the lowest von Neumann entropies among all possible equipartitions of the valence space. In contrast, orbitals with opposite angular momentum projection have relatively large entropies, especially in spherical nuclei. This analysis provides a guide for designing more efficient quantum algorithms for the noisy intermediate-scale quantum era.

arXiv:2307.05197•The European Physical Journal A•Oct 25, 2023•48 citations

Shannon entropy of optimized proton-neutron pair condensates

Shu-Yuan Liang, Yi Lu, Yang Lei +3 more

Proton-neutron pairing and like-nucleon pairing are two different facets of atomic nuclear configurations. While like-nucleon pair condensates manifest their superfluidic nature in semimagic nuclei, it is not absolutely clear if there exists a $T=0$ proton-neutron pair condensate phase in $N=Z$ nuclei. With an explicit formalism of general pair condensate with good particle numbers, we optimize proton-neutron pair condensates for all $N=Z$ nuclei between $^{16}\mathrm{O}$ and $^{100}\mathrm{Sn}$, given shell model effective interactions. As comparison, we also optimize like-nucleon pair condensates for their semimagic isotones. Shannon entanglement entropy is a measurement of mixing among pair configurations, and can signal intrinsic phase transition. It turns out the like-nucleon pair condensates for semimagic nuclei have large entropies signaling an entangled phase, but the proton-neutron pair condensates end up not far from a Hartree-Fock solution with small entropy. With artificial pairing interaction strengths, we show that the general proton-neutron pair condensate can transit from an entangled $T=1$ phase to an entangled $T=0$ phase, i.e., pairing phase transition driven by external parameters. In the $T=0$ limit, the proton-neutron pair condensate optimized for $^{24}\mathrm{Mg}$ turns out to be a purely $T=0$ P-pair condensate with large entanglement entropy, although such cases may occur in cold atom systems, unlikely in atomic nuclei.

arXiv:2411.01439•Physical Review C•Feb 13, 2025•12 citations

Entanglement in Few-Nucleon Scattering Events

Tanja Kirchner, Wael Elkamhawy, H.‐W. Hammer

Abstract We investigate the spin entanglement in few-nucleon scattering processes involving nucleons and deuterons. For this purpose, we consider the entanglement power introduced by Beane et al. We analyze different entanglement entropies as a basis to define the entanglement power of the strong interaction and calculate the corresponding entanglement powers for proton–neutron, neutron–deuteron, proton–deuteron, and deuteron–deuteron scattering. For the latter two processes, we also take into account the modification from the Coulomb interaction. In contrast to proton–neutron scattering, no universal low-energy features are evident in the spin entanglement in neutron–deuteron, proton–deuteron, and deuteron–deuteron scattering.

arXiv:2312.14484•Few-Body Systems•Mar 22, 2024•21 citations

The Effects of Quantum Entanglement in Low-Energy Proton–Proton Scattering

E. F. Zagirdinova, Konstantin Kouzakov

Abstract Generation of an entangled spin state as a result of a low-energy elastic collision of two protons is considered. The scattering process is described by a theoretical model that is in good agreement with the available experimental data on the angular differential cross sections of proton–proton collisions at low energies. The entanglement of the spin state of final protons as a function of the scattering angle is analyzed using Bell’s inequality and pair concurrence. The numerical results for different values of the collision energy are compared with the results without considering nuclear forces. It is shown that nuclear interaction significantly enhances the effects of spin entanglement.

Moscow University Physics Bulletin•Jun 1, 2022•0 citations
Abstract We compute the proton-neutron entanglement entropy in the interacting nuclear shell model for a variety of nuclides and interactions. Some results make intuitive sense, for example, that the shell structure, as governed by single-particle and monopole energies, strongly affects the energetically available space and thus the entanglement entropy. We also find a surprising result: that the entanglement entropy at low excitation energy tends to decrease for nuclides when N ≠ Z. While we provide evidence this arises from the physical nuclear force by contrasting with random two-body interactions which shows no such decrease, the exact mechanism is unclear. Nonetheless, the low entanglement suggests that in models of neutron-rich nuclides, the coupling between protons and neutrons may be less computationally demanding than one might otherwise expect.
The interacting shell model, a configuration-interaction method, is a venerable approach for low-lying nuclear structure calculations, but it is hampered by the exponential growth of its basis dimension as one increases the single-particle space and/or the number of active particles. Recent, quantum-information-inspired work has demonstrated that the proton and neutron sectors of a nuclear wave function are weakly entangled. Furthermore, the entanglement is smaller for nuclides away from N=ZN=ZN=Z, such as heavy, neutron-rich nuclides. Here we implement a weak entanglement approximation to bipartite configuration-interaction wave functions, approximating low-lying levels by coupling a relatively small number of many-proton and many-neutron states. This truncation scheme, which we present in the context of past approaches, reduces the basis dimension by many orders of magnitude while preserving essential features of nuclear spectra.
We report on a recently proposed approach, inspired by quantum information theory, for calculating low-energy nuclear structure in the framework of the configuration-interaction shell-model. Empirical evidence has demonstrated that the many-proton and many-neutron partitions of nuclear configuration-interaction wave functions are weakly entangled, especially away from N = Z . This has been developed into a practical methodology, the Proton And Neutron Approximate Shell-model (PANASh). We review the basic ideas and present recent results. We also discuss some technical developments in calculations.
Abstract Quantum entanglement offers a unique perspective into the underlying structure of strongly-correlated systems such as atomic nuclei. In this paper, we use quantum information tools to analyze the structure of light and medium-mass berillyum, oxygen, neon and calcium isotopes within the nuclear shell model. We use different entanglement metrics, including single-orbital entanglement, mutual information, and von Neumann entropies for different equipartitions of the shell-model valence space and identify mode-entanglement patterns related to the energy, angular momentum and isospin of the nuclear single-particle orbitals. We observe that the single-orbital entanglement is directly related to the number of valence nucleons and the energy structure of the shell, while the mutual information highlights signatures of proton–proton and neutron–neutron pairing, as well as nuclear deformation. Proton and neutron orbitals are weakly entangled by all measures, and in fact have the lowest von Neumann entropies among all possible equipartitions of the valence space. In contrast, orbitals with opposite angular momentum projection have relatively large entropies, especially in spherical nuclei. This analysis provides a guide for designing more efficient quantum algorithms for the noisy intermediate-scale quantum era.
Proton-neutron pairing and like-nucleon pairing are two different facets of atomic nuclear configurations. While like-nucleon pair condensates manifest their superfluidic nature in semimagic nuclei, it is not absolutely clear if there exists a T=0T=0T=0 proton-neutron pair condensate phase in N=ZN=ZN=Z nuclei. With an explicit formalism of general pair condensate with good particle numbers, we optimize proton-neutron pair condensates for all N=ZN=ZN=Z nuclei between 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}16O and 100Sn^{100}\mathrm{Sn}100Sn, given shell model effective interactions. As comparison, we also optimize like-nucleon pair condensates for their semimagic isotones. Shannon entanglement entropy is a measurement of mixing among pair configurations, and can signal intrinsic phase transition. It turns out the like-nucleon pair condensates for semimagic nuclei have large entropies signaling an entangled phase, but the proton-neutron pair condensates end up not far from a Hartree-Fock solution with small entropy. With artificial pairing interaction strengths, we show that the general proton-neutron pair condensate can transit from an entangled T=1T=1T=1 phase to an entangled T=0T=0T=0 phase, i.e., pairing phase transition driven by external parameters. In the T=0T=0T=0 limit, the proton-neutron pair condensate optimized for 24Mg^{24}\mathrm{Mg}24Mg turns out to be a purely T=0T=0T=0 P-pair condensate with large entanglement entropy, although such cases may occur in cold atom systems, unlikely in atomic nuclei.
Abstract We investigate the spin entanglement in few-nucleon scattering processes involving nucleons and deuterons. For this purpose, we consider the entanglement power introduced by Beane et al. We analyze different entanglement entropies as a basis to define the entanglement power of the strong interaction and calculate the corresponding entanglement powers for proton–neutron, neutron–deuteron, proton–deuteron, and deuteron–deuteron scattering. For the latter two processes, we also take into account the modification from the Coulomb interaction. In contrast to proton–neutron scattering, no universal low-energy features are evident in the spin entanglement in neutron–deuteron, proton–deuteron, and deuteron–deuteron scattering.
Abstract Generation of an entangled spin state as a result of a low-energy elastic collision of two protons is considered. The scattering process is described by a theoretical model that is in good agreement with the available experimental data on the angular differential cross sections of proton–proton collisions at low energies. The entanglement of the spin state of final protons as a function of the scattering angle is analyzed using Bell’s inequality and pair concurrence. The numerical results for different values of the collision energy are compared with the results without considering nuclear forces. It is shown that nuclear interaction significantly enhances the effects of spin entanglement.